X10: IBM

1
X10 IBMs bid into parallel languages

• Paul B Kohler
• Kevin S Grimaldi
• University of Massachusetts Amherst

2
introduction

• A new language based of Java
• IBMs entry to the DARPAs PERCS project
  (Productive Easy-to-use Reliable Computer
  Systems)
• Built for NUCCs(Non-Uniform Computing Clusters)
  where different memory locations incur different
  cost.

3
intro continued

• Will eventually be combined with new tools for
  Eclipse
• Goals
• Safe
• Analyzable
• Scalable
• Flexible

4
PGAS

• Past attempts at parallel languages have used the
  illusion of a single shared memory
• This does not represent the situation in NUCC.
• Problems occur when we try divide memory among
  processors.
• X10 uses PGAS to reveal the non-uniformity and
  make the language scalable.

5
PGAS(co nt)

• PGASPartitioned Global Address Space
• Memory partitioned into places. Data is
  associated with a place and can only be
  read/changed locally.
• Provided in X10 through the abstractions of
  places and activities.

6
Places

• Contain a collection of resident mutable data
  objects and associated activities
• Places represent locality boundaries
• Very efficient access to resident data
• Set of places remains fixed at runtime
• Places are virtual
• Mapped to physical processors by runtime
• Runtime may transparently migrate places

7
Using Places

• Accessible via place.places
• First activity runs at place.FIRST_PLACE
• Iterate over places with next() and prev()
• here represents current place

8
Activities

• Similar to java threads.
• Activities are associated with a place.
• Activities never migrate places.
• Activities may only read/modify mutable data that
  is local to its place.
• However immutable data (i.e.final or value) maybe
  accessed by any activity.

9
Activities (cont)

• Activities are GALS(Globally Asynchronous Locally
  Synchronous)
• Local data accesses are synchronized
• Global data accesses are not by default.
  Synchronization can be explicitly forced.

10
ActivitiesSyntax

• It is very simple to spawn new activities
• async(place)statement
• This runs the specified statement at the
  specified place.
• Example
• final int result
• async(here.next())resultab
• This would add two numbers at the adjacent place
  and store the result(since result is final it can
  be accessed by other places)

11
Type System

• X10 is strongly typed
• Unified type system
• Everything is an object no primitive types
• Library supplies boolean, byte, short, char, int,
  long, float, double, complex, String classes
• Borrows Javas single inheritance combined with
  interfaces

12
Reference vs Value Types

• Two types of objects
• Value types are immutable and can be freely
  copied
• Reference types can contain mutable fields but
  cannot be migrated
• Value classes are declared value keyword instead
  of class
• Value classes can still contain fields that are
  of reference types
• Allows them to refer to mutable data
• Copying bottoms out on reference fields

13
Type System (cont)

• Objects are either scalar or aggregate
• Each of value and reference types can be either
  scalar or aggregate
• Types consist of two parts
• Data type The set of values it can take
• Place type The place at which it resides
• No generics (yet)

14
Variables

• Variables must be initialized (can never be
  observed without a value)
• final variables cannot be changed after
  initialization
• Declared by using the final keyword and/or using
  a variable name that starts with a capital letter

15
Nullable Types

• Designers view ability to hold null value as
  orthogonal to value vs reference type
• Either reference or value types can be preceded
  by nullable
• Adds a null value to the type
• Multiple nullables are collapsed (i.e. nullable
  nullable T nullable T)
• Can cast between T and nullable T
• (nullable T) v always succeeds
• (T) null throws an exception if T is not nullable

16
Rooted exceptions

• What should happen when a thread/activity
  terminates abnormally?
• In java its unclear since the spawning thread
  may have already terminated.
• X10 uses a rooted exception model. All uncaught
  exceptions get passed to the calling activity.
• A new blocking command finish s is introduced.
  This command waits for all activities in s to
  terminate before proceeding.

17
Exceptions (cont)

• Finish allows exceptions to travel back towards
  the root activity and possibly be caught and
  handled along the way.
• Example
• try
• finish async(here.next())
• throw new Exception()
• catch(Exception e)

18
Arrays

• X10 features an array sub-language similar to
  ZPL.
• Arrays have
• Regions
• Distributions
• Arrays are operated on by
• for
• foreach
• ateach
• And more!

19
Even more arrays

• Arrays may be value(immutable) or
  reference(mutable)
• Keyword unsafe allows arrays that will play nice
  with java code.
• Arrays can run code as an initialization step.

20
ArraysRegions

• RegionsAs in ZPL a region is a set of indexed
  data points.
• Regions and distributions are first class
  constructs.
• Regions can be specified like this
• 0128,0256 creates a region 128x256

21
Regions(cont.)

• Regions can be modified by operation such as
  union(), intersection() and set
  difference(-).
• Predefined regions types can be constructed using
  factories.
• region R2 region.factory.upperTriangular(25)
• In the future users may be able to define there
  own regions.

22
ArraysDistributions

• Every array has a distribution.
• A distribution is mapping of array elements to
  places.
• Distributions are over a particular region.
• Arrays are typed by their distribution.

23
Distributions cont.

• Currently must use pre-defined distributions(uniqu
  e,block,cyclicetc.)
• Have set operations like regions.
• Can be used as functions so for a point p and
  distribution d dpplace which point p maps
  to(i.e. where the pth element lives).

24
Subarrays

• Use various boolean operations on distributions
  to create subdistributions
• To get the portion of a block distribution that
  is located here
• block(1100) 1100-gthere
• a D1 is the portion of array a corresponding to
  the subdistribution D1

25
Array construction

• Here is an example of array initialization
• float . data
• newfactory.cyclic(0200,50250)
• (point i, j)return ij

26
Array construction

• Here is an example of array initialization
• float . data
• newfactory.cyclic(0200,50250)
• (point i, j)return ij
• This specifies a 200x200 region

27
Array construction

• Here is an example of array initialization
• float . data
• newfactory.cyclic(0200,50250)
• (point i, j)return ij
• This specifies a 200x200 region.
• This specifies a cyclic distribution over the
  region.

28
Array construction

• Here is an example of array initialization
• float . data
• newfactory.cyclic(0200,50250)
• (point i, j)return ij
• This specifies a 200x200 region.
• This specifies a cyclic distribution over the
  region.
• This code initialize each element to the some of
  its i,j coordinates

29
Array iteration

• Once you have an array what can you do with it?
• Array iterators for, foreach, ateach
• for Sequentially iterates over a supplied
  region. At each point it binds the point to a
  variable and executes the accompanying statement.
• foreach As with for but operations are done in
  parallel. That is it spawns a new activity for
  each point.
• ateach takes a distribution instead of a
  region. Performs operations in parallel at the
  place specified by the distribution.

30
Iteration example

• Example
• for(point p A)
• ApApAp

31
More array ops

• lift Takes a binary function and two arrays of
  the same distribution. Produces a new array
  formed by a pointwise application of the function
  to the two arrays.
• reduce As in MPI applies a binary function to
  every element to produce a single value.
• scan Creates a new array where the ith element
  is the result of reduction on the first i
  elements.

32
Atomic Blocks

• X10 allows you to define atomic blocks
• The contents of a block is guaranteed to execute
  as a single atomic event. This is only in
  regards to other activities in the same place.
• While this is guaranteed to be atomic the details
  are implementation specific.
• Syntax atomic S

33
Conditional Atmc Blck

• Also provides when(Cond) S
• This blocks until cond is true and then executes
  S atomically.
• This allows the creation of a number of
  synchronization mechanisms.
• Dangerous! If cond is never true or if there is
  a cycle deadlock occurs.

34
Future and Force

• As discussed before futures allow the
  asynchronous computation of a value that may be
  used in the future.
• Futures return a object of type FutureltTgt
• Force is a blocking call that waits for a
  particular future to be finished

35
Futures(cont.)

• Can only access final variables. This prevents
  side effects.
• Syntax future(p)e
• Example Future ltfloatgt blah future(here.next)s
  qrt(a2b2)

36
Clocks

• Act as barriers
• Much more flexible
• Guarantee no deadlock
• Dynamically associated with different sets of
  activities

37
Clock Semantics

• Activities register with zero or more clocks
• Can register/unregister at any time
• Clocks are always in some phase
• Do not advance until all currently registered
  activities quiesce
• Activities quiesce with next operation
• Indicates they are ready for all their clocks to
  advance
• Suspends until all clocks have advanced
• This makes deadlock impossible

38
Status

• IBM has supposedly built a single VM reference
  implementation
• Language still under heavy revision
• GPLed X10-XTC compiler available
• Doesnt conform to current language spec
• Uses what will possibly be version 0.5
• Speculatively contains support for operator
  overloading and generics
• Currently very poor performance

39
conclusion

• So is X10 the answer to all our parallel
  programming woes?

40
conclusion

• So is X10 the answer to all our parallel
  programming woes?
• In my opinion probably not.

41
conclusion

• So is X10 the answer to all our parallel
  programming woes?
• In my opinion probably not.
• Parallelism still very explicit. Still
  opportunities for deadlock, race conditions etc.

42
conclusion

• So is X10 the answer to all our parallel
  programming woes?
• In my opinion probably not.
• Parallelism still very explicit. Still
  opportunities for deadlock, race conditions etc.
• Takes a and the kitchen sink approach which
  makes learning the syntax a chore.

43
conclusion

• So is X10 the answer to all our parallel
  programming woes?
• In my opinion probably not.
• Parallelism still very explicit. Still
  opportunities for deadlock, race conditions etc.
• Takes a and the kitchen sink approach which
  makes learning the syntax a chore.
• Its not FORTRAN. Will people bother to use it?