Title: Investment Club:
1- Investment Club
- Stock recommendation Buy CMG
- November 27, 2007
2Agenda
- Conclusions
- Industry highlights
- Stock recommendations
- Summary
- Appendices
3Conclusions and recommendation
- Value prop, execution, and expansion drive
earnings in restaurant industry - Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG) is an A operator
with broadly appealing value proposition - CMG will exceed earnings expectations via
per-restaurant performance and expansion - Valuation risk diminishes with long-term view
- CMG looks overvalued based on short-term metrics
- Long-term expansion potential justifies
short-term valuation risk - Consensus is overly short-termed focused
- The Street is not looking far-enough ahead at the
expansion potential of CMG - The Street is discounting operating leverage in
CMG system - BUY Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG), current price
126 - Price target 175-200
- Upside 40
4Agenda
- Conclusions
- Industry highlights
- Stock recommendations
- Summary
- Appendices
5Restaurants grow profits through per-store
performance and expansion
- Per-store performance
- Pricing power
- Increase in of transactions/visits
- Working capital management
- Quality, service
- Expansion
- Not too much, not too little for capex
- Adequate supporting infrastructure
- Managerial talent
- Inventory management
Investment implication in evaluating restaurant
chains, evaluate per-store performance and
expansion capability
6Value prop and execution drive industry
profitability
Investment implication great restauranters do a
great job selling great food
7Agenda
- Conclusions
- Industry highlights
- Stock recommendation
- Summary
- Appendices
8CMG makes money through restaurant profits and
expansion
- CMG fulfills restaurant-dining niche as gourmet
fast-casual - Business model drives high-quality earnings
- Simple menu, few ingredients ? fast, efficient
service and high throughput - Organically-grown meats and fresh ingredients ?
drives pricing power - Fresh food and mostly-cash or credit transactions
? lowers working capital - CMG will continue to make money by
- Increasing spread of revenue and costs per store
(same-store sales up 12 YTD) - Increasing the of stores (from 667 today to
over 1,000 by 2010)
Healthy
Fast
Investment implication CMG business model drives
operating leverage
9Competitive advantages outweigh risks
Investment implication CMG strengths outweigh
weaknesses
10CMG looks overvalued on short-term metrics
- CMG is more richly valued than peers on a FY
(08) PE, EV/EBITDA (ttm), and EV/restaurant
outlet (ttm) basis - Cash metrics also reveal disparity since CMG is
spending heavily to grow
Investment implication Must focus on long-term
potential to uncover value
11but must forecast long-term performance to
better gauge valuation
Conservative pricing, volume increases, and store
growth assumptions for 2008-2012
Investment implication Conservative assumptions
of the future produce attractive investment
returns
12Price targets show 40 upside
Valuation summary
Investment implication Degree of upside provides
margin of safety
13Consensus myopia provides opportunity
- 2 major points of difference with consensus
- Longevity of forecast I see CMG as the next
great chain - Pace of store expansion and operating leverage in
model
Investment implication Consensus myopia gives us
opportunity with CMG
14Conclusions and recommendation
- Value prop, execution, and expansion drive
earnings in restaurant industry - Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG) is an A operator
with broadly appealing value proposition - CMG will exceed earnings expectations via
per-restaurant performance and expansion - Valuation risk diminishes with long-term view
- Consensus is overly short-termed focused
- BUY Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG), current price
126 - Price target 175-200
- Upside 40
15Agenda
- Conclusions
- Industry highlights
- Stock recommendations
- Summary
- Appendices
16Appendix I Revenue forecast
?conservative pricing, volume increases, and
store growth assumptions for 2008-2012
17Appendix II PE-based valuation
PE-based valuation 189
18Appendix III EV/EBITDA valuation
EV/EBITDA-based valuation 159
19Appendix IV DCF valuation
20Appendix V Comp tables (operating performance)
21Appendix VI CMG table (operating performance)
- Rising gross margins ? pricing power
- Rising operating margins ? operating leverage
- Best-in-class cash conversion cycle ?
self-financed growth - Rising fixed asset turnover ? efficient expansion
and growth - Increasing returns on capital ? CMG is creating
shareholder value
22Appendix VII CMG stock chart
23Appendix VIII US restaurant market is large and
growing
2005 Market size 181B
All major categories show growth
24Appendix IX Americans are spending more eating
out
Two strong trends support CMG 1) rise in
disposable income 2) spend on
restaurants