Research and Education in SSG: New approaches colearning, Feedback and Knowledge Portal Technology I

1
Research and Education in SSG New approaches
(co-learning, Feedback and Knowledge Portal
Technology Integration in Security Education )
NATO ARW Enhancing Security Sector Governance
trough Education and Research, Plovdiv 3-7 June

• Dr. Velizar Shalamanov
• IPP-BAS - Information Security Dept with JTSAC
• www.caxbg.com/is
• Bulgarian Academy of Sciences and
• George C. Marshall Assoc. - Bulgaria

2
Contents

• Security environment
• SECRES-2008 Project results and SECREV-2009
  expectations
• Security Sector Strategic Map
• New approaches for SSG Research and Education

3
Security and Development Environment Sources of
Risks and Lines of Influence
US
NATO
Russia
SEE
Bulgaria
WB
Caucasus
EU
Turkey
China??? India???
4
Geo-pilitical context of defense / security
sector governance
2029
Euro-Atlantic model US, NATO, ?U
Euro-Asia model Russia, China
People
2021
Money
2011
resources
2008
security
2001
1998
1991
1989
5
Temple of SecurityArchitecture Framework for
Security Sector
Security
Operations
RE- SOUR- CES
DO- CU- MENTS
IN- STI- TU-TIONS
CA-PA-BILI-TIES
National and International cooperation /
integration
Democratic Control
Change management
Soft Environment RD, ET, Industry, NGO, PM/SC,

6
Distribution of projects according to the
financing organization
7
Distribution of projects according to the area of
study (there are some projects that cover more
than one area of study and are counted in more
than one area)
8
Distribution of projects according to the
implementation of the concept for the integrated
security sector versus study of the certain
element of the sector
9
Distribution of projects according to the level
of security studied state level, society,
citizen level (incl. 112 ECS)
10
Education and training courses

• Universities
• Defense Staff College
• Academy of MoI
• University of National and World Economy
• Sofia University
• New Bulgarian University
• Varna free university
• others
• SECREV-09 Review of SSG and students knowledge?

• Test Modules in BAS CSDM / JTSAC
• Center for Security Defense Management
• SSG / DIB / BIDE, incl. management of
  organization/project, Capabilities based
  scenario driven planning
• Crisis Management, incl. CIP, Civil Security
• Security Watch Bulletin at www.GCMArshall.bg
• Joint Training Simulation Analysis Center
• Use of OA / CAX in SSG/CM
• IT Governance
• CAX portal www.caxbg.com

??? American University in Bulgaria key
regional educational institution for the SEE,
WBSA is security studies needed there ???
11
Centre for Security and Defence Management

• Security and Defence Policy and Strategy
• Foresight-based, Capabilities-oriented Planning
• Organisational Design and Process Improvement
• Security and Defence Technological and Industrial
  Base
• Critical Infrastructure Protection Civil
  Security
• Information Security
• Good Governance in the Security Sector
  Transparency, Accountability, Integrity
• Knowledge Management and Organisational Learning

12
Joint Training Simulation Analysis Center
(JTSAC)
Mission Be a key partner of the integrated
security sector (ISS) institutions in planning
and analysis process with the help of Operational
Analysis (OA) Computer Assisted eXercises
(CAX). Vision With high-professional team to
support the complete life cycle of OA CAX
projects Strategy Knowledge Technology
integration for strong research development,
education training for the ISS

• Team
• (33 average age of the sc. personnel)
• Dr. Minchev director
• Res. Nikolova res. mngmnt
• Res. Georgiev biofeedback
• Res. Tsenkov risk mngmnt
• Eng. Dukov software engineering
• Eng. Tsankov comms sensors
• Eng. Angelov hardware engineering
• Georgieva admin support
• Sen. Res. Dr. Shalamanov founder/advisor

13
Integrated Security Sector as Strategy Focused
Organization
Mission Security for the citizens, communities,
state and support for social and economic
development Results Success
Organizational and Technology NATO/EU
Integration and in operations
Leadership international
cooperation Key competencies defense,
expeditionary capabilities, air security,
maritime security, border security, public order,
fighting crime, incident/emergency management,
intelligence, security policy Internal
Processes Leadership Good Governance
Change management Analytical Support
Integrity
capacity
capacity Knowledge and
Development People Values Training Recreation
Career Medical Support Housing Social
Integration Research Knowledge
Industrial Reputation Public
Political Budget infrastructure
base
support
14
Key topics

• Air security ASOC / multirole fighter
• Maritime Security - MSOC
• Border security - BBSC
• Public order Association of police chiefs
• Expeditionary operations joint training ranges
• Emergency management and 112 ECS (DPPI)
• Critical infrastructure protection, Energy
  security / climate change
• Reserve forces with National Guard functions
  military support to civilian authorities (MSCA)
  ACT CoE in Bulgaria
• Transparency, Accountability and Integrity
  Building NATO Trust Fund and PAP-DIB
• New challenges
• Common funded regional projects governance /
  management
• NATO-EU centered Security Architecture
  governance and coordination

15
Balance Score Cards for the Integrated Security
Sector
Yesterday
Today
Tomorrow
16
(No Transcript)
17
New approaches based on IT

• Library and documentation center
• Computer Assisted eXercise environment
• Knowledge Management Portal
• Integration of Security / Security Sector Studies
  and IT Studies with focus on Governance and
  Integrity Building for stronger RD and ET Base

18
Library / documentation center and ADL

• Reports of all the security related projects
  (supported by SECRES type projects SECRES -
  2008)
• Course Thesis, Master Thesis, PhD Thesis works in
  SSG/IT (supported by SECREV type projects
  SECREV - 2009)
• Training documentation on the key courses
  resident and distant / ADL (supported by SECTRA
  type projects)
• Selected books / journals on Security (SSG) and
  IT
• Project management / CSDM-JTSAC management
  documentation (part of MANMOD project for BPM of
  the JTSAC)
• Library is supporting RD and ET in security
  area / IT in BAS and is in process of integration
  in the Knowledge Portal

19
CAX environment

• JTSAC was presented in previous ARW and is
  currently further developed as an instrument for
• Co-learning / Video Teleconferences
• Computer Assisted eXercise BEST (basic
  environment for training and simulation)
• Advanced Technology Demonstration environment and
  link with technology projects in C4ISR area
• Feedback and Knowledge Acquisition trough after
  Action Reports and Analysis Lessons Learned
  (feedback mechanisms, including bio-feedback)
  capacity

20
Knowledge Portal

• ISSAC (Integrated Security Sector trough
  Analytical Coordination) project proposal for KP
  on SSG
• Topics
• Security and operations
• Integrated security sector architecture
• Integrated security sector governance
• Integrated security sector management
• Integrated security sector C4ISR
• Change management for the Integrated security
  sector
• Analytical support to the Integrated security
  sector
• Users
• Parliament and President office
• Administration from Security council to the
  directorates / services in MoFA, MoD, MoI, MoES,
  intell services, local authorities
• Industry (security and defense related)
• Academia and research bodies
• Achieve solid base through integration of subject
  area knowledge and IT for building an Integrated
  security sector around its Strategic Map,
  Strategic Initiatives, Balanced Score Cards and
  integrated analytical support of decision making
  process for higher effectiveness, efficiency,
  transparency, accountability Smart, Good and
  Small Governance of the Security Sector

21
Integration of New Technologies in a Creative
Environment for ET / RD on Integrated Security
Sector Change Management
Change Management (Smart Governance)
Process Management and Assessment
Scenario Development and Analysis (MS, DMS)
Capabilities based planning and Good Governance
Concept Development
Basic Environment for Simulation and Training
(incl. ATD)
Environment of sensors and comms with controlled
QoS
AARLL feedback and knowledge acquisition
(incl. bio-feedback)
Knowledge Management Portal
Experimentation
Analytical work / Library
22
ARW to propose ways for improving the existing
models of security education and/or for
consolidating efforts and initiatives

• BAS to develop capacity for sponsor account
  management for integrated security sector,
  industry, NATO (NC3A, RTO) and EU (EDA), regional
  partners (Adriatic Caspian Seas) based on CNSDR
  with key production elements CSDM and JTSAC
• UNWE to develop jointly with BAS an education
  program in Integrated Security Sector Development
  for Administration, Industry and partners from
  NATO, EU, large SEE
• Network around BAS Security RD Center and UNWE
  Security ET Center of research and education
  institutions of MoFA, MoD, MoI, MoES, SA NS, NIS,
  NPS, SC PCI and other elements of the integrated
  security sector to provide reach-out capacity
• National security RD/ET program with
  coordinator in PM Office
• Science consultative committee to the Security
  Council of the Prime Minister
• Consolidated representation in NATO SC, NC3A,
  NATO RTO, NIAG, EDA, EU JRC and FP on theme
  Security
• Joint effort between national network and AUBG in
  cooperation with AUBG Alumni Associations in the
  region in promoting good practices in SSG /
  Public Sector Governance