Title: Attachment Disordered Children with Fetal Alcohol and Drug Exposure
1Attachment Disordered Children with Fetal Alcohol
and Drug Exposure
- Lois A. Pessolano Ehrmann PhD, LPC, CAC-
Diplomate - Registered ATTACh Therapist
-
- Carol McFall M.Ed. LPC, CAC
- Outpatient Therapist
- Counseling Alternatives Group
- 444 East College Avenue, Suite 460
- State College, PA 16801
- (814) 231-0940
2Spider Web Walking
3Learning Objectives
- Review the neurological deficits or impairments
in this population. - Strategies to support and guide parents in
understanding behaviors and issues. - Treatment strategies specific to this population.
4Overview of Presentation
- Introductory Remarks
- Definitions and concepts
- Current Models of FASDs.
- Incidences of FASDs in US foster and adopted
children and in adopted children from foreign
countries. - Signs and Symptoms
- Visible versus invisible
- Attachment versus FASD versus Complex Trauma
- FASD versus true ADHD versus PTSD versus LDs
- Some Helpful Strategies, Tools and Resources
5What is FASD?
- Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder refers to a
constellation of physical and mental birth
defects that may develop in individuals whose
birth mothers consumed alcohol during pregnancy.
(Duquette et al., 2006) - Ethanol freely crosses the placenta, thus
directly affecting developing fetal cells and
tissues. (Niccols, 2007) - Alcohol as are other drugs as well is a teratogen.
6History
- First reference to adverse effects of alcohol on
the fetus - Beware and drink no wine or strong drinkfor lo,
you shall conceive and bear a son. (Judges 134,
5) - First scientific study
- Sullivan 1899 increased rate of still-birth and
infant death in children of alcoholic women - 1940s Haggard and Jellinek concluded that the
developmental abnormalities of children born to
alcoholic mothers were secondary to the
environment in which they were raised. - 1950s and 1960s French studies identified
children of alcoholic mothers as having
malformations, growth deficiency, and psychomotor
disturbances (Lamache, 1967 Lemoine, Harousseau,
Borteryu, Menuet, 1968 as cited in Niccols,
2007). No one really paid too much attention. - 1970s interest in the adverse effects of alcohol
increased and concern about alcohol as a
teratogen was mentioned. Streissguth, now an
famous researcher in the field of FASDs started
researching the patterns of malformation that
occurred in children born to alcoholic mothers
who drank while they were pregnant and the tern
Fetal Alcohol Syndrome was coined. - 1980s-the new millennium in 2008 there have been
hundreds of investigations identifying the risks
and consequences of consuming alcohol during
pregnancy and these reports have been
supplemented by animal experimental study as
well. Streissguth (1997) in her book Fetal
Alcohol Syndrome reports on her most
comprehensive well know study. - Lots of studies have looked at the
characteristics of children prenatally exposed
and new brain imaging technologies have really
helped to link brain effects to behavioral
expressions or manifestations. - Very few studies on how to assist persons who
have been exposed.
7Current Model and Conceptions of Fetal Alcohol
Spectrum Disorders
- From animal studies (rats)
- Investigations on children, adolescents and
adults with known histories of maternal use
during pregnancy including post-mortem
evaluations - In last 10 years greatly prolific due to new
technologies in fMRIs, SPECT scans and other
neuro-imaging procedures.
8FASDs
PAE
FAS
PFAS
ARND
FAE
Death
ARBD
38 of all individuals who have a FASD have the
physical craniofacial features which means that
62 do not!
9Facial Anomalies
From Wattendorf et al., (2005)
10Examples of Variability
11The Faces of Persons who have Fetal Alcohol
Syndrome
12People who have FASD
13Diagnosis of Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders
- Fetal Alcohol Syndrome
- (American Academy of Pediatrics,
2000) - Confirmed maternal alcohol consumption
- Growth deficiency
- Specific patterns of anomalies
- Central nervous system abnormalities
- FAS Diagnostic and Prevention Network (2004)
- 4 digit code of all FASDs
14Prevalence of FASD in the US Population
Statistics on FASD in US For full blown FAS CDC
0.2-1.5/1000 births Other Studies
suggest 0.5-2.0 per 1000 births For all
FASD Researches believe all FASDs are 4Xs the
prevalence of FAS. 10 per 1000 births or 1 of
the US population UDHHS (2007) 40,000 newborns
a year meet the criteria for a FASD. High Risk
US Populations Native Alaska 3.0-5.6 per 1000
births Native American 9-10 per 1000
births Source NIAAA May Gossage retrieved
2008
15Prevalence of Prenatal Drug Exposure
- Chasnoff (1989) 11 of all newborns,
approximately 459,690 are exposed prenatally each
year. - Gomby Shiono (1991) 739, 000 women use illicit
drugs during pregnancy every year. - Schipper (1991) A substance exposed infant is
born more frequently than once ever 90 seconds.
16FASD and Prenatal Drug Exposure Incidences in US
Foster/Adopted Children
About our Children Not much is known. Wedding
et al., (2007) psychologist did not have
accurate understanding about FASDs, danger of
alcohol use in pregnancy. Peadon et al., (2008)
Very few places do accurate diagnosis of FASDs
and most are located in North America. What is
follows Foster Children study in Washington
State. Astley, Stachowiak, Clarren, Clausen
(2002) FAS 10-15 times higher than in the
general population Mayet et al., (1983),
Streissguth et al., (1985) estimated that 73 to
80 of all children in US foster care or placed
for adoption have full blown FAS. Ehrmann (2006)
found that 28 of adopted children out of the US
foster care system were exposed to alcohol
prenatally and 47 were exposed to some illicit
drug prenatally.
17Adopted Children from Foreign Countries
Eastern Europe 15 per 1000 births Extrapolated
to approximately 21,000 children born with FASD
each year Source Orphan Doctor _at_
www.orphandoctor.com
18Risk Factors
- Dose of alcohol
- Pattern of exposure
- Binge versus chronic
- Developmental timing
- Of exposure
- Genetic variation
- Maternal characteristics
- Synergistic reactions with
- other drugs
- Interaction with nutritional
- variables
19Dosage Effect
Source Larry Burd, PhD North Dakota Fetal
Alcohol Syndrome Center 501 N. Columbia
Road Grand Forks, ND 58203
20Dosage Example
21Developmental Timing of Exposure
22The Rest of The StoryStreissguth and Colleagues
- Primary Disabilities
- Lower IQ
- Impaired ability in reading, spelling, and
arithmetic - Lower level of adaptive functioning more
significantly impaired than IQ
23Typical Disabilities
- Typical Disabilities
- Sensory Integration Issues
- Are overly sensitive to sensory input
- Upset by bright lights or loud noises
- Annoyed by tags in shirts or seams in socks
- Bothered by certain textures of food
- Have problems sensing where their
body is in space (i.e., clumsy)
24Typical Disabilities Continued
- Memory Problems
- Working memory
- Multiplication
- Time sequencing
- Information Processing Problems
- Do not complete tasks or chores and may appear to
be oppositional - Have trouble determining what to do in a given
situation - Do not ask questions because they want to fit in
- Say they understand when they do not
- Have verbal expressive skills that often exceed
their level of understanding - Misinterpret others words, actions, or body
movements - Have trouble following multiple directions
25Typical Disabilities Continued
- Executive Function Problems
- Go with strangers
- Repeatedly break the rules
- Do not learn from mistakes or natural
consequences - Frequently do not respond to point, level, or
sticker systems - Have trouble with time and money
- Give in to peer pressure
- Cannot entertain themselves
- Trouble shifting from task to task
- Attention issues
- Self-Esteem and Personal Issues
- Function unevenly in school, work, and
development - Experience multiple losses
- Are seen as lazy, uncooperative, and unmotivated
- Have hygiene problems
- Do not accurately pick up social cues
26Typical Disabilities Continued
- Hearing, speech and language
- Due to craniofacial abnormalities of FAS
- Cleft palate
- Otitis media with effusion and conductive hearing
loss - Voice dysfunction, articulation disorders
- Speech and language delays
- Language abilities seem lower than would be
expected given child IQ
27Typical Disabilities Continued
- Social Development Issues
- Atypical attachment behavior and impairment in
state regulation - Outgoing, socially engaging, affectionate and
excessively friendly - Preschoolers tend not to appear to differentiate
familiar from unfamiliar - Studies citing parental and teacher reports
indicate arrested social development rather than
delayed social development - Deficits in Theory of Mind (TOM)
28Secondary Disabilities
- Mental health issues
- Disrupted school experience
- Trouble with the law
- They lie (Rasmussen, Talwar, Loomes, Andrew
(2008) - Inappropriate sexual behavior
- Confinement in jail or treatment facilities
- Alcohol and drug problems
- Dependent living
- Employment problems
29Percentage of Persons with FAS or FAE that had
Secondary Disabilities
? Age 6 ? Age 12 ? Age 21
30FASDs and the Brain
31Alcohol Affects the Brain
Source Teaching Students with Fetal Alcohol
Spectrum Disorders Florida State University
Center for Prevention and Early
Intervention Policy (2005)
32Brain Structure and Function Studies
- Damage depends on the state of embryological
development - Conception to first weeks of prenatal
development - cytotoxic or mutagenic
- 4-10 weeks after conception
- Excessive cell death in the CNS and abnormal
nerve cell migration - Disorganization of tissue structure and
microcephaly - 8-10 weeks and on
- Disorganization and or delay in cell migration
and development - Third Trimester
- Damage to the cerebellum, hippocampus, and
prefrontal cortex
33Continuum of Brain Dysfunction
Source Larry Burd, PhD North Dakota Fetal
Alcohol Syndrome Center 501 N. Columbia
Road Grand Forks, ND 58203
34Before Birth
- Low growth rate due to suppression of growth
hormone in hypothalamus - Increases HPA activity and disrupts hormonal
interactions between maternal and fetal systems
affecting the development of fetal metabolic,
physiologic and endocrine functions - Disrupts synaptogenesis causing neurons to commit
suicide (die by apoptosis) on a massive scale
35Disrupted Synapsogenesis
36Early Development
- HPA disruptions result in high basal and post
stress corticol levels - Hyper-responsiveness to stress and immune system
vulnerabilities - High levels of irritability and feeding and
sleeping problems - As preschoolers short, skinny children with
butterflylike movements who are hyperactive
and/or excessively friendly and fearless
(Streissguth Giunta, 1988). - Developmental delays, language issues and poor
motor coordination are also noted during this
period of development
37Hippocampus in the Human Brain
38Hippocampus
- Plays a major role in
- Short term memory
- Spatial navigation
- In a MRI study Rijkonen, Salonen, Partanen,
Verho (1999) found that children with FAS have
smaller left hippocampus volume then right and
this is associated with memory deficits.
39Hypothalamus in the Human Brain
40Hypothalamus
- The Hypothalamus does the following
- Hormone regulation and metabolic processes
- Linking of nervous system to the endocrine system
via the pituitary gland - Controls hunger, thirst, body temperature,
fatigue, anger, circadian cycles and sexual drive
and is part of fight/flight/freeze - Suppression of growth hormone controlled by
Hypothalamus happens in children with FASD. - Dysregulation
41Basal Ganglia in the Human Brain
42Basal Ganglia
- A group of nuclei/interconnected in healthy
individuals brains with the cerebral cortex,
thalamus and brain stem. - Responsible for
- Motor control
- Cognition
- Emotions
- Learning
- MRI studies show disproportionate reductions in
basal ganglia volume in children with FAS and FAE
especially in the caudate nucleus which is
involved in higher cognitive functions and
connected neuronally to the frontal lobes where
executive functioning resides (Archibald et al.,
2001). - PET studies reveal reduced metabolic activity in
the caudate nucleus in high functioning
adolescents and adults with FAS (Clark et al.,
2000).
43The Corpus Callosum
44Corpus Callosum
- What does it do?
- Connects the left and right hemispheres of the
brain - Consists of 200- 250 million contralateral axonal
projections - Inter-hemispheric communication
- Abnormalities in individuals with FAS including
agenesis and thinning in the anterior and
posterior regions. - Displacement of the isthmus and splenium related
to deficits in verbal learning.
45Corpus Callosum in the Human Brain
A. Magnetic resonance imaging showing the side
view of a 14-year-old control subject with a
normal corpus callosum B. 12-year-old with FAS
and a thin corpus callosum C. 14-year-old with
FAS and agenesis (absence due to abnormal
development) of the corpus callosum. Source
Mattson, S.N. Jernigan, T.L. and Riley, E.P.
1994. MRI and prenatal alcohol exposure Images
provide insight into FAS. Alcohol Health
Research World 18(1)4952.
46Alcohol Effects of Corpus Callosum
These two images are of the brain of a 9-year-old
girl with FAS. She has agenesis of the corpus
callosum, and the large dark area in the back of
her brain above the cerebellum is essentially
empty space. Source Mattson, S.N. Jernigan,
T.L. and Riley, E.P. 1994. MRI and prenatal
alcohol exposure Images provide insight into
FAS. Alcohol Health Research World 18(1)4952.
47Cerebellum in the Human Brain
48Cerebellum
- Responsible for
- Integration of neural pathways between cerebellum
and cerebral motor cortex - Motor skills
- Balance, coordination
- Learning in terms of attention and language and
music processing - Sensory perception/ proprioceptive feedback
- For individuals with FASDs
- Reductions in cerebellar volume specifically in
the anterior vermis. - Reductions are linked to dyslexia
- Jacobson et al., (2008)
- Eye blink conditioning is a cerebellular-mediated
Pavlovian conditioning paradigm that involves
contingent temporal pairing of conditioned
stimulus (tone) with an unconditioned stimulus
(brief air puff to the eye that elicits a
reflexive blink). Children with FASD are impaired
in this response indicating that the cerebellum
and brain stem areas are highly affected by
alcohol prenatally. This procedure could help in
diagnosis and treatment intervention.
49Frontal Lobes
50Other Anomalies
- EEG readings (Kaneko et al., 1996)
- Atypical in approximately 50 of the children and
adolescents with FASD - Reductions in the power of the left H alpha
frequencies suggesting less mature brain
activity. - Prolonged latency in P300 spikes in parietal
cortex suggesting deficits in information
processing.
51Other Anomalies Continued
- Too much grey matter
- Not enough white matter
- Similar metabolic activity in both hemispheres
when it is supposed to be different - Too much blood in the right frontal region which
is characteristic of children with executive
function problems
52Interventions What will Help?
- Lots of studies on characteristics and brain
differences - Not a lot of studies on intervention efficacy or
outcome
53Premji et al., 2006
- Only three intervention studies out of ten had
the rigor needed required to support efficacy. - Conclusion There is limited scientific evidence
upon which to draw recommendations regarding
efficacious interventions for children and youth
with a Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder.
Clinicians, researchers, service providers,
educators, policy makers, affected children and
youth and their families and others need to
urgently collaborate to develop a comprehensive
research agenda for this population.
54Common Co-occurring/Misdiagnoses of FASD
- ADD
- ADHD
- ODD
- RAD
- LD
- Speech and language delay
- PDD
- Developmental Receptive Language Disorder
- Sensory Integration Dysfunction
- Conduct Disorder, Seriously Emotionally Disturbed
- Borderline Personality Disorder
- Antisocial Personality Disorder
- Autism, Aspergers
55Misdiagnosis
- ADHD
- Hausknecht et al., (2006)
- Rats exposed prenatally to alcohol have attention
deficits similar to children with FASD ADHD. - Mattson et al., (2006)
- Children with FASDs have pervasive deficits in
visual focused attention and deficits in
maintaining auditory attention over time but no
deficits in the ability to disengage and reengage
attention with required to shift attention
between visual and auditory stimuli although
reaction times to shift were slower
56Misdiagnosis
- FASD versus ODD
- FASD Versus RAD
- FASD Versus Autism Spectrum Disorder
57Protective Factors
- Stable home
- Early diagnosis
- No violence against oneself
- More than 2.8 years in each living
- situation
- Recognized disabilities
- Diagnosis of FAS
- Good quality home from
- ages 8 to 12
- Basic needs met for at least
- 3/4th of the persons life
58Helpful Strategies for Parents
- Education that helps parents
- distinguish between I wont
- and I cant in their children.
- Parents have to think
- younger
- SELF Led Parenting helping
- parents to discover their
- own triggers and then
- resolving them.
- Respite in either direction
- Support groups.
59Helping a Child with FASD
- Graefe (2003)
- The 4 Ss C
- Structure, Supervision, Simplicity, Steps
-
- Context
60Strategies for Children with FASD
Working Memory Issues Yellow Stickies. What did
Ben do well today? Take a picture of the sand
tray. Bilateral Stimulation to keep something in
memory. IEP at school to accommodate this as a
brain based issue due to permanent impairment
from fetal alcohol exposure. External memory
reminders
61Example External Memory Reminders
62Chore Check List Example
63Strategies for Helping Children with FASD
Problems with Cause and Effect Let natural
consequences happen as long as they are not
dangerous or deadly. Writing for Greater Self
Knowledge Exercise Sheets Choices Have
Consequences EMDR protocol
64More Strategies
- Behavioral offenses
- ALWAYS have the child make amends in a concrete
physical way. - Teach for habituation rather then understanding
- Time management
- Describe time in TV episodes
- Affect Regulation
- Resource development with bilateral stimulation
- Deep breathing and body signal awareness
- Mindfulness techniques
- Drumming
- Self calming or self soothing strategies
- Find a nook or cranny for the child to tuck in.
- For motor coordination and self-esteem
- Feather exercise
65Resources
- SAMHSA FASD Center for Excellence
fasdcenter.samhsa.gov - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention FAS
Prevention Team www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/fas - National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and
Alcoholism (NIAAA) www.niaaa.nih.gov/ - National Organization on Fetal Alcohol Syndrome
(NOFAS) www.nofas.org - National Clearinghouse for Alcohol and Drug
Information ncadi.samhsa.gov - Diagnostic Guide for Fetal Alcohol Spectrum
Disorders The 4-Digit Diagnostic Code Third
Edition (2004) - http//depts.washington.edu/fasdpn
- These sites link to many other Web sites.
66References
- American Academy of Pediatrics. (2000). Fetal
alcohol syndrome and alcohol related
neurodevelopmental - disorders. Pediatrics, 106(2), 358-361.
- Astley, S., Stachowiak, J., Clarren, S.,
Clausen, C. (2002). Application of the fetal
alcohol syndrome facial photographic screening
tool in a foster care popuLation. Journal of
Pediatrics, 141(5), 712-717. - Barr, H., Streissguth, A., Darby, B., Sampson,
P. (1990). Prenatal exposure to alcohol,
caffeine, tobacco and aspirin Effects on fine
and gross motor performance in 4-year old
children. Developmental Psychology, 26(3),
339-348. - Bennett, D., Bendersky, M., Lewis, M. (2008).
Childrens cognitive ability from 4 to 9 years
old as a function of prenatial cocaine exposure,
environmental risk, and maternal verbal
intelligence. Developmental Psychology, 44(4),
919-928. - Bishop, S., Gahagan, S., Lord, C. (2007).
Re-examining the core features of autism a
comparison of autism spectrum disorder and fetal
alcohol spectrum disorder. Journal of Child
Psychology and Psychiatry, 48(11), 1111-1121. - Chasnoff, I. (1989). Drug use in women
Establishing a standard of care. Annals of the
New York Academy of Science, 562, 208-210. - Dean, R., Davis, A. (2007). Relative risk of
perinatal complications in common childhood
disorders. School Psychology Quarterly, 22(1),
13-25. - Duquette, C., Stodel, E., Fullarton, S.,
Hagglund, K. (2006). Persistance in high school
Experiences of adolescents and young adults with
fetal alcohol spectrum disorder. Journal of
Intellectual and Developmental Disability, 31(4),
219-231.
67References Continued
- FAS Diagnostic and Prevention Network. (2004).
Diagnostic guide for fetal alcohol spectrum
disorders The 4-digit diagnotic code (third
edition). Washington University of Washington. - Gomby, D. Shiono, P. (1991). Estimating the
number of substance exposed infants. The Future
of Children Adoption, 1(1), 17. - Hausknecht, K., Acheson, A., Farrar, A., Kieres,
A., Shen, R., Richards, J., Sabol, K. (2005).
Prenatal alcohol exposure causes attention
deficits in male rats. Behavioral Neuroscience,
119(1), 302-310. - Jacobson, S., Stanton, M., Molteno, C., Burden,
M. et al., (2008). Impaired eyeblink conditioning
in children with fetal alcohol syndrome.
Alcoholism Clinical and Experimental Research,
32(2), 365-372. - Kable, J., Coles, C., Taddeo, E. (2007).
Socio-cognitive habilitation using the math
interactive learning experience program for
alcohol affected children. Alcoholism Clinical
and Experimental Research, 31(8), 1425-1434. - Kalberg, W., Buckley, D. (2007). FASD what
types of intervention and rehabilitation are
useful? Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews,
31, 278-285. - Lawrence, R., Bonner, H., Newsom, R., Kelly, S.
(2008). Effects of alcohol exposure during
development on play behavior and c-Fos expression
in response to play behavior. Behavioral Brain
Research, 188, 209-218. - Mattson, S., Calarco, K., Lang, A. (2006).
Focused and shifting attention in children with
heavy prenatal alcohol exposure. Neuropsychology,
20(3), 361-369. - Niccols, A. (2007). Fetal alcohol syndrome and
the developing socio-emotional brain. Brain and
Cognition, 65, 135-142. - OConnor, M., Frankel, F., paley, B., Schonfeld,
A., Carpenter, E., Laugeson, E., Marquardt, R.
(2006). A controlled social skills training for
children with fetal alcohol spectrum disorders.
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,
74(4), 639-648.
68References Continued
- Peadon, E., fremantle, E., Bower, C., Elliott,
E. (2008). International survey of diagnostic
services for children with fetal alcohol spectrum
disorders. BMC Pediatrics, 8(12), 1-8. - Premji, S., Benzies, K., Serrett, K., Hayden,
K.A. (2006). Research-based interventions for
children and youth with a fetal alcohol spectrum
disorder Revealing the gap. Child Care, Health
and Development, 33(4), 389-397. - Rasmussen, C., Talwar, V., Loomes, C., Andrew,
G. (2008). Brief report Lie-telling in children
with fetal alcohol spectrum disorder. Journal of
Pediatric Psychology, 33(2), 220-226. - Schipper, W. (1991). Testimony before the U.S.
House of Representatives Select Committee on
Narcotics Abuse and Control. Retrieved from
http//www.statistics .adoption.com - Seigal, D. (1999). The developing mind. NY
Guildford Press. - Siegal, D. (2007). The mindful brain Reflection
and attunement in the cultivation of well-being.
NY W.W. Norton Co. - Streissguth, A., Kanter, K. (1997). The
challenge of fetal alcohol syndrome Overcoming
secondary disabilities. Washington University of
Washington Press. - Wattendorf, D., maj, U., Muenke, M. (2005). Fetal
alcohol spectrum disorders. American Family
Physician, 72(2), 279-285. - Wedding, D., Kohout, J., Mengel, M., Ohlemiller,
M., Ulione, M., Cook, K.., Rudeen, K.,
Braddock, S. (2007). Psychologists knowledge and
attitudes about fetal alcohol syndrome, fetal
alcohol spectrum disorders, and alcohol use
during pregnancy. Professional Psychology
Research and Practice, 38(2), 208-211.