NEMO: Requirements Analysis draft-eddy-nemo-aero-reqs-02.txt draft-baldessari-c2ccc-nemo-req-01.txt draft-ng-nemo-ce-req-01.txt - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Title: NEMO: Requirements Analysis draft-eddy-nemo-aero-reqs-02.txt draft-baldessari-c2ccc-nemo-req-01.txt draft-ng-nemo-ce-req-01.txt


1
NEMO Requirements Analysisdraft-eddy-nemo-aero-r
eqs-02.txtdraft-baldessari-c2ccc-nemo-req-01.txt
draft-ng-nemo-ce-req-01.txt
2
List of Requirements
Aeronautics C2CCC CE
Req1 Separability Ability to bypass RO for some traffic Req1 Separability Ability to bypass RO for some traffic Req1 Unmodified LFN LFN must not be modified
Req2 Multihoming Ability to use multiple access networks Req2 MNN IPSec Ability for MNN to use IPSec for RO traffic Req2 Processing Load No excessive processing for MR
Req3 Latency Must not block unoptimized flow Req3 RO Security NO falsely claim MNP ownership Req3 Security NO falsely claim MNP ownership NO tricking MR to send large packets
Req4 Availability No single point of failure Req4 Privacy Protection Reveal MNP to only selected nodes
Req5 Packet Loss No additional packet loss due to RO Req5 Multihoming Ability to use multiple access networks
Req6 Scalability Ability to handle 10,000 nodes Req6 Sub-IP RO Coexistence Ability to choose NEMO-RO or sub-IP RO
Req7 Efficient Signaling Minimal additional signaling
Req8 Security Ability to use IPSec over RO Data used for RO decision authenticable
Req9 Adaptability Work for new applications/protocols
3
Aeronautics Perspective
Aeronautics C2CCC CE
Req1 Separability Ability to bypass RO for some traffic Req1 identical Missing no conflict, probably can add to the draft
Req2 Multihoming Ability to use multiple access networks Req5 identical Missing no conflict, probably can add to the draft
Req3 Latency Must not block unoptimized flow Missing no conflict Missing no conflict
Req4 Availability No single point of failure Missing no conflict Missing no conflict
Req5 Packet Loss No additional packet loss due to RO Missing no conflict Missing no conflict
Req6 Scalability Ability to handle 10,000 nodes Missing no conflict Missing no conflict, probably not necessary
Req7 Efficient Signaling Minimal additional signaling Missing no conflict Req2 - implied
Req8 Security Ability to use IPSec over RO Data used for RO decision authenticable Req2, Req3 Req3 cover ROs security, not MNNs use of IPSec
Req9 Adaptability Work for new applications/protocols Req6 somewhat similar with coexistence Req1 somewhat similar with unmodified LFN
4
C2CCC Perspective
Aeronautics C2CCC CE
Req1 identical Req1 Separability Ability to bypass RO for some traffic Missing no conflict, probably can add to the draft
Req8 in part Req2 MNN IPSec Ability for MNN to use IPSec for RO traffic Missing no conflict, probably can add to the draft
Req8 in part Req3 RO Security NO falsely claim MNP ownership Req3
Missing no conflict Req4 Privacy Protection Reveal MNP to only selected nodes Missing no conflict
Req2 identical Req5 Multihoming Ability to use multiple access networks Missing no conflict, probably can add to the draft
Missing probably not applicable Req6 Sub-IP RO Coexistence Ability to choose NEMO-RO or sub-IP RO Missing probably not applicable
5
CE Perspective
Aeronautics C2CCC CE
Missing maybe similar to Req9 (Adaptability) Missing maybe similar to Req6 (Coexistence), Req2 (MNNs IPSec) Req1 Unmodified LFN LFN must not be modified
Missing maybe similar to Req7 (Efficient Signaling) Missing no conflict Req2 Processing Load No excessive processing for MR
Req8 in part, no DoS part Req3 no DoS part Req3 Security NO falsely claim MNP ownership NO tricking MR to send large packets
6
List of Desired Features
Aeronautics C2CCC CE
Des1 Configuration Simple to configure Des1 MR-to-MR RO for MR-to-MR
Des2 Nesting Nesting of NEMOs Des2 Nested-NEMO RO RO for Nested NEMO
Des3 System Impact Lower complexity Des3 IntraNEMO RO RO within a merged NEMO
Des4 VMN Support Allow RO for VMNs
Des5 Generality Single solution for Aero, Automotive, CE
7
Comparison of Desired Features
Aeronautics C2CCC CE
Des1 Configuration Simple to configure Missing Missing Probably needed
Des2 Nesting Nesting of NEMOs Missing Des2
Des3 System Impact Lower complexity Missing Missing Probably not needed
Des4 VMN Support Allow RO for VMNs Missing Missing Probably PMR as a VMN instead of allowing VMN
Des5 Generality Single solution for Aero, Automotive, CE Missing Missing
Aeronautics C2CCC CE
Missing is there plane to plane communications? Missing probably use SubIP Des1 MR-to-MR RO for MR-to-MR
Des2 Missing Des2 Nested-NEMO RO RO for Nested NEMO
Missing Missing Des3 IntraNEMO RO RO within a merged NEMO