Title: Purchasing and Supply Chain Management, 3e MonczkaTrentHandfield
1Contract ManagementChapter 14
Purchasing and Supply Chain Management
2Chapter Overview
- This chapter addresses contracting from several
perspective. - The different types of contracts available to
purchasing managers are discussed. - The benefits of long-term contracts and alliance
agreements are presented.
3Chapter Overview
- Unique contracts and basic requirements of
writing contracts are addressed. - The chapter concludes with the issue of
contractual disputes.
4Types of Contracts
- Purchasing contracts can be classified into
categories based on their characteristics and
purpose. - Almost all purchasing contracts are based on some
form of pricing mechanism. - The two basic types based on price mechanisms
fixed-price and cost based contracts.
5Types of Contracts
- Firm fixed price Price stated in the agreement
does not change, regardless of any type of
environmental change. - Fixed price with escalation/de-escalation Base
prices can increase or decrease based on specific
identifiable changes in material prices.
6Types of Contracts
- Fixed price with re-determination Initial
target price based on best-guess estimates of
labor and materials, then renegotiated once a
specific level or volume of production is
reached. - Fixed price with incentives Initial target
price based on best-guess estimates of labor and
materials, then cost savings due to supplier
initiatives are shared at a predetermined rate
for a designated period.
7Types of Contracts
- Cost plus incentive fee Base price is based on
allowable supplier costs, and any cost savings
are shared between the buyer and supplier based
on a predetermined rate for a designated time
period. - Cost sharing Actual allowable costs are shared
between parties on a predetermined percentage
basis and may include cost productivity
improvement goals.
8Types of Contracts
- Time and materials contract Supplier is paid
for all labor and materials according to a
specified labor, overhead, profit, and material
rate. - Cost plus fixed fee Supplier receives
reimbursement for all allowable costs up to a
predetermined amount, plus a fixed fee, which is
the percentage of the targeted cost of the good
or service.
9Considerations When Selecting a Contract Type
- Issues to consider when determining the
appropriate type of contract - Market uncertainty
- Industry practices
- Desired length of the agreement
- Outcomes sought from the agreement
10Considerations When Selecting a Contract Type
- Issues to consider when determining the
appropriate type of contract (contd) - Relationship between contracting parties
- Process or technological uncertainty
- Suppliers impact on cost or other performance
variables - Total dollar value of the agreement
11Long-Term Contracts
- Industrial buying contracts often classified
based on length of contract term. - Spot Contracts non-recurring limited basis.
- Short-term Contracts routinely made over
limited time horizon one year or less. - Long-term Contracts continuing basis for a
specified or indefinite time exceeds one year.
12Long-Term Contracts
- Benefits of Long-Term Contracts
- Assurance of Supply
- Access to Supplier Technology
- Access to Cost/Price Information
- Volume Leveraging
- Supplier Receives Better Information for Planning
13Long-Term Contracts
- Risks of Long-Term Contracts
- Supplier Opportunism
- Selecting the Wrong Supplier
- Supplier Volume Uncertainty
- Supplier Foregoes Other Business
- Buyer is Unreasonable
14Long-Term Contracts
- Contingency Elements of Long-Term Contracts
- Initial Price Must be set at a level that will
be beneficial for the buyer yet motivate the
seller to perform. - Price-Adjustment Mechanisms - An appropriate
index must be selected to gauge price adjustments
against.
15Long-Term Contracts
- Contingency Elements of Long-Term Contracts
- Supplier Performance Improvements Long-term
contracts can be an incentive for suppliers to
improve over time. - Evergreen, Penalty, and Escape Clauses These
elements in contracts can ensure longevity as
well as termination when desired.
16Nontraditional Contracting
- IT Systems Contracts
- Also known as systems outsourcing, IT Systems
Contracts are designed to provide access to
expensive computer networks and software that
single companies couldnt afford on their own. - I.e. SAP, Oracle, IBM, and EDS
- Other systems and services outsourced include
facilities management services, research and
development, logistics and distribution, and
accounting.
17Nontraditional Contracting
- Minority-owned Supplier Contracts
- Minority owned supplier is defined as having a
minimum 51 ownership by minorities such as
African American, Hispanic Americans, Native
Americans, or Asian-Pacific Americans. - Women-owned businesses and firms owned by
physically disabled people are separate classes
of firms with unique designations.
18Nontraditional Contracting
- Consulting Contracts
- In writing contracts for consulting services it
is important to remember the person is an agent
for your organization not an employee. - As such, the consultant retains ownership of any
intellectual properties developed during the
consultation.
19Nontraditional Contracting
- Consulting Contracts
- Language must be written into the contract
specifying that the intellectual property shared
remains with the buyer. - The development of a standard contract template
for all consulting services will help ensure the
buyer get the most protection from the contract.
20Nontraditional Contracting
- Construction Contracts
- Construction contracts are often the result of a
lengthy bid process. - The contract process can be lengthy as well
buyers should consider the following - Bid submissions should include a breakdown of the
total price into different costs by type, phase,
or area. - Safety requirements should be part of the
construction contract. - Penalties for cost overruns, delays, etc. should
be included in the contract.
21Other Types of Contracts
- Purchasing Agreement
- Agreements that group similar items together for
procurement. - The results are less paperwork, lower costs, and
leveraging of volume of business.
22Other Types of Contracts
- Purchasing Agreement
- Variations of purchasing agreements
- Annual Contract
- National Contract
- Corporate Agreement
- National buying agreements
- Blanket Order
- Pricing Agreements
- Open-ended order
23Other Types of Contracts
- Online Catalogs and E-Commerce Contracts
- Electronic commerce further reduces
administrative overhead. - Automated online catalogs allow users to buy
directly from national contracts.
24Settling Contractual Disputes
- Action Description
- Legal action File a lawsuit in court
- Non-legal actions
- Arbitration Use of impartial third party to
- settle dispute.
- Mediation Intervention of third party to
- promote a settlement.
-
25Settling Contractual Disputes
- Action Description
- Non-legal actions
- Minitrial Exchange of information,
followed by negotiations - between managers of each
-
organization. - Rent-a-judge Neutral party conducts trial
- and is responsible for final
- decision.
26Settling Contractual Disputes
- Action Description
- Non-legal actions
- Dispute A progressive schedule of
- prevention negotiation, mediation,
- arbitration, and legal proceedings
agreed to in the - contract.
27Settling Contractual Disputes
- Factors to consider in selecting
dispute-resolution mechanism. - Status of relationship between parties.
- Outcome desired by purchaser.
- Desired speed in obtaining resolution.
- Quicker resolution is generally cheaper.
- Courtrooms are more public.