Title: SG3_200201_271_PalomarPres.doc
1Palomar ISO 18000-6 WD submission presented
by Ulrich Friedrich, Atmel Germany GmbH email
ulrich.friedrich_at_atmel-wm.com
2- Overview
- What is Palomar
- The consortium
- Application requirements
- Frequencies, regulations
- The link
- Data management
- Conclusion
3The project framework of Palomar - IST-1999-10339
PAssive based on backscatter technique, no
battery LOng range up to 4 meters in an
anechoic chamber single dipole antenna _at_
tag Multiple Access Anticollision high
frequency RFID UHF considering the -
European regulations - on-going discussions
about world-wide regulations
4Who is behind Palomar ?
- VTT
- research institute specialised on RF and
microwave, Finland - Idesco (Owner Polar Group, Finland)
- interface to industrial applications in paper
mill - development of reader modules, Finland
- Rafsec (Owner UPM-Kymmene Group, Finland)
- interface to paper mill industry
- Label assembly technology based on flip chip,
Finland - Atmel Nantes (Atmel Corp. headquartered in San
Jose, CA) - RF circuit development based on 0.5 u CMOS
technology - production of transponder ICs, France
- Atmel Germany (Atmel Corp. headquartered in San
Jose, CA) - project leadership
- transponder IC development, Germany
5Where we are ?
- Based on the RFID, RF and application know how
inside the consortium we have started in 2000 to
combine the competence aiming an European answer
for global SCM solutions - Palomar1 system (OSI 1 to 3) is currently under
test - 4 m in an anechoic arrangement (868 MHz and 0.5W
ERP) is a realistic target - Palomar2 system (based on Palomar1) is under
development - Palomar2 silicon is scheduled for springtime 2002
6SCM(N) solution
SCM - host
SCM server (gate)
SCM - host
company network wired / wireless several levels
server
wired bus / wireless
RFID system
RFID system
tags - low cost minimum feature tags - high
cost tags
reader - fixed reader
- hand held reader
7Data in a Supply Chain Management (Network)
- SCM
- UID
- information about the next steps in the chain
- (brand protection)
- expanded SCM
- ID containing an UID (licence plate)
- tracking data
- (brand protection)
- SCMN
- same as in the expanded SCM
- security features against reading (guaranty,
several companies are inside, ...) - security features for brand protection
8Fundamental needs of the applications
- added value
- long range feasibility considering local RF
regulations - stationary reader
- hand held reader low(er) power consumption
- low cost feasibility for low end tags
- family concept of readers and tags
- minimum protocol
- minimum features
- expandable features and protocol solutions
- security
- longer communication ranges
- user defined functions
- world wide accepted solutions
- multi reader and multi tag feasibility
- flexible data management options
9The pilot application
10UHF Regulations in Europe
Under discussion in Europe
- 869.4 - 869.65 MHz
- Power 500 mW ERP
- Bandwidth 25 kHz / 250 kHz
- Duty cycle 10
- 862 - 870 MHz or 865 - 868 MHz
- Power 4 W EIRP indoor
- Bandwidth 100 kHz
- Duty cycle no
- 15 channels (200 kHz each)
- 865 to 865.6 MHz _at_ a power level of 100 mW ERP
- 865.6 to 867.6 MHz _at_ a power level of 2 W ERP and
- 876.6 to 868 MHz _at_ a power level of 500 mW ERP
The attempt to get a world wide accepted UHF
frequency for passive RFID solutions was failed
11- Overview
- The link
- challenges
- power planes
- principal solutions
- power link mechanism
- OSI layers
- Data management
- Conclusion
12Challenges of an UHF RFID solutions
- free space attenuation
- attenuation of the goods
- reflections, noise, humans
- power consumption of the transponder chip
- leakage
- activity on the chip
- effectiveness of the rectifier
- different RF regulations
- power limitations
- frequency ranges
- bandwidth regulations
- no world wide excepted standards
- challenges of the applications
- for the data management
- data rates
13The power plan of the Palomar UHF solution
- Forward link
- Output power 27 dBm
- TX antenna gain 2 dB
- Free space attenuation _at_ 4 m - 43.3 dB
- Power at the transponder antenna - 14.3 dBm
- Backward link
- Reflected power - 30 dBm (1 uW)
- Gain tag antenna 2 dB
- Free space attenuation _at_ 4m - 43.3 dB
- Target - 71.3 dBm at the RX antenna
Additionally modulation losses, fading, ...
14The main challenge power to supply the tag
(destructive interference)
distance
dBm
15General challenges of the tag - IC design
- To get a small power consumption
- weak (long time stability, accuracy, ..) or no
oscillator to decode the stream - pure analogue accuracy
- no PLL, A/D converter, mixer, carrier clock
divider, etc. are allowed - small active chip areas
- low activity
- low leakage current which is a function of the
technology, the area and the temperature - high efficiency rectifier
- low price technology which contains programmable
structures like EEPROM - low supply voltage, has to be less than 1.5 to 2
V - ripple on the power supply voltage, POR, stand
by, ... - and / or use of bigger capacitance on chip, area,
price,... - CMOS design with non-volatile memory capability
and good RF circuits
16Forward modulation possibilities to get world
wide acceptance
- ASK is very simple
- ASK - OOK as a special case is good for
realisation (signal2noise) - but to achieve the allowed spectrum in Europe
- the modulation losses are high
- ASK (m
- easy to generate and good for the spectrum
- but it is a strong challenge for UHF RFID
- moving objects
- fading effects
- it is also a strong challenge for the tag itself
- detection is not easy
- it must be possible to distinguish if it is a
symbol or a fading effect - detection needs more power than OOK
- FSK needs bandwidth (in Europe 100 to 250 kHz
total) and power - DSBM
17DSBM
- effective power transport
- clock ticks combined with 0,1,EOT symbols
- synchronous communication style
- reduced side band effects
- enables higher data rates as ASK - OOK
- robust and easily detectable return link
18Data transport
Required signal / noise ratio dB as a function
of - the bit error rate (BER) and - the type of
modulation
BER 10-3 10-5 10-7 Modulation PSK 6.8 9.6 11.4
FSK 9.5 12.2 15.2 ASK (OOK) 12.6 15.2 httpvulc
ain.fb12.tu-berlin.de/ILR/Aquarius/Telemetrie/raus
chen.html
- for ASK m than for ASK-OOK
- additionally fading effects, moving objects
- power transport
19Properties of the physical layer realised in
Palomar
- Power / data transport
- DSBM to reduce modulation losses and to transmit
symbols quickly - synchronous communication style
- default reader talks first
- Forward link
- DSBM to transport data and the system clock
- robust link mechanism
- enables high bit rate variations
- higher data rates as with ASK-OOK
- system clock extraction is easy
- enables low power concepts at the transponder
side for decoding - Return link
- system clock from the reader
- ASK / PSK possible
- phase measurement technologies are possible
higher signal2noise
20The advantage of Double Side Band Modulation
(DSBM)
Changing only I the result is s(t) cos(2 ?
f_carrier t) cos(2 ? f_mod t) If Q 0 all the
time this results in a signal crossing zero
(notch signal). Normally this effect is an
unwanted effect, but here it helps Theoretically
cos(2 ? f_mod t) can be extracted as the
baseband signal directly. The RF spectrum can be
easily adapted.
This kind of PSK modulation results in an AM
signal in the baseband without the disadvantage
of the corresponding spectrum generated by an ASK
modulation and is able to transport more power
to the tag than an ASK-OOK modulated
carrier (Patent pending, VTT)
21Comparison ASK-OOK vs DSBM to transport power
OOK
DSBM
modulation signals
on
off
-
possibilities to receive power
after the rectifier
Q
22The clock extraction system of the RFID system
Condition same RF spectrum
ASK-OOK
DSBM
LF input to mixer
1 0 -1
baseband signal (RSSI)
system clock as part of the protocol (notch)
no clock extraction possible
23The clock ticks
The detector has to detect ABS(cos(2 ? f_mod t))
Using a bandwidth of 250 kHz the minimum length
for a notch is theoretically 4 us
DSBM do not require an on - chip oscillator for
time measurement functions on the tag - IC
(power saving possibility) DSBM allows a
synchronous communication style in the forward
and backward link
24Forward link with adaptive baud rate setting
Based on pulse width measurement in the header
section Data rate is constant during each
forward link, but flexible
(Patent pending, Atmel Germany)
The resulting error rate in the stream is
therefore a function of the borderlines and the
distances between the symbols
25Synchronous data transport
- Advantages
- tolerant to worse oscillator concepts and low
accuracy decoders on the tag - no synchronisation frame needed
- if in a free running osc-concept the tolerance of
the oscillator is - 20 or worse then a long
time synchronisation frame is needed to control
the return link in an accepted way. - needed sync.-length f(protocol length)
- start of frame detection and plausibility check
is easy to implement - high signal 2 noise for detection of the back
scattered signal per definition - The Palomar solution
- The communication can be interrupted (EOT
symbols) at any position (each direction) - references for the return link are in the header
symbol - easy, low time and low power calibration possible
- NRZ or NIRZ in the return link
26OSI layers 2 and 3 (forward link)
- OSI 2
- structure header, command, parameter, data, 16
bit CRC, EOT sequence - commands
- read
- program
- reset
- select and un-select
- anticollision
- able to support different solution for clock
extraction (power consumption) - OSI 2a / MAC layer
- quasi deterministic anticollision
- random (Aloha) also possible
- OSI 3
- 2 bit command CRC and 16 bit over all CRC
according to ISO/IEC 13223 - position of EOT symbols
- forward header check (plausibility)
27OSI2 layer, forward direction (default mode)
baud rate control
optional
8 bit command
Header
8 bit parameter field
Data field
Parameters, to control for example - coding
style - modulation (subcarrier) control - tag
selection control (all / single / group) - reset
selection for anticollision procedures - UID
control - select control - address modes -
arbitration control - .....
commands - 2 bit CRC - 2 bit command class -
Reset - Program - Read - (Un)Select -
Anticollision - ....
28OSI layers 2 to 3 (return link)
- OSI 2
- structure header, status field, data, 16 bit
CRC, EOT - loop function is default
- reference symbols in the header section
- synchronous transmission controlled by the reader
- subcarrier of 200 kHz possible, controlled by the
command - multi reader application considering current ETSI
- influence of other channels ?
- OSI 3
- Reference symbols
- 16 bit CRC according to ISO/IEC 13223 (same as
18000-3, 15693-3)
29The header in the return link (default mode)
As an example
EOTreturn
return header tag baseband view
modulation by the tag static modulation
subcarrier modulation by the tag
30Functionality of the return header
- enable new data rate configuration
(signal2noise_f / signal2noise_r) - first sub symbol can be used to adapt the data
rate - during the first sub symbol the modulator stage
is on - last sub symbol is used to declare the minimum
length of EOT_return - lengths of sub symbol 2 and sub symbol 3 are
reserved for further use - IPs in preparation
31Structure of the return link (default mode)
header
8 bit status
EOT
optional
RFU, if no program or reset command
Data stream is encrypted. If no read command RFU
32Properties of the return header
- allows a new data rate which is different from
the data rate of the forward link - modulation can be used as a reference symbol in
the Rx channel of the reader - the reader is able to check which data rate is
needed in this environment - the minimum data rate is defined by the
EOTreturn symbol - static and subcarrier modulation is possible and
controlled by the command - the minimum length of the EOT-return symbol is
fixed by the header - it allows to stop the communication at each bit
position - the maximum length of the EOT-return can be
defined also by the EOT-return symbol located in
the header
33Why two EOT symbols (forward and return link) ?
- general
- enabling options for further use (more features
such as security) - enabling a symbol decoding concept without using
an on-chip oscillator - forward link
- case1 both symbols are side by side no
additional option - case2 n clock ticks between the two symbols
additional options and symbols possible - to transmit keys
- to transmit clock ticks
- ...
- backward link
- case1 both symbols are side by side no
additional option - case2 n clock ticks in between
- to transfer a short command
34Properties of the link mechanism realised in
Palomar
- data clock system is part of the OSI1 layer
description (DSBM) - data links
- forward synchronous, pulse length
- return synchronous, NRZ / NIRZ, subcarrier
optional (new type (IP) under development) - able to support different data rates (RF
spectrum) - forward link 2 to 80 kbit/s
- return link 10 to 80 kbit/s (noise)
- communication link is based on phase shifting
methods to - get higher data rates
- to get higher distances
- to get high noise immunity
- Option to support the communication link without
an on-chip oscillator, to save power
communication distance increase
35Anticollision
- Two solutions are possible
- deterministic procedure
- random based (Aloha) procedure
- Anticollision is a philosophic problem
- Anticollision for item management has also
technical challenges - detection of the collision
- attenuation is a function of the location, the
distance and the things which are between - signal to noise
- dynamic population
- speed
- Anticollision needs
- flexible pre-selection structure in front
- subcarrier if the random based procedure is used
(speed) - the possibility of arbitration if deterministic
procedure is used - A more optimised anticollision procedure is under
development
36Random based anticollision
- group mechanism up front are possible
- is normally based on Aloha principles
- static modulation can not be used to detect a
collision (attenuation) - sub carrier modulation (FM0 could also be a
solution) - is strongly recommended to detect the collision
- more than one sub carrier symbols per bit is
recommended - if more than one reader is active in Europe the
subcarrier is influencing the other channel
(f(sub) 200 kHz) - tag has to be selected by a select command after
receiving the ID, to read out the contents of the
memory. Time! - each tag must receive an un-select command after
detection
37Deterministic anticollision
- group mechanism (select commands) up front are
possible - pre-selection is possible
- mainly based on a modified binary tree search
- based also an arbitration mechanism to support
dynamic population - static and subcarrier modulation is possible
- subcarrier modulation might be a problem in
Europe in multi reader arrangements - tag is automatically selected after a successful
arbitration - tag is then selected until a new anticollision
command is received - tag is silent after selection and receiving a new
anticollision command as long as it receives an
un-select or reset command
38Quasi deterministic anticollision
- a quasi deterministic anticollision procedure is
currently under development - based on master slave arbitration mechanism
- a first type is currently implemented in Palomar
1, but not optimised - high speed, close to normal read is the target
for Palomar 2 - IP is under development
39- Overview
- The link
- Data management
- Aims
- Memory construction
- UID
- Select mechanism
- Conclusions
40Aims of the data management realised in Palomar
- low cost
- minimum set of control mechanism
- only the ID and minimum control mechanism
- effective management if more memory area is
required - flexibility to allow
- different ID and data concepts (default)
- different levels of security (default)
- OTP for parts of the ID
- password mechanism
- encryption possibilities
- migration ID types, data types and structures,
files - cost effectiveness
- added value must be higher than the costs of the
additional features
41Security options during read
read out directly, no security
data
42Memory construction
- sizing
- page 128 bit containing 4 blocks
- block 32 bit
- default
- user memory
- optional
- user memory
- control memory
Physical page construction, Table 6
43The administration control word
The administration word, table 7
If bit(9) 0 then bit(1510) RFU (CRC)
- ID
- ISO 15963
- ISO 15459
- ISO 15394
- GTAG / MIT proposal
- other solutions
- data structure keys
password control against over programming (ID is
special case, master password or OTP)
44Select mechanisms
- single and stack mechanism are possible and based
on - the system info
- a part of the system info (hard wired and/or
EEPROM contents) - (package) level
- tag type
- AFI and sub family
- data key
- GTAG compatible
- etc.
- the type of ID / UID
- any octet inside the lower ID- section (256 bit)
- any line (32 bit) of the lower 8 blocks of the
user memory
45- Overview
- The link
- Data management
- Conclusions
46Current Palomar transponder chip
47The prototype reader
48One result
Conditions - omnidirectional tag antenna (no
gain at the tag) - Palomar1 frontend on tag -
Palomar1 needs 1 dB additional - analyser near
the tag - power at the tag location same - no
gap zone - same antenna orientation Palomar aims
for -12 dBm as minimum power at the antenna pins
49Advantages of the Palomar system solution (1)
- Palomar concept is based on the stronger RF
regulations in Europe - easy to adapt the FCC regulations
- DSBM
- much smaller modulation losses compared to
ASK-OOK - much better spectrum than ASK-OOK (same data
rate) - improved immunity against dynamic arrangements
(moving objects) than ASK with modulation index m
- synchronous protocols (high signal2noise per
definition) - clock tick is part of the protocol
- no synchronisation frame needed faster
communication per definition - no on - chip oscillator for the communication
link is needed - power reduction
- longer communication ranges
- no header for chip clock adaptation needed
- wide range of possible data rates
- supporting also a worse oscillator concept
- controlled by the reader (protocol)
50Advantages of the Palomar system solution (2)
- flexible command structure
- able to support random and deterministic based
anticollision procedures - able to support several command classes (64 main
commands sub commands are possible) - able to support also short commands between the
EOT symbols of the return link (faster
communication) - if no on-chip oscillator is active during the
link options can be realised by additional clock
ticks between the EOT symbols - robust return link
- fully synchronous to the clock ticks given by the
reader (high signal2noise) - PSK, ASK
- modulation coding and style is fully controlled
by the reader - NRZ, NIRZ (other low power realisations are under
development) - sub carrier
- option for an additional symbol level during the
return link - short commands (return link)
- option for additional clock ticks (tags without
an active on-chip oscillator)
51Advantages of the Palomar system solution (3)
- wide range of security options during EEPROM
access - pointer system to owner information which can
contain a pointer information to an external data
base IP-address application pointer etc. - OTP(lower part (112 bit) of the UID)
- 3 levels of passwords (2 level for each page or
master password) - up to 64 kbit EEPROM in the default mode via 8
bit address - up to 32 kbit user memory (default)
- up to 32 kbit control and user memory (high
security area) - pointer to owners
- master password
- system info (soft parts)
- high security user data
- each block can be selected separately
- flexible data management possibilities
- supports a low end solution as well as high end
solutions - supports several ID concepts via 4 bit key
- supports several data concepts via 4 bit key
- symbolic addressing possible
52Palomar2, the next generation
- based on the stronger UHF RF regulations in
Europe - currently in the circuit design phase
- silicon out springtime 2002
- tags mounted on boards and in foil
- field test in the pilot, target from Mai 2002 to
July 2002 - supports the features described in ISO 18000-6 WD
(Palomar) - high speed quasi - deterministic anticollision
procedure - new types of low power modulation in the return
link - less power consumption
- higher efficiency rectifier
53IP Declaration (up to the 5th of December 2001)
Patent number Company Title Expiration
date FI 20011943 VTT A method to improve the
performance 041021 of RFID systems DE
10138217.2 Atmel Procedure to transmit
data 030821 - Next IPs on OSI layers are in
preparation - Currently several other mechanism
to optimise the link (OSI1 to OSI3 including
OSI2a) and the data management are under
development - Further hardware IPs implemented
on the tag are under development
54Thanks for your attention !