Title: Implementing Alabama's RtI Framework: Interventions
1Implementing Alabama's RtI Framework
Interventions, Interventions, Interventions
STUDENT SUCCESS
PST
RtI
- Christine R. Spear, Education Administrator
- Alabama Department of Education
- Dr. Denise P. Gibbs, Director
- Alabama Scottish Rite Foundation Learning Centers
2The portion of this presentation provided by Dr.
Gibbs is being provided today at no cost by the
Alabama Scottish Rite Foundation. The
philanthropy of the Alabama Scottish Rite
Foundation began in the 1950s in Alabama and
continues today. The mission of the Alabama
Scottish Rite Foundation is to provide help to
Alabama Schools as they work with students who
struggle in reading -particularly those students
with dyslexia.
33 Part Series at MEGA on AL RtI Framework
- Part 1 Wed 815-1130 Problem Solving Teams
Overview (to be repeated Thurs 1-415) - Part 2 Wed 1-415 Problem Solving Teams and
Intervention Plans - Part 3 Thurs 815-1130 Interventions,
Interventions, Interventions! (This session)
4Alabama RtI Framework
- Some documents for download at alsde.edu (special
links) - Response to Instruction Alabama Core Support For
All Students - A Problem Solving Team Process
- A Problem Solving Team Process Sample Forms
5Outcomes for this session
- Participants will become familiar with
- Some intervention scheduling issues and options
- Principles of Tier 2 and Tier 3 reading, math,
and behavior interventions - Specific examples of selected research-based Tier
2 and Tier 3 reading, math, and behavior
interventions.
6The big picture (in case you missed parts
1and 2 yesterday)
7Elementary Tier Model (K-3)
PlusSpecial Education
?
5
Tier 3
Intensive Intervention 60 minutes
Intervention 30 minutes per dayin the classroom
Tier 2
15
Comprehensive Core 90 minutes per day reading60
minutes per day math
Tier 1
80
8Grade 4-12 Tier Model
PlusSpecial Education
?
5
Tier 3
Intensive Intervention classes
Differentiated strategy instruction in content
classes small group-intentional groupings
15
Tier 2
Tier 1
80
Core instructionStrategy instruction in content
classes whole and small group
9RTIB K-12 Tiers
PlusSpecial Education
?
5
Tier 3
Intensive Intervention classes
15
Supplementalbehavior supports implemented in
classrooms
Tier 2
Tier 1
80
Universal positive behaviorsupports practiced
school-wideor district-wide
10Intervention Scheduling
11 In thinking about scheduling.
- Remember the expected outcomes (80 15 - 5)
- If we are achieving the desired results with our
core instruction, only 20 out of every 100
students will need intervention. - In a class of 20, only 4 should need Tier 2
- Of those 20 out of 100 who need intervention, 15
should reach grade-level proficiency with Tier 2
and only 5 of 100 should need Tier 3
interventions - In a class of 20, only 1 should need Tier 3 !!
- If you are not at 80 15 5, adjust where
needed.
12 K-3 Tier 2 Intervention Particulars
- Best practice is to have the classroom teacher
deliver the Tier 2 interventions. - Can build upon what the teacher knows about the
student and observes in the daily Tier 1 context. - Deliver the Tier 2 additional small group
intervention with fidelity - Document students participation in intervention
and weekly progress monitoring results - Student Intervention Documentation Form
13 K-3 Tier 2 Intervention Outcomes
- Decide within a reasonable period of time if this
level of intervention support is sufficient - With most interventions, you should know within
10-12 weeks if you are on the right track - Team analyzes progress monitoring data at 4 week
intervals. - Data-based decision making graphs
- If this level of intervention support is not
sufficient, move the student to a more intensive
level of support (Tier 3)
14 K-3 Tier 3 Intervention Schedules
- Students receiving Tier 3 interventions, may not
necessarily continue to participate in Tier 2
interventions - Tier 2 interventions need to be at a common time
for each grade - This would allow a walk to intervention model
if desired. - Tier 3 interventions could be scheduled to
overlap with Tier 2 for each K-3 grade. - This minimizes the time out of the classroom
for the student in Tier 3 intervention.
15K-3 Reading Schedule Tier 2 3 Overlap Example
- Kindergarten
- 9-1030 Tier 1
- 1200-1230 Tier 2
- 1200-100 Tier 3
- Grade 1
- 800-930 Tier 1
- 100-130 Tier 2
- 100-200 Tier 3
- Grade 2
- 800-930 Tier 1
- 930-1000 Tier 2
- 930-1030 Tier 3
- Grade 3
- 930-1100 Tier 1
- 900-930 Tier 2
- 830-930 Tier 3
Grade 4 Tier 3 _at_ 200-300 Grade 5 Tier 3 _at_
1030-1130
16 Schedule Examples
- Schedule example with overlapping Tier 2 and Tier
3 blocks for grades K-5 - Schedule example with acceleration block with
reading and with reading and math for grades K-5. - Schedule example with acceleration block for
grades 6-12.
17 Acceleration Block A scheduling option?
- A possible way to Raise the bar and close the
gap? (DuFour, et al., 2010) - Borrow minutes from periods throughout the day
to create an extra period - Schedule this early in the day
- All faculty and all students participate
- Intervention for tier 3 students
- Entire year or until no longer needed
- Enrichment for on level and above level students
- Different classes each grading period?
18 4-12 Intervention Particulars
- Tier 2 intervention is embedded in core
instruction in every content area during time
designated for collaborative group work - Intentional student grouping
- Heterogeneous groups Orange day
- Each Tier 2 student is partnered with a non-Tier
2 student - Teacher spends time with each group
- Homogeneous groups Crimson day
- All Tier 2 students are grouped together
- Teacher works closely with this group
19INTERVENTIONS!
20Some VERY Useful Websites for INDEPENDENT Reviews!
- What Works Clearinghouse (WWC)
- http//ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/
- Best Evidence Encyclopedia (BEE)
- http//www.bestevidence.org
- Promising Practices Network (PPN)
- http//www.promisingpractices.net/default.asp
- National Center on Response to Intervention
- www.rti4success.org
21Tier 2 Behavior Intervention
22Some Tier 2 Ideas
- Can be implemented in the classroom and monitored
with a behavior report card. - Pre-Correction
- Self Monitoring
- Behavior Momentum
- Check-in Check-out
23Pre-Correctionexample from The Tough Kid Book
- Example teaching a replacement behavior
- The Sure I Will plan
- replacement behavior for arguing
- research shows it replaces arguing as well as
increases compliance - for every teacher directive given, the student
says Sure I Will - praise/reward randomly - about every 3 - 4th
response
24Self-Monitoring
- Teach self-monitoring and targeted social skill
simultaneously - Plan carefully for success
- Age 4 and above
- Periodic, random checks on accuracy
- initially only praise/reward accuracy (until 80
accurate) then reinforce success related to
behavior monitored
25Behavior Momentumexample from The Tough Kid Book
- Tom, will you help me hand out the papers?
- Thanks Tom, please help me straighten up the
chairs. - Now Tom, please sit down and do your math
assignment.
26Some Tier 2 Behavior Resources
- Tough Kid series
- The Behavior Education Program
- Project RIDE
27The Tough Kid Books and Audio Series
- Practical Classroom Management Strategies
- A Tough Kid is compliant lt 40, average kid
complies with teacher requests 80 of the time
28Behavior Education Program
- Responding to Problem Behavior in Schools The
behavior education program by Crone, Horner
Hawken
29Overview of BEP Elements
- Daily positive adult contact
- Check-in/Check-out system
- Daily report card - Increased attention to
behavioral goals - For all school settings
- Home-School partnership
- Collaborative team-based process
30Project RIDE
- Responding to Individual Differences in Education
- K-6 students
- 600 behavioral and academic tactics and 100
videos
31Tier 3 Behavior Intervention
32Some Tier 3 Ideas
- May include behavior intervention class utilizing
various curricula such as - Skillstreaming Series
- The PREPARE Curriculum Teaching Prosocial
Competencies - Second Steps
- I Can Problem Solve
- Bullying Prevention Program
33Skillstreaming Series
- For students who display aggression, immaturity,
withdrawal, or other problem behaviors. - Students develop competence in dealing with
interpersonal conflicts, learn to use
self-control, and contribute to a positive
classroom atmosphere. - Three levels
- PreK 1
- Grades 2-5
- Grades 6-12
- www.researchpress.com
34The PREPARE Curriculum
- For middle and high schools
- 10 course length interventions
- Reducing anger, reducing stress, reducing
prejudice - 93 supplementary activities
- Researchpress.com
35Teaches, models, and reinforces skills in
empathy, impulse control, problem solving and
anger management
www.cfchildren.org
36Second Step
- Whole classroom
- Pre-K through 9th grade
- Teacher friendly
- Lots of role playing and problem solving
- Explicit teaching of social skills
- Research validated
- Small Group
- Re-teach classroom lessons
- More practice
- More feedback
- Use puppets and role-play
37I Can Problem Solve(3 volume set)
- Helps students resolve interpersonal conflicts
and prevent antisocial behaviors - Three levels Preschool K-Primary grades
Intermediate Elementary grades - USDOE and NASP awards
- Researchpress.com
38Bullying Prevention Program
- Includes school-wide implementation and targeted
intensive instruction - Additional cyber bullying prevention and suicide
prevention materials - www.olweus.org
39Math Instruction and Intervention Principles
40What we are learning about math
- What Works in Teaching Math (Slavin, et al.,
2010) - Reviewed 189 studies and found
- Programs that emphasize classroom management,
motivation, and collaborative groups are more
effective that those that emphasize textbooks and
technology! - The most successful math programs encourage
student interaction!
41Tier 2 Math Intervention
42Peer Assisted Learning Strategies - Math
- www.kc.vanderbilt.edu/pals
- Students work with a partner and take turns being
the coach or player - WWC and BEE highly effective!
- Awesome research!
43Power Teaching
- http//www.sfapowerteaching.org
- Cycle of effective instruction
- Active instruction
- Teamwork
- Assessment
- Celebration
- Elementary and middle school resources
44Team Accelerated Instruction TAI Math
- http//www.charlesbridge.com/school/html/tai.html
- Students in grades 3-8
- Includes cooperative learning and interactive,
individual instruction - Team goals which can only be achieved if all
succeed. - Highest possible rating by BEE awesome
research! - Correlated to AL standards!
45Tier 3 Math Intervention
46AMP Math System
- Three levels for students in middle and high
school. - Based on math focal points as detailed by the
NCTM - Placement test
- Lessons include whole and small group activities
and individual practice - Schedule can be 45 minutes or 90 minutes per day.
- Six problem solving strategies
47Transmath
- For students in grades 5-10 who are 2 or more
grade levels below their enrolled grade. - Three levels
- Number sense
- Rational numbers
- Algebraic thinking
- Assessments!!!
- Direct instruction and online components
- www.Cambiumlearning.com
48V-Math
- Seven levels (grades 2-8) with a placement test
- Combination of teacher-led instruction,
manipulatives, and online components - Assessments!!!!
- Aligned with NCTM Math Focal Points
- www.voyagerlearning.com (now part of Cambium!)
49Tier 2 Literacy Intervention Grades K-3
50Effective Tier 2 Literacy Intervention
- A standard treatment protocol may be a good
option at this level. - Use screening criterion to determine students
need for Tier 2 intervention. - Provide a broad-based intervention which will
meet the needs of at least 75 percent of your
struggling readers.
51Some ideas from K-3 Intervention Research
Scammacca, N., Vaughn, S., Roberts, G., Wanzek,
J., Torgesen, J. K. (2007).
- Extensive interventions (100 sessions or more)
can be effective when provided by personnel other
than certified teachers (e.g. paraprofessionals,
teacher assistants, etc.) in small groups or
one-on-one with appropriate training.
52Some ideas from K-3 Intervention Research
Scammacca, N., Vaughn, S., Roberts, G., Wanzek,
J., Torgesen, J. K. (2007).
- All of the effective Tier 2 interventions
included training in - phonological awareness
- decoding, and word study
- guided and independent reading of progressively
more difficult texts - writing exercises
- engaging students in practicing comprehension
strategies while reading text
53Intervention studies illustrating effective
Tier 2 options.
54Early Interventions in Reading(Torgesen and
Mathes, 2005)
- 120 lessons, 40 minutes, 3-5 students.
- Mathes, et al 2005 study .
- Excellent gains after 91 hours of instruction.
- Only 1 of the students were reading below the
average range (30th percentile)! - Intervention students had steeper rates of
improvement than typical readers on word reading,
passage fluency, and phonological awareness. - Published by SRA.
55Responsive Reading Instruction(Denton and
Hocker, 2006)
- 40-minute lessons 3 students.
- Mathes, et al 2005 study .
- Excellent gains after 91 hours of instruction.
- Only 7 of the students were reading below the
average range (30th percentile)! - Intervention students had steeper rates of
improvement than typical readers on word reading,
passage fluency, and phonological awareness. - Published by Cambium Learning.
56Sound Partners(Vadasy, et al, 2004)
- 11 tutoring (paraprofessionals)
- 30-minute lessons
- Average gains from 10th percentile to 50th
percentile after 80 lessons - Published by Cambium Learning
57Tier 2 Intervention Grades 4-12
58 Grades 4-12 Tier 2 Strategies
- Strategies which are utilized in both Tier 1 and
Tier 2 for grades 4-12 must be grounded in
research. - Research provides clear evidence of what works
with students in grades 4-12. - Marzanos High Impact Strategies
- Get everyone to use the Magnificent Seven
strategies while they are reading.
59Gains From Instructional Strategies Research
Findings (Marzano, 2001)
60Gains From Instructional Strategies Research
Findings (Marzano, 2001)
61The Magnificent Seven..
- Good readers use these seven comprehension
strategies - Making connections to prior knowledge
- Inferring and predicting
- Asking questions
- Determining important ideas and summarizing
- Visualizing
- Synthesizing and retelling
- Monitoring and clarifying understanding of text
62Engagement Strategies(Rozzell Scearce, 2009)
- Strategies to get students to be active
participants in classes - Three-step Interview
- Jigsaw Modified
63Cooperative and Partnered Learning Tools(Rozzell
Scearce, 2009)
- 3-Step Interview
- Form random pairs
- Students answer what do you already know about
or what are two big ideas from or other
questions - Students listen to and summarize their partners
response - Put two pairs together and students introduce
their partner and share their partners response
this is my partner Carol and she said that...
64Cooperative and Partnered Learning Tools(Rozzell
Scearce, 2009)
- Jigsaw Modified
- Divide text into 4 segments and have 4 students
in each group (Home team) - Students number off 1-4 and then regroup by those
numbers (expert team). - 1s discuss segment 1, 2s discuss segment 2,
etc. - Home team group reconstitutes and each segment is
then discussed - Design an assessment to see how well the groups
acquired the information from the various sections
65Vocabulary Strategies
- Marzanos Six steps
- Introduce the term authentically
- Have student restate the meaning in their own
words - Use / create visuals
- Get to a deeper understanding (associations,
connections, etc) - Vocabulary discussions
- Word play
- Vocabulary Visual Word Association (VVWA)
66Vocabulary Tree (Beers, 2003)
- 1. Choose a root word you want for students to
study and have them write it in the root of the
tree. - 2. Under the root, students write its definition.
- 3. In the trunk of the tree, students write a key
word that you provide that uses that root. - 4. Under the word, students write the definition
of the word. - 5. Then in the branches of the trunk, students
write as many other words as they find that use
that root. - 6. Students define the word and copy a sentence
that uses it. This could be a sentence they
heard, one they read, or one they said
themselves. - 7. In the twigs of the branch, they record where
they heard or found the sentence.
67- Some word root sources
- http//www.espindle.org/roots.html
- http//www.virtualsalt.com/roots.htm
- http//www.betterendings.org/homeschool/Words/Root
20Words.htm - http//www.prefixsuffix.com/
68Reading Comprehension Active Reading Strategies
- Before strategies
- Set the stage
- Assess and build content knowledge
- During strategies
- Metacognition
- Support and monitor comprehension
- After strategies
- Review, organize
- Evaluate, extend, and transfer content knowledge
69Think Aloud Powerful for differentiating!
- 1. Read a selection aloud to the class (or to a
small group in the class) - Orally describe the thinking going on in your
head as you make sense of the text. - As you prepare to do this, you might use sticky
notes as prompts. - Can teach students how to do this also.
70- ABC Graffiti (Rozzelle Searce, 2009)
- Present the topic of the brainstorm to the
students. - Students list all the letters of the alphabet
down a sheet of paper, leaving room beside each
letter to write out the rest of a word or phrase. - Students work individually thinking of as many
words as they can that are associated with the
topic and write the words beside the appropriate
letters. - After a few minutes, let the students pair up or
work in small groups to fill in blank letters
they have not yet completed. - Allow students to share with the entire class
possible terms for the different letters of the
alphabet.
71- Cornell Note-Taking (Allen, 2004)
- Provide Cornell Note-Taking form or folded paper
- Read text and model for students the notes you
would take while reading that text - Develop questions that the notes would answer
- Use notes and questions to summarize the main
ideas in 2-3 sentences.
72- 3-2-1
- Purposes (1) self-monitor comprehension, (2)
identify important details in the content, (3)
make connections to content, and (4) identify
areas in the content where understanding is
uncertain - Procedure
- After reading a portion of text, viewing a
portion of a video, or listening to a portion of
a lecture students working alone, with a
partner, or in small groups fill out a 3-2-1
chart. - 3 Important Details
- 2 Connections
- 1 Question I Still Have
- Students repeat the procedure until the entire
content has been completed. - Students can use the important details from their
3-2-1 charts to summarize the entire lesson.
73Free Graphic Organizers
- http//wrhs.pasco.k12.fl.us/wordpop/WordPOP
- http//www.dinah.com/manipulatives.php
- http//foldables.wikispaces.com/Foldables
- http//pages.sbcglobal.net/cdefreese/foldables/
- http//www.readingquest.org/strat/home.html
- http//go.solution-tree.com/literacy/
74Content Literacy Strategy Resources
- Power Tools for Adolescent Literacy (2009) by Jan
Rozzelle Carol Scearce - Strategies for engaging students
- Comprehension strategies (before, during, and
after) - Vocabulary strategies
- Strategic learning
- Website with free downloadables
- Go.solutions-tree.com/literacy
75Content Literacy Strategy Resources
- Inside Words Tools for Teaching Academic
Vocabulary Grades 4-12 (2007) by Janet Allen - 22 vocabulary strategies with examples for use in
secondary content classes - Includes a CD with graphic organizers.
76Content Literacy Strategy Resources
- Tools for Teaching Content Literacy (2004) by
Janet Allen - 15 before, during, and after strategies for use
in content classes (with examples)
77Content Literacy Strategy Resources
- More Tools for Teaching Content Literacy (2008)
by Janet Allen - More than 20 additional strategies with graphic
organizers for easy implementation.
78Tier 3 Interventions K-3 Principles and Examples
79Tier 3 Literacy Interventions
- No standard treatment protocols at this
level.one size will not fit all! - Word-level interventions
- Comprehension/Vocabulary interventions
80Word-level Interventions Emphasize(Simmons
Kame'enui, 2004)
- Phonemic awareness (prerequisite skills)
- Letter sound correspondence
- Regular word reading (using decoding skills)
- Regular word reading in text (lots of text!)
- Irregular word reading
- Advanced word analysis
- All six syllable types
- Prefixes and suffixes
81Comprehension/Vocabulary Interventions Emphasize
- Magnificent seven (Pearson, et al., 1992)
- Making connections to prior knowledge
- Inferring and predicting
- Asking questions
- Determining important ideas and summarizing
- Visualizing
- Synthesizing and retelling
- Monitoring and clarifying understanding of text
and vocabulary
82Tier 3 Word-Level Interventions
- If student is dyslexic (weak in phonological
skills, in phonics, and in spelling but strong in
problem-solving and listening comprehension) - a dyslexia-specific, word-level intervention (one
that is Orton-Gillingham-based) may be the best
Tier 3 choice.
83Examples of Tier 3 Word-Level Interventions
- LANGUAGE! www.sopriswest.com
- Project Read www.projectread.com
- Slingerland www.slingerland.org
- Spalding Writing Road to Reading www.spalding.org
- S.P.I.R.E. www.epsbooks.com
- Take Flight www.tsrhc.org
- Wilson Reading System www.wilsonlanguage.com
84Tier 3 Comprehension-Vocabulary Interventions
- If the student has relatively strong word level
skills but very weak listening comprehension and
vocabulary along with poor reading comprehension
skills - an intervention to improve language skills which
are fundamental for school success may be the
best Tier 3 choice.
85Examples of Tier 3 Comprehension/Vocabulary
Interventions
- Corrective Reading Comprehension
- www.sraonline.com
- Language for Learning
- www.sraonline.com
- Language for Thinking
- www.sraonline.com
- Text Talk
- www.scholastic.com
- Voyager Passport
- http//voyagerlearning.com
86Tier 3 Interventions grades 4-12Principles and
Examples
87Effective literacy interventions
- Word-level interventions
- Multisyllabic words
- Monosyllabic and multisyllabic words
- Comprehension interventions
88A few examples of effective word-level
interventions
- Wilson Reading System www.wilsonlanguage.com
- Corrective Reading www.sraonline.com
- LANGUAGE! www.sopriswest.com
- Earobics REACH http//www.hmlt.hmco.com/Earobics-
Reach.php - Alphabetic Phonics (Texas Scottish Rite Literacy
Program) www.epsbooks.com - REWARDS www.sopriswest.com
89Wilson Reading System (1988)
- for students with below 3rd grade level
word-level skills. - 60-90 minute lessons
- Group size 1-6
- Orton-Gillingham based, multisensory, sequential,
process-oriented - Steps 1-6 focus upon decoding and encoding
- Steps 7-12 focus on advanced word analysis,
vocabulary, and comprehension - Grades 2-12
90Corrective Reading (1998 2008)
- Tier 3 intensive word-level and/or comprehension
intervention - Grades 4-12
- Four levels for decoding and four levels for
comprehension - Scripted lessons
- Extensive skill practice
- Outstanding research data on efficacy
91LANGUAGE! (4th Ed.)
- Tier 3 intensive word-level and comprehension
intervention (could be a parallel ELA course?) - Grades 3-12
- phonemic awareness/phonics, word
recognition/spelling, vocabulary/morphology,
grammar/usage, speaking/writing,
listening/reading comprehension - 90 minute lessons
92Earobics REACH
- Grades 4-8 or struggling readers in high school
- 72 units taking students from lexile of 360 to
850 - Computers and an avatar!
- Fiction and nonfiction
- Comprehension, fluency, vocabulary, and phonics
- Built-in assessments and progress monitoring
- Very engaging!
93REWARDS (Reading Excellence Word Attack and Rate
Development Strategies)
- Tier 3 intensive word-level intervention for
students with 3rd to 5th grade word-level skills
(short-term) - Grades 4-12
- 20 lessons 40-50 minutes in length
- Lessons 1-12 focus upon decoding multisyllabic
words and lessons 13-20 focus on fluency
94Alphabetic Phonics Texas Scottish Rite Hospital
Literacy Program
- 160 one hour lessons on DVD
- 1 year
- Training provided through an orientation video
- Students 14 years and older
- Groups of 10 or fewer
95A few examples of effective comprehension
interventions
- Corrective Reading Comprehension
- www.sraonline.com
- Read 180 Enterprise
- http//teacher.scholastic.com
- AMP-Achieving Maximum Potential
- http//www.pearsonschool.com
- Voyager Passport Reading Journeys
- www.voyagerlearning.com
96READ 180 Enterprise Ed. (2006)
- Tier 3 intensive comprehension and word-level
intervention (best if word-level skills are 3rd
grade or higher) - Stages B and C for middle and high school
- 9 workshops lasting 4-6 weeks in each stage
- targets decoding, fluency, vocabulary,
comprehension, and writing skills - 90 minute lessons with whole group and small
group activities (computer, direct instruction,
and independent reading) - Assessments!
97AMP Reading Program (2006)
- Tier 3 intensive comprehension intervention
- Interest level 6-12, reading level 3-5
- Seven comprehension strategies
- Content specific strategy use for Science, Math,
and Social Studies - Vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension
98Voyager Passport Journeys
- Whole group, small group, and on-line instruction
- Targets middle and high school students reading
3-4 years below grade level - Builds comprehension, vocabulary, and fluency
- Uses DVDs to build background knowledge and to
improve student engagement - Includes benchmark and progress monitoring tools
99- THANK YOU!
- gibbsdenise_at_aol.com
- cspear_at_alsde.edu