Title: OPINION SURVEY REGARDING THE HOLOCAUST IN ROMANIA
1- OPINION SURVEY REGARDING THE HOLOCAUST IN ROMANIA
- AND PERCEPTIONS OF
- INTERETHNIC RELATIONS
Developed for the "Elie Wiesel" National Institu
te for the Study of the Holocaust in Romania
Project financed by The International Task Force
for Cooperation on Holocaust Education,
Remembrance, and Research
May 2007
2Content
- Foreword 2
- Methodology 4
- Summary 5
- Perception of democratic institutions 14
- Perception of minorities the whole
sample 18
- Perception of minorities Ethnic Romanians
responses 25
- Perception of the HOLOCAUST 32
- Ion Antonescus image 40
- Perception of the State of Israel 43
3FOREWORD
The "Elie Wiesel" National Institute for the
Study of the Holocaust in Romania was created in
September 2005 under the authority of the
Ministry of Culture and Religious Affairs. The
main objectives of the institute are the
following the development of historiographical
research regarding the Holocaust in Romania, the
creation of a documentary archive regarding
anti-Semitic policies and activities of the
Romanian Government between 1938-1944, the
development of educational programs based on
European civic values, such as tolerance, the
acceptance of human diversity, the fight against
anti-Semitism, racism and xenophobia.
The Conclusions and Recommendations chapter of
the Final Report issued by the International
Commission for the Study of the Holocaust in
Romania in November 2004 states the need for
education in this field both for increasing
awareness of the recent history (to know not to
repeat the mistakes of the past) and for the
understanding of the significance of being a
citizen with equal rights. The Holocaust can be
a controversial subject in certain societies, in
which memory and perception are often matters of
debate. People perceive the Jewish ordeal during
the Second World War differently, according to
their age, rational or emotional states, their
prejudice or knowledge. Therefore, we need
effective strategies for promoting educational
programs on this topic, based on a good
understanding of the target public. This project
is especially designed for measuring the opinions
and attitudes of the population towards the
Holocaust and related subjects.
4FOREWORD
Key terms used for evaluation of this public
opinion survey at the national level
1. The Holocaust in Romania
2. Ion Antonescus image as a Romanian leader
3. Attitudes regarding state institutions and
values such as democracy / authoritarianism/
tolerance / rejection 4. Perceptions of ethnic
minorities (especially Jews and Roma)
5. Attitude towards Israel as a source of
anti-Semitism. During the project we had continuo
us financial and consultancy support from The
International Task Force for Cooperation on
Holocaust Education, Remembrance, and Research.
The public opinion survey was conducted by
TNS-CSOP. We want to express gratitude to our col
laborators for their special support in the
realization of this public opinion survey.
The ELIE WIESEL NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR THE
STUDY OF THE HOLOCAUST IN ROMANIA
5Methodology
- Research type Omnibus survey
- Data collection period 25 April 3 May 2007
- Sample 1,026 respondents, error margin of
3.06.
- Target respondents National representative
sample of the Romanian population aged 15 years
old and above. The sample is representative
according to gender, age, residence and region
according to National Statistic and Economic
Studies official data. - Number of sampling points 118
- Random selection of respondents, using random
route for selecting households, with statistical
step according to area type, and next birthday
rule for respondent selection in the household. - Data collection method face to face interviews
using a structured questionnaire.
6SUMMARY
- Population attitudes Democracy and reliance on
public institutions
- Democracy in Romania is considered hardly
satisfactory by the population, 43 being
dissatisfied or very dissatisfied by it and only
19 declaring that they are satisfied or very
satisfied by it. - This result might be influenced by political
events which developed during the survey
(impeachment of the Romanian President by the
Parliament). - The Church (78) and the Army (64) are
considered the most reliable institutions by the
Romanian population, followed by local
authorities (45) and mass media (44). - The Presidency (40), the Police (39) and - at a
certain distance- the Judiciary (27) are the
next institutions which the Romanians trust
more. - The Parliament (13) and the Government (14)
are the least trusted.
7SUMMARY
- Population perceptions regarding anti-Semitism
- Only a small proportion of respondents (16)
declared that there are parties with anti-Semitic
discourse in Romania.
- Partidul Romania Mare is the most frequently
mentioned as having an anti-Semitic discourse
(84 of those who identified a political
organization with this type of message).
8SUMMARY
- Perceptions of minorities (1)
- Only a small proportion of Romanians perceives
some minorities living in Romania as a threat,
Roma (14) and Hungarians (11) registering the
highest scores. Using a different analytical
category, the same minorities are also mentioned
as representing a problem for Romania (33 -
Roma and 18 - Hungarians), without being labeled
in this final case as minorities that represent
a threat. - The Jews are perceived in a neutral manner by
almost one-third of all Romanian respondents,
neither as a problem, nor as an advantage for
Romania. This minority benefits also from
positive responses, 15 of respondents consider
that Jews have a useful contribution in certain
regions and occupations and 10 declare that they
are a valuable resource for our country. - Most of the respondents (58-71) consider that
minorities have the same rights as the rest of
Romanian citizens.
- Some of the respondents (20) consider that the
Hungarian minority has more rights than the
Romanian majority and some (10) have the same
opinion about the Roma minority.
9SUMMARY
- Perceptions of minorities (2)
- In this section only ethnic Romanians opinions
are analyzed
- Using Bogardus social distance measure scale
(see the annex), where 1 indicates the closest
accepted relationship with people from a certain
minority (family member) and 7 the most distant
(should not come to Romania), we notice there is
a greater tolerance toward Jews (4.23) and
Hungarians (4.21) and a significantly lower
tolerance regarding Roma (5.14) and Arabs
(5.18). - These differences change depending on the
respondents education level for Jews - from
4.41 (for people with medium education) to 3.66
(for people with academic education) - and
similarly for Hungarians (from 4.35 to 3.85, at
educational extremes). - Regarding Roma and Arabs there are no
significant differences, the social distance
remaining the same for all educational levels.
- The smaller social distance towards Jews is due
to the fact that they are accepted in the family
(9), in friends groups (14) or as neighbors
(11). There is also a smaller proportion (8) of
those who declares Jews should not come to
Romania. - Towards the Hungarians, the behavior of ethnic
Romanians is a similar one they are accepted as
family members (8), in friends groups (13) or
as neighbors (9) only 12 declares that
Hungarians should not come to Romania. - The Roma (39) are better accepted than Arabs
(27) to live in Romania, but they have a similar
weak position for other closer variants (only 2
accepts having Roma in the family, 5 to have
them in friends groups and 7 accepts having
people from this minority as neighbors 22 of
Romanians do not want Roma to come to Romania).
10SUMMARY
- Perceptions of minorities (3)
- More than half of the respondents agree that Jews
have good relations with the rest of the
population, many important personalities in
various fields and a lot of international
influence. This last affirmation registered the
higher scores 27 fully agree that Jews have a
great deal of international influence. - Jews represent an important minority for Romania
according to 42 of the respondents and they
represent a community which leads to the
progress of the country where they are living.
There is a problem with the last point many
respondents (41) cannot mention - perhaps they
dont know - the achievements of this minority. - Only 22 of respondents believe that Jews should
go to live in their country, while 42 does not
agree with that, and about 20 agree that they
are focused only on their own goals even if these
are harming others. 35 does not agree with the
last affirmation. - Only 12 agree that Jews supported the
instauration of communism in Romania, while about
55 cannot answer this question.
- About 10 of respondents consider that Jewish
actions lead to a lack of stability in the
society, while 48 do not agree with that.
11SUMMARY
- Perceptions of the Holocaust (1)
- Most of the respondents declared they have heard
about the Holocaust (65), depending on their
education level and their residence (the
percentage increases with the education level and
it is the lowest in rural areas). - Most of those who declared they have heard about
the HOLOCAUST, spontaneously define this term as
extermination of the Jews by the Germans
(54). - The following affirmations are placed at a
certain distance from the first one persecution
of the European Jews (14), Mass crimes (8)
and deportation of the Jews (7). - The Holocaust is considered to have taken place
in Germany by the majority of respondents (66)
fewer respondents agreed that the Holocaust also
took place in other European countries (39). 52
of Hungarian respondents mentioned that the
Holocaust took place in other European countries,
significantly higher than average. - About 28 agree the Holocaust took place in
Romania and 27 cannot say in which countries
this happened.
- Those who admitted there was a Holocaust in
Romania, associated it with Deportation of Jews
to isolated areas or to other countries (74),
Mass imprisonment of Jews (67) and
Expropriation and forced evacuation of Jews
(62). Mass executions of Jews (pogrom) is
rarely mentioned (26).
12SUMMARY
- Perceptions of the Holocaust (2)
- Nazi Germany is considered mainly responsible
for the Holocaust in Romania (79), followed at a
certain distance by Antonescus government
(11). - When all responsible factors are considered,
Nazis Germany is mentioned by 90 of respondents,
Antonescus government by 47 and the USSR by
11. - The population is not highly interested in the
Holocaust only 6 declared themselves interested
or very interested in this topic.
- Those interested in Holocaust issues obtain
information mainly from television (38), history
books (14) and radio (11).
- About 22 know there is a national day
commemorating the Holocaust in Romania.
- Only 10 people interviewed were able to mention
the date of Holocaust Day in Romania.
13SUMMARY
- Ion Antonescus image
- More than 40 of the respondents cannot make any
assessments on Marshal Ion Antonescus
personality, which shows a lack of knowledge of
his activities and the events of that time. - He is highly appreciated by some of the
respondents as a great patriot (46), a great
strategist (44), while 1/3 of the interviewed
people believe he should be rehabilitated for
what he did for Romania. - About 24 agree that Ion Antonescu was a
democratic leader, while 27 disagree. Similarly,
22 admit that he achieved unification of the
country (Great Romania), while 27 disagree with
this affirmation. - Only 15 consider that he rescued Jews, while
31 do not agree with this affirmation.
- About 33 of respondents agree that he was
responsible for crimes against gypsies and 28
agree that he was a dictator.
- Only a quarter of respondents consider him
responsible for crimes against Jews and about 20
consider that he was a war criminal and led
Romania to disaster, while 32 disagree with
these last two affirmations.
14SUMMARY
- Perception of the State of Israel
- The image of the State of Israel is rather
unclear, close to a neutral point, which makes
the respondents have very different opinions.
- Sometimes Israel is negatively perceived, as a
non-democratic state which supports terrorism. It
might influence the respondents who consider that
Romania should not have closer relations with
Israel.
15Perceptions of democratic institutions
161. Generally speaking, how pleased are you about
democracy in our country?
- Democracy in Romania is considered rather
unsatisfactory by the population, 43 being
unpleased or very unpleased and only 19
declaring that they are pleased or very pleased
by this. - This result could be influenced by political
events during the data collection period
(impeachment of the Romanian President by the
Parliament).
Base 1026 respondents
172. How much do you trust the following
institutions in Romania
- Church (78) and Army (64) are institutions in
which Romanians trust more, followed by local
authorities (45) and Mass Media (44).
- Presidency (40), Police (39) and - at a
certain distance - Judiciary (27) follow.
- Parliament (13) and Government (14) are placed
on the opposite side.
Base 1026 respondents
1819. In your opinion, are there parties or
political formations with anti-Semitic discourse
in Romania now?
20. Which parties?
Base 167 respondents who declared there
are parties with an anti-Semitic message in
Romania Each respondent could give more than one
answer
Base 1026 respondents
- Only a small proportion of respondents (16)
declare there are parties with an anti-Semitic
message in Romania.
- Partidul Romania Mare is most frequently
mentioned as having anti-Semitic discourse (84
of those who identified a political organization
with this type of message).
19Perception of minorities
The whole sample in this section are included
the responses from all respondents
203. Considering your general opinion about
national minorities in our country would you say
that these minorities represent
Base 1026 respondents
- Only a small proportion of Romanians perceive
some minorities living in Romania as a threat
Roma (14) and Hungarians (11) registered the
highest scores on this. These two minorities are
also mentioned as representing a problem for
Romania (33 - Roma and 18 - Hungarians), but
not a threat. - Jews are rather perceived in a neutral manner by
almost 1/3 of all Romanian respondents, neither
as a problem, nor an advantage for Romania. This
minority benefits also from positive responses,
15 of respondents consider that Jews have a
useful contribution in certain regions and
occupations and 11 declaring that they are a
valuable resource for our country.
214. Do you think the following minorities living
in Romania, compared to the majority of the
population have rights...
Base 1026 respondents
- Most of the respondents (58-71) consider that
minorities have the same rights as the rest of
Romanian citizens.
- There are some respondents who consider that the
Hungarian minority has more rights than the
Romanian majority (20), and 10 has the same
opinion on the Roma minority.
225. Which of these best describes the closest
relationship you would accept with people
belonging to the following minorities?
Base 1026 respondents
- A smaller social distance regarding Jews is
generated by the fact that they could be accepted
in the family (7), as personal friends (12) or
as neighbors (10) and by the fact that there is
a smaller proportion (7) of those who declare
that Jews shouldnt have come to Romania. - Regarding the Hungarians, the Romanians have a
similar comportment accepting them as family
members (12), as personal friends (11) or as
neighbors (7), while 9 declare that Hungarians
shouldnt have come to Romania. - Related to the citizenship variable, the Roma
are better accepted compared to the Arabs 34 of
all respondents accept this right for the Roma
while only 22 for the Arabs. These two groups
have a similar weak position for other nearness
variables (e.g. only 2 agree to have Roma in the
family, 5 to have them in friends group and 6
accept having people from this minority as
neighbors, and 19 of Romanians want Roma not to
come to Romania).
235. Which of these best describes the closest
relationship you would accept with people
belonging to the following minorities?
Base 1026 respondents
- Using Bogardus social distance measure scale (see
the annex), where 1 indicates the closest
accepted relation with people from a certain
minority (family member) and 7 the most distant
(shouldnt come to Romania), we notice there is a
greater tolerance toward the Jews (4.23) and the
Hungarians (4.21) and a significantly lower
tolerance regarding the Roma (5.14) and the Arabs
(5.18). - These differences change depending on the
respondents education level for Jews - from
4.41 (for people with mid-level education) to
3.66 (for people with academic education) - and
similarly for Hungarians (from 4.35 to 3.85, at
educational extremes). - For the Roma and the Arabs there are no
significant differences, the social distance
regarding those two minorities remains the same
for all educational levels.
246. Considering now only the Jews, to which extent
do you agree or disagree with the following
affirmations?
Base 1026 respondents
POSITIVE AFFIRMATIONS
- More than half of respondents agree the Jews
have good relations with the rest of the
population, many important personalities in
various fields and a lot of international
influence. This last affirmation registered the
highest scores 27 fully agree that Jews have a
lot of international influence. - The Jews represent an important minority for
Romania according to 42 of the respondents and
they Represent a community which leads to the
progress of the country where they are living.
There is a problem with the last point many
respondents (41) cannot mention - perhaps they
dont know - the achievements of this minority.
256. Considering now only the Jews, to which extent
do you agree or disagree with the following
affirmations?
Base 1026 respondents
NEGATIVE AFFIRMATIONS
- Only 22 of respondents believe that the Jews
should go to live in their country, while 42 do
not agree with that, and about 20 agree that
they are focused only on their own goals even if
these are harming others interests. 35 do not
agree with this affirmation. - Only 12 agree that the Jews supported the
instauration of communism in Romania, while about
55 cannot answer this question.
- About 10 of respondents consider that Jewish
actions lead to a lack of stability in the
society, while 48 dont agree with that.
26Perceptions of minorities
In this section only the opinions of the ethnic
Romanians are analyzed
273. Considering your general opinion about
national minorities in our country would you say
that these minorities represent
Base 927 Romanian ethnic respondents
- Only a small proportion of Romanians perceives
part of the minorities living in Romania as a
threat Roma (14) and Hungarians (13)
registered the highest scores on this. These two
minorities are also mentioned representing a
problem for Romania (33 - Roma and 19 -
Hungarians), but not as a threat. - Jews are perceived in a neutral manner by almost
one-third of all Romanian respondents, neither as
a problem, nor as a perceived advantage for
Romania. This minority benefits also from
positive responses, 15 of respondents consider
that Jews have a useful contribution in certain
regions and occupations and 10 declare that they
are a valuable resource for our country.
284. Do you think the following minorities living
in Romania, compared to the majority of the
population have rights...
Base 927 Romanian ethnic respondents
- Most of respondents (58-72) consider that
minorities have the same rights as all the rest
of Romanian citizens.
- There are some respondents who consider that the
Hungarian minority has more rights than the
Romanian majority (21), and 11 has the same
opinion on the Roma minority.
295. Which of these best describes the closest
relationship you would accept with people
belonging to the following minorities?
Base 927 Romanian ethnic respondents
- A smaller social distance regarding Jews is
generated by the fact that they are accepted in
the family (9), in a group of friends (14) or
as neighbors (11) and by the fact there is a
smaller proportion (8) of those who declares
that Jews shouldnt have come to Romania. - Regarding the Hungarians, the Romanians have a
similar comportment accepting them as family
members (8), in friends groups (13) or as
neighbors (9), while 12 declare that Hungarians
shouldnt have come to Romania. - Related to the citizenship variable, the Roma
are better accepted comparative to the Arabs 39
of all respondents accept this right for the Roma
while only 27 for the Arabs. These two groups
have a similar weak position for other nearness
variables (e.g. only 2 agree to accept Roma in
the family, 5 to have them in friends groups, 7
accept having people from this minority as
neighbors, and 22 of Romanians want Roma not to
come to Romania).
305. Which of these best describes the closest
relationship you would accept with people
belonging to the following minorities?
Base 927 Romanian ethnic respondents
- Using Bogardus social distance measure scale (see
the annex), where 1 indicates the closest
accepted relationship with people from a certain
minority (Family member) and 7 the most distant
(Shouldnt come to Romania), we notice there is a
greater tolerance toward the Jews (4.29) and the
Hungarians (4.46) and a significantly lower
tolerance regarding the Roma (5.16) and the Arabs
(5.17). - These differences change depending on the
respondents education level for Jews - from
4.49 (for people with mid-level education) to
3.77 (for people with academic education) - and
similarly for Hungarians (from 4.67 to 3.95, at
educational extremes). - For the Roma and the Arabs there are no
significant differences, the social distance
regarding those two minorities remains the same
for all educational levels.
316. Considering now only the Jews, to which extent
do you agree or disagree with the following
affirmations?
Base 927 Romanian ethnic respondents
POSITIVE AFFIRMATIONS
- More than half of respondents agree the Jews
have good relations with the rest of the
population, a lot of important personalities in
various fields and a great deal of international
influence. This last affirmation registered the
highest scores 27 fully agree that Jews have a
great deal of international influence. - The Jews represent an important minority for
Romania according to 42 of the respondents and
they represent a community which leads to the
progress of the country where they are living.
There is a problem with the last point many
respondents (41) cannot mention - perhaps they
do not know - the achievements of this minority.
326. Considering now only the Jews, to which extent
do you agree or disagree with the following
affirmations?
Base 927 Romanian ethnic respondents
NEGATIVE AFFIRMATIONS
- Only 23 of respondents believe that the Jews
should go to live in their country, while 42 do
not agree, and about 20 agree that they are
focused only on their own goals even if these are
harming the interests of others. 35 do not agree
with this affirmation. - Affirmation that the Jews supported the
establishment of communism in Romania obtain only
12 agreement, and about 55 of Romanian
respondents cannot answer this. - About 10 of respondents consider that Jewish
actions lead to a lack of stability in the
society, while 48 do not agree with that.
33Perceptions of the HOLOCAUST
348. Have you heard about the HOLOCAUST?
Base 1026 respondents
- Most of respondents declare that they are aware
of the Holocaust (65), depending on their
education level and their residence (the lowest
awareness is in the rural areas).
359. Please tell me what do you mean by HOLOCAUST?
Each respondent could give more than one answer
Base 1026 respondents
Base 667 respondents who declared that they kno
w
about Holocaust
- Most of the people who declared in the previous
question that they have heard about the
HOLOCAUST, spontaneously define this term as
Jews extermination by Germans (54). - The following affirmations are placed at a
certain distance from the first one persecution
of European Jews (14), Mass crimes (8) and
deportation of Jews (7).
3610. Considering the HOLOCAUST represents the
systematic state organized persecution and
extermination of the Jewish people by Nazi
Germany, allies and collaborators between 1933
and 1945, do you think this happened
Base 1026 respondents
- The Holocaust is considered to have takne place
in Germany by the majority of respondents (66)
fewer respondents agreed that the Holocaust also
took place in other European countries (39). 52
of ethnic Hungarian respondents mentioned that
the Holocaust took place in other European
countries, significantly higher than average. - Only about 28 of respondents agree that the
Holocaust also took place in Romania, and about
27 cannot name any country.
3711. What did the HOLOCAUST in Romania consist of?
Each respondent could give more than one answer
Base 283 respondents who declared that HOLOCAUS
T
happened also in Romania
- The respondents who declared that the Holocaust
also took place in Romania associated it most
often with Deportation of Jews in isolated areas
or other countries (74), followed by Mass
imprisonments of Jews (67) and Expropriation
and forced evacuation of Jews (62). Mass
executions of Jews (pogrom) is rarely mentioned
(26).
3812. In your opinion, who was responsible for the
HOLOCAUST in Romania?
Base 283 respondents who declared that HOLOCAUST
happened also in Romania
Each respondent could give more than one answer
- Nazi Germany is considered as being mainly
responsible for the Holocaust in Romania (79)
followed at a certain distance by Antonescus
government (11). - Considering all responsible factors, Nazis
Germany was mentioned by 90 of respondents,
Antonescus Government by 47, and the USSR by
11.
3914. How much are you interested in the HOLOCAUST?
15. What is your information source for the
HOLOCAUST?
Base 853 respondents who declared an interest
Base 1026 respondents
Each respondent could give more than one answer
- The population is not highly interested in the
Holocaust only 6 declared themselves interested
or very interested in this topic.
- The main information sources for those who are
interested in the Holocaust are television (38),
followed by history books (14) and radio (11).
4016. Is there a national day for HOLOCAUST
commemoration in Romania?
Base 1026 respondents
- About 22 know there is a national day for
Holocaust commemoration in Romania.
- Only 10 of all the people interviewed mentioned
the date of this event.
41Ion Antonescus Image
4218. Ion Antonescu governed Romania between 1940
and 1944. I will read some attributes of a state
leader and Id like you to tell me how these fit
his character?
Base 1026 respondents
POSITIVE AFFIRMATIONS
- More than 40 of the respondents cannot make any
assessments on Marshal Ion Antonescus
personality, which shows a lack of knowledge
about his activities and the events of that time.
- He is highly appreciated by some of the
respondents as a great patriot (46), a great
strategist (44), while 1/3 of the people
interviewed believe he should be rehabilitated
for what he has done for Romania. - About 24 agree that Ion Antonescu was a
democratic leader, while 27 disagree. Similarly,
22 admit that he achieved the unification of the
country (Great Romania), while 27 disagree with
this affirmation. - Only 15 consider him a rescuer of the Jews,
while 31 do not agree with this statement.
4318. Ion Antonescu governed Romania between 1940
and 1944. I will read some attributes of a state
leader and Id like you to tell me how these fit
his character?
Base 1026 respondents
NEGATIVE AFFIRMATIONS
- Almost 33 of the respondents agree that he was
responsible for crimes against gypsies and 28
agree that he was a dictator.
- Only a quarter of respondents consider him
responsible for crimes against Jews and about 20
consider that he led Romania to disaster and was
a war criminal. About 32 disagree with the last
two statements.
44Perception of the State of Israel
457. Considering Israel and everything you know
about it, what is your opinion regarding this
country?
Base 1026 respondents
NEUTRAL 2,5
- Israel has a rather unclear image, close to a
neutral point, which divides the opinions of
respondents.
- In some regards the image of Israel is negative,
an image of a non-democratic state which supports
terrorism. This might influence the respondents
who consider that Romania should not have closer
relations with Israel.
467. Considering Israel and everything you know
about it, what is your opinion regarding this
country?
Base 927 Romanian ethnic respondents
NEUTRAL 2,5
- When the analysis was focused only on the
Romanian ethnic group we found that, with some
small differences, the entire population holds
similar opinions.