Title: THE FUNDAMENTALS OF GOOD
1- THE FUNDAMENTALS OF GOOD
- DISCLOSURE FOR A 529 PLAN
NAST TREASURY MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE DECEMBER 6,
2004 Elizabeth L. Bordowitz, General Counsel
Finance Authority of Maine Kenneth B. Roberts,
Partner Hawkins Delafield Wood LLP
2Were here to talk about
- DI-S-C-L-O-S-U-R-E
- DISCLOSURE, DISCLOSURE, YEAH!
3What is Disclosure?
- The fundamental aim of the disclosure provisions
in the 33 and 34 Acts is to secure to
potential buyers the means of understanding the
intricacies of the transaction into which they
are invited H.R. Rep. No. 85, 73d Cong., 1st
Sess. 8 (1933)
4OFFICIAL STATEMENT
- final official statement means a document or
set of documents prepared by an issuer of
municipal securities or its representatives
that sets forth information concerning the terms
of the proposed issue such issuers and
entities, enterprises, funds, accounts, and
other persons material to an evaluation of the
Offering (1994) - Those statements that may give rise to federal
securities law liability (2004)
5ANTI FRAUD PROVISIONS
- The antifraud provisions of the Securities Act
give some assurance that caution rather than
recklessness will characterize the issuance of
securities. In other words, the spectre of
liability will have a tendency to make for
conservatism in statements and representations
(1933)
6- When a municipal issuer releases information to
the public that is reasonably expected to reach
investors and the trading markets, those
disclosures are subject to the antifraud
provisions. The fact that they are not published
for purposes of informing the securities markets
does not alter the mandate that they not violate
antifraud proscriptions (1994)
7Who is Responsible for Disclosure?
- Issuers are primarily responsible for the
content of their disclosure documents and may be
held liable under the federal securities laws for
misleading disclosure Because they are
ultimately liable for the content of their
disclosure, issuers should insist that any
persons retained to assist in the preparation of
their disclosure document have a professional
understanding of the disclosure requirements
under the federal securities laws (1989)
8Disclosure Standard
- Rule 10b-5
- unlawful for any person . . . to make any untrue
statement of a material fact or to omit to state
a material fact necessary in order to make the
statements made, in the light of the
circumstances under which they were made, not
misleading . . . in connection with the purchase
or sale of any security - Material
- substantial likelihood that, under all the
circumstances, the omitted fact would have
assumed actual significance in the deliberations
of the reasonable investor . . . put another
way . . . that the disclosure of the omitted
fact would have been viewed by the reasonable
investor as having significantly altered the
total mix of information made available (1994)
9Litigation
- SEC
- administrative
- civil
- criminal (referral to Department of Justice)
- Private Plaintiff
10Rights of Action
- Exchange Act Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 SEC
enforcement and implied private right - Securities Act Sections 11 and 12 express
private rights, applicable to mutual funds but
not to municipal securities - Securities Act Section 17(a) SEC enforcement
- (a)(1) - scienter
- (a)(2) (a)(3) - negligence
11Rule 10b-5 SEC Action
- a materially misleading misstatement or omission
- made or omitted with scienter (fraudulent intent
or recklessness) - in connection with the purchase or sale of a
security
12SEC Municipal Securities Enforcement Actions
- Orange County
- Maricopa County
- Syracuse
- City of Miami
- Massachusetts Turnpike
13Orange County
- SEC report addressed Board members individually
enforcement actions addressed the Board as a
Board, the Treasurer and Assistant Treasurer and
the County and related entities. - a public official may not authorize disclosure
that the official knows to be false - nor may a public official authorize disclosure
while recklessly disregarding facts that indicate
that there is a risk that the disclosure may be
misleading - What is acting recklessly?
- public official has knowledge of facts bringing
into question the issuers ability to repay the
securities - fails to take steps appropriate under the
circumstances to prevent the dissemination of
materially false or misleading information
regarding those facts
14Advice to Issuer Officials
- review the entire document
- ask for clarification as to treatment of facts
known to be material that raise questions of
accuracy or sufficiency - seek information and ask questions of the
officials, employees, professionals, advisors and
third parties who supplied information to be
included in the document - ask follow up questions to determine the
reasonableness of any assumptions or estimates
and - be prepared to defend disclosure practices as
conforming to an appropriate standard of care
15Reliance on Professionals Defense
- make complete disclosure to the appropriate
professional, - request the professionals advice as to what
disclosure is proper, - receive advice regarding the appropriate
disclosure, and - rely in good faith on that advice
16Comparison of Mutual Fund and Municipal Bond
Disclosure
- Mutual Fund
- issuers and principal operating affiliates are
regulated under federal securities law - mutual funds are highly uniform in structure with
controlled differences that lend themselves to
easy comparison - disclosure is comprehensively prescribed, and
reviewed, by SEC regulation - continuous offering
- little need to address external policies
- more institutional than 529 plans
- Municipal Bond
- issuers are States or entities regulated under
state law - issuers and issues are extremely diverse in
factually complex ways - disclosure is largely customary, guided by market
practice, to some extent articulated by industry
statements and developed by working groups - discrete offering
- substantial need to address external policies
- more institutional than 529 plans
17SEC FORM N-1A
- CONTENTS OF FORM N-1A
- GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS Page
- No.
- A. Definitions
5 - B. Filing and Use of Form N-1A
. 5 - C. Preparation of the Registration
Statement . 6 - D. Incorporation by Reference 8
- PART A INFORMATION REQUIRED IN A
PROSPECTUS . 9 - Item 1. Front and Back Cover Pages
. 9 - Item 2. Risk/Return Summary Investments, Risks,
and Performance . 10 - Item 3. Risk/Return Summary Fee
Table 13 - Item 4. Investment Objectives, Principal
Investment Strategies, Related Risks, and - Disclosure of Portfolio Holdings
17 - Item 5. Management, Organization, and Capital
Structure 17 - Item 6. Shareholder Information
19 - Item 7. Distribution Arrangements
21 - Item 8. Financial Highlights Information
. 24
18PART B INFORMATION REQUIRED IN A STATEMENT OF
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
.. 26 Item 9. Cover Page and Table of
Contents 26 Item 10. Fund
History ...........................
26 Item 11. Description of the Fund
and Its Investments and Risks
.26 Item 12. Management of the
Fund 28 Item 13.
Control Persons and Principal Holders of
Securities ..35 Item 14.
Investment Advisory and Other Services
36 Item 15. Brokerage Allocation and
Other Practices .. 39 Item 16.
Capital Stock and Other Securities
40 Item 17. Purchase, Redemption, and
Pricing of Shares 40 Item 18.
Taxation of the Fund
41 Item 19. Underwriters
41 Item 20. Calculation of
Performance Data 42 Item
21. Financial Statements
47
19PART C OTHER INFORMATION
53 Item 22. Exhibits ..........................
..................................................
..................................................
............54 Item 23. Persons Controlled by or
Under Common Control with the Fund
55 Item 24. Indemnification
.55 Item 25. Business and
Other Connections of the Investment
Adviser 55 Item 26. Principal
Underwriters 55 Item
27. Location of Accounts and Records
.55 Item 28. Management Services
.................................................
..................................................
................55 Item 29. Undertakings
..56 SIGNATURES
.56
20COLLEGE SAVINGS PLANS NETWORK DISCLOSURE
PRINCIPLES
- intended to establish a reference for basic
disclosure practices - intended to improve comparability between Plans
- intended to improve comparability, where
applicable, between Plans and direct investment
in mutual funds - not intended to be comprehensive
- not intended to be exclusive
- not intended to be final
21The Definition of Offering Materials
- all documents identified by the State Issuer as
intended to provide substantive disclosure of the
terms and conditions of an investment in its
Section 529 Plan - may include appendices and physically separate
documents - do not include marketing materials or
advertisements that do not include substantive
disclosure or that refer to the Offering
Materials - the Offering Materials should present information
in a clear, concise and understandable manner
22Updating the Offering Materials
- by supplement or republication
- approximately annually to reflect the most recent
annual performance data and other material
changes in the information presented since the
last Offering Materials were issued - interim supplements to the Offering Materials as
deemed necessary by the State Issuer in order to
prevent the Offering Materials from containing an
untrue statement of material fact or omitting to
state a material fact necessary in order to make
the statements made, in light of the
circumstances under which they were made, not
misleading - supplements should be distributed to all existing
account owners and should become part of the
Offering Materials
23Offering Materials Should Include
Finance Authority of Maine
Hawkins Delafield Wood LLP
22
24- the cover page, or its equivalent, should
identify the name of the State or State Issuer at
least as prominently as the name of any private
program manager or investment manager
25- a summary of key features of the Section 529 Plan
26- a prominent statement as to the absence or, if
applicable, the nature of any guarantee (full
faith and credit or otherwise) by, or recourse
to, the State Issuer or the State - if applicable, a prominent statement that the
State tax treatment or other benefits offered by
the State with regard to the Section 529 Plan are
available only to the taxpayers or residents, as
applicable, of the State - in any event, a statement in bold to the effect
that Section 529 Plans offered by other states
may offer tax or other benefits to taxpayers or
residents of those states that are not available
with regard to the State Issuers Section 529
Plan and that taxpayers or residents of those
states should consider such state tax treatment
and other benefits, if any, before making an
investment decision - if applicable, a prominent statement that the
State offers one or more other Section 529 Plans
27 - a prominent statement indicating the principal
location or locations, in the Offering Materials,
of disclosure addressing certain topics,
including, at a minimum - fees and costs
- investment options and investment managers and
how and when the State Issuer may change these - investment performance
- federal and state tax considerations
- risk factors
- limitations or penalties imposed by the Section
529 Plan upon transfers or nonqualified
distributions
28- a description of the federal tax considerations
relevant to Section 529 Plans
29- a description of the state tax considerations
relevant to the Section 529 Plan to which the
Offering Materials relate under the laws of the
State
30WHAT DOES THE DARN THING COST???
COME OUT, COME OUT WHEREEVER YOU ARE
31- a clear and concise description of the initial
and on-going fees and costs, including whether
fees are received by the State Issuer, by any
private program manager or investment manager or
by other private parties
- if applicable, that fees and costs are subject to
change at any time - all applicable fees should be disclosed in a
single section of the Offering Materials - which fees are determined by the amount invested
and which fees are the same regardless of the
account size and should disclose the total fees
payable - if a State Issuer receives a fee, the Offering
Materials should disclose whether the use of that
fee is restricted to Section 529 Plan purposes
and should describe those purposes - If there are fee reductions for any class of
participants or type of withdrawal, those should
be disclosed
32Continued
- the description of fees and costs should include
a fee table - if a Section 529 Plan includes fees and costs in
categories that differ from the categories
included in the suggested fee table form, then a
different tabular presentation that is at least
as specific should be used
33- a discussion of the performance of investment
options which should generally conform to the
requirements that would be applicable to the
underlying investments if invested in directly
- to the extent available, investment option
performance data should be disclosed for one,
five and ten year periods - to the extent not available, data should be
disclosed for the life of the investment option - performance data should be disclosed net of all
generally applicable fees and costs and
identified as such
34- a description of the investment options available
under the Section 529 Plan - a discussion of the investment risks associated
with each option - the description of investment options should also
discuss the right of the State Issuer to change
investment options or managers
35- a prominent discussion of risk factors associated
with the Section 529 Plan which should be
tailored to the particular Section 529 Plan but
should include, at a minimum, the risks of - investment losses,
- federal tax law changes,
- state tax law changes,
- Section 529 Plan changes and contributions to the
Section 529 Plan may adversely affect the
eligibility of the beneficiary or the account
holder for financial aid or other benefits (which
need not include a detailed description of
benefits other than State and federal tax
benefits)
36-
- contact information for the Section 529 Plan as
well as its web address, if any
37- Suggested Fee Charts
- for
- Inclusion in Offering Materials
381 For registered mutual funds, in the absence of
a change that would materially affect the
information, based on most recent fiscal year
reported upon in the applicable funds most
recent prospectus, and for investment options
invested in multiple registered mutual funds,
based on a weighted average of each funds
expense ratio, in accordance with the investment
options asset allocation among the applicable
funds as of date. 2 A footnote should
explain what the miscellaneous fee represents. 3
This total is assessed against assets over the
course of the year and does not include sales
charges or account maintenance fees. The
investor should be referred to the cost table
that shows the total assumed investment cost over
1-, 3-, 5-, and 10-year periods. 4 This footnote
should include a cross reference to a breakpoint
chart, if applicable. 5 If account
maintenance fees can be waived for certain
investors, it should be included in this
footnote. This footnote should explain that
the charge applies to sales during the first 12
months after the investment, if applicable.
39(No Transcript)
401. For registered mutual funds, in the absence of
a change that would materially affect the
information, based on most recent fiscal year
reported upon in the applicable funds most
recent prospectus, and for investment options
invested in multiple registered mutual funds,
based on a weighted average of each funds
expense ratio, in accordance with the investment
options asset allocation among the applicable
funds as of date. 3 This total is assessed
against assets over the course of the year and
does not include sales charges or account
maintenance fees. The investor should be
referred to the cost table that shows the total
assumed investment cost over 1-, 3-, 5-, and
10-year periods. 5 If account maintenance fees
can be waived for certain investors, it should be
included in this footnote.
41Approximate Cost of 10,000 Investment
1 Assumes redemption at the end of the
period 2 Assumes no redemption
42(No Transcript)
43Electronic Distribution and Website Practices
- available guidance is primarily in the form of
several SEC releases - 33-7233 (October 6, 1995)
- 33-7288 (May 9, 1996)
- 33-7289 (May 9, 1996)
- 33-7856 (April 28, 2000)
- areas of concern for 529 Plans
- treatment of hyperlinked material
- evidence of delivery of disclosure documents
- consistency between website and disclosure
documents - republication theory in the context of a
continuous offering
44Rule 15c2-12
- limited utility
- trap for unwary
- best policy would be for the SEC to amend Rule to
exempt 529 Plans from continuing disclosure
requirements and to and develop continuous
offering concept
45Cost Containment
- schedule to permit reasonable professional work
- early, disciplined full working group involvement
- make sure working group understands real
production and distribution requirements - consider bidding production
- front load formatting
- tax disclosure
46Proposed Internal Revenue Service Circular 230
Tax Disclosure Requirements
- regulations governing tax advisors practicing
before the IRS in connection with tax shelters - currently expressly excludes tax-exempt bonds and
does not address 529 Plans - proposed elimination of exclusion raises separate
issue of applicability to each - defines tax-shelter opinion to include federal
tax disclosure included in a public offering
document - requires consideration and conclusion with
respect to any federal tax issue for which the
IRS has a reasonable basis for successful
challenge and which could have a significant
impact under any reasonably foreseeable
circumstance, on the federal tax treatment of a
taxpayers item of income, gain, loss,
deduction, or credit, the existence or absence of
a taxable transfer of property, or the value of
property - requires specific cautionary language
47Regulation of Advertising and Sales
- MSRB Notice 2004-16
- NASD Special Notice to Members 03-17
- SEC Release 33-8358, file No. 57-06-04 (proposed
Rules 15c2-2 and 15c2-3 confirmation and point
of sale disclosure requirements)