Dr Justin Greaves

1
Interaction With Social and Economic Sciences
(the RELU Experience)

• Dr Justin Greaves
• University of Warwick

2

• We are not students of some subject matter, but
  students of problems. And problems may cut right
  across the borders of any subject matter or
  discipline (Popper, 1963)

3
RELU 1 at Warwick

• Project on the regulatory and environmental
  sustainability of biopesticides
• Essentially a collaboration between political
  scientists and plant scientists
• The University of Warwick sought to bring
  together natural scientists from Warwick HRI with
  social scientists from the main campus to explore
  possible common research projects
• The creation of the RELU programme created a
  relevant funding opportunity

4
RELU 3 at Warwick

• Project on the Governance of Livestock Disease
  (GoLD)
• One challenge here has been the large and diverse
  mix of disciplines involved. There are four team
  members from Biological Sciences (including a
  veterinary epidemiologist, an infectious disease
  epidemiologist, an ecologist and a mathematical
  modeller), two from Political Science, two from
  Economics and one from Law

5
Politics a junction subject?

• In many ways politics is the junction subject of
  the social sciences, born out of history and
  philosophy, but drawing of the insights of
  economics and sociology and, to a lesser extent,
  the study of law, psychology and geography
• This openness (eclecticism) can be seen as a
  strength allowing interdisciplinary work to
  flourish

6
However.....

• A recent ESRC benchmarking review of political
  science notes that interdisciplinary networks
  are patchy
• Relatively little co-operation between natural
  scientists and political scientists
• Writers such as Moran (2006) and McKenzie (2007)
  take a rather pessimistic view of
  interdisciplinary collaboration
• Recent symposium issue of European Political
  Science on interdisciplinarity

7
Is Politics a discipline?

• We cannot talk about political science as a
  discipline if those who call themselves political
  scientists and pretend to teach it are unable to
  agree on its basic substance and methodology
  (EPSNet, 2003)
• It is questionable whether politics is a
  discipline in the strictest sense at all (Kelly
  2009)
• A field of enquiry rather than a discipline?

8
What is interdisciplinarity?

• I think what we mean .. is people from different
  disciplines coming together with the various
  research methods, tools, techniques and processes
  that they know about. . . and doing two things
  sharing that knowledge between the disciplines,
  so theres a kind of import and export of
  knowledge between them, but actually bringing
  those things together to create new tools,
  research methods, which can be applied to
  problems that genuinely sit between or problems
  that disciplines have in common or problems where
  you need a multi-disciplinary approach to solve
  them (Tom Innes, Director of Designing for the
  21st Century)

9
Our projects in practice

• Benefit of close geographical proximity
• Importance of email correspondence (electronic
  brainstorming)
• Steep learning curve for the political scientists
• Biologists thought that political scientist might
  be identified with a particular political
  position, or at least researching the legitimacy
  of different political positions

10
Creating understanding

• In both projects a procedure followed of each
  discipline reading literature selected from the
  other disciplines and presenting their
  understanding of the article to team meetings
• This allowed misunderstandings to be resolved and
  helped create an understanding of how the other
  disciplines worked in terms of methodology and
  vocabulary

11
The importance of interaction

• On the GoLD project we have regular research team
  meetings (organised and run by the post-doctoral
  researchers)
• Importance of informal interaction
• It would be ironic, although historically
  rather symmetrical, if the genesis of future
  great ideas owed more to the consequences of
  lunch than to metrics

12
Language and terminology

• Often talk of the need for a common language in
  interdisciplinary research
• The phrase trading zone is often used to denote
  an interdisciplinary partnership in which two or
  more perspectives are combined and a new, shared
  language develops (Collins, Evans and Gorman,
  2007)
• Perhaps the key is a shared understanding
  (Bracken Oughton, 2006). We aspire to a GoLD
  terminology

13
Co-authorship

• Perhaps the greatest challenge has been writing
  together for joint publications
• Biological scientists are used to tersely argued
  research papers that present key findings in a
  few printed pages, perhaps as few as one
• Political science articles more discursive
• It can be a challenge, therefore, to carve out a
  coherent and readable paper.
• How do you standardise the jargon of different
  disciplines without losing thread of the content?
  

14
Change consultant

• We are working with a change consultant and
  business coach, specialising in practical,
  measurable methods of improving individual, team
  and business performance
• Given the challenges of an interdisciplinary
  project this should promote effective team
  working. We hope it will allow team meetings to
  be even more productive and improve and focus our
  interdisciplinary writing

15
Please visit our websites

• http//www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/pais/biopesticid
  es
• http//www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/gld
  
• Thanks to all members of the RELU 1 and RELU 3
  project teams (principal investigators Wyn Grant
  and Graham Medley)