Title: RADIATION PROTECTION IN DIAGNOSTIC AND INTERVENTIONAL RADIOLOGY
1RADIATION PROTECTION INDIAGNOSTIC
ANDINTERVENTIONAL RADIOLOGY
IAEA Training Material on Radiation Protection in
Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
- L 21 Optimization of Protection in Pediatric
Radiology
2Introduction
- Good radiation protection policy in Pediatric
radiology is essential. - There exist International recommendations and
code of good practice in this field which
constitute a framework for an effective
implementation of the optimization principle to
diagnostic examinations.
3Topics
- General recommendations
- Quality criteria for radiographic images
(EUR-16261 document) - Recommendations for X Ray equipment and rooms for
pediatric radiology - References
4Overview
- To become familiar with the principles of
radiation protection in pediatric radiology, the
X Ray systems to be used and the principles of
optimization and quality assurance.
5Part 21 Optimization of Protection in Pediatric
Radiology
IAEA Training Material on Radiation Protection in
Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
- Topic 1 General recommendations for pediatric
radiology
6General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- General, equipment and installation
considerations - The generator should have enough power to allow
short exposure times (3 milliseconds) and the
timer should allow short exposure times - The generator should be of high frequency to
improve the accuracy and reproducibility of
exposures - Automatic exposure control (AEC) devices should
be used with caution in pediatrics - AEC should have specific technical requirements
for pediatrics
7General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Careful manual selection of exposure factors
usually results in lower doses - X Ray rooms for pediatrics should be designed for
improving the childs cooperation (control panel
with easy patient visibility and contact, etc.) - Fast film-screen combinations have advantages
(reduction of dose) and limitations (higher
repetition rate) - Low-absorbing materials in cassettes, tables,
etc. Are specially important in pediatrics
radiology
8General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- The antiscatter grid in pediatrics gives limited
improvement in image quality and increases
patient dose given the smaller irradiated volume
(and mass) the scattered radiation is less - Antiscatter grids for pediatrics should have
specific technical requirements - Antiscatter grid should be removable in pediatric
equipment, particularly fluoroscopic systems - Image intensifiers should have high conversion
factors for reducing patient dose in fluoroscopic
systems
9General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Specific kV-mA dose rate curves for automatic
brightness control (ABC) should be used in
fluoroscopic systems for pediatrics. - It is preferable not to use the ABC unless there
is an automatic cut-off device. - For CT examinations, the use of specific
technical radiographic parameters for CT
examinations should be promoted (lower mAs than
for adults, and lower kV in some cases). - The use of mobile X Ray units in pediatrics could
raise special problems (low power, etc).
10General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- In pediatrics, there are advantages and
disadvantages of under-couch and over-couch
fluoroscopy units - Pulsed fluoroscopy allows patient dose reduction
- Digital equipment and the role/use of frame-grab
technique may allow dose reductions - The cine playback (digital) and video playback
(digital/conventional fluoroscopy) in screening
examinations may allow patient dose reductions - Additional tube filtration may allow dose
reductions
11General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Reduction of exposure
- The causes of repeating films in pediatrics
should be analyzed periodically (reject analysis)
as part of the audit program. Feedback should be
foreseen - Immobilization can reduce the repeating film rate
- The different immobilization devices available
for pediatric radiology to make application
atraumatic should be considered. The role of
simple aids such as sticky tape, sponge wedges
and sand bags should also be considered.
12General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Short exposure times can improve image quality
and reduce the number of films repeated - The use of mobile X Ray units for pediatrics
should be restricted due to the difficulty in
getting short exposure times - Radiographers should have specific training in
pediatric radiology - Gonadal protection is specially important in
pediatric radiology. Several sizes and types of
protectors should be available
13General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Collimation is important (in addition to the
basic collimation corresponding to the film size)
in pediatric patients, particularly window
protection for hips and lateral collimation
devices for follow-up scoliosis - The correct patient positioning and collimation
is important in pediatrics, particularly for
excluding the gonads from the direct beam - It is important to establish whether adolescent
girls (over 12 years) might be pregnant when
abdominal examinations are contemplated
14General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Motion is a greater problem in children and could
require specific adjustment of radiographic
techniques - Proper consultative relationship between the
referring physician and the radiologist is
specially important in pediatrics - Agreed protocols and diagnostic pathways should
be promoted
15General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Some radiological examinations are of
questionable value in children (like some
follow-up chest radiographs in simple pneumonia,
abdominal radiographs in suspected constipation,
etc.) - The repetition of a radiological examination in
pediatrics should always be decided by the
radiologist.
16General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Appropriate projections for minimizing dose in
high risk tissues should be used (PA projections
should replace AP where possible for spinal
examinations) - Additional filters should be available to enable
them to be easily changed (1 mm Al 0.1 and 0.2
mm Cu should be available).
17General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Dedicated pediatric room or complete sessions
dedicated to pediatric radiology should be
available -
- Experienced staff who can obtain the childs
confidence and cooperation in a secure and
child-friendly environment are of paramount
importance in reducing radiation doses in
pediatrics - Specific referral criteria for pediatric
radiology should be available, e.g. for head
injury where the incidence of injury is low
18General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Referral criteria for all X Ray examination of
children should be established, especially those
which may be age-related, e.g. scaphoid not
ossified, below age of 6 years, nasal bones
cartilaginous below age of 3 years - High kV techniques should be used when possible
- Long focus patient distances could be used to
minimize patient entrance dose (with the
compromise of appropriate exposure times)
19General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Light beam diaphragm to move the patient into
position should be used rather than screening
during overcouch fluoroscopy procedures - Audit and quality assurance should be promoted in
maintaining or improving image quality with
reasonable dose
20General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Risk factors
- As children are at greater risk of incurring
stochastic effects, pediatric examinations should
require special consideration in the
justification process -
- Thus the benefit of some high dose examinations
(e.g. computed tomography, IVU, etc.) should be
carefully weighed against the increased risk
21General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Risk factors
- Longer life expectancy in children means a
greater potential for manifestation of possible
harmful effects of radiation - Radiation doses used to examine young children
should generally be smaller than those employed
in adults - Risk factors for cancer induction in children is
between 2 and 3 times higher than for adults
22General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Patient dosimetry - Guidance levels
- Measuring patient doses in pediatrics presents
special difficulties (small values) - Dosimetric techniques used for patient dosimetry
in pediatrics should be specifically adapted - Patient dose values are related to patient size
23General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Guidance levels in pediatrics should be related
with patient size - Guidance levels available at present for
pediatrics are limited of a small set of values - The use of guidance levels in pediatric radiology
should be used with caution due to the difficulty
of measuring patient dose and the limited set of
available values to be used as reference
24General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Protection of personnel and parents
- Parents can cooperate in the radiological
examination of their children if they are duly
informed and duly protected - Parents exposure in this situation can be
considered as a medical exposure but optimization
criteria must be applied
25General recommendations for pediatric radiology
- Parents or helpers should be duly informed and
should know exactly what is required of them - Pregnant women should not be allowed to help
during pediatric examinations - Lead aprons and lead gloves (if the hands are
near the direct radiation field) should be used
in these situations
26ICRP-ISR smart message for pediatrics
27Part 21 Optimization of protection in Pediatric
Radiology
IAEA Training Material on Radiation Protection in
Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
- Topic 2 Quality criteria for radiographic images
(EUR document)
28European Guidelines on Quality Criteria for
Diagnostic Radiographic Images in Paediatrics,
July 1996. EUR 16261 EN Free PDF version
available at http//www.cordis.lu/fp5-euratom/sr
c/lib_docs.htm
29(No Transcript)
30(No Transcript)
31Criteria related to images
- The Image Criteria for pediatric patients
presented for a particular type of radiograph are
those deemed necessary to produce an image of
standard quality - No attempt has been made to define acceptability
for particular clinical indications - The image criteria allow an immediate evaluation
of the image quality of the respective
radiograph. They are appropriate for the most
frequent requirements of radiographic imaging of
pediatric patients
32Criteria related to images
- The anatomical features and body proportions vary
due to the developmental process in infancy,
childhood and adolescence - They are different in the respective age groups
and are distinct from those of a mature patient - The Guidelines presuppose knowledge of the
changing radiographic anatomy of the developing
child. - The term consistent with age indicates that the
respective image criteria essentially depend on
the age of the patient
33Criteria related to images
- The smaller body size
- The age dependent body composition
- The lack of co-operation and many functional
differences (e.g. higher heart rate, faster
respiration, inability to stop breathing on
command, increased intestinal gas etc.) - Prevent the production of radiographic images in
pediatric patients to which standard adult image
criteria can be applied
34Criteria related to images
- Correct positioning of pediatric patients may be
much more difficult than in co-operative adult
patients - Effective immobilization often necessitates the
use of auxiliary devices - Sufficient skill and experience of the imaging
staff and ample time for the particular
investigation are the imperative prerequisites to
fulfil this quality criterion in infants and
younger children
35Criteria related to images
- Incorrect positioning is the most frequent cause
of inadequate image quality in pediatric
radiographs - Image criteria for the assessment of adequate
positioning (symmetry and absence of tilting etc)
are much more important in pediatric imaging than
in adults - A lower level of image quality than in adults may
be acceptable for certain clinical indications
36Criteria related to images
- An inferior image quality, however, cannot be
justified unless this has been intentionally
designed and must then be associated with a lower
radiation dose - The fact that the X Ray was taken from a
non-cooperative pediatric patient (anxious,
crying, heavily resisting) is not an excuse for
producing an inferior quality film which is often
associated with an excessive dose
37Criteria for Radiation Dose to the Patient
- Expressed in terms of a reference value for the
entrance surface dose for a standard sized
pediatric patient - Reference dose values are available only for the
most frequently performed types of radiographs
for which sufficient data were acquired in a
series of European Trials on infants, 5 year old
and 10 year old patients
38Criteria for Radiation Dose to the Patient
- The assessment of compliance with the criteria
for radiation dose to the patient for a specific
radiograph unavoidably involves some form of dose
measurement - This requires representative sampling of the
patient population - A number of dose measurements methods are
described in the European Guideline
39General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Image Annotation
- The patient identification, the date of
examination, positional markers and the name of
the facility must be present and legible on the
film - These annotations should not obscure the
diagnostically relevant regions of the radiograph - An identification of the radiographers on the
film would also be desirable
40General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Quality Control of X Ray Imaging Equipment
- Quality control programs should be instigated in
every medical X Ray facility and should cover a
selection of the most important physical and
technical parameters associated with the types of
X Ray examination being carried out - Limiting values for these technical parameters
and tolerances on the accuracy of their
measurement should be required
41General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Low Attenuation Materials
- Recent developments in materials for cassettes,
grids, tabletops and front plates of
film-changers using carbon fiber and some new
plastics enable significant reduction in patient
doses - This reduction is most significant in the
radiographic-voltage range recommended in
pediatric patients and may reach 40. Use of
these materials should be encouraged
42General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Patient Positioning and Immobilization
- Patient positioning must be exact whether or not
the patient co-operates. - In infants, toddlers and younger children
immobilization devices, properly applied, must
ensure that - the patient does not move
- the beam can be centered correctly
- the film is obtained in the proper projection
- accurate collimation limits the field size
exclusively to the required area - shielding of the remainder of the body is
possible.
43General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Patient Positioning and Immobilization
44General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Patient Positioning and Immobilization
45General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Patient Positioning and Immobilization
46General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Patient Positioning and Immobilization
47General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Patient Positioning and Immobilization
- Immobilization devices must be easy to use, and
their application atraumatic to the patient. - Their usefulness should be explained to the
accompanying parent(s). - Radiological staff members should only hold a
patient under exceptional circumstances - Even in quite young children the time allocation
for an examination must include the time to
explain the procedure not only to the parents but
also to the child
48General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Field Size and X Ray Beam Limitation
- Inappropriate field size is the most important
fault in pediatric radiographic technique - A field which is too small will immediately
degrade the respective image criteria - A field which is too large will not only impair
image contrast and resolution by increasing the
amount of scattered radiation but also, most
importantly, result in unnecessary irradiation of
the body outside the area of interest
49General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Field Size and X Ray Beam Limitation
- Correct beam limitation requires proper knowledge
of the external anatomical landmarks by the
technician - These differ with the age of the patient
according to the varying proportions of the
developing body. - In addition, the size of the field of interest
depends much more on the nature of the underlying
disease in infants and younger children than in
adults
50General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Field Size and X Ray Beam Limitation
- A basic knowledge of pediatric pathology is
required for radiographers and other technical
assistants to ensure proper beam limitation in
these age groups - The acceptable minimal field size is set by the
listed recognizable anatomical landmarks for
specific examinations
51General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Field Size and X Ray Beam Limitation
- Beyond the neonatal period, the tolerance for
maximal field size should be less than 2 cm
greater than the minimal - In the neonatal period, the tolerance level
should be reduced to 1.0 cm at each edge
52General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Field Size and X Ray Beam Limitation
- In pediatric patients, evidence of the field
limits should be apparent by clear rims of
unexposed film - Beam-limiting devices automatically adjusting the
field to the full size of the cassette are
inappropriate for pediatric patients - Discrepancies between the radiation beam and the
light beam must be avoided by regular assessment
53General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Additional filtration
- The soft part of the radiation spectrum which is
absorbed in the patient is useless for the
production of the radiographic image and
contributes unnecessarily to the patient dose - Part of it is eliminated by the filtration of the
tube, tube housing, collimator etc., but this is
insufficient - Most tubes have a minimum filtration of 2.5 mm
Al - Additional filtration can further reduce
unproductive radiation and thus patient dose
54General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Additional filtration
- For pediatric patients, total radiation dose must
be kept low, particularly when high speed screen
film systems or image intensifying techniques are
used - Not all generators allow the short exposure
times that are required for higher kV technique - Low radiographic voltage is frequently used for
pediatric patients. This results in comparatively
higher patient doses.
55General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Additional filtration
- Adequate additional filtration allows the use of
higher radiographic voltage with the shortest
available exposure times, thus overcoming the
limited capability of such equipment for short
exposures - This makes the use of high speed screen film
systems and image intensifier photography possible
56General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- For all examinations of pediatric patients, the
examples for Good Radiographic Technique
include standard equipment of lead-rubber
shielding of the body in the immediate proximity
of the diagnostic field - Special shielding has to be added for certain
examinations to protect against external
scattered and extra-focal radiation
57General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- For exposures of 60 - 80 kV, maximum gonadal dose
reduction of about 30 to 40 can be obtained by
shielding with 0.25 mm lead equivalent rubber
immediately at the field edge - However, this is only true when the protection is
placed correctly at the field edge
58General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- The gonads in "hot examinations", i.e. when they
lie within or close (nearer than 5 cm) to the
primary beam, should be protected whenever this
is possible without impairing necessary
diagnostic information - It is best to make one's own lead contact
shields for girls and lead capsules for boys - They must be available in varied sizes
59General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- By properly adjusted capsules, the absorbed dose
in the testes can be reduced by up to 95 - In girls, shadow masks within the diaphragm of
the collimator are as efficient as direct
shields. They can be more exactly positioned and
do not slip as easily as contact shields - When shielding of the female gonads is
effective, the reduction of the absorbed dose in
the ovaries can be about 50
60General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- There is no reason to include the male gonads in
the scrotum within the primary radiation field
for radiographs of the abdomen - The same applies, usually, for films of the
pelvis and micturating cystourethrographies. The
tests should be protected with a lead capsule,
but kept outside the field - In abdominal examinations gonad protection for
girls is not possible
61General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- In practice, the great majority of pelvic films
show that female gonad protection is completely
ineffective - The position of all sorts of lead material is
often ludicrous - There are justifiable reasons for omitting gonad
protection for pelvic films in girls, e.g.
trauma, incontinence, abdominal pain, etc
62General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- The eyes should be shielded for X Ray
examinations involving high absorbed doses in the
eyes, e.g. for conventional tomography of the
petrous bone, when patient cooperation permits - The absorbed dose in the eyes can be reduced by
50 - 70 - In any radiography of the skull the use of
PA-projection rather than the AP-projection can
reduce the absorbed dose in the eyes by 95
63General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- PA-projection, therefore, should be preferred as
soon as patient age and co-operation permit prone
or erect positioning - As developing breast tissue is particularly
sensitive to radiation, exposure must be limited - The most effective method is by using the
PA-projection, rather than the AP
64General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Protective Shielding
- While this is well accepted for chest
examinations, the greatest risk is during spinal
examinations, and here PA examinations must
replace AP - It should also be remembered that thyroid tissue
should be protected, whenever possible, e.g.
during dental and facial examinations
65General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Radiographic Exposure Conditions
- Knowledge and correct use of appropriate
radiographic exposure factors, e.g. Radiographic
voltage, nominal focal spot value, filtration,
film-focus distance is necessary because they
have a considerable impact on patient doses and
image quality - Permanent parameters of the apparatus such as
total tube filtration and grid characteristics
should also be taken into consideration
66General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Automatic Exposure Control
- Adult patients vary in size, but their variation
is minimal compared to the range in pediatric
patients from premature infants, weighing
considerably less than a thousand grams, to
adolescents approaching 70 kg - Those investigating pediatric patients must be
able to adapt to this range. One would expect
that a device for automatic exposure control
(AEC) would be helpful
67General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Automatic Exposure Control
- Many of the AEC systems commonly available are
not satisfactory - They have relatively large and fixed ionization
chambers. Neither their size nor their shape nor
their position is able to compensate for the many
variations of body size and body proportion in
pediatric patients - In addition, the usual ionization chambers of
AECs are built in behind a grid
68General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Automatic Exposure Control
- AEC-use may be associated with the use of the
grid (where the grid is not removable) which is
frequently unnecessary - The optimal adaptation of the radiographic
technique to the clinical needs requires the use
of screen film systems of different speeds and
different switch-off doses at the image receptor
69General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Automatic Exposure Control
- Screens and AEC chambers are wavelength
dependant, particularly in the lower range of
radiographic voltage, but these dependencies do
not correspond with each other - AECs lengthen the minimal exposure times
- All these factors must be considered when AECs
are used in pediatric patients
70General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Automatic Exposure Control
- Specially designed pediatric AECs have a small
mobile detector for use behind a lead-free
cassette - Its position can be selected with respect to the
most important region of interest - This must be done extremely carefully, as even
minor patient movement may be disastrous
71General principles associated with good imaging
performance
- Automatic brightness control
- Automatic brightness control (ABC) has to be
switched off during fluoroscopic examinations
where there are relatively large areas of
positive contrast material to avoid excessive
dose rates, e.g. full bladders
72Guidance on implementation of quality criteria
- Quality Criteria are presented for a number of
selected radiographic projections used in the
course of routine types of X Ray examination - They apply to pediatric patients with the usual
presenting symptoms for the type of examination
being considered - They are to be used by radiologists,
radiographers, and medical physicists as a check
on the routine performance of the entire imaging
process
73Guidance on implementation of quality criteria
- However, the Quality Criteria cannot be applied
to all cases -
- For certain clinical indications lower level of
image quality may be acceptable, but this should
ideally always be associated with a lower
radiation dose to the patient
74Guidance on implementation of quality criteria
Under no circumstances should an image which
fulfils all clinical requirements but does not
meet all image criteria ever be rejected
75(No Transcript)
76(No Transcript)
77Diagnostic Reference Doses in Pediatrics
Examples of Diagnostic Reference Doses in
Pediatrics, for standard five-year-old patients,
expressed in entrance surface dose per image, for
single views (from EUR-16261)
78Diagnostic Reference Doses in Pediatrics
Examples of Diagnostic Reference Doses in
Pediatrics, for standardfive-year-old patients,
expressed in entrance surface dose per image,for
single views (from EUR-16261)
79Part 14.1 Optimization of Protection in
Pediatric Radiology
IAEA Training Material on Radiation Protection in
Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
- Topic 3 Recommendations for X Ray room and
equipment
80Recommendations for X Ray room and equipment to
be used in pediatrics
- Visibility of the patient and easy audio
communication from the control panel - High frequency generators of 600-800 mA with
linearity from 50 until 120-150 kV - Exposures of 3 ms should be possible. AEC devices
should be specifically adapted - Different control for the anode rotation and
exposure (specially important for chest
examinations to avoid respiratory movement)
81Recommendations for X Ray room and equipment to
be used in pediatrics
- Low absorption materials and plastic cassettes
should be used - Antiscatter grid should be removable
- When using the grid, this should be Fixed
(specific for pediatric) or with very fast
movement due to the short exposure times - Image intensifier (I.I.) of 15 cm can be the
appropriate size for small patients. Higher sizes
or multimode I.I. can produce worse images
82Recommendations for X Ray room and equipment to
be used in pediatrics
- The use of additional filtration should be
considered in pediatric X Ray equipment - Mobile X Ray system for pediatrics should have
the highest possible output - Immobilization devices should be available in
pediatric rooms
83References
- European Guidelines on Quality Criteria for
Diagnostic Radiographic Images in Paediatrics,
July 1996. EUR 16261. Available at
http//www.cordis.lu/fp5-euratom/src/lib_docs.htm
- ICRP Publication 34, Protection of the Patient in
Diagnostic Radiology. Annals of the ICRP (2/3)
1982. - NCRP 68. Radiation protection in pediatric
radiology, 1981.
84References
- Cook JV, Shah K, Pablot S, Kyriou J, Pettet A,
Fitzgerald M. Guidelines of best practice in the
X-ray imaging of children. Edited by the Queen
Marys Hospital of Children. London 1998. - Guidelines on education and training in radiation
protection for medical exposures. Radiation
Protection 116. European Commission 2000.
Available at http//europa.eu.int/comm/environmen
t/radprot
85References
- Guidance on diagnostic reference levels (DRLs)
for medical exposures. Radiation Protection 109.
European Commission 1999. Available at
http//europa.eu.int/comm/environment/radprot - Rational use of diagnostic imaging in pediatrics.
WHO, 1987.
86Summary
- Particular attention should be given to technical
specifications of X Ray equipments and protocols
used in X Ray pediatric radiology. - Radiologists and radiographers should be
specifically trained and the higher
radiosensitivity of the patients should be taken
into account. - General rules of protection and guidelines are
presented.