Zero Defects in Semiconductor Manufacturing for Automotive Applications

1
Zero Defects in Semiconductor Manufacturing for
Automotive Applications https//yieldwerx.com/
2
The semiconductor industry plays a critical role
in providing electronic components for automotive
applications. With the increasing complexity and
reliance on electronic systems in vehicles, the
need for zero defects in semiconductor
manufacturing has become paramount. Automotive
customers demand high-quality components to
ensure the reliability, safety, and performance
of their vehicles. Therefore, semiconductor
manufacturers are focusing on implementing
stringent quality control measures to minimize
defects, reduce field returns and warranty
issues, and mitigate liability concerns. The Role
of Part Average Testing (PAT) in Achieving Zero
Defects The Automotive Electronics Council has
recommended the use of Part Average Testing (SPAT
semiconductor) as a methodology to improve the
quality and reliability of semiconductor parts.
PAT involves the identification and removal of
abnormal parts from the population based on their
test results. The goal is to eliminate outliers
and ensure that only parts meeting the specified
quality standards are shipped to customers. PAT
is typically performed by identifying test
results that fall outside the six-sigma limit
from the population mean for a given wafer, lot,
or group of parts being tested. Any test result
beyond this limit is considered an outlier and is
removed from the population. By implementing PAT,
semiconductor manufacturers can significantly
enhance the quality and reliability of their
supplied parts. Importance of PAT in the
Automotive Industry The automotive industry
presents unique challenges for semiconductor
manufacturers due to the criticality of
electronic components in safety-critical systems
such as braking, traction control, and stability
control. The failure of a semiconductor component
in these systems can have severe consequences,
including accidents and potential loss of
life. To meet the stringent reliability
requirements of the automotive industry,
semiconductor suppliers must prioritize the
implementation of zero defects initiatives. PAT
serves as a crucial tool in achieving this
objective by identifying and eliminating parts
that do not meet the required quality standards.
By adhering to the Automotive Electronics
Council's recommendations and performing PAT at
both wafer probe and final test stages, suppliers
can ensure the highest quality parts are
delivered to their automotive customers.
3
Challenges in Implementing PAT While the benefits
of implementing PAT are clear, semiconductor
suppliers face various challenges in effectively
applying this methodology. One significant
challenge is minimizing the impact on yields and
manufacturing costs. As manufacturing costs
continue to decrease, the cost of testing remains
relatively constant, leading to shrinking profit
margins for semiconductor devices. Thus,
suppliers must carefully evaluate their test
processes and identify candidate tests for PAT
while minimizing yield losses. Furthermore, the
implementation of PAT requires sophisticated
analysis and simulation tools. Suppliers need to
have a deep understanding of the impact of
applying PAT on their supply chain. Without
proper analysis and simulation, suppliers may
apply the specifications blindly, potentially
missing critical tests and compromising
reliability. Real-Time PAT versus Statistical
Post-Processing There are two main approaches to
implementing PAT real-time processing and
statistical post-processing (SPP). Each approach
has its advantages and considerations, and
semiconductor manufacturers must choose the most
suitable method based on their specific
requirements. Real-time PAT involves calculating
dynamic PAT limits and making binning decisions
in real time as parts are tested. This approach
requires a dynamic real-time engine capable of
handling complex data streams, as well as a
robust statistical engine for calculating new
limits and monitoring the entire process for
stability and control. Real-time processing works
for both the wafer probe and final test stages
and allows for immediate feedback and corrective
actions. On the other hand, statistical
post-processing involves analyzing test data
after a lot has been completed. Binning decisions
are made based on the processed data, and the
results are typically used for wafer probe tests.
However, at the package test stage, where
tracking and serialization are not available,
statistical post-processing becomes
challenging. Choosing the appropriate approach
depends on factors such as test time
requirements, the need for real-time process
feedback, and the ability to handle baseline
outliers. Real-time PAT offers the advantage of
immediate feedback and proactive quality
management during testing, while statistical
post-processing is suitable for analyzing large
volumes of data after the completion of a lot.
4
Sophisticated Analysis and Simulation Tools for
Effective PAT Implementation To successfully
implement PAT and achieve zero defects in
semiconductor manufacturing, suppliers must
leverage sophisticated analysis and simulation
tools. These tools enable a comprehensive
evaluation of the test processes, identification
of candidate tests for PAT, and iterative
refinement of the candidate list. Advanced
analysis and simulation tools provide insights
into the potential impact of applying PAT on
yield, manufacturing costs, and overall quality.
They allow suppliers to optimize their test
processes and identify the most effective tests
for ensuring high-quality parts. By utilizing
these tools, semiconductor manufacturers can make
informed decisions, reduce yield losses, and
achieve the desired level of quality and
reliability. The Benefits of Real-Time, Active
Quality Management Real-time, active quality
management based on sound statistical
methodologies is the preferred approach for
semiconductor manufacturers aiming to meet
reliability requirements without disrupting the
test process. This approach offers several
benefits, including Dynamic Limit
Calculation Real-time PAT enables the calculation
of dynamic PAT limits, which adapt to the
performance of the material being tested. This
ensures that the limits are continuously adjusted
based on the specific characteristics of each
wafer or lot, resulting in tighter control over
the quality of the parts. Immediate Binning
Decisions With real-time PAT, binning decisions
can be made during testing, allowing for
immediate identification of outliers and their
segregation into dedicated outlier bins. This
proactive approach enables early detection of
potential quality issues, enabling prompt
corrective actions. Real-Time Process
Feedback Real-time quality management provides
the opportunity for immediate process feedback.
By monitoring the test process in real time,
semiconductor manufacturers can identify trends,
patterns, or anomalies that may indicate process
variations. This enables them to take timely
actions to maintain stability and control
throughout the manufacturing process.
5

• Advanced Failure Pattern Analysis
• Both real-time PAT and statistical
  post-processing methods enable the application of
  advanced algorithms for failure pattern analysis.
  These algorithms can identify specific failure
  patterns, such as regional PAT, where certain
  devices pass while surrounded by failing devices.
  Identifying such patterns helps in further
  improving reliability by eliminating potentially
  unreliable devices.
• Conclusion
• Achieving zero defects in semiconductor
  manufacturing is crucial for meeting the demands
  of the automotive industry. By implementing Part
  Average Testing (PAT) and adhering to the
  recommendations of the Automotive Electronics
  Council, semiconductor manufacturers can improve
  the quality and reliability of their supplied
  parts. The choice between real-time PAT and
  statistical post-processing depends on factors
  such as test time requirements and the need for
  immediate process feedback.
• Leveraging sophisticated analysis and simulation
  tools is essential for effective PAT
  implementation. Real-time, active quality
  management based on sound statistical
  methodologies offers significant benefits,
  enabling semiconductor manufacturers to meet
  reliability requirements while maintaining
  efficient testing processes.
• References
• Automotive Electronics Council (AEC) - AEC-Q001
• Erb, A. et al. (2018). Part Average Testing
  Using Robust Statistics to Optimize Device Test
  and Manufacturing. IEEE Transactions on
  Semiconductor Manufacturing, 31(2), 191-200. DOI
  10.1109/TSM.2018.2820758
• Han, Y. et al. (2016). An Efficient Framework for
  Real-Time Semiconductor Test Data Processing.
  IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing,
  29(1), 59-71. DOI 10.1109/TSM.2015.2428445
• Wang, C. et al. (2020). Statistical Process
  Control in Semiconductor Manufacturing A
  Comprehensive Review. IEEE Access, 8,
  201329-201347. DOI 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3038626