Letting end users add constraints

1
The following slides show how KANAL results can
be used in answering some of the questions in the
CP spec
2
COA Critique from CP spec

• Engagement of Main Elements of Enemy combat power
  (B.3. 1st paragraph 2nd line)
• Q Are the assigned Blue units sufficient
  against the Red force?
• ? For each step, check the preconditions that
  compare the required force ratio of the given
  task with the actual force ratio

3
KANAL results for the answer

• Step Attack by Fire (aviation battalion attacks
  Red artillery)
• Checking effects
• Remaining strength of 29th Guards is 60
• Step Holding Attack supporting attack by 1st
  brigade against 29th guards
• Checking conditions
• actual force ratio (1.2) gt requred force ratio
  (1)
• ? this condition succeeded
• Step Attack to Destroy main attack by 3rd and
  4th brigade against 29th guards
• Checking conditions
• actual force ratio (3.5) gt requred force ratio
  (3)
• ? this condition succeeded
• Checking effects
• Remaining strength of 29th Guards is 50
• Step

modify critiquing knowledge
Disagree
4
COA Critique (cont)

• Risk
• (Q15 of section 3.4)
• Q Have I accepted too much risk to my own forces
  in this COA?
• ? Highlight the tasks with large attrition

5
KANAL results for the answer

• Step Moving 1st and 2nd brigade on Axis Green to
  Jayhawk
• Checking conditions
• Units can move on the path (axis green)
• ? This condition succeeded
• Checking effects
• 1st and 2nd brigade is near Jayhawk
• Step Attack to Destroy main attack by 1st and
  2nd brigade against 29th guards
• Checking conditions
• Required force ratio gt 3 (2.9)
• ? this condition succeeded
• Checking effects
• Remaining strength of 29th Guards 70
• Remaining strength of 1st and 2nd brigade 60
• Step

6
COA Critique (cont)

• Mission Accomplishment (c.4.1)
• Use expected effects

7
KANAL results for the answer

• Step Move
• You said that 3rd and 4th brigade should be near
  Jayhawk after this step
• The effect is in fact achieved
• Expected Effects of the COA
• You said that
• Red unit should be destroyed (remaining strength
  lt 50) Destruction of 29th guards
• This effect is in fact achieved
• Blue is located at Jayhawk seizure of Obj
  Jayhawk
• This effect is in fact achieved
• Blue strength gt 90
• This effect is not achieved
• end tasks by 1720 hrs
• This effect is in fact achieved

details