Title: Chapter 3: FixedIncome Securities
1Chapter 3 Fixed-Income Securities
- Initial Example (p. 48, Luenberger, Running
Amortization). - You take out a 1,000, 5-year loan you will repay
at 12 interest, compounded monthly. You pay the
bank 22.24 each month. For the bank, this is
like a fixed-income security. The bank provides
1,000 up front, and then gets 22.24 a month for
60 months. - Each month balance is increased by interest of 1
and then decreased by payment.
2Example (Contd)
3Example (Contd)
4Example (Contd)
- Questions of Interest
- How do we compute the monthly payment of 22.24
to pay off the loan in 5 years? - Does as much of the loan go towards interest in
later months as in earlier months? - Basically the same thing happens if you take out
a mortgage to buy a house. The loan amount,
period, and interest rates will be different, of
course. How would we compute the monthly
payment? Would your equity in the house increase
more per month in the initial months of the
mortgage, or in the final months? From the
viewpoint of the bank, you provide them with a
type of fixed-income annuity when you take out a
mortgage.
5F-I Instruments
- This chapter is about various types of
fixed-income annuities, the most important of
which are bonds. - Financial Instrument a promise of payment
- Security a financial instrument that can be
traded freely and easily in a well-developed
market. - Fixed-income security a financial instrument
that is traded in a well-developed market, and
promises a fixed (definite) income to the holder
over a span of time. Such a security represents
ownership of a definite CFS.
6U.S. Government (F- I) Securities
- Web Sites www.ustreas.gov
- go to www.ustreas.gov/sales.html
- U. S. Treasury bills
- are issued in denominations of 10K or more,
- have terms to maturity of 13, 26 and 52 weeks,
- are sold on a discount basis (bill with face
value of 10 K may sell for 9.5K), - can be redeemed for the full face value at
maturity. - U. S. Treasury bills
- are offered weekly,
- are highly liquid (can be sold easily),
- can be sold prior to maturity date.
7U. S. Treasury Notes
- have maturities of 1 to 10 years
- are sold in denominations of 1K or more
- can be purchased by individuals dealing directly
with a FRB (Federal Reserve Bank), e.g.,
Jacksonville - can be sold prior to maturity
- Owner of note receives a coupon payment every 6
months until maturity. - Coupon payment represents an interest payment of
fixed magnitude throughout the life of the note.
8U. S. Treasury Notes (Contd)
- At maturity, the note holder receives the last
coupon payment and the face value of the note. - Purchaser has option to renew the note at
maturity at the rate prevailing at that time. - The only risk (unless government goes bankrupt)
with these notes is that the going rate could go
up after the note has been purchased. E.g., you
might buy a 5-year note at 6, and two years
after you buy it the rate goes up to 8. - Example, 5-year note, denomination 1K.
- CFS (-1000,30,30,30,30,30,30,30,30,30,1030)
9U. S. Treasury bonds
- Are issued with maturities of more than 10 years
- Are similar to Treasury notes they make coupon
payments - Are not similar to Treasury notes in that they
may be callable. - A note is callable if at some scheduled coupon
payment date the Treasury can force the
bondholder to redeem the bond at that time for
its face value.
10U. S. Treasury Strips
- Are bonds issued in stripped form
- Example. 10-year stripped bond has 20 semiannual
coupon securities, each with its own ID number
(CUSIP) and also the principal security. Each
security generates a single cash flow. There are
no (zero) intermediate coupon payments. This type
of security is called a zero-coupon bond. - STRIPS means the Separate Trading of Registered
Interest and Principal of Securities. The STRIPS
program lets investors hold and trade the
individual interest payments or principal payment
of certain Treasury notes and bonds as separate
securities in book-entry form.
11U. S. Treasury Strips (Contd)
- A fully-constituted Treasury note or bond
consists of a principal payment and semiannual
interest payments. For example, a 10-year
Treasury note for 1,000 consists of 20 interest
payments one every six months for 10 years
and a principal payment of 1,000 when the note
matures. If this security were stripped each
of the 20 interest payments and the principal
payment would become a separate component or
security. Each of the components could then be
separately sold or traded.
12U. S. Treasury Strips (Contd)
- The components of a stripped security are
frequently referred to in the marketplace as
Treasury zeroes or Treasury zero coupons.
They are called zeroes because purchasers of
such securities do not receive explicit periodic
interest payments. - STRIPS may be purchased and held only through
financial institutions and government securities
brokers and dealers.
13Meaning of F-I Security
- Originally, this was a security paying a fixed,
well-defined CFS to the owner. - The only uncertainty about the CFS payment was
default by the payer. - Nowadays, f-I securities promise CFSs whose
magnitudes are tied to various contingencies or
fluctuating indices.
14F-I Security Meaning (Contd)
- Example . Adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) Payment
levels may be tied to an interest rate index. - Example . Corporate bond payments may be in part
governed by a stock price. - General Idea F-I Security a security with a CFS
that is fixed except for variations due to
well-defined contingent circumstances.
15Savings Deposit
- Offered by commercial banks, SLs, credit
unions. Deposits guaranteed (in U.S.) by some
agencies of the federal government. - - demand deposit pays a rate of interest that
varies with market conditions. - - time deposit account- pays a guaranteed
interest when the deposit is maintained for some
given time length, or assesses a penalty for
early withdrawal. - - certificate of deposit similar to 2), but
issued in standard denominations. Large CDs can
be sold in a market.
16Money Market
- Money Market is the market for short-term (1 year
or less) loans by corporations and financial
intermediaries, such as banks. - Well-Known Money Market Example in U.S. Money
Market Checking Account. - There is some minimal deposit amount (e.g., 5K)
- There is a limit on the number of checks that can
be written - Deposits are invested in the money market, which
is the source of interest on the account, and
reason for name - Currently paying about 5 interest
- Rate paid varies daily (usually very little).
- Money market checking accounts are not insured by
agencies of the federal government. Sometimes
they are insured by an insurance company.
17Commercial Paper
- Commercial Paper is an unsecured loan (loan
without collateral) in the money market made to
corporations. - Bankers Acceptance ( MORE ON ACCEPTANCES.DOC )
- Company A sells goods to company B
- Company B sends a written promise to A to pay for
the goods within a fixed time. - A bank accepts the promise if the bank promises
to pay the bill on behalf of company B. - Company A can then sell the acceptance to C (at a
discount) before the fixed time has expired. - A gets money from C, bank then pays C, B pays
bank at some point. B uses the acceptance to buy
goods on credit. A deals with the bank and does
not need to worry about Bs credit rating.
18Eurodollar Deposits
- Eurodollar deposits are denominated in dollars
but held in a bank outside the US. - Eurodollar CDs. CDs denominated in dollars and
issued by banks outside the U.S. - Banking regulations and insurance may be
different from in the U.S. - A U. S. company might prefer to trade in
Eurodollars to avoid problems with currency
fluctuations.
19Bonds
- Are issued by agencies of the federal government,
by state and local governments, and by
corporations. - Indenture the contract of terms that comes with
a bond. - Debt Subordination. To protect bond holders,
limits may be set on the amount of additional
borrowing by the issuer. Also the bondholders
may be guaranteed that in the event of
bankruptcy, payment to them takes priority over
payments of other debt the other debt is
subordinated. - Callable bonds. A bond is callable if the issuer
has the right to repurchase the bond at a
specified price. Usually this call price falls
with time. Often there is an initial call
protection period when the bond cannot be called.
20Municipal Bonds
- Are issued by agencies of state and local
governments. - general obligation bonds backed by a governing
body, e.g., the state - revenue bonds backed either by the revenue to be
generated by the project funded by the bond
issue, or by the agency responsible. - Municipal bonds, and related mutual funds based
on them, are popular with very wealthy investors.
The interest income is exempt from federal
income tax, and from state and local taxes in the
issuing state. Usually this means a lower
interest rate compared to other securities of
similar quality. (If you had a taxable bond
paying 6, and were in the 31 tax bracket, a
municipal bond paying (1-0.31) ? 6 4.14
would be competitive.)
21Corporate Bonds
- Corporate bonds are issued by corporations to
raise capital for operations and new ventures.
They vary in quality depending on the strength of
the corporation and features of the bonds. - Most corporate bonds are traded over-the-counter
in a network of bond dealers. They are often not
traded on an exchange, and so may not be as
liquid.
22Sinking Funds
- Rather than incur the obligation to pay the
entire face value of a bond issue at maturity, an
issuer may establish a sinking fund to spread
this obligation out over time. Under such an
arrangement, the issuer may repurchase a certain
fraction of the outstanding bonds each year at a
specified price.
23Mortgages
- Mortgages are bonds. A home owner who takes out
a mortgage sells it to bank or lending agency,
the mortgage holder, to generate immediate cash
to pay for the home. The owner is obligated to
make periodic payments to the mortgage holder. - Standard mortgage structure equal monthly
payments throughout the term. Early repayment is
often allowed. - Compare to standard bond structure final payment
is equal to the face value at maturity, earlier
payments are for interest.
24Mortgages (Contd)
- Because of allowing early repayment of a
mortgage, it is not completely fixed income to
the mortgage holder. - Balloon payment mortgages modest sized periodic
payments, and then a final balloon payment to
complete the contract. - Adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) the interest
rate is adjusted periodically according to an
interest rate index. Such mortgages do not
generate fixed income. - Remark. Mortgages are often bundled into large
packages and traded among financial institutions.
In this sense they are securities, even though
they are contracts between two parties.
Mortgage-backed securities are quite liquid.
25Mortgages (Contd)
- Important Practical Note. In the U.S., interest
on mortgages is tax deductible from federal
income tax. - For example, if your annual income is 50,000,
and 6,000 of your 10,000 annual mortgage
payments in some year goes to interest, then you
would be taxed on an income of 44,000. Assuming
you are in the 28 tax bracket, and ignoring
other deductions, instead of paying a federal
tax of 0.28 ? 50,000 14,000 you would pay a
federal tax of 0.28 ? (50000 6000) 12,320.
In effect, the government provides a subsidy of
your mortgage. You reduce your taxes by 0.28 ?
6,000 1,680. - See an example at the file MORTGAGE.XLS
26Annuities
- An annuity is a contract that pays the holder
the annuitant money periodically, according to
a predetermined schedule or formula, over a
period of time. - Example. Pension for the life of the annuitant.
Purchase price would depend on age of annuitant
when purchased, and number of years until
payments begin. - Remark. Sometimes interest can be earned until
the payments begin. Interest accumulates tax
free until the payments begin. Postponing tax
payments can make an annuity more attractive as
an investment. - Annuities are not traded. However, they are
considered to be investment opportunities
available at standardized rates. To the
investor, they serve the same role as other F-I
instruments.
27Value Formulas
- Motivating Questions.
- You make a car payment, or mortgage payment,
every month. What is the present value of all
the payments? - You get a treasury note payment every six months.
What is the present value of all the payments? - You get an annuity payment every month. What is
the present value of all the payments?
28Perpetual Annuity
- Perpetual Annuity is an annuity that pays a fixed
sum, A, periodically forever. (Useful for
analytical purposes. Actually exist in the U.K.)
A amount paid per period
r the
per-period
interest rate
forever
P the present value
P A/(1r) A/(1r)2 A/(1r)3 A/(1r)4
Note
P A/(1r) 1/(1r) A/(1r)1 A/(1r)2
A/(1r)3
A/(1r) P/(1r)
P (A P)/(1r)
Þ
P r P A P
Þ
Þ
P A/r A(P/A,r,n)
29Perpetual Annuity Formula
- The present value P of a perpetual annuity that
pays an amount A every period, beginning one
period from the present, when r is the one-period
interest rate, is given by - Example. Annuity of 6,000 per year at r 6
- P 6000/0.06 100,000.
30Finite-Life Streams
- A amount paid per period
- r the per-period interest rate
- P the present value
- n number of periods
31Finite-Life Streams (Contd)
32Annuity Formula
- Consider an annuity that begins payment one
period from the present, paying an amount A each
period for a total of n periods. Suppose the
one-period interest rate is r, and the number of
periods is n. The present value P of the annuity
is given by - Equivalently
-
33Annuity Formula (Contd)
- An easy way to handle the computations is to
first compute the following term, say k(n,r) - k(n,r) (1/r)1 1/ (1r)n.
- It then follows that
- P A ? k(n,r), A P/k(n,r)
34Annuity Example
- A 6,000 per year. r 6. n 30.
- P (A/r)1 1/(1r)n
- 1000001 1/(1.06)30
- 1000001 0.17411013 100000 ? 0.825889869
- 82,589
- With 82,589 at 6 interest you could get an
annuity of 6,000 for 30 years. (Compare w.
100,000 to get 6,000 per year forever.) - Warning. In the annuity formulas, r is the
per-period interest rate (e.g. month)
35Amortization
- Amortization is the process of substituting
periodic payments for a current obligation of
quantity P. - Given P, k(n,r), compute A P / k(n,r) to get
the periodic payment. - Example. Take out a loan at 6 for 5 years to
pay off a car purchase. We amortize the cost of
the car over 5 years. With monthly payments, n
60, r 0.06/12 0.005, k(n,r) 51.725566075.
If the car costs P 20,000, then A
386.66/month is the value of each periodic
payment.
36Annual Percentage Rate (APR)
- Rate the base interest rate not including any
fees and expenses associated with the mortgage - Points percentage of loan amount charged
up-front for providing the mortgage - Terms the time length to pay off the mortgage
- Max amt the amount borrowed for the mortgage
- APR the rate of interest that, if applied to
the loan amount with all fees and expenses, would
result in a monthly payment of A.
All the fees and expenses are added to the loan
balance, and the sum is amortized at the stated
rate over the stated period. This results in a
fixed monthly payment amount, A.
37APR Example
- Example
- Base Rate r 7.625,
- APR ra 7.883,
- Term 30 years
- Loan amount P 203,150
- number of periods n 12 x 30 360
- rate with fees and expenses ra 0.07883/12
0.006569 - Capital Recovery Factor (A/P,n,ra) 0.007256
- monthly payment Aa P (A/P,n,ra) 203,150
0.007256 1,474.11 - We have computed the monthly payment.
- This amount includes amortized fees and expenses.
38APR Example (Contd)
- By contrast, at 7.625 compounded monthly for 360
month, - n360 r0.007625/12 P203,150
- A P (A/P,n,r) 1,437.88
- we would only need to pay 1,437.88 a month.
- The difference Aa - A 1,474.11 - 1,437.88
36.23 - is because of the amortized fees and
expenses. - Rate without fees and expenses r 0.07625/12
0.006354167 - Multiplier (P/A,n,r) 141.2840966
- Present value of payments Pa Aa (P/A,n,r)
208,267 - Total initial balance 208,267
- This is the present value of the payments of A
each month for 360 months, at 7.625. - We see it exceeds the amount of the loan,
- because Aa includes the other (amortized) fees
and expenses.
39APR Example (Contd)
- Total fees and expenses ? 208,267 - 203,150
5,117 - Alternatively, at r7.625, with n 60,
- the PV of the fees and expenses CFS is
- 36.23 (P/A,n,r) 36.23 141.2840966 ?
5,118 - Loan fee is 1 of 203,150, ? 2,032.
- Other expenses 5,117 - 2,032 3,085 (about
1.52 of the loan amount) - If we know the amount of the loan, we can compute
the other expenses the broker would charge,
although they are not in the ad.
40Summary, Mortgage Example, 30 year loan
- Data
- APR ra 7.883 with fees expenses
- rate r 7.625 without fees expenses
- n 30 ? 12 360 payments
- P 203,150 is the maximum loan amount
- Monthly Payment With fees expenses
- ra 0.07883/12, n 360 ? (A/P,n,ra)
0,007256 ? - Aa P (A/P,n,ra) 1,474.11 monthly payment
with amortized fees and expenses - Monthly Payment Without fees expenses
- r 0.07625/12, n 360 ? (A/P,n,r) 0,007078 ?
- A P (A/P,n,r) 1,437.88 monthly payment w/o
fees expenses
41Summary, Mortgage Example (Contd)
- Monthly difference of two CFSs
- Aa - A 1,474.11- 1,437.88 36.23 is the
amortized fees and expenses. - PV of Monthly difference
- At r7.625, with n 60, the PV of the fees and
expenses CFS is - 36.23 (P/A,n,r) 36.23 141.2840966 ?
5,118 - PV of monthly payments with fees expenses
- Alternatively, at r7.625 with n 60, the PV
of the monthly payment of Aa1,474.11 is - Aa (P/A,n,r) 1,474.11 141.2840966
208,267 - Total fees expenses 208,267 - 203,150
5,117 - Loan fee is 1 of 203,150 ? 2,032.
- Other expenses 5,117 - 2,032 3,085
- (about 1.52 of the loan amount).
42Annual Worth
- Suppose we have a CFS (x0, x1,, x1n)
- Present value analysis transforms this stream to
the equivalent stream (v, 0,, 0) - The annual worth method transform the stream to
- (0,A,,A), where A is called annual worth
43Bonds
- Features of bonds
- have the greatest monetary value among F-I
securities - are the most liquid of the F-I securities
- are very important as investment vehicles
- are very complicated in the details, but
basically simple
44- Example of a 1,000, 9 Bond, annual coupons, 5
years. - You pay 1,000, the face value or par value, to
the issuer or the seller. - At the end of years 1,2, 3, 4, and 5 you get
coupon payments of 90. - Also at the end of year 5 you get the face value,
1,000. - CFS (-1000,90,90,90,90,1090)
- Bonds in the US often have a period of 6 months
between payments. In this case this 9 bond
would have coupon payments of 45.
45- The issuer sells the bonds to raise capital
immediately, and then is obligated to make the
prescribed payments. - Usually bonds are issued with the coupon rates
close to the prevailing general rate of interest. - The vast majority of bonds are sold either at
auction or through an exchange organization.
Prices are determined by a market and thus may
vary.
46- Table 3.3 illustrates US. Treasury Bonds.
- Prices are quoted as a percent of face value. A
price of 100 for a 1,000 bond means a price of
1,000 95 means 950. - The indicated coupon rate is the annual rate.
- The bid price is the price dealers are willing to
pay for the bond. - The ask price is the price at which dealers are
willing to sell the bond.
47- Prices are quoted in 32nds of a point. An asked
price of 103 30/32 is shown in the table as
10330. For a bond of 1,000 face value, this
means its price would be 1,039.38. - (The 32nds idea goes back to dividing a gold
coin into halves, then quarters, then eighths,
.) - The yield is based on the ask price in a manner
to be discussed.
48- Bond quotations ignore accrued interest, which
must be added to the price quoted to find the
actual amount you pay for a bond. -
Accrued Interest Example - Feb. 15- May 8- Aug.15
- On May 8 you buy a 1,000 US Treasury bond that
matures on August 15 in some later year. - Coupon rate is 9. Each coupon payment is 45.
- Coupon payments are every February 15 and August
15. - May 8 is 83 days from February 15, and 99 days
until August 15 (in a leap year).
49- Accrued Interest Example (Contd)
- You will receive your first coupon payment of 45
in 99 days, but the coupon payment is based on
182 days (in a leap year). Without an
adjustment, you would be receiving too big a
first payment. - The adjustment is called accrued interest, AI,
and is added to the price quoted for the bond. - In this example, AI is computed as
- AI 83/(8399) ? 4.50 (83/182) ? 4.50 2.05
.
50-
- Accrued Interest Example (Contd)
- This 2.05 is added to the price of the bond,
20.50, so you pay 1,020.50 instead of 1,000.
All of your coupon payments are 45.00. - More generally, AI is computed as follows
- AI ( of days since last coupon)/( days in
current coupon period) ? coupon amount.
51- Bonds are essentially F-I securities. However,
they may default if issuer has financial
difficulties or declares bankruptcy. - Bonds are rated by rating organizations to
characterize the risk associated with them. US
Treasury bonds are considered risk free, and are
not rated.
52(No Transcript)
53- Ratings reflect a judgment of the likelihood
that bond payments will be made as scheduled.
Bonds with low ratings usually sell at lower
prices than comparable bonds with high ratings. - Web Addresses
- www.moodys.com
- www.standardpoor.com
54- A bond rating organization considers the
following aspects, among others, in assigning a
bond rating - - ratio of debt to equity
- - ratio of current assets to current liabilities
- - ratio of cash flow to outstanding debt
- - various other ratios
- - trend in ratios over time
- Bonds with low ratings must have lower prices
than bonds with high ratings. Buyers will only
accept more risk if they can expect to increase
their earnings.
55- Yield is the IRR for the bond
- A bonds yield is the interest rate implied by
the payment structure. The yield is the interest
rate at which the present value of the stream of
payments (all the coupon payments plus the final
face-value redemption) is equal to the current
price. - The yield is termed yield to maturity to
distinguish it from other yield measures. Yields
are quoted on an annual basis.
56(No Transcript)
57- F face value of bond
- C total of yearly coupon payments
- m number of coupon payments per year
- P current price of the bond
- ? the yield (to maturity) ? is the number that
satisfies - P F/(1?/m)n (C/m)/(1?/m) (C/m)/(1?/m)2
(C/m)/(1?/m)n
58(No Transcript)
59- Notes
- ? is not given, but must be computed, as in IRR
computations. - Excel has a Yield function.
60Sensitivity Analysis Price-Yield Curve
- How does price depend on yield, i.e., how does P
depend on ?? - Boundary Case ? 0.
- P F/(1?/m)n (C/m)/(1?/m) (C/m)/(1?/m)2
(C/m)/(1?/m)n F n(C/m) - (add all the coupon payments to the face value
to get the price)
61- Remaining Case ? gt 0
- P F/(1?/m)n (C/?) 1 1/1 (?/m)n
- Questions of interest
- - What happens to price (as of face value) as
yield increases? - - At what rate does price (as of face value)
change as yield increases? - - What is the effect of the value of the coupon
(as of face value) on the price-yield curve? - - What is the effect of the value of the
maturity, n, on the price yield curve? - - How does sensitivity of price to yield depend
on the coupon rate?
62(No Transcript)
63- Consider the 10 graph for a bond with a 10
coupon payment. - Price decreases as yield goes up. The bond
market went down means that yields went up. - Price decreases at a decreasing rate.
- The price-yield curve is convex.
- For ? 0, to 100 we add 30 ? 10 300 to get
400. There are 30 10 payments added to the 100
face value.
64- What is the price if ? 0.1 (i.e., 10 )?
-
- P/F 1/(1?/m)n (C/F)/? 1 1/1
(?/m)n - If the bond is 10, this means C/F 10 and
- (C/F)/? 1. Thus
- P/F 1/(1?/m)n 1 1/1 (?/m)n
1 - So PF . Value of bond, P par value, F.
- A bond with yield rate coupon rate is called a
par bond. A bond is like a loan where the
interest on principal is paid each year and
principal remain constant.
65(No Transcript)
66- 15 Coupon Rate Curve
- If ? 0, price 100 15 ? 30 550.
- Par point of 100 is at 15 now.
- This price-yield curve is larger everywhere than
the corresponding 10 curve. For a fixed
maturity date, the price-yield curve rises as the
coupon rate increases.
67- Graphs of price-yield for bonds with 10 coupon
rate for three different maturates 30, 10 and 3
years.
68- All bonds are at par with a yield of 10. The
curves pivot about the par point. - As maturity increases, the price-yield curve
becomes steeper. - Implication longer maturities imply greater
sensitivity of price to yield. - The price-yield curve gives information on the
interest rate risk associated with a bond. - Suppose you can buy a 10 bond at par (yield
10) with a maturity of either 3 years or 30
years. - For the 30-year bond, if the yield goes up to
11, the price drops from 100 to 91.28.
69- Yield Risk
- If yields change, bond prices also change. If
the yield goes up and you must sell the bond
prior to maturity you will get less for it. This
is an immediate risk, affecting the near-term
value of the bond. - If you can continue to hold the bond you will
continue to receive the promised coupon payments,
and the face value at maturity (assuming no
default). - The bond with the 30-year maturity is much more
sensitive to yield changes than the bond with the
3-year maturity (see the following pictore and
compare).
70- Graphs of price-yield for bonds with 10 coupon
rate for three different maturates 30, 10 and 3
years.
71- Other Yield Measures
- Current Yield (CY) Example
- A 10, 30-year bond. It sells at par (at 100).
Coupon payment 0.1 ? 100 10. - CY 10/100 ? 100 10
- CY (annual coupon payment/bond price) ? 100
- If bond price sells at 90, CY 10/90 ? 100
11.11
72- Yield to Call (YTC) For callable bonds
- This is the IRR calculated assuming the bond is
in fact called at the earliest possible date. - YTC is a conservative approach to calculating
yield. - Other yield measures exist.
73Bond Duration
- Bonds with long maturities have steeper
price-yield curves than bonds with short
maturities. - The prices of long bonds are more sensitive to
interest rate changes than those of short bonds - (see the following table).
74- Table 3.5. Prices of 9 Coupon Bonds
Yields
Time to
5
8
9
10
15
maturity
1 year
103.85
100.94
100.00
99.07
94.61
5 years
117.50
104.06
100.00
96.14
79.41
10 years
131.18
106.80
100.00
93.77
69.41
20 years
150.21
109.90
100.00
91.42
62.22
30 years
161.82
111.31
100.00
90.54
60.52
75- The bond with the 30-year maturity is much more
sensitive to yield changes than the bond with the
1-year maturity. - Because maturity affects sensitivity to yield
changes, it is useful to consider various
measures of time length.
76- Example Duration (after Figure 3.5) A 7 bond
with 3 years to maturity. Bond sells at 8
yield.
77- For each period k, find the present value of the
payment received at period k, say PVk. - Compute the total present value, say PV
- Let tk denote the time of payment k.
- For each k, compute the product (PVk/PV) ? tk
- Add these products to get the duration, D.
78- Example (Contd)
- k 1, , 6 tk 0.5, 1.0, , 3.0
- The PVk are in column D, PV 97.3789
- The ratios (PVk/PV), i.e., weights, are in
column E - The products (PVk/PV) tk are in column F
- D is the total of the column F entries, D
2.75271 years
79- Note the biggest weight is for the
biggest-payment period. - Question. What is the duration of a zero-coupon
bond? - Answer. Its maturity
- Conclusion. Duration can be viewed as a
generalized maturity measure. It is an average
of the maturities of all the individual payments.
80Macaulay Duration
- When the PV is calculated using the bonds yield
as the interest rate, the general duration
formula becomes the Macaulay duration. - A financial instrument makes payments m times per
year - there are n periods
- ck is the payment in period k, k 1, , n
- ? is the YTM
- PVk ck/1 (?/m)k
- PV PV1 PVn
- tk k/m
- D (PV1/PV)(1/m) (PV2/PV)(2/m)
(PVn/PV)(n/m)
81- Macaulay Duration Formula
- (coupon payments are identical)
- y yield per period
- c coupon rate per period
- m periods per year
- D (1y)/my-1yn(c-y)/mc(1y)n-1my
82(No Transcript)
83- Observations
- Durations do not increase appreciably with
maturity. - With a fixed yield, duration increases only to a
finite limit as maturity is increased. - Durations do not vary rapidly with respect to the
coupon rate. - Very long durations (20 years or more) are
achieved only by bonds that have both very long
maturities and very low coupon rates.
84Duration and Sensitivity
- Key Conclusion Price sensitivity formula. The
rate of change of the price of a bond is
inversely proportional to its duration. If D
denotes the duration, and P the price, then - dP/d? -1/(1(?/m)) D P - DM P
- ?
- (1/P) dP/d? - DM
- where DM 1/(1(?/m)) D is called the modified
duration.
85- Note for large m, small ?, DM 1/(1(?/m)) D ?
D. - We can use the equation dP/d? - DM P to
estimate the change in price due to a small
change in yield by using the approximation - ?P/?? ? dP/d? - DM P
- ?P ? - DM P ??
- We now have an explicit (approximate) equation
for the impact of yield variations on prices.
86- Example 3.8 A 30-year, 10 coupon bond.
- price P 100 at par point, ? 0.10.
- duration D 9.94 for ? 0.10
- DM D/(1?/m) D/(1 0.1/2) 9.94/1.05
9.47. - dP/d? - DM P -947
- ?P ? - DM P ?? -947 ??
- If yield changes from 10 to 11, ?? 0.01, ?P
? -9.47, so price drops from 100 to about 90.53.
87- Example 3.8 (Contd)
- An exact calculation shows price 91.3062 for ?
0.11. The estimate is 90.53. - If YTM decreased from 10 to 9, we would
estimate price is now 100 9.47 109.47. An
exact calculation shows price 110.2737 for ?
0.09.
88(No Transcript)
89- See Figure 3.6.
- Using this approximation amounts to constructing
a tangent line to the price-yield curve of the
bond at ? 0.10, and estimating the function
locally with the linear approximation the tangent
line provides. Because of convexity of the
price-yield curve, this linear approximation will
always overestimate the change due to an increase
in ?, and underestimate the change due to a
decrease in ?.
90- Derivation of Slope Result
- P c1 1(?/m)-1 c2 1(?/m)-2 cn
1(?/m)-n - PVk ck1 (?/m)-k,
- dPVk/d? -k ck1 (?/m)-k-1(1/m)
- -(k/m) ck1 (?/m)-k-1
- -(k/m) 1 (?/m)-1 ck1 (?/m)-k
- -(k/m) 1 (?/m)-1 PVk
91- Derivation of Slope Result (Contd)
92Duration of a Portfolio
- You have a portfolio of several bonds, say A and
B, of different maturities. - The portfolio acts like a master F-I security.
- The payments for various bonds in portfolio may
differ. - All the bonds in the portfolio have the same
yield (bond yields tend to track each other
closely). - Basic Question. What is the duration of the
portfolio?
93- Bond Duration
- DA (PV0A/PA) t0 (PVnA/PA) tn
- DB (PV0B/PB) t0 (PVnB/PB) tn
- Portfolio PV
- P PA PB
- By analogy, a way to define the duration D for
A,B is - D (PV0A PV0B )/P t0 (PVnA PVnB)/P
tn
94- Note the following
- PA DA PV0A t0 PVnA tn
- PB DB PV0B t0 PVnB tn
- PA DA PB DB (PV0APV0B)t0
(PVnAPV0B)tn - (PA /P) DA (PB /P) DB
- (PV0A PV0B )/P t0 (PVnA PVnB)/P tn
D
95- Conclusion
- If we know the durations of DA and DB of the
bonds A and B, all with a common yield, we can
compute the duration D of the portfolio A,B,
given - P PA PB
- as follows
- D (PA /P) DA (PB /P) DB
- (a weighted average of DA, DB)
96Important Implications
- The duration of a portfolio measures the interest
rate sensitivity of the portfolio just as normal
duration does for a single bond. - If the yield changes by a small amount, the total
value of the portfolio will change approximately
by the amount predicted by the equation relating
prices to (modified) duration - dP/d? -1/(1(?/m)) D P - DM P
- ?P ? - DM P ??
97- If the bonds in the portfolio have different
yields, the composite duration can still be used
as an approximation. In this case a single
yield, perhaps the average, is chosen. - We calculate PVs with this single yield value,
so they will only be approximations. We then
compute the weighted average duration as above.
98Immunization of a Portfolio
- Immunization of a portfolio is the structuring of
a bond portfolio to protect against interest rate
risk. We try to make the portfolio value
immune to interest rate changes. - Immunization is one of the most widely used
analytical techniques in investment science. It
is used to shape portfolios of F-I securities
held by pension funds, insurance companies, and
other financial institutions. - To properly structure a portfolio we must know
its purpose. The purpose gives insight into the
associated risks.
99- Example 1. You buy T-bills to use next year for
a house renovation. There is little or no risk,
because you know how much they will be worth in a
year, and that you will use them in a year. - Example 2. You buy a 10-year zero-coupon bond to
use next year for a house renovation. You will
need to sell the bond in a year, but you do not
know what its value will be then. Its purchase
would be risky.
100- Example 3. You must pay off a balloon mortgage
in 10 years. You buy a 10-year zero-coupon bond.
Its value in 10 years is known, and there is very
little risk. - Example 4. You must pay off a balloon mortgage
in 10 years. You buy 1-year T-bills and renew
them annually. You are now subject to
reinvestment risk, since you do not know what the
renewal rates will be. - Example 5. An insurance company faces a series
of cash obligations. It would like to buy a
portfolio of bonds to pay for the obligations as
they arise.
101- One Approach Perfect Matching. Buy a set of
zero-coupon bonds with maturities and face values
exactly matching the separate obligations (if
possible). - Second Approach Buy corporate bonds (higher
yields). Perfect matching is no longer possible.
- Buy a portfolio with a value equal to the present
value of the stream of obligations. - Sell some of the portfolio whenever you need
cash. - Buy more bonds if the portfolio delivers more
cash than needed at a given time.
102- If the yield does not change, with the second
approach the value of your portfolio will
continue to match the PV of the remaining
obligations. - However, if the yields change, the value of your
portfolio and the present value of the obligation
stream will both change, and probably by
different amounts. You may no longer be able to
meet your obligations with your portfolio. Your
portfolio will no longer be matched.
103- We would like to achieve several things with the
portfolio - have enough money to meet the obligations,
- make the rate of change of the portfolio w.r.t.
yield the same (or almost the same) as the rate
of change of the obligations w.r.t. yield. - The goal can be achieved
- (1) by making the PV of the portfolio the same
as the PV of the stream of obligations, - (2) by making the duration of the portfolio the
same as the duration of the stream of
obligations.
104- Achieving (2) relies on the fact that ?P ? - DM P
??. Matching the durations also (approximately)
matches the rates of change of the prices w.r.t.
changes in yields. If - yields increase, the PV of the portfolio and of
the obligation will decrease by approximately the
same amount - yields decrease, the PV of the portfolio and of
the obligation will increase by approximately the
same amount - This means the value of the portfolio will still
be adequate to cover the obligation.
105- Example. Corporation X has an obligation to pay
of 1 M in 10 years. - Available Bond Choices
106- Example (Contd)
- Question
- If Corp. X chooses bonds 2 and 3, can it match a
duration of 10 years? - Now, suppose Corporation X chooses Bonds 1 and 2.
Would there be a weighted average of the two
durations equal to 10 years? -
-
107- Example (Contd)
- make the PV of the portfolio the same as the PV
of the stream of obligations, - make the duration of the portfolio the same as
the duration of the stream of obligations. - At 9, PV of obligation is PV 414,643. Let
- V1 PV of Bond 1 and V2 PV of Bond 2
- We want V1 and V2 to satisfy
- V1 V2 414,643 PV
- (V1/414,643) 11.44 (V2/414,643) 6.54 10
- that is,
- V1 V2 PV
- D1 V1 D2 V2 10 PV
108- This is a system of two linear equations in two
variables. It has the solution - V1 292,788.73, V2 121,854.27
- Let us do some sensitivity analysis in yield
changes to see if the solution achieves its
purpose. - Using bonds prices and values (see the table),
- for bond 1 we need 292,788.73/69.04 ? 4,241
shares - for bond 2 we need 121,854.27/113.01 ? 1,078
shares
109- Table 3.8, p. 65, Immunization Results
110- Notes
- A sequence of yield changes reduce the degree of
matching of the portfolio. - Once the yield changes, the portfolio will not be
immunized at the new rate. - It is desirable to rebalance (reimmuninze) the
portfolio periodically. - In practice, more than two bonds would be used,
partly to diversify default risk.
111- Notes (Contd)
- The basic approach assumes all yields are the
same they are not. - It is difficult to find both long-duration and
short-duration bonds with identical yields. - When the yields change, not all may change by the
same amount, making re-balancing difficult. - We address some immunization extensions in
Chapter 4.
112- Notes (Contd)
- Overall, the technique given here is surprisingly
practical and used by many investment companies. -
- Instructors Comment. We can use goal
programming to solve more general immunization
systems.
113- Goal Programming Example,
- (the Ds are durations, Vs are values)
-
- minimize s1 r1 s2 r2
- st
- V1 V2 V3 Vn s1 - r1 PV
- D1 V1 D2 V2 D3 V3 Dn Vn s2 r2 D PV
- V1, V2, V3, , Vn, s1, r1, s2, r2 ? 0
114- When this approach finds a solution with zero
objective, it gives a nonnegative solution to the
corresponding linear system. This goal
programming approach would only pick 2 bonds. - Generally, if there are two optimal points, we
can get solutions with more than 2 bonds by
taking any weighted average of the alternative
optima, e.g., - ½ (V1, V2, V3, , Vn, s1, r1, s2, r2)
- ½ (V1, V2, V3, , Vn, s1, r1, s2, r2)
115Convexity/Relative Curvature
- The modified duration measures the relative slope
of the price-yield curve at a given point. - The basic immunization model uses a first-order
approximation to the price-yield curve. A
second-order approximation of the curve would
give a better approximation. - The second-order approximation is based on
convexity, which is the relative curvature at a
given point on the price-yield curve.
116- Convexity is defined as
- In terms of cash flow streams can be expressed
- Assuming m coupons per year
117- Note that
- convexity has units of time squared
- convexity is the weighted average of tktk1,
where the weights are proportional to the present
values of the corresponding cash flows - The second order approximation of the price-yield
curve is - Convexity improves the immunization in the sense
that it maintain a closer match of the of asset
portfolio value and obligation value, as yields
vary.
118- Files in the directory Lecture_9_Chapter_3.5_3.6_
and_3.7 - Immunization_handouts.doc file with more
detail explanation of immunization - Chapter3_Summary.doc