Title: AcSEC Presentation January 26, 2005
1AcSEC PresentationJanuary 26, 2005
- AICPA Healthcare Organization Expert Panel
2U.S. Health System
- Industry History and Background
- Disclosure Framework and Analysts
Interests/Concerns
3U.S. Health System
- While I can explain
- the meaning of life,
- I dont dare try to
- explain how the U.S
- health system works.
1817110
4National Health Spending
Components of U.S. GDP 2002 Total Spending 1.6
Trillion
of GDP
Source CMS (2003)
5National Health Spending
Source GAO (est. 2004)
6Personal Health Spending
Other DME, public health, dentist
services, over-the-counter drugs, research, etc.
Source GAO (est. 2004)
7U.S. Hospitals
Source AHA (2004)
8U.S. Hospitals
- Current operating environment
- Workforce shortages and increased labor costs
- Rapid increase in professional liability premiums
- Medical advances/new tech increase supply costs
- Need to modernize/expand facilities
- Regulatory burden
- Disaster readiness
- Quality and patient safety
Source American Hospital Association (2003)
9U.S. Physicians
- 888,061 Number of licensed physicians
- 31 Primary care physicians
- 70 Health care spending decisions driven
by physicians
Source CMS (2004)
10 Insurance Coverage
Source GAO (2003)
11Government Roles
UNDERWRITER
PROVIDER
REGULATOR
Source Jonas Health Care Delivery in the U.S,
Anthony Kovner Infoworld.com (2000)
12 Federal Role
- SCHIP
- 3.5 billion in funding (FY 02-FY 04)
- 3.9 million children
- MEDICARE
- 274 billion
- 14 of population
- 18.6 of U.S. budget
- MEDICAID
- 280.9 billion
- 14 of population
- 7.4 of U.S. budget
- 14 of state budgets
- FEHBP
- 19.5 billion
- 9 million beneficiaries
- TRICARE
- 29.3 billion
- 9.1 million beneficiaries
- 75 hospitals, 461 clinics
- VA
- 29.1 million (health care)
- 224,724 employees
- 1,266 facilities
13U.S. Health System
How Did We Get Here?
14 Beginnings
1930s The Growing Federal Role
- The Depression sparks federal recognition of
health care needs - Employer insurance model (Blue Cross) HMO model
(Kaiser) - FDRs Economic Security Plan omits national
health insurance proposal - SSA institutionalizes federal policy role
15Beginnings
1940s Access, Coverage and Payment
- Employer-based indemnity insurance becomes
dominant coverage model - Physicians and hospitals associate develop
integrated models of care - Henry Ford System Geisinger System
- Lovelace Clinic Oschner Medical
Institutions -
16 Beginnings
1940s Access, Coverage and Payment
- Trumans national health insurance plan sparks
5-year Congressional debate - McCarren-Ferguson Act recognizes state regulation
of insurance - Proposed indigent care subsidy for states
- Hill-Burton accelerates hospital construction
17 Medicare / Medicaid
Compromise Social Security Act Amendments July
30, 1965
18 Point Counterpoint
1973-9 Cost Containment Rapid Growth
- President Carter advocates rate-setting
- HEW reorganizes establishes HCFA
- NHRPDA Mandates health planning
- HMO Act Fosters market competition
- SSA Amend. Elevate fraud to felony status
- ERISA Regulates self-funded plans
19 Changing Focus
1980s Outpatient Alternative Delivery
- OBRA 80 Adds intent requirement to
Anti-kickback Law - OBRA 81 Allows Medicaid waivers
- TEFRA Limits Medicare hospital payment
- PPS Creates prospective payment for
inpatient hospital services
20 Changing Focus
1980s Outpatient Alternative Delivery
- COBRA Continues insurance benefits
- HCQIA Creates practitioner data bank
- EMTALA Prohibits patient dumping
- OBRA 89 Establishes RBRVS Stark I
21 Reform Redux
1990s . . . Contraction
- Industry mergers skyrocket 4,000
- Transactions involving physician groups increase
170 - HMO MAs cause 3.6 billion in assets to change
hands
22 Reform Redux
1990s . . . Compliance
- HCFA publishes Stark I regulations
- Operation Restore Trust spawns a series of
federal fraud initiatives - HIPAA
- Insurance portability
- Fraud
- Privacy
23 Balanced Budget Act
MedicareChoice PSOs Fraud Abuse Payment
Freezes Payment Cuts Expansion of PPS DSH
Cuts Medicaid Managed Care Childrens Health
Insurance Program
MEDICAID 13 Billion
MEDICARE 115 Billion
24Balanced Budget Act
Source The Lewin Group analysis of Medicare cost
reports AHA annual survey data. (1999)
25 Balanced Budget Act
Source The Lewin Group analysis of Medicare cost
reports AHA annual survey data. (1999)
26 New Realities
2002 2003
- Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor
Act (Sarbanes-Oxley) (2002) - The Hospital Mortgage Act (2003)
- HHS publishes final HIPAA privacy regulations
(2002) and security standards (2003) - Stark II, Phase II
- The Medicare Prescription Drug and
Modernization Act (MMA) (2003)
27How Accounting, Reporting, and Auditing is
Impacted
- Business/operating environment (mission-based)
- Formation Issues (consolidation)
- Unique payment schemes (revenue recognition)
- Revenue recognition (uninsured, bad debt, etc.)
- Professional liability (cost containment,
relationship/structure, accounting, etc.) - Investments (on balance sheet, off balance sheet,
returns, etc.)
28Consolidation Issues
Health System
NFP
NFP
NFP
NFP
NFP
FP
FP
FP
FP
FP
- Accounting Differences
- Goodwill/intangibles
- Consolidations (FIN 46 (R))
- Taxes
- Etc.
29Consolidation/Framework Issues
Example JOA
50
50
100
100
30Unique Payment Schemes
- Cost reports
- Long settlement process
- Reserves/revenue recognition
- Compliance/regulation
- 100s of payment schemes and prices for same
service - Federal mandatory programs (tax)
31Revenue Recognition
- Charity care
- Uninsured
- Bad debts
- Discounting process
32Professional Liability
- Significant cost
- Different roles
- Captives
- Self-insured
- Claim made / Occurrence
- Related parties
33Whats Needed
- Clarity, Guidance, Consistency, and Transparency
34-
- Disclosure Framework
- Analysts Interests/Concerns
35NFP HCOs Capital Raising
- Relatively few HCOs are SEC registrants
- Yet financial statements of NFP HCOs are widely
used for capital raising in one of the worlds
largest securities markets the municipal bond
market - Municipal bonds are bought and sold in the
over-the-counter market rather than on an
organized exchange
36How Big is the Municipal Bond Market?
- Approximately 1.3 trillion of bonds are
currently in the hands of investors - More than 50,000 entities issue municipal
securities - 1.5 million separate bond issues outstanding
- In 2004, HCOs issued 28 billion of debt
securities - Many were auction-rate deals coupled with
floating-to-fixed interest rate swaps
37Investor Profile
- An estimated 5.1 million households own municipal
bonds in some formeither through direct
ownership of individual bonds or through
investment in institutional portfolios (mutual
funds, unit investment trusts, bank trust
accounts, etc.) - Commercial banks and insurance companies are also
major institutional holders of munis
38Regulation
- Congress does not allow SEC to directly regulate
the muni market - Regulation through broker-dealers
- Disclosure requirements are fluid and flexible
(unlike SEC registrants) - Primary offering documents (Official
Statements) - Secondary market disclosure requirements
39Disclosure Framework in Muni Market
- SEC Rule 15c2-12 (Municipal Securities
Disclosure) - SEC Rule 10b-5 (Antifraud provisions of 33 and
34 Acts) - Industry practice/market demands
40SEC Rule 15c2-12Disclosure Requirements
- Obligors must covenant to disclose financial and
operating information annually (and material
event notices as needed) for dealers to be able
to underwrite their bonds - Information must be filed with 4
nationally-recognized municipal securities
information repositories (NRMSIRs) and, if
applicable, state information depositories (SIDs) - Failure to make filings timely must be disclosed
in subsequent bond issuances omission
constitutes violation of SEC anti-fraud rules
41What does the SEC Say About Transparency?
"The difference in the quantity, quality, and
availability of ongoing disclosure in the
municipal market can be expected to be noticed
and affect investment decisions. It will be more
important than ever for municipal issuers and
conduit borrowers to establish good disclosure
practices that go beyond the legal minimums of
15c2-12."
Martha Mahan Haines Director, SEC Office of
Municipal Securities
42Best Practices for Health Care and Senior
Housing Credits
- Credits with excellent disclosure "win
accolades and possibly quicker consideration for
upgrades" - Credits with poor disclosure viewed with
increased skepticism and caution" - Recommendations for content, format,
presentation of quarterly/annual disclosure data
http//www.fitchratings.com
43What Does SEC Say About Web-based Disclosure?
- "We encourage the use of web sites for posting
old and new official statements as well as
financial and operating data. Issuers in the
equity market are already disclosing information
online and investors are going to expect the same
electronic access to information from the
fixed-income market. If you don't have that
information available, you're going to fall
behind those who do."
Martha Mahan Haines, Chief, SEC Office of
Municipal Securities
44Obligated Group Financing Structures are Common
- Govt agency (issuer) issues bonds and loans
the proceeds to NFP HCO - NFP HCO responsible for repayment (obligor)
- Obligation usually secured by security interest
in gross receipts of HCO/ obligated group and by
a mortgage - May be accompanied by credit enhancements
- Reserve fund created to pay a portion of the debt
service, if necessary
45Obligated Group Model
Created by a Master Trust Indenture
- Members of the obligated group denoted by blue
shading - Obligated group members have joint and several
liability - Debt covenants imposed
- Typically excludes
- Leased/managed facilities
- Non-healthcare ventures
- For-profit subsidiaries
- Money-losing operations (e.g., physician
practices)
46Corporate style Unsecured GO Pledge Model
- Involves a promise to pay by a corporate parent
with no underlying revenue pledge or mortgage
from individual facilities/operating units - Frequently used in corporate debt market gaining
acceptance in healthcare debt market - Bulk of revenue-producing assets not directly
obligated on the debt
47Analysts ConcernOff-balance sheet financing
- Nonprofit HCOs increasingly using off-balance
sheet arrangements to finance certain assets,
such as - Sale/leasebacks
- REIT financings
- Operating leases/guarantees
- Contribution agreements to finance jointly-owned
assets with unrelated parties - Joint ventures or partnerships