Title: Corporate Spend Under Pressure
1Corporate Spend Under Pressure
- Presented by
- Michael Lynch
- Commodity Manager Travel
- ICG Commerce
2Q What is Indirect Spend?
A The goods and services required to operate
an organization that do not contribute to the
cost of goods sold.
3Indirect Spend A Source of Untapped Value for
Many Companies
- Indirect purchases represent up to 35 of
expenditures but are typically under resourced - Large number of buying categories
- Highly disbursed across company locations spend
not leveraged - High volume of low-dollar purchasing transactions
- Cost reductions drop straight to the bottom-line
- Significant opportunity to reduce costs via more
effective sourcing and order processing
Transpor
-
tation
Contract
Labor
IT/
Telecom
Marketing
Packaging
MRO
Steel/
Metals
Utilities
Travel
Etc.
Direct
Indirect
Spent
Spend
65
35
4Historic Practices in Indirect Spend
- Current
- Strategic role with high level organizational
ownership - Center-led global organization with strategic and
operational spend control - Automated systems enforce policies and processes
drive compliance to preferred suppliers - Measurements designed to communicate
organizational performance and value - Strategic sourcing as a practice and discipline
involving quantifiable results
- Past
- Tactical, administratively focused function
- Decentralized local organization with limited
spend control - Highly manual processes with limited ability to
enforce policies or compliance - Limited spend visibility and measurement
- Long-standing relationships without ability to
validate decisions
5Where Does the Responsibility for Travel Fall
Within Companies?
Represents ICG Commerce customer base
6Shift from Tactical to Strategic Role and Focus
Tactical, administrative focus
Need Identified
Expert Selects Vendor
Procurement Executes Contract
Examples
- Consulting project
- Major IT program
- New engineered part
- Business change, i.e., satellite TV in airplane
Strategic role and higher-level ownership
Need Identified
Expert Crafts Functional Spec or Statement of
Work
Procurement Sources with Expert Input
Team Selects Vendor
7Center-led Organization with Strategic and
Operational Spend Control
1
3
4
2
Decentralized
Coordinated
Center-Led
Centralized
- Completely decentralized
- None
- All direction-setting, decision-making and
transactions
- Establishment of a formal group to coordinate
corporate buy-needs on a periodic basis - Facilitation, as required
- Same as decentralized plus supplies coordinating
group mentors
- Permanent corporate organization sets direction
for multi-divisional purchases informally leads
all purchasing functions - Strategic direction
- Retains decision making for division-specific
purchases, executes transaction
- All decision-making and procurement
responsibility with corporate - Decision-making divisional control
- Transaction execution
Model Description
Corporate Role
Division Role
Best Practice
8Systems and Processes Improve Compliance and
Effectiveness
Processes
Impact
- More spend addressed - additional savings
- Higher savings realization
- Better user experience leading to higher adoption
- Better, more reliable spend performance data
Skilled Professionals
Competitive Quoting
Centralized Transactional Procurement Group
Compliance Management
Procurement Help Desk
Service Focus
Policies Procedures
Order Processing
Invoice Reconciliation
Automated Tools
9Measurements Focus on Organizational Performance
and Value
- Spend Under Management
- / Spend Sourced
- / Spend Fully Managed
- Weighted Average Sourcing Savings
- / Sourcing Savings by Category vs. Baseline
- / Sourcing Savings by Category vs. Index
- Transactional Efficiency Effectiveness
- Orders per Purchasing FTE
- Service Levels
- Compliance Savings Realization
- Spend with Preferred Suppliers vs.
Non-preferred - Compliance by Category
- Supplier Performance
- Quality Performance
- Transaction Accuracy
- User SatisfactionSuppliers and Procurement
Measure Results vs. Goals and vs. Prior Year
10Shift from Long-standing Relationship-based
Sourcing to Objective Strategic Sourcing
Strategic Sourcing Process Advances
Spend Visibility /Control
Supplier Cost Reduction
Dynamic Bidding/Price Transparency
Total Cost of Ownership
Strategic Sourcing
Trends/ Strategies
Long-TermContracting
- eSourcing tools
- Optimization/Decision Support
Structured Negotiation
- Global Sourcing
- Supplier Collaboration
eProcurement
- The X Step Process
- Deeper Analytical Rigor
- RFPs
- 1st/2nd Tier IntegratedSupply
- Internal/ Industry Aggregation - GPOs
- Competitive bidding - RFQs
- Corporate Agreements
- SRM
- Spend Analytics
- Contract Management
- Reverse Auctions
- Industry Exchanges / Marketplaces
- Should-cost Modeling
- TCO modeling
- ABC
Tools/Techniques
- Supply-chain Re-engineering
- Supplier Development
1984
1990
1992
1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
1986
1988
2006
11Leverage best practices to quickly establish a
world-class, indirect procurement capability
Company Situation
Best Practices Applied
- Industry 4B Telecommunications
- Objectives
- Drive savings by broadening the spend managed and
influenced by procurement - Increase compliance and ROI from existing
technology investments - Apply best-practices to transactional procurement
processes to maximize and sustain compliance and
increase end user satisfaction - Formalize category management capabilities to
improve supplier performance and year-over-year
continuous cost reductions - Expand procurement impact and influence beyond
policy enforcement - Standardize procurement processes across
geographies
- Approach
- Develop center-led organization to support for 7
key commodity groups - Implement centralized procurement transaction
group to proactively manage 900MM in
transactions per year including 40 business
processing 30,000 POs per year - Partnering with business to deliver measurable
savings using standardized strategic sourcing
methodologies and gain organizational credibility
- Deployed end-to-end processes - Sourcing, Legal,
Commodity Management, Initiative Management,
Supplier Enablement - Leveraging internal and external data and market
insights to sustain and improve cost reductions - Results
- Addressing 60 more spend, with an average
savings rate of 19.5 - 97 of indirect spend is processed through Ariba
- 85 of identified savings targets are realized
- Operating costs are in line with value delivered
and have been slightly reduced even while
capabilities expanded
12Use best practices to extend reach into new
buying regions
Company Situation
Best Practices Applied
- Industry 2B Heavy Equipment Manufacturer
- Objectives
- Increase/accelerate the full utilization of SAP
EBP - Reduce expenditures on indirect goods and
services globally - Improve the speed and impact of strategic
sourcing - Promote collaboration and visibility across
business units - Drive compliance, cost savings, and ongoing
improvement - Automate a heavily manual purchasing process
- Augment existing resources for indirect
categories - Move from relationship-based contracts to
strategically sourced contracts - Improve compliance on national supplier contracts
- Approach
- Establish center-led indirect procurement
organization - New category teams provide sourcing and category
management across key indirect categories (Office
Supplies, MRO, Travel, Temporary Labor,
Facilities, Marketing, IT/Telecom and
Transportation) - Automate transactions and built content to
increase adoption and accelerate ROI of SAP EBP - Implement new policies and processes across 5
major buying regions - Streamline approval and payment processes
- Implement services procurement solution to
improve control and visibility for specialized
temporary labor spend - Results
- 8 - 25 savings on strategic categories
- Private catalogs built in 8 - 10 weeks
- Strong executive sponsorship and category adoption
13Center-led strategy and sourcing standards power
new indirect organization
Company Situation
Best Practices Applied
- Industry 2B Packaging Company
- Objectives
- Significantly drive down the cost of indirect and
some direct material expenditures - Automate the purchase-to-pay process, moving from
manual to automated invoice processing - Significantly increase historical purchase data
to allow for better management of expenditures
- Approach
- Establish center-led indirect procurement
organization - Using standardized Strategic Sourcing
methodologies identified cost-saving
opportunities, rationalize suppliers, and improve
contracted supplier service levels. - Deploy automated procurement solution across the
system in over 60 plants to gain access to
detailed compliance, spend and savings
information - Use additional transactional information along
with market index data and benchmarks to drive
continuous cost and service improvements - Results
- Actively managing a significant portion of the
companys indirect expenditures - Driving solid savings and value-driven
opportunities from 5 36 - Achieving 90 compliance target.
14Thank You!
- Questions?
- Contact
- Mlynch_at_icgcommerce.com
- 484-690-5044