Title: The Wind Farms Are Coming - Offshore
1September 19, 2011
The Windmills are Coming Offshore
Steven Harris Vice President EQECAT,
Inc. 510.817.3105
2Americas First Offshore Wind FarmWill it be
3Americas First Offshore Wind FarmOr
"This is Texas. We don't have Walter Cronkite
and Ted Kennedy whining about their back yards,"
Texas State General Land Office Jerry Patterson
- Commissioner
4What are Offshore Wind Farms?
- Wind turbines and foundation structures
- Underwater high voltage cables
- Offshore substations and operations
- Onshore substations
- Onshore high voltage transmission
5Why are they Coming?Projected Energy Use
Global energy use by fuel type 1990-2035
From US DOE
6The United States has Ambitious regional growth
targets
- State and Federal incentives
- Green energy renewable portfolio standards
- Texas 7 by 2025
- New Jersey 20 by 2021
- California 33 by 2020
- Hawaii 40 by 2030 !!
7Offshore Wind Farm Siting and Economics
- Siting Requires
- Good wind resource
- Close to load demands
- Onshore transmission capacity
- Total Cost of Energy
- Cost of generation should be around 0.10 / kWh
- Most wind farms are financed and require adequate
insurance
8U.S. Offshore Wind Resource andTransmission
Grids to U.S. cities
Cape Wind
Others?
Galveston-Offshore
9What are theCatastrophic exposures?
- Gulf of Mexico and Caribbean hurricane
- West Pacific Typhoon
- European winter windstorm
- Earthquake in Japan, Western US and Canada,
Caribbean, South America, and others
10What is the OnshoreCatastrophic Loss Experience?
Typhoon Maemi Okinawa Japan 2003
Tropical Cyclone 03/A India 1998
(Ishihara et al., 2005a)
(Winter-Jensen et al., 1999)
11Hurricane Risks to Offshore Farms
- Hurricanes have damaging wind speeds for wind
farms located offshore and near the coast. - Hurricanes have wind speeds more than 76 mph over
widths of 60 to 120 miles - Hurricanes are also accompanied by large wave
loadings on structural foundations
12Wind is the Source of Power
Power Generated by Turbine
Turbine PowerOperating Range
Cut-out Speed
Cut-inSpeed
Wind Speed
13Technology Trend for Wind TurbinesEach
generation is a bigger prototype
13
14Direction in Offshore Wind Technology
- Capital and Energy Costs are declining
- Higher capital costs than land based
installations are dropping rapidly - Installed capital costs, reliability, and energy
capture are all improving - Technical and Infrastructure Challenges
- Transmission from windy areas to the load centers
are being built - Specialized vessels, purpose built portside
infrastructure, robust undersea electricity
transmission lines will come with development - Resource characterization is improving
15Challenges Facing Offshore Wind Deployment (Cont.)
- Permitting Challenges or NIMBY Not In My Back
Yard - New and untested permitting processes
- Uncertainty and risk faced by potential project
developers and financiers - State and federal entities have authority over
siting, permitting, and installation of offshore
wind facilities
16Emerging technology Risk
- Rapid paradigm shifts with growing technologies
like wind turbines - Larger wind turbines and blades
- Identical installations and new technologies
- Highly correlated loss potential
- Limited cat loss damageability data makes
engineering expertise critical to rate these
exposures - Potentially expensive coverage
17Onshore Insurance StructuresTypical Retentions /
Limits Structure
- Common deductible structures
- 2-5 for CAT
- 15 45 days Business Interruption (BI)
- Limits driven by lenders, corporate or
partnership property program, (MFL, PML studies) - CAT exposures and limits can drive the overall
premium - Manufacturers warranty period for defects (2 -
5 years) - Contingent business interruption
- Hedges can provide some BI/CBI protection
18Insurance Questions
- Who will insure this new technology?
- How will the infrastructure be insured?
- Offshore wind turbines
- Offshore substations
- Submarine cables
- Onshore Transmission lines
- What will the insurance cost be?
19Business Interruption Risks
- Potential impact of transformers and transmission
cable losses with long lead times - Limited numbers of available marine vessels and
cranes - Damage to onshore transmission and distribution,
without damage to turbines, poses contingent BI
issues - Rapid obsolescence of turbines results in spare
parts and extended BI issues
20Future technology Insurance Issues
- Wind farms will go further offshore and into
deeper waters - New and technically challenging design concepts
- Floating structures
- Cable moored structures
- And others
21EQECATs Approach to Offshore Wind Farm Risk
- EQECAT and ABS Consulting are sister companies of
the ABS Group headquartered in Houston - EQECAT is a catastrophe modeling company that
provides cutting edge natural hazard models to
the insurance industry - ABS Consulting is a global risk, safety, and
integrity management firm - ABS Consulting provides full life cycle
engineering, operations and maintenance, and
in-service inspection services to the wind energy
industry
22ABS Group Wind Energy Services
- Technology Development/Qualification
- Offshore Expertise
- Structure
- Stability
- Mooring/soils
- Certification Authority
- Certified Verification Agent (CVA) Services
23Wind Energy Life Cycle Services
- VII. IN-SERVICE
- Operational Data Management(Wind Speed,
Turbulence, Wake, Power Performance) - Maintenance Management
- Mechanical Integrity Management Systems (MMS)
- Inspection Planning including RBI(Wind Turbines
and Foundations) - Gear Box Condition Monitoring and Inspections
- Rotor Blade Condition Monitoring and Inspections
- Coating and Corrosion Protection Monitoring
- End of Warranty Consultancy and Inspections
- HSE Consultancy
- I. CONCEPTUAL PHASE
- Technical Due Diligence (Energy Yield, Permits,
Technology Grid) - Consultancy and Project Management
- VI. COMMISSIONING
- Monitoring and Supervision
- Functional Safety and Safety Tests
- Commissioning Supervision
- HSE Consultancy
- II. DESIGN BASIS SITE ASSESSMENTS
- Owners Representative
- Tender Support and Consultancy
- Project Management
- V. INSTALLATION
- Monitoring and Supervision
- HSE
- Project Management
- III. SITE SPECIFIC DESIGN WIND TURBINE
FOUNDATION - Owners Representative
- Technical Consultancy
- HSE Design and Consultancy
- Project Management
- IV. MANUFACTURING
- Manufacturing Quality Audits
- Supervision
- HSE
- Project Management
24EQECAT Vulnerability Models Developed by
Engineering Studies
- EQECAT uses a ground up engineering approach
in the development of vulnerabilities. - Claims data incorporated into vulnerabilities
- Failure modes of power system components, support
and foundations - Manufacturing processes, and control systems
effects - Extreme natural hazard performance measures
25EQECAT Hazard Models
26Key EQECAT Model Attributes
- Fully Probabilistic results
- Scenario loss simulations
- Underwritting and Portfolio aggregation
- Extra-Tropical Wind Storm Surge
- Gulf of Mexico hurricane wind, and wave models
- Earthquake models including time dependency in
California
27Examples of EQECAT Projects
- Offshore wind farm portfolio for European winter
storm - Onshore wind farms analyses for earthquake peril
- Hurricane and earthquake risk models for onshore
transmission grids - Hurricane risk models for offshore oil gas
platforms - Hurricane risk models for Gulf of Mexico oil and
gas pipelines - And more
28Questions?