Title: Growth hormone treatment in GHdeficiency adults
1Growth hormone treatment in GH-deficiency adults
- Journal reading
- R5 ???
- 2004-6-2
2Growth hormone replacement therapy in adult-onset
GH deficiency effects on body composition in men
and women in a double-blind, randomized,
placebo-controlled trial
- Journal of the clinical endocrinology
metabolism 89(5)20482056 ,2004
3- Adult GH deficiency (AGHD) ---
- Abnormal body composition
- fat mass , visceral fat ?
- lean body mass ?
- Strength , exercise capacity ?
- Altered lipid metabolism
- Increased cardiovascular disease
- Diminished quality of life , social isolation ,
decreased energy - BMD? ? 3-fold increase in bone fracture rate
4- Short-term GH replacement therapy in adult
?Beneficial effects on body composition, fate
distribution , quality of life - GH at least 18 months ? improvement in bone
mineral content and BMD
5Subjects and methods
- 19931995
- Multicenter, radomized, placebo-controlled,
double blind study - Age 1870 y/o
- Inclusion criteria ---
- AGHD ( result of hypothalamic-pituitary disease)
- Two GH stimulation tests --- maximal GH lt 5ng/ml
- Clonidine, Levodopa, insulin tolerance test,
arginine stimulation test - No previous history of GH therapy
- No change in steroid , thyroid hormone, or
gonadal hormone replacement therapy within 2
months before study entry - Gonadal steroid replacement therapy could be
started no later than 12 months before entry - 12 lead EKG, CBC, serum chemistry test ? normal
6Subjects and methods
- Exclusion criteria
- Psychological or physical impairment
- History of acromegaly
- Fasting blood glucose gt 140 mg/dl
- Carpal tunnel syndrome
- Malignancy
- Methods
- Daily sc injections of recombinant human GH
(somatropin) or placebo for 12 months - GH
- initial dose 0.0125 mg/kg.d for the first month
- Increased to 0.025 mg/kg.d if tolerable
- Decreased to 0.00625 mg/kg.d if adverse events
7Subjects and methods
- Primary endpoints
- A reduction in the proportion of body mass
composed of fat - An increase in maximum voluntary thigh muscle
force production and endurance - Improved of quality of life
- Beck Depression Index, the Nottingham Health
Profile, the General Well-being Schedule, the
Paffenbarger Questionnaire, the National Health
Interview Survey , Trail-Making Tests - Additional efficacy measures
- Serum IGF-I SD score
- Anthropomorphic measurement
- Weight, height, BMI, ring size, hip/waist ratio,
midarm circumference, skinfold thickness. - BMD ( DXA)
8(No Transcript)
9Results
10(No Transcript)
11(No Transcript)
12- Baseline IGF-1
- 52 of men and 75 of women lt -2SDS
- 15 of men and 27 of women lt-4SDS ( normal
range for age ) - Women lt men
- Women taking estrogen lower IGF-I SDS
- Baseline cholesterol
- 59 of men and 66 of women gt 200mg/dl
- Baseline anthropometric and body composition
- 62 of subjects , BMI gt 25 kg/m2
- 64 of men , total body fat gt 25
- 90 of women , total body fat gt 30
- Baseline BMD
- 51 of subjects -- Spine T-score lt -1
- 64 of subjects -- femoral T-scorelt -1
13GH dose
- 79 of subjects 0.0125 mg/kg.d
- 21 of subjects 0.00625 mg/kg.d ( because of
edema ) - Compliance high ( only 5 missing more than
10 of injections)
14Change in serum IGF-I SDS
15Strength and endurance and quality of life
- GH did not produce a significant change in
strength and endurance ( data not shown) - Quality of life
- Generally normal at baseline
- Did not change with GH therapy
16Changes in body composition
17Changes in body composition
- No significant changes were observed in BMD
measurement in GH treatment women and men
18Changes in anthropometric measurement
- Skinfold thickness ? significantly decreased from
baseline - GH-treated men at month 6
- GH-treated women at month 9
19Changes in serum lipids
9 mg/dl
-3 mg/dl
-15 mg/dl
20Safety
- Adverse events
- 2 subjects edema
- 1 subjects arthritis
- 4 subjects arthritis-like syndrome
- 3 subjects carpal tunnel syndrome
- 2 subjects increasing suprasellar mass size
- 1 subject abnormal glucose tolerance test
- 1 subject Graves disease
21(No Transcript)
22(No Transcript)
23(No Transcript)
24- No significant change in renal function , blood
chemistry, urinalysis - No significant change in physical examination
- A small increase ( 5 bpm) in mean pulse rate in
GH group - No acromegalic change seen on x-ray
- Ring size increase
- Antibodies to GH not detected
25Discussion
26- GH replacement therapy at a dose of 0.00625 or
0.0125 mg/kg.d - produced significant changes in body composition
( total body and trunk fat?, lean body mass?) - LDL cholesterol , LDL/HDL ratio improved
-
- improved cardiovascular risk profile
27- Discrepant effects of GH replacement therapy
between men and women - Premenopausal women are resistance to the effects
of GH - Oral estrogen decrease the ability of GH therapy
to stimulate IGF-I levels - Woman may need a higher replacment dose of GH
- No significant changes in BMD
- Other study more prolonged GH dose lead to
increased BMD
28- Weight-based dosing regimens have recently been
criticized - Leading to excessively high IGF-I ? increased
incidence of adverse events - GH secretion is negatively correlated with BMI ?
weight based dose may be nonphysiologic - GH replacement therapy in adult should be
titrated to achieve a target IGF-I within 2 SD of
the mean for age and gender-matched control
29- Testosterone stimulate IGF-I production
- Oral estrogen increase GH secretion and
decrease IGF-I - women with AGHD in premenopausal
age can be treated with transdermal estrogen (
do not lead to GH resistance )
30Conclusion
31- GH replacement therapy
- Improve body composition
- Improve serum lipid profile
- Did not affect exercise performance or quality of
life - some of these changes were
small ? similar effect may be more easily
achieved by lifestyle modification and oral
lipid-lowering agent
32- Other investigators
- Improvement of quality of life ( long-term
therapy) - Regression of carotid artery intimal thickness
- Increase BMD after 18 months of GH therapy
- GH dose should be individualized
- Starting at a dose of 0.20.4mg/d (0.003 mg/kg)
- Titrated with the goal of normalizing IGF-I
33Impact of growth hormone treatment on
cardiovascular risk factors in GH-deficient
adults A metaanalysis of blinded, randomized,
placebo-controlled trials
- The journal of clinical endocrinology
metabolism 89(5)2192-2199,2004
34- AGHD patients exhibit cardiovascular risk
factors ( abdominal obesity, hypercholesterolemia,
hypertriglyceridemia) - GH replacement therapy
- Reduce cardiovascular risk factor
- Adverse effect insulin resistance , increased
volemia
35Subjects and methods
- Inclusion criteria
- all blinded , randomized , placebo-controlled
trials, published up to August 2003 - patients aged over 17 yr with GHD corresponding
to less than 5 ug/liter after stimulation
36Results
- 37 blinded, randomized, placebo-controlled trials
37(No Transcript)
38(No Transcript)
39(No Transcript)
40Discussion
41- GH treatment
- Small but statistically significant beneficial
effect of GH treatment on lean and fat body mass
, LDL , total cholesterol , diastolic blood
pressure - Significant increased plasma glucose and insulin
levels
42- Effects on LDL cholesterol and total cholesterol
were variable - Half showed o significant difference
- Overall effect size ? beneficial effect
- No effect on HDL, or triglyceride was observed
- Most study mild fluid retention
- The relationship between blood pressure and GH
therapy - No significant effect was noted in most studies
- One trial ? hypertension
- One trial ? decrease in diastolic blood pressure
- Overall effect size ? decrease in diastolic blood
pressure, no change in systolic blood pressure
43- The relationship between blood pressure and GH
therapy may be due to - Stimulation of the Renin-aldosterone system
- Increase in NO formation
- Decrease in intima-media thickness
44- The effect of GH on fasting insulin and glucose
- Varied
- One trial 2 case of incident diabetes
- Overall effect sizes ? significant increase in
glucose and insulin during GH treatment - Men were more sensitive to the effect of GH on
insulin sensitivity - Not support previous suggestions that insulin
resistance falls during low-dose and long-term GH
therapy
45- Young patients may be more sensitive than older
patients to GH treatment - Beneficial effects on body mass, cholesterol,
blood pressure increased with the duration of
treatment , whereas adverse effects remained at a
similar level - GH treatment seemed to be more beneficial in AGHD
than in adults with childhood-onset GHD . - No difference in GH effects between patients with
multiple hormone deficiency and those with
isolated GHD