Presentation to Television Bureau of Advertising - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1 / 41
About This Presentation
Title:

Presentation to Television Bureau of Advertising

Description:

GM has operational momentum, but faces pension and health care issues. ... Strategy has enabled GM to gain share and has put severe pressure on Ford and DCX. ... – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:69
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 42
Provided by: soei7
Category:

less

Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Presentation to Television Bureau of Advertising


1
Presentation to Television Bureau of Advertising
  • Stephen J. GirskySeptember 2003

2
Disclosures
  • Analyst Certification
  • The following analysts hereby certify that their
    views about the companies and their securities
    discussed in this report are accurately expressed
    and that they have not received and will not
    receive direct or indirect compensation in
    exchange for expressing specific recommendations
    or views in this report Stephen J. Girsky.
  • Important US Regulartory Disclosures on Subject
    Companies
  • The information and opinions in this report were
    prepared by Morgan Stanley Co. Incorporated
    (Morgan Stanley).
  • As of July 31, 2003, Morgan Stanley beneficially
    owned 1 or more of a class of common equity
    securities of the following companies covered in
    this report Delphi, Ford, General Motors,
    Goodyear Tire Rubber, Johnson Controls, Magna
    Intl Inc., TBC and Tower Automotive.
  • Within the last 12 months, Morgan Stanley managed
    or co-managed a public offering of securities of
    DaimlerChrysler AG, Delphi, Ford, General Motors,
    Standard Motor Products and Tenneco.
  • Within the last 12 months, Morgan Stanley, Morgan
    Stanley or an affiliate has received compensation
    for investment banking services from Aftermarket
    Technology, American Axle and Mfg., BorgWarner
    Inc., DaimlerChrysler AG, Delphi, Ford, General
    Motors, Standard Motor Products, Superior
    Industries, Tenneco, Tower Automotive and Visteon
    Corporation.
  • In the next 3 months, Morgan Stanley expects to
    receive or intends to seek compensation for
    investment banking services from Aftermarket
    Technology, American Axle and Mfg., ArvinMeritor,
    Borg Warner Inc., DaimlerChrysler AG, Dana Corp.,
    Delphi, Ford, General Motors, Genuine Parts Co.,
    Goodyear Tire Rubber, Johnson Controls, Lear
    Corp., Magna Intl Inc., Standard Motor Products,
    Superior Industries, Tenneco, Tower Automotive
    and Visteon Corporation.
  • The research analysts, strategist, or research
    associates principally responsible for the
    preparation of the research report have received
    compensation based upon various factors,
    including quality of research, investor client
    feedback, stock picking, competitive factors,
    firm revenues and investment banking revenues.
  • Morgan Stanley Co. Incorporated makes a market
    in the securities of Aftermarket Technology,
    Delphi, Dura Automotive, Ford, General Motors,
    Magna Intl., TBC and Tower Automotive.
  • Global Stock Ratings Distribution
  • (as of May 1, 2003)

3
Disclosures
  • Data include common stock and ADRs currently
    assigned ratings. For disclosure purposes (in
    accordance with NASD and NYSE requirements), we
    note that Overweight, our most positive stock
    rating, most closely corresponds to a buy
    recommendation Equal-weight and Underweight most
    closely correspond to neutral and sell
    recommendations, respectively. However,
    Overweight, Equal-weight, and Underweight are not
    the equivalent of buy, neutral, and sell but
    represent recommended relative weightings (see
    definitions below). An investor's decision to buy
    or sell a stock should depend on individual
    circumstances (such as the investor's existing
    holdings) and other considerations. Investment
    Banking Clients are companies from whom Morgan
    Stanley or an affiliate received investment
    banking compensation in the last 12 months.
  • Analyst Stock Ratings
  • Overweight (O or Over) - The stock's total return
    is expected to exceed the average total return of
    the analyst's industry (or industry team's)
    coverage universe, on a risk-adjusted basis over
    the next 12-18 months.Equal-weight (E or Equal)
    - The stock's total return is expected to be in
    line with the average total return of the
    analyst's industry (or industry team's) coverage
    universe, on a risk-adjusted basis over the next
    12-18 months.Underweight (U or Under) - The
    stock's total return is expected to be below the
    average total return of the analyst's industry
    (or industry team's) coverage universe, on a
    risk-adjusted basis, over the next 12-18
    months.More volatile (V) - We estimate that this
    stock has more than a 25 chance of a price move
    (up or down) of more than 25 in a month, based
    on a quantitative assessment of historical data,
    or in the analyst's view, it is likely to become
    materially more volatile over the next 1-12
    months compared with the past three years.Stocks
    with less than one year of trading history are
    automatically rated as more volatile (unless
    otherwise noted). We note that securities that we
    do not currently consider "more volatile" can
    still perform in that manner.Unless otherwise
    specified, the time frame for price targets
    included in this report is 12 to 18 months.
    Ratings prior to March 18, 2002 SBStrong Buy
    OPOutperform NNeutral UPUnderperform. For
    definitions, please go to www.morganstanley.com/co
    mpanycharts.
  • Analyst Industry Views
  • Attractive (A). The analyst expects the
    performance of his or her industry coverage
    universe to be attractive vs. the relevant broad
    market benchmark over the next 12-18 months.
  • In-Line (I). The analyst expects the performance
    of his or her industry coverage universe to be in
    line with the relevant broad market benchmark
    over the next 12-18 months.
  • Cautious (C). The analyst views the performance
    of his or her industry coverage universe with
    caution vs. the relevent broad market benchmark
    over the next 12-18 months.
  • Other Important Disclosures
  • For a discussion, if applicable, of the valuation
    methods used to determine the price targets
    included in this summary and the risks related to
    achieving these targets, please refer to the
    latest relevant published research on these
    stocks. Research is available throught your
    sales representative or on Client Link at
    www.moganstanley.com and other electronic
    systems.
  • This report does not provide individually
    tailored investment advice. It has been prepared
    without regard to the individual financial
    circumstances and objectives of person who
    receive it. The securities discussed in this
    report may be suitable for all investors. Morgan
    Stanley recommends that investors independently
    evaluate particular investments and strategies,
    and encourages investors to seek the advice of a
    financial adviser. The appropriateness of a
    particular investment or strategy will depend on
    an investors individual circumstances and
    objectives.
  • This report is not an offer to buy or sell any
    security or to participate in any trading
    strategy. Morgan Stanley, Morgan Stanley DW
    Inc., affiliate companies and.or their employees
    may have investments in securities or derivatives
    of securities of companies mentioned in this
    report, and may trade them in ways different from
    this discussed in this report. Derivatives may
    be issued by Morgan Stanley or associated
    persons.
  • (Continued)

4
Disclosures
  • Morgan Stanley is involved in many businesses
    that may relate to companies mentioned in this
    report. These businesses include specialized
    trading, risk arbitrage and other proprietary
    trading, fund management, investment services and
    investment banking.
  • Morgan Stanley makes every effort to use
    reliable, comprehensive information, but we make
    no representation that it is accurate or
    complete. We have no obligation to tell you when
    opinions or information in this report change
    apart from when we intend to discontinue research
    coverage of subject company.
  • Reports prepared by Morgan Stanley research
    personnel are based on public information. Facts
    and views presented in this report have not been
    reviewed by, and may not reflect information
    known to, professionals in other Morgan Stanley
    business areas, including investment banking
    personnel.
  • The value of and income from your investments may
    vary because of changes in interest rates or
    foreign exchange rates, securities prices or
    market indexes, operational or financial
    conditions of companies or other factors. There
    may be time limitations on the exercise of
    options or other rights in your securities
    transactions. Past performance is not
    necessarily a guide to future performance.
    Estimates of future performance are based on
    assumptions that may not be realized.
  • This publication is disseminated in Japan by
    Morgan Stanley Japan Limited and/or Morgan
    Stanley Nippon Securities Limited in Singapore
    by organ Stanley Dean Witter Asia (Singapore)
    Pte., regulated by the Monetary Authority of
    Singapore in Australia by Morgan Stanley Dean
    Witter Australia Limited A.B.N. 67 003 734 576, a
    licensed dealer, which accepts responsibility for
    its contents in certain provinces of Canada by
    Morgan Stanley Canada Limited, which has approved
    of, and has agreed to take responsibility for,
    the contents of this publication in Canada in
    Spain by Morgan Stanley, S.V.,S.A., a Morgan
    Stanley group company, which is supervised by the
    Spanish Securities Markets Commission (CNMV) and
    states that this document has been written and
    distributed in accordance with the rules of
    conduct applicable to financial research as
    established under Spanish regulations in the
    United States by Morgan Stanley Co.
    Incorporated and Morgan Stanley DW Inc., which
    accept responsibility for its contents and in
    the United Kingdom, this publication is approved
    by Morgan Stanley Co. International Limited,
    solely for the purposes of section 21 of the
    Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. Private
    U.K. investors should obtain the advice of their
    Morgan Stanley Co. International Limited
    representative about the investment concerned.
  • The trademarks and service marks contained herein
    are the property of their respective owners.
    Third-party data providers make no warranties or
    representations of any kind relating to the
    accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the data
    they provide and shall not have liability for any
    damages of any kind relating to such data. The
    Global Industry Classification Standard ("GICS")
    was developed by and is the exclusive property of
    MSCI and SP.
  • This report or any portion hereof may not be
    reprinted, sold or redistributed without the
    written consent of Morgan Stanley.
  • Additional information on recommended securities
    is available on request.

5
Overview
  • Auto Outlook Its not how many cars you sell,
    its how much money you make
  • Global Dilemma Most participants spending for
    growth yet the industry does not grow.
  • Economic Demographic factors suggest auto sales
    may bottom this year, but the recovery is likely
    to be modest.
  • Profit recovery is likely to lag for a variety of
    reasons
  • Price pressure remains brutal
  • Market share pressures continue
  • Excess capacity is large more is on the way
  • Mix covering for price declines, but is hard to
    sustain
  • Higher interest rates create risk of weaker
    demand, weaker mix and lower finance company
    earnings

6
Global Light Vehicle Sales Slow Growth
CAGR 1.2
Source LMCJ.D. Power Morgan Stanley Research
7
Excess Capacity at 25-30 or 20mm units
Source Autofacts Morgan Stanley Research
8
Global Capital Expenditures to DA
Assets Being Put in Place Much Faster than They
are Being Used Up
Source Company data Morgan Stanley
Research Adjusted to fit scale
9
Conclusion Zero Sum Game
  • Slow growth and excess capacity suggest
    deflation/revenue pressures likely to continue.
  • Everybody cant be a winner.
  • Winners will be low cost producers who deliver a
    good product that consumers are willing to pay
    for.

Source Morgan Stanley Research
10
State of the NA Industry
  • Demand Economic and demographic factors suggest
    auto sales are likely to bottom this year, but
    recovery is likely to be modest.
  • Pricing Pricing environment unusually weak
    despite strong demand. Elasticity of demand is
    fading.
  • Used car pricing also weak.
  • Competition intensifying Industry plagued with
    excess capacity, and more is on the way.

Source Morgan Stanley Research
11
North American Sales
Sales should bottom this year
16.2mm Units FY03E
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
12
Economic Conditions
Better than they were, but still not robust
Source CPI Morgan Stanley Research
13
Weighted Median Age of a Vehicle vs. Sales
1 Year Lead Correlation 77.6
Source Polk Morgan Stanley Research
14
Off Lease Vehicles Begin to Decline
Fewer Consumers Being Forced Back to the
Dealerships
Source Manheim Morgan Stanley Research
15
Taking Longer to Establish Consumer Equity
Source FRB Morgan Stanley Research
16
Affordability Near 20 Year Best
Number of Weeks of Income to Purchase a Vehicle
Source FRB Morgan Stanley Research
17
Revenue Pressures Worst Since 1970s
New Car CPI vs. Domestic Light Vehicle Sales
Source CPI Morgan Stanley Research
18
Y/Y Change in Monthly New Car CPI
Source CPI Morgan Stanley Research
19
Price Reductions Pressure Manufacturers
  • Every 1 Decline in Prices is Worth
  • 1.0bn at GM
  • 850mm at Ford
  • 550mm at DCX

Source Morgan Stanley Research
20
Big Three Market Share Continues to Slide
Every 1 Point of Share is Worth Roughly 1bn in
Profit
76.0
61.7
60.5
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
21
Market Share Winners / Losers 2003YTD
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
22
Big Three Share of Sales by Segment 2003YTD vs.
2002 FY
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
23
NA Capacity Additions, Despite Flat Outlook
Net Increase Of 1.2mm Units or Roughly 6.0 of NA
sales
2003


2005
Ford Nissan Mitsubishi
(170) 250 60 140
2006
(292) 235 (57)
Ford Hyundai
GM Ford DCX Honda Nissan Toyota
125 100 80 180 200 240 925
Toyota
150
Source Company data Morgan Stanley Research
24
Excess Capacity More Is On The Way
Every 1 Pt. of Market Share Translates into
1.0bn in Profits 1.2mm Units of Added Capacity
is 6.0 of NA Capacity, or 6bn in Pretax Profits
NA Pretax Profit Big Three
FY03E (in MM) 3,710
Source Morgan Stanley Research Estimates
25
The Big Three
  • Each Company Faces Unique Challenges
  • GM has operational momentum, but faces pension
    and health care issues.
  • Ford share is under attack and Revitalization
    Plan is just getting out of the gate.
  • DCX continues to struggle.

Source Morgan Stanley Research
26
General Motors
  • Significant operational momentum.
  • Balance sheet risks may be out of companys
    control.
  • Strategy GM appears to have a variable cost
    advantage versus Ford and DCX, which it is using
    to cut price and drive volume.
  • Strategy has enabled GM to gain share and has put
    severe pressure on Ford and DCX.
  • This strategy may benefit them in the near term,
    but poses longer term risks.

Source Morgan Stanley Research
27
GM Car / Light Truck / Total Market Share
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
28
Big Three NAO Profit per Unit FY02 vs. FY01
2002 2001 Change
352 775 1,180

401 (143) (849) 545 1,250
753 632 331 121 422
GM Ford DCX GM b/(w) Ford GM b/(w) DCX
Source Company data Morgan Stanley
Research b/(w)Better or Worse Operating
profit/unit incl pension/OPEB expense
29
Big Three NAO Profit per Unit FY02 vs. FY01
Excluding U.S. Pension Healthcare Costs
Adjusted 2001
Adjusted 2002
1,158 246 (470) 913
1,628
1,705 1,091 670 614 1,035
GM Ford DCX GM b/(w) Ford GM b/(w) DCX
Source Company data Morgan Stanley
Research b/(w)Better or Worse Operating
profit/unit incl pension/OPEB expense
30
U.S. Pension Fund Healthcare Liabilities
Source Company data Morgan Stanley Research
(In MM)
31
U.S. Pension OPEB Expenses 2003E
Source Company data Morgan Stanley Research
(In MM)
32
U.S. Healthcare Pension Cost/Unit FY03
Source Company data Morgan Stanley Research
33
Ford Motor Company Riders On The Storm
  • Fords fall from grace is well documented.
  • Costs
  • Quality
  • Market share
  • Profitability
  • Revitalization Plan is starting to help, but is
    it enough?
  • Ford is spending a lot of money Will they get
    bang for their buck?

Source Morgan Stanley Research
34
Ford Car / Light Truck / Total Market Share
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
35
DaimlerChrysler Struggling to Its Feet
  • Chrysler profitability unstable.
  • Cost performance is fair but revenue performance
    is lagging.
  • DCX still very exposed to light truck segment.
    Focus on cars important.
  • New product is critical.

Source Morgan Stanley Research
36
DCX Car Lt. Truck Sales As A of Parent
Light Trucks
1,134
Cars
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
37
DCX Car / Light Truck / Total Market Share
Source Autodata Morgan Stanley Research
38
Global Operating Margins FY02
16.4 10.6 8.9 8.4 8.1 6.1 5.0
4.7 4.0 2.0 1.7 3.1 0.2 -6.2
Porsche Nissan BMW Honda Toyota Hyundai Peugeot Ki
a VW GM Renault DCX Ford Fiat
Source Company data Morgan Stanley
Research Morgan Stanley Estimates
39
Global Operating Margins FY02
Excluding Pension OPEB Expense for the Big Three
16.4 10.6 8.9 8.4 8.1 6.1 5.7
5.0 4.7 4.0 3.8 1.7 1.8 -6.2
Porsche Nissan BMW Honda Toyota Hyundai GM Peugeot
Kia VW DCX Renault Ford Fiat
Source Company data Morgan Stanley
Research Morgan Stanley Estimates
40
Implications
  • GM will continue to pursue its grow our way out
    strategy.
  • DCX improved cost structure is keeping it in the
    game. New product is critical to alleviating
    revenue pressure.
  • Foreign OEMs are likely to continue to add
    capacity in NA. Imports are likely to rise.
  • Ford remains the odd man out in a zero sum game.
    If the company does not execute, another crisis
    may be on the horizon. Q1 results may be a
    start.
  • On the bright side, the Big Three product is the
    best its ever been.

Source Morgan Stanley Research
41
Stephen.Girsky_at_MorganStanley.com
Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
About PowerShow.com