Title: PRENATAL DIAGNOSIS AND SCREENING
1PRENATAL DIAGNOSIS AND SCREENING
M Huggins, 2008
2Learning Objectives
- Discuss current guidelines for Prenatal Screening
and Diagnostic testing - Review the biochemical markers used in each
Prenatal screening method - Understand the importance of accurate clinical
information in prenatal screening - Emphasize the underlying theme of informed
decision making
3You are seeing a 42 Year old woman for first PN
visit at 10 weeks of gestation.
- What is her risk of Down syndrome?
- What options can you offer her?
Are your answers different if she is 32 years old?
4Canadian Guidelines for Prenatal
DiagnosisGENETIC INDICATIONS FOR PRENATAL
DIAGNOSIS(CCMG / SOGC, 2001)
- The traditional recommendation is that all women
who will be 35 years of age or older on the
estimated date of delivery should be offered
invasive prenatal testing
5Prenatal Screening for Fetal AneuploidySOGC
Practice Guideline(CCMG / SOGC, 2007)
- Maternal age screening is a poor minimum standard
for prenatal screening for aneuploidy and should
be removed as an indication for invasive testing.
- Amniocentesis/chorionic villi sampling (CVS)
should not be provided without multiple marker
screening results except for women over the age
of 40. Patients should be counselled accordingly.
6ACOG Practice BulletinScreening for Fetal
Chromosomal Abnormalities(Obstet Gynecol, 2007)
- Screening and invasive diagnostic testing for
aneuploidy should be available to all women who
present for prenatal care before 20 weeks of
gestation regardless of maternal age. - Women should be counseled regarding the
differences between screening and invasive
diagnostic testing.
7Prenatal Screening Options
- First Trimester Screening (FTS)
- Maternal Serum Screening (MSS)
- Integrated Prenatal Screening (IPS)
8IPS and MSS Screen for Which of the Following
Conditions?
- Down syndrome
- Trisomy 18
- Trisomy 13
- Neural tube defects
- All of the above
9IPS and MSS Screen for Which of the Following
Conditions?
- Down syndrome
- Trisomy 18
- Trisomy 13
- Neural tube defects
- All of the above
10Maternal Serum Markers Can you Name Them?
- First Trimester
- Second Trimester
11Maternal Serum Markers Can you Name Them?
- First Trimester Papp-A free beta hcG
- Second Trimester AFP
- uE3
- hcG
- Inhibin-A
Are they low or high in Down syndrome?
12Maternal Serum Markers in Down syndrome
pregnancies
- First Trimester Papp-A (0.4 x normal) hcG
(2.0 x normal) - Second Trimester AFP (0.75 x normal)
- uE3 (0.72 x normal)
- hcG (2.0 x normal)
- Inhibin-A (2.0 x normal)
13Prenatal Screening Options
- First Trimester Screening (FTS)
- Maternal Serum Screening (MSS)
- Integrated Prenatal Screening (IPS)
14First TrimesterCombined Screening (FTS)
- When maternal age, NT, CRL, PAPP-A
- and free beta are combined
- (week 11 to 14)
- Detection rate T21 83
- Detection rate T18 91
- False positive rate 5
Cut off for positive 1 in 350 DS
15Second Trimester Screening (MSS, Quad Screen)
- When AFP, uE3, hCG and inhibin-A are combined
with maternal age - (week 15 to 20)
- detection rate DS 81
- T18 65
- ONTD 85
- false positive rate 5
Cut off for positive 1 in 200 DS
16Maternal Serum Screening (MSS, triple screen)
(no longer in use)
- When maternal age, AFP, uE3 and hCG are combined
- (week 15 to 20)
- detection rate 70
- false positive rate 8
- screens for Down syndrome, trisomy 18 and NTD
Cut off for positive 1 in 385 DS
17Integrated Prenatal Screening (IPS)
- Part One 11-14 weeks
- NT ultrasound
- PAPP-A
- Part Two 15-18 weeks
- AFP
- uE3
- hCG
- Results reported only after Part Two
- Detection rate T21 88 T18 90
- Detection rate NTD 85
- False positive rate 3
Cut off for positive 1 in 200 DS
18The Process of Prenatal Screening
- The results take 2 to 4 days to be reported
(after the second blood test for IPS). - Positive (high risk) results are reported by
telephone or fax, while negative (low risk)
results are sent in the mail. - If the screen is positive, genetic counselling is
available to discuss the risks and benefits of
diagnostic testing (either CVS or amniocentesis,
depending on gestational age and availability of
CVS).
19An Example of Prenatal Screening Introducing
April
- 38 year old Black woman
- 12 weeks pregnant
- Healthy 2 year old son, full term vaginal
delivery - Family history is non-contributory
What is her risk of Down syndrome? Any other
genetic issues?
20April Is 38 Years Old
- Risk of Down syndrome 1 / 175
- Total risk of aneuploidy 1 / 100
- 12 weeks pregnant
- Family history non-contributory
- Hemoglobinopathy screening negative
Prenatal Screening Options for April?
21Aprils Chooses IPS
- Nov 2nd first PN visit, requests IPS (12w1d)
book an ultrasound for NT, prepare requisitions
for part I and part II, decide when part II will
be done - Nov 9th ultrasound for NT, part I IPS (13w1d)
- Nov 21st part II IPS, bloodwork only (15w0d)
reminder sent from screening lab if sample not
received by 17w6d - Nov 24th IPS positive, report sent to ordering
physician or midwife by phone or fax from the
reporting centre PND clinic on behalf of the CVH
screening lab
22Aprils IPS Result
- Maternal Age at EDD 38.1 years
- Gestational Age 1st sample 13w1d
- Gestational Age 2nd sample 15w0d
- Nuchal 2.0 mm 1.08 MoM AFP 0.47 MoM
- PAPP-A 0.34 MoM uE3 0.67 MoM hCG 1.52
MoM
Risk of Down syndrome 1 in 14 Risk of NTD 1 in
11000
Screen Positive for Down syndrome
23Aprils IPS Result
- What is the chance that Aprils baby has Down
syndrome?
Risk of Down syndrome 1 in 14 Approximately 7
24Screen Positive for Down syndrome
25The Prenatal Diagnosis Clinic
- Genetic Counsellors, Genetic Nurse
- Sarah Ruddle, Marlene Huggins, Gwen White
- Physicians
- Dr. Mohide, Dr. Winsor, Dr. Defrance, Dr.
McDonald - (Dr. Smith, Dr. Mueller, Dr. Brennan, Dr.
Muggah) - Business Clerks
- Lynn Watson, Dianne Maynard, Joanne Whittaker
- Clinical Manager
- Kathy Clark
26Who We Serve
- Hamilton, Central West and Central South Regions
- Population 2.2 million, 22000 births
- 7 counties
- 9 cities Hamilton, Burlington, Guelph,
Cambridge, Kitchener-Waterloo, Brantford,Niagara
Falls, St. Catharines, Welland - 9 towns Fergus, Arthur, Paris, Simcoe,
Dunnville, Fort Erie, Port Colborne, Grimsby,
Niagara-on-the-Lake - 10 hospitals with birthing units
- Multicultural complexity
- Hamilton has a high proportion of immigrants
- Mennonites in Kitchener area
- Brant Reserve
27Central West and Central South Regions
28Who we see
- Late maternal age (LMA)
- Positive prenatal screening
- (T21, NTD , T18)
- Abnormal community ultrasound
- Suspected anomalies
- Soft signs
- Past history / family history of congenital
anomalies, abnormal chromosomes or genetic
conditions - Exposure to potentially harmful drugs, infections
or toxins - Pre-conception counselling
29Aprils Experience with Prenatal Diagnosis
- November 30th (16w2d)
- PND clinic consultation
- genetic counselling
- Option to do same day amniocentesis
30Counselling Patients About Abnormalities
- What do we know and what do we not know?
- What are the possibilities? (ie the difference
between a screening result and a diagnosis) - Options for further testing risks and benefits
(either for delivery planning or for
decision-making about TOP) - Prognosis for survival prognosis for
developmental outcome - Availability of specialist consultations
31Aprils Amniocentesis Result
32Aprils Experience with Prenatal Diagnosis
- Nov 30th seen for genetic counselling, requests
amniocentesis, done same day (16w2d) - Dec 15th karyotype 47,XX,21
- Phone call to April to tell her the result
- Dec 19th seen for genetic counselling (18w5d)
33Counselling Patients About Abnormalities
- What do we know and what do we not know
- What are the possibilities (ie the difference
between a screening result and a diagnosis) - Options for further testing either for delivery
planning or for decision-making - Prognosis for survival prognosis for
developmental outcome - Availability of specialist consultations
34Genetic Counselling
- Guilt and blame
- Comprehension of complex medical information
- Personal supports
- Social context
- Grief and anger
- Decision-making
35Counselling patientscontd
- Who to tell, how to tell?
- Why did this happen, will it happen again?
(possible need for further testing eg autopsy) - What will we tell the other children?
- Induction of labour vs DE
- Possible need (or choice) for burial / cremation
36Aprils Experience with Prenatal Diagnosis
- Nov 30th seen for genetic counselling, requests
amniocentesis, done same day (16w2d) - Dec 15th karyotype 47,XX,21
- Phone call to April to tell her the result
- Dec 19th seen for genetic counselling (18w5d)
Undecided, requests ultrasound for more
information
37How Is April Doing?
- Dec 19th seen for genetic counselling (18w5d)
- Known trisomy 21
- Undecided, requests ultrasound for more
information - December 28th no major anomalies, NF8mm,
echogenic intracardiac focus (soft markers for
Down syndrome) - Met with social worker, genetic counsellor,
obstetrician.
38- April requested pregnancy termination,
- and was admitted for induction of labour on Jan
5th at 21w5d of gestation
39Prenatal Screening in Ontario
- First Trimester Screening (FTS)
- Second Trimester Screening (MSS) (quad screen in
Ontario) - Integrated Prenatal Screening (IPS)
- Nuchal Translucency ultrasound (for twins, not
recommended for singletons without biochemistry) - Ultrasound (18 20 weeks) current standard of
care for all patients
Patients option to decline
40PRENATAL SCREENINGClinical Information Needed
- Date of Birth for age related a priori risk
- Gestation by LMP or by ultrasound
- Multiple Gestation AFP increases with number of
babies serum screening for DS not available for
multiples - Maternal Weight marker levels decrease with
increasing maternal weight, most important for
AFP
41PRENATAL SCREENINGClinical Information Needed
- Diabetic Status Why is it important for prenatal
screening?
- Maternal IDDM increases the risk of ONTD
- MSAFP is lower in women with IDDM
42PRENATAL SCREENINGClinical Information Needed
- Race why is it important for prenatal screening?
Blacks have higher MSAFP and lower population
prevalence of ONTD
43Prenatal Screening
- Case Examples
- (Trouble-shooting)
- Gestational age
- Maternal Weight
- Maternal Race
- Abnormal NT
- part II IPS not done
44Screen Positive for Down Syndrome Gestational
Age?
- Maternal Age at EDD 20.1 years
- Gestational Age 20w1d by LMP
- AFP 0.53 MoM
- uE3 0.56 MoM
- hCG 2.91 MoM
- InhibinA 1.66 MoM
- Risk of Down syndrome 130
45Screen Positive for Down SyndromeGestational
Age?
- Gestational Age (20w1d) AFP 0.53 MoM
- uE3 0.56 MoM
- hCG 2.91 MoM
- InhibinA 1.66 MoM
- 16w5d by BPD
- AFP 0.94 MoM
- uE3 1.23 MoM
- hCG 2.05 MoM
- InhibinA 1.99 MoM
- Risk of Down syndrome 11400
- INTERPRETATION SCREEN NEGATIVE
46MSS Positive for Down SyndromeCorrect
gestational age?
- Maternal Age at EDD 37.4 years
- Gestational Age 19w6d by u/s
- AFP 0.59 MoM
- uE3 0.82 MoM
- hCG 1.54 MoM
- Inhibin-A 0.81 MoM
- Risk of Down syndrome 1180
47MSS Positive Down SyndromeTranscription Error
CRL vs BPD
- Maternal Age at EDD 37.4 years
- Ultrasound BPD 15 mm (10w6d)
- Gestational Age (19w6d)
- AFP 0.59 MoM
- uE3 0.82 MoM
- hCG 1.54 MoM
- Inhibin-A 0.81 MoM
CRL 15 mm (8w0d) 17w0d at MSS AFP 0.95
MoM uE3 1.58 MoM hCG 1.16 MoM Inhibin-A
0.94 MoM
- Risk of Down syndrome 1880
- INTERPRETATION SCREEN NEGATIVE
48Practical Tidbit
- Accurate dating (by ultrasound) is important for
correct interpretation of prenatal screening - Less critical for IPS since ultrasound is
incorporated (CRL correlated with NT) - Dont forget to check dates even if MSS is
negative
49Prenatal Screening
- Case Examples
- (Trouble-shooting)
- Gestational age
- Maternal Weight
- Maternal Race
- Abnormal NT
- part II IPS not done
50IPS positive for Down syndromePatients Weight
not provided
- Maternal Age at EDD 36.8 years
- Gestational Age 1st sample 13w3d
- Gestational Age 2nd sample 16w3d
- Nuchal 2.0mm 0.40 MoM AFP 0.40 MoM
- PAPP-A 0.38 MoM uE3 0.65 MoM hCG 0.80
MoM
Risk of Down syndrome 170 Risk of NTD 113000
51IPS positive Patients Weight included
- Maternal Age at EDD 36.8 years
- Weight not known
- Gestational Age 16w3d by U/S
- AFP 0.40 MoM
- uE3 0.65 MoM
- hCG 0.80 MoM
- PAPP-A 0.38 MoM
Weight 295 lbs AFP 0.70 MoM uE3 0.89
MoM hCG 1.37 MoM PAPP-A 1.52 MoM
- INTERPRETATION SCREEN NEGATIVE
- (Down syndrome 13100 NTD 114000)
52IPS positive forDown syndrome and T18 Correct
Information?
- Maternal Age at EDD 30.9 years
- Gestational Age 1st sample 12w3d
- Gestational Age 2nd sample 15w1d
- NT 1.3mm 0.88 MoM AFP 0.73 MoM
- PAPP-A 0.15 MoM uE3 0.55 MoM hCG 0.64
MoM
Risk of Down syndrome 1180 Risk of trisomy 18
114
53Screen Positive Corrected Patients Weight
- Maternal Age 33 years
- Weight 117.5 lbs
- Gestational Age 16w2d
- AFP 0.73 MoM
- uE3 0.55 MoM
- hCG 0.64 MoM
- PAPP-A 0.15 MoM
Weight 117.5 kg AFP 1.34 MoM uE3 0.66
MoM hCG 1.09 MoM PAPP-A 0.28 MoM
- INTERPRETATION SCREEN NEGATIVE
- (Down syndrome 13200 T18 no number reported if
negative)
54Prenatal Screening
- Case Examples
- (Trouble-shooting)
- Gestational age
- Maternal Weight
- Maternal Race
- Abnormal NT
- part II IPS not done
55Screen positive NTDCorrect Information?
- Maternal Age at EDD 33.0 years
- Gestational Age 16w2d by U/S
- AFP 2.27 MoM
- uE3 0.49 MoM
- hCG 1.78 MoM
Risk of Open Spina Bifida 1399
56Screen Positive NTDCorrected Patients Race
- Maternal Age at EDD 33 years
- Race Caucasian
- Gestational Age 16w2d by U/S
- AFP 2.27 MoM
- uE3 0.49 MoM
- hCG 1.78 MoM
Race Black AFP 2.06 MoM uE3 0.49 MoM hCG
1.78 MoM
- Risk of Spina Bifida 11300
- INTERPRETATION SCREEN NEGATIVE
57Prenatal Screening
- Case Examples
- (Trouble-shooting)
- Gestational age
- Maternal Weight
- Maternal Race
- Abnormal NT
- part II IPS not done
58Patient chose IPS, but NT is abnormal
- Maternal Age at EDD 37.8 years
- CRL 56.9mm 12w2d
- Nuchal Translucency 3.8 mm 3.01 MoM
- (ideally, reported by phone or fax from the
ultrasound unit)
59Abnormal NTOption to change IPS to FTS
- Maternal Age at EDD 37.8 years
- CRL 56.9mm 12w2d
- Nuchal Translucency 3.8 mm 3.01 MoM
- (discuss with patient, call or fax the screening
lab) - PAPP-A 0.43 MoM
- free beta hCG 1.73 MoM
Risk of Down syndrome 2 in 3
60FTS positive DS 2 in 3
- Ultrasound, blood drawn Feb 9th (12w2d)
- FTS report Feb 15th
- Seen in PND clinic Mar 3rd (15w3d).
- Amniocentesis same day.
- (could have been CVS if referred sooner)
Karyotype 47, XY, 21 Mar 17th (17w3d)
61Practical Tidbit
- Abnormal nuchal translucency should be treated as
any other abnormal ultrasound finding - Discuss options with patient, refer for genetic
counselling and / or further testing as needed - BUT normal NT is not a stand alone test for
aneuploidy screening
62Prenatal Screening
- Case Examples
- (Trouble-shooting)
- Gestational age
- Maternal Weight
- Maternal Race
- Abnormal NT
- part II IPS not done
63IPS Requires Both Part I and Part II
- Maternal Age at EDD 34.8 years
- CRL 63.3 mm 12w4d
- Nuchal Translucency 1.5 mm 1.10 MoM
No result, waiting for part II serum
screening. Notification from lab at 17w6d when
part II not recd Report issued at 20w6d when
part II still not recd.
64IPS Requires Both Part I and Part II
- Maternal Age at EDD 34.8 years
- CRL 63.3 mm 12w4d
- Nuchal Translucency 1.5 mm 1.10 MoM
PAPP-A 0.53 MoM free beta hCG 4.43 MoM
Risk of Down syndrome 1 in 180 (reported at 21
weeks of gestation) Counselling Issues?
65Practical Tidbit
- Timing for IPS is determined by CRL
- (range for part I from 45 to 84 mm, or BPD less
than 26.2 mm) - If you dont complete IPS II before 17 6/7 weeks
(according to the CRL for IPS I), they will send
a reminder. - If IPS II not received by 20 6/7, they will
report FTS.
66Prenatal Screening
- Dont be too pessimistic
- Ride the PND roller coaster
- Screening for other conditions
67IPS positive Down syndrome
- Maternal Age at EDD 35.8 years
- Gestational Age 1st sample 13w2d
- Gestational Age 2nd sample 17w1d
- Nuchal 2.8 mm 3.01 MoM AFP 0.84 MoM
- PAPP-A 0.43 MoM uE3 0.75 MoM hCG 1.73
MoM
Risk of Down syndrome 9 in 10 Risk of NTD 1
in 16000
68Screen positive DS 9 in 10
- Seen in PND clinic (19w2d).
- G3, 2 healthy children at home.
- Family history of a paternal aunt with Down
syndrome, another relative possible DS. - Maternal karyotyping recommended (normal result).
- Amniocentesis same day.
- PI FISH Normal final karyotype Normal
- Ultrasound Normal (21w2d)
Whats the diagnosis?
69Prenatal Screening
- Dont be too pessimistic
- Ride the PND roller coaster
- Screening for other conditions
70Case ExampleRide the PND roller coaster
- 26 year old,, first pregnancy
- routine prenatal screening
Gestational Age 20w0d AFP 5.54 MoM uE3
0.82 MoM hCG 0.85 MoM Inhibin-A 0.56 MoM
Risk of Neural Tube Defect 15 Screen
positive Risk of Down syndrome 120000 Screen
negative
71Screen positive NTD
- Referred for detailed ultrasound
- No evidence of NTD
- Abdominal wall defect, most likely an omphalocele
(vs gastroschisis) - Patient is completely blindsided
- Well prepared to hear about spina bifida,
prepared to make decisions if severe anomalies - Never heard of omphalocele
72Fetal omphalocele
- Abdominal wall defect, frequently associated with
elevated maternal serum AFP - Most are isolated, some have multiple anomalies,
potential for syndromic associations - Surgery in newborn period, potential
complications - 30 risk of chromosomal abnormalities (mostly
T21, T18 or T13)
Counselling implications unexpected findings
73Abdominal Wall Defect Omphalocele
74Fetal omphalocele
- Most are isolated, some have multiple anomalies,
potential for syndromic associations - Surgery in newborn period, potential
complications - 30 risk of chromosomal abnormalities (mostly
T21, T18 or T13)
- Amniocentesis, 21 weeks of gestation
- PI FISH is normal
- Apparently isolated omphalocele, transfer to MFM
for ongoing care
Karyotype mosaic trisomy 14 (23 weeks)
75Prenatal Screening
- Dont be too pessimistic
- Ride the PND roller coaster
- Screening for other conditions
76MSS positive T18
Maternal Age at EDD 32 years Gestational Age
17w3d by u/s AFP 2.21 MoM uE3 MoM hCG 0.28 MoM
- Screen Positive Risk of T18 18
77- Seen in PND 19w 6d. Ultrasound normal.
- 32 yo G1.
- Family history sisters son dry skin, needs
moisturizer daily. - No other family history
78Low uE3
- Associated with Smith Lemli Opitz syndrome (SLOS)
- Associated with X-linked ichthyosis steroid
sulfatase (STS) deficiency - Associated with normal outcome
79Amniocentesis
- Normal male karyotype
- FISH for STS probe microdeletion
- 46,XY.ish del(X)(p22.3p22.3)(STS-)
Diagnosis Steroid sulfatase deficiency, X-linked
ichthyosis
80Prenatal Screening Options
- First Trimester Screening (FTS)
- Maternal Serum Screening (MSS)
- Integrated Prenatal Screening (IPS)
81PRENATAL SCREENINGClinical Information Needed
- Date of Birth for age related a priori risk
- Gestation by LMP or by ultrasound
- Maternal Weight marker levels decrease with
increasing maternal weight, most important for
AFP - Diabetic Status maternal IDDM increases risk of
ONTD, MSAFP is lower in women with IDDM - Race Blacks have higher MSAFP and lower
population prevalence of ONTD - Multiple Gestation AFP increases with number of
babies serum screening for DS not available for
multiples
82PRENATAL SCREENINGGeneral Principles
- Should be offered to all women
- Originally designed for women for any age
- Offers women options for further testing if
positive - Reassurance if results negative does not
guarantee healthy baby - All positives reported by phone or fax
- Check dates if negative (MSS)
83Canadian Guidelines for Prenatal
DiagnosisGenetic Indications for Prenatal
Diagnosis(CCMG / SOGC, 2001)
- Screening for chromosomal anomalies based on
biochemical markers should only be considered
within a comprehensive screening and prenatal
diagnosis program - including interpretation, education, and
follow-up counselling.
84Prenatal Screening for Fetal AneuploidySOGC
Practice Guideline(CCMG / SOGC, 2007)
- Screening programs should show respect for the
needs and quality of life of persons with
disabilities. - Counselling should be nondirective and should
respect a womans choice to accept or to refuse
any or all of the testing or options offered at
any point in the process.
85Things to think about in deciding about testing
- Understand that conditions such as Down syndrome
or spina bifida are generally unrelated to family
history all pregnancies have some risk. - Pregnant women can choose whether to learn if
their own pregnancy is at increased risk compared
to background.
86Womens Perceptions
- Does any woman believe herself to be at risk?
- Family lore mothers and grandmothers had
healthy babies in their 40s and they didnt have
testing or screening options. - Prenatal screening as just one more blood test
without really understanding that its about the
health of the baby, and could lead to decisions
about further testing.
87Points to Consider..
- What would it mean for you if your baby has Down
syndrome? Would you rather know that before the
baby is born? - What would it mean for you to find out during the
pregnancy that the baby has a serious health
problem? How would that be different if you find
out after the baby is born? - If you choose to do testing, you accept the added
risk of miscarriage with the procedure. How
would you handle a miscarriage?
88Reasons to Perform Prenatal Screening
- In most cases, the news will be good and may
reassure the patient. - Some patients may decide to terminate the
pregnancy when faced with a significant
abnormality.
89Reasons to Perform Prenatal Screening
- Anomaly detection may allow specialized antenatal
or perinatal treatment in case of a lethal
anomaly it might be reasonable to avoid a
cesarean delivery for fetal distress. - The parents have time to prepare emotionally and
financially. They can educate themselves and
their family members about the anomaly other
children may be prepared before the birth.
90(No Transcript)