Title: EOY Presentation
1(No Transcript)
2- Class of 2007
- End-of-Year Presentation
3Agenda
- Introductions
- Mayer Fund
- Objectives
- Investment Approach
- Market and Economic Environment
- Investment Holdings and Key Decisions
- Mayer Fund Performance
- Relative Performance
- Risk Adjusted Performance
- Performance Attribution Analysis
- Sector Allocation and Security Selection
Decisions - Looking Ahead
- Market Outlook
- Portfolio Update Since Fiscal Year End
- Senbet Fund Performance Presentation
- Questions Answers
- Reception 3rd Floor Atrium
4Mayer Fund Team 2007
- Akinola Dosunmu Portfolio Manager
- Tray Spilker Portfolio Manager
- Sachin Agarwal Energy Utilities Analyst
- Michael Alessi Technology Analyst
- Mauricio Klecky Industrials Materials Analyst
- Avi Lerner Healthcare Materials Analyst
- Chris Mandozzi Healthcare Analyst
- Pablo Ortega Telecommunications Financials
Analyst - Johannes Thorsteinsson Technology Analyst
- Chris Van Horn Consumer Discretionary Analyst
- Eun Mi Yu Consumer Staples Analyst
- Sherwood Zhang Financials Analyst
5Mayer Fund Team 2008
- Eric Olesh Portfolio Manager
- Bill Song Portfolio Manager
- Alex Obaza Energy Utilities Analyst
- Rahul Prabhu Technology Analyst
- Qi Guo (Alex) Industrials Materials Analyst
- Denny Chu Healthcare Analyst
- Siddharth Mathur Telecommunications Analyst
- Chananate Niyamosot (Fai) Consumer
Discretionary Analyst - Fang Fang Consumer Staples Analyst
- Jonathan Steele Financials Analyst
6Performance Summary
7Mayer Fund Objectives
- Achieve long-term growth of capital
- Maximize risk adjusted return
- Provide a 5 annual dividend to Smith School
- Educational benefits for members
- Experiential learning model - real world
application of stock selection, equity analysis
and portfolio management - Enhance the reputation of the Smith School
- Meetings with Wall Street and local finance
professionals - Employment with world-class companies
8Investment Approach
- Modern portfolio theory
- Benefits of diversification
- Top Down approach
- Economy, Industry, and Company framework (EIC)
- Fundamental equity research
- Qualitative analysis
- Detailed financial statement and red flag
analysis - Discounted cash flow valuation
- Comparable company valuation
- Growth at a reasonable price
- Risk Adjusted Return
9Why GARP?
- Why Growth at a Reasonable Price?
- Investment discipline balancing risk and return
- Why GARP instead of pure growth?
- Valuation concerns about pure growth stocks
- Less downside risk in declining market
- Why GARP instead of pure value?
- Imperfect information and market efficiency
- Time frame for market recognition of intrinsic
value
10Portfolio Allocation Approach
- Guidelines
- No more than 25 in any one sector
- Representation and diversification across sectors
- Considerations for Sector Weightings
- Economic outlook
- Input from sector analysts
- SP 500 allocations
11Security Selection Approach
- Guidelines
- No more than 5 in any one security
- Presence across SP economic sectors
- At year end we held 45 securities
- Selection Criteria
- Choose strong industry players with minimum 100M
market cap - Security must be covered by minimum of 3 Wall
Street analysts - Opportunities for Extra Diversification
- International Exposure (mutual funds and
individual securities)
12Market Economic Environment
13Recap of Key Fiscal Year Issues
- Liquidity and Growth in U.S. and Global Markets
- Fueling Private Equity and MA Activity
- Stock Market Appreciation/ Housing Weakening
- Imbalances
- Sub-prime Lending
- Household Spending
- Current Account
- Fiscal Deficit
- Dollar Depreciation
- Inflation Concerns Rates increased through Aug
06 - Geopolitical Concerns
- Record Company Earnings
14The Economy
- Growing Trade Deficits and Rising Oil Prices
15The Economy
- Inflation (CPI) - Interest Rates - GDP -
Unemployment
16Market Performance
SP 500 Performance Timeline FY07
Democrats take control of Congress
Fed Pauses
Oil Prices Over 75/barrel
Mayer Fund members ring opening bell at NYSE
Chinese stock market drops 9
Dow breaks through 12,000 for the first time
17 What Drove the SP 500
18Mayer Fund Performance
19Performance Summary
20Relative Performance
21Relative Performance
22Relative Performance
Mayer Fund vs. Comparable Mutual Funds
23Risk Adjusted Performance
- Treynor Ratio
- Ratio of portfolio excess return to beta
- Adjusts for systematic risk
- Jensens Alpha
- Measures return over and above that predicted by
CAPM - Sharpe Ratio
- Ratio of portfolio excess return to standard
deviation - Adjusts return for total risk
- M Squared
- Adjusts for total volatility and is easy to
interpret
24Risk Adjusted Performance
Mayer Fund vs. Comparable Mutual Funds Relative
Basis Year ended March 31, 2007
25Risk Adjusted Performance
Mayer Fund vs. Comparable Mutual Funds Relative
Basis Three Years ended March 31, 2007
26Performance Attribution Analysis
Sector Performances vs. SP 500
27Performance Attribution Analysis
Key Holdings
28Performance Attribution Analysis
Key Purchases
29Investment Holdings Key Decisions
30Mayer Fund Top Ten Holdings
31Portfolio Allocation Strategies
- Summer 2006
- Spike in market volatility
- Key concerns were direction of oil prices and
interest rates - Decided to go overweight in energy and
underweight in financials - Fall 2006
- Reviewed impact of a pause in interest rate hikes
to the portfolio - Winter 2006-2007
- Optimized/rebalanced portfolio
- Spring 2007
- Transitioned to 2008 team including portfolio
rebalancing - Increased exposure to financials
32Security Selection Strategies
- Fundamentals driven
- Market Leadership
- GameStop, Coach, McDonalds
- Strong Financials
- Organic growth vs. acquisitive growth
- Optimal use of leverage
- Strong Growth Potential
- America Movil
- Quality driven
- Proctor Gamble
- American Express
- Anixter International
- Waste Management Inc.
33Thoughts from our analysts
34Security Selection Decisions
Consumer Discretionary Sector GameStop (GME)
- Industry Dynamics
- Video game industry sales at all time high
- New consoles coming to market
- Minimal competition for a stand alone video game
retailer - Demographic expansion and consumer spending
increases - Industry defensive to slowdown
- Industry Position
- Industry leader/pioneer in used video game sales
- Created virtual monopoly in stand alone retailer
of video game products
35Security Selection Decisions
Consumer Discretionary Sector GameStop (GME)
- Fundamental Analysis
- Industry high operating margin of 5.81 compared
to industry average of 0.48 - Unique video game retailing model
- Company Performance
- 37 appreciation from purchase date through
3/31/07 - FY 2006 Sales and NI increased 95.83 and 58.80
over 2 years - Strong balance sheet
- Strong same store sales growth of 27
- Beat EPS estimates
36Security Selection Decisions
Consumer Discretionary Sector GME vs. Best Buy
37Portfolio Issues
How do we add Alpha in a stagnant market?
- Covered call program
- Write out-of-money calls for incremental return
- Choose securities that have been beaten down by
the market - Timing based around information dates
- - Earnings reports
- - Analyst calls
- Candidates within portfolio
- Pfizer
- General Electric
- Qualcomm
38Security Selection Decisions
The Case for Pfizer
- Overlooked in the market
- Low P/E relative to industry with strong cash
flow - Market leader with strong product pipeline
- Reasons for recent stock decline
- Torcetrapib pulled from market
- Loss on patent protection on major drugs
- Divestiture of consumer products division
- 12 drop in price
39Pfizer vs. Pfizer Option
- Wrote PFEAY on 12/7/06 for income of 202.79
- Expired 1/19/07 unexercised
40Looking Ahead
41Market Outlook
- We have positioned the portfolio for the future
based on - Economic outlook Neutral
- Slow economic growth between 2 to 2.5
- Persistent inflationary pressures with CPI above
2 - Lower year-over-year earnings for Q3 and Q4
because of recent declines in CAPEX spending - Concerns
- Stagflation which will delay FOMC rate cut
- Decrease in liquidity
- Geopolitical tensions in Iran, Venezuela and
emerging markets - Conundrum
- High asset prices
- Global economic boom
- Increased wealth
42Class of 2008 Objectives
- Dont Lose Money (Eric)
- Beat the SP 500 benchmark (Bill)
- Improve ability to effectively pitch and defend
investment ideas (Alex) - Learn the art of market analysis and fundamental
valuation (Rahul) - Replace performance model with portfolio
management software package (Eric) - Pinpoint how companies are exploiting new
opportunities in mature industries (Fang) - Meet alumni and network with those on Wall Street
(Bill) - Make lifelong friends and future partners
(Siddharth)
43Performance Update
44Closing Remarks
45Lessons Learned
- In reality, even the experts cant accurately
predict oil prices.or the market for that
matter. (Sachin) - Emerging markets offer excellent growth
opportunities. However, a thorough analysis of
the companys fundamentals along with
geopolitical factors is a must in order to make
an investment that fits the risk adjusted return
pursued by the Mayer Fund. (Pablo) - Models dont generate precise outcomes, but
rather force you to analyze all inputs that
affect a firms value. (Mike) - Keep a long-term view and put short-term
volatility in perspective. Be calm and evaluate
whether long-term fundamentals have changed.
(Mauricio) - Dont worry about trying to time the market,
itll give you gray (or no) hair. (Tray) - Stick to your discipline and sell stocks when
targeted gain has been realized. (Van Horn) - Good investments can still be found in a frothy
market environment. (Johannes)
46Educational Milestones
- First time money managers in a summer selloff!
- First reports with much room to grow
- New research report template
- Senbet Fund Recruiting
- New MF/SF Office
- Synergies in stock selections and mentorship
- Executed first covered call positive result
- NYC Trek Lehman Brothers, RockView Capital, Park
Avenue Equity Partners, and a successful combined
reception - NYSE Tour and Opening Bell January 19th, 2007
- Recruited class of 2008
- Developed new brand logo for Mayer Fund
- Rolled out new Mayer Fund Newsletter (Thanks to
Class of 2008)
47Special Thank You
Time and Advice Contributions
48Special Thank You
Time and Advice Contributions
49Special Appreciation
- We wish to thank
- Sarah Kroncke
- Our Faculty Advisor and Mayer Fund Alumni
50QA
51Mayer Fund Backup Slides
52Mayer Fund Ratios vs. SP 500
53Sell Transactions
54Non-SP 500 Mayer Fund Holdings
55Transactions since 3/31/07
56Portfolio Turnover
57Performance Attribution Analysis