Title: Antibiotic
1Antibiotic Stewardship
Cliff Wlodaver, MD Chris May, Pharm D
2- Antibiotics the root cause for resistance
- Darwinism
- Alexander Flemming
- Louis Weinstein
- Native American wisdom
3Goal of Antibiotic Stewardship
- Attack the root cause by fine tuning antibiotic
use - Condense clinical infectious disease,
- ad absurdum
- Create mini-ID specialists,
- by recipe
- Practicality?
4Agenda
- Basics (theory)
- Specifics (practice)
- Physician/administration approval
- Physician response
- Measurement/reporting
- Cost implications
- BREAK
- Clinical vignettes
- Summary/Implementation
- Questions/Discussion
5What is Antibiotic Stewardship?
- A program that encourages judicious (vs
injudicious) use of antibiotics. -
6- Antibiotics are relatively so effective,
non-toxic and inexpensiveso easy to usethat
they are - prone to misuse
- When the diagnosis is uncertain, antibiotics
are often prescribed, viewed as a medical
necessity (drugs of fear) but theyre not
benign - We need a paradigm shift
7- Man has an inborn craving for medicinethe
desire to take medicine is one feature which
distinguishes man, the animal, from his fellow
creatures. - Sir William Osler
- Teaching and Thinking,
- in Aequanimitas
8- Risk Perception and Inappropriate
Antimicrobial Use Yes, It can Hurt - Powers. Clin Infect Dis 2009481350-3
9 Emergency Department Visits for Adverse Drug
Reactions
- Sheab et al. Clin Infect Dis 2008 4773543
10Stewardship strives to fine tune antibiotic Rx
in regards to
- Efficacy/Toxicity
- Resistance-induction/C. difficile
- Cost
- Appropriate discontinuation
11What are its Limitations?
- Its difficult dangerous outrageous to
practice clinical infectious diseases with
limited information - Select cases very carefully
- Primum non nocere
- Practicality?
12Does it work?
13Outcomes of the University of Pennsylvania
Hospitals Antibiotic Stewardship Program
Gross. et al. Clin Infect Dis. 2001 289-295.
14MRSA and C. difficille Rates After Implementation
of an Antibiotic Stewardship Program
Fowler et al. JAC 2007 59, 990995
15Effect of an Antibiotic Stewardship Program on
the Rate of Resistant Enterobacter Infections
Carling et al. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol
200324699-706).
16Recommended by
- Collaborative
- Drs. Perl, Bratzler, CW
- IDSA
- Dellit et al. Clin Infect Dis 2007 44 159-77
- CDC
- Tattevin et al. Emerg Infect Dis 2009 15 953-5
- Practiced regularly
17How does it work?
- A pharmacist, par excellence, or someone else
reviews patients on antibiotics and makes
recommendations, prn overseen by a PHYSICIAN
CHAMPION, an ID-trained physician, when
available - Training
- Contact the prescribing physician
- Telephone call
- Announce non-threatening dont interrupt
(leave message) - Chart notation
- Rx change implemented
- Physician
- Pharmacist, verbal order
18Common Interventions
- Allergies, interactions
- Dosing
- IV-to-po switch
- Redundancy
- Cost
- Empiric Rx, then Streamlining, (de-escalation)
- When not to use antibiotics in the first place
- Discontinuation
19Common InterventionsSome are so evident that
they should be/are automatic
- Allergy, e.g.
- PCN PCN-cephalosporin cross-reactivity
- Drug-drug interactions, e.g.
- Vanco-gentamicin synergistic toxicity
- Rifampins effect on hepatic drug metabolism
- Coumadin
- Address toxicities, e.g.
- Renal
- Aminoglycosides
- Hepatic
20 - Dosing
- Cefazolin q8h
- Ceftriaxone q24h
- Aminoglycosides q24h
- Levels
- Aminoglycosides
- Vancomycin
21Vancomycin Dosing
- MRSA epidemic
- MIC creep
- Dosing reviewed
- Traditional 1gm q12 h
- New recommendation 15mg/kg q12 h
- (ATS/IDSA. Am J Respir Crit
Care Med 2005171388-416) - Nomogram for renal impairment
22Vancomycin Levels
- Therapeutic and toxic levels uncertain (CID 94)
- Resistance has led to aiming for trough of 15-20
(ATS/IDSA) - And this has led to nephrotoxicity
- Measuring levels often leads to under-dosing
- Management options
- Dont do levels
- Exceptions
- 1. Patients receiving vanco/aminoglycoside
combination - 2. Anephric patients undergoing dialysis
- 3. Patients with rapidly changing renal function
- 4. Patients receiving higher-than-usual doses
- Use a different antibiotic
23IV-to-po Switch
- Criteria
- Afebrile, WBC normalized
- Maybe the patient doesnt need any further
antibiotics in the first place - Intact GI tract, i.e. no N/V/D
- Oral bioavailability, e.g. quinolones
- Patient can often go home, on po AB,
- without further in-hospital observation
- Ramirez
et al. Arch Intern Med 2001 16184850
24IV removal 1 defense vs BSI
- Requirement for hospitalization
- intensity of care criterion
- Leave in place
- just in case
- what if?
25 Antibiotic Redundancy
- vs Anaerobes PCN/pcn-ase inhibitor (e.g. Zosyn,
Unasyn) or carbapenem (e.g. Primaxin) Flagyl - vs C. diff po Flagyl po vanco
- Etc.
26Promoting use of less costly alternativesCascade
reporting
27Cost IssuesTherapeutic Substitutions
- When the efficacy and safety profiles are
almost identical, use the less expensive
alternative - Quinolones
- Cephalosporins
- Cabapenems
- Echinocandins
28(No Transcript)
29Empiric broad-spectrum antibiotic Rx,then
streamline
- Empiric, i.e before the diagnosis is determined
- Must acknowledge the MDRO epidemic
- vs gpc, gnr, anaerobes, fungi
- Then, streamline (a.k.a. de-escalate) based on
CS
30When to Not Use in the First Place or When to
Discontinue Antibiotics Altogether?
- Asymptomatic UTI
- Viral URI
- Exacerbation of COPD?
- CHF, misdiagnosed as pneumonia
- CoNS bacteremia, when contamination more likely
than true infection - Duration? criteria to d/c
31Asymptomatic UTINicolle et al. Infectious
Diseases Society of America guidelines for the
diagnosis and treatment of asymptomatic
bacteriuria in adults. Clin Infect Dis
200540643-54
- Definition pyuria/bacteriuria, without Sx, with
normal temperature and WBC - Common
32Asymptomatic UTI
Nicolle et al. Clin Infect Dis 200540643-54
33Asymptomatic UTI
Boscia et al. JAMA 1987 2571067-71 Nordenstam
et al. NEJM 1986 3141152-6 Nicolle et al. NEJM
1983 369 1420-5 Ouslander et al. Ann Intern Med
1995122 749-54
34Mortality in patients with asymptomatic UTIs
treated with antimicrobial agents or placebo
Abrutyn, E. et. al. Ann Intern Med
1994120827-833
35- Practitioners do not feel comfortable ignoring
bacteriuria once they are aware of its presence. - Encourage physicians not to screen for
asymptomatic bacteriuria - U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. Screening
for asymptomatic bacteriuria in adults U.S.
Preventive Services reaffirmation recommendation
statement. Ann Intern Med 200814943-7
36- Increase adherence to non-treatment guidelines
- Gross, Patel. Reducing antibiotic overuse a
call for a national performance measure for not
treating asymptomatic bacteriuria. Clin Infect
Dis 2007451335-7
37Asymtomatic UTIIs it applicable to catheter-
associated bacteriuria?
- Yes
- Cope et al. Inappropriate Treatment of
Catheter-Associated Asymtomatic Bacteriuria in a
Tertiary Care Hospital. Clin Infect Dis.
2009481182-88 - Kunin. Editorial Commentary Catheter-Associated
UTIs A Syllogism Compounded by a Questionable
Dichotomy. - Ibid 1189-90
38Viral URI Review of Acute Rhinosinusitis.
JAMA. 2009301(17)1798-1807
- How do you know its viral and not bacterial?
- Physical exam non-specific
- Temperature
- WBC
- Prevailing attitude of physicians and patients
- Take an antibiotic, just in case what if
- Changing paradigm, because of
- MDROs
- Side effects
- C. diff
- Other
- Recommendation Withhold AB for the first 10
days
39Antibiotics for Treatment of Acute Maxillary
Sinusitis
JAMA 20082982487-96
40Cdc rx
41Cdc return to school letter
42- Materials order form
- http//www.cid.gov/ncidod/dbmd/antibiotic
resistance/educatio.htm
43Exacerbation of COPD?Van Der Valk et al. Clin
Inf Dis 200439 980-6
- How do you know if its bacterial?
- Tough question, not adequately answered in the
literature - Antibiotics not unreasonable.
- 5 days should suffice
44CHF, misdiagnosed as pneumonia
- How do you distinguish one from the other?
- HP, temperature, WBC, CXR, BNP, BioZ, cultures
(sputum and blood), pneumococcal urine antigen - The patient could have both
45Community-Acquired Pneumonia When to Begin
Antibiotics?
-
- The 2-4-6-8 hour rules
- IDSA/ATS Guidelines for CAP in Adults. Clin
Infect Dis 2007 44 S27-72. - CMS Specifications Manual For National Inpatient
Quality Measures
46Timing of antibiotics for CAPControversy
- Earlier better than later
- Intuitive
- Data
- Embraced by CMS
- IDSA/ATS response
- Rebuts the data
- Points out the negative consequences of
injudicious antibiotics - Present state of affairs
47-
- IDSA/ATS Guidelines
- A problem of internal consistency is also
present, because, in both studies 109, 264,
patients who received antibiotics in the first 2
h after presentation actually did worse than
those who received antibiotics 24 h after
presentation
48- For these and other
- reasons, the committee did not feel that a
specific time window - for delivery of the first antibiotic dose should
be recommended. - However, the committee does feel that therapy
should be administered as soon as possible after
the diagnosis is considered likely.
49- Conversely, a delay in antibiotic therapy has
adverse consequences in many infections. For
critically ill, hemodynamically unstable
patients, early antibiotic therapy should be
encouraged, although no prospective data support
this recommendation.
50- Delay in beginning antibiotic treatment during
the transition from the ED is not uncommon.
Especially with the frequent use of once-daily
antibiotics for CAP, timing and communication
issues may result in patients not receiving
antibiotics for 18 h after hospital admission.
The committee felt that the best and most
practical resolution to this issue was that the
initial dose be given in the ED.
51(No Transcript)
52- If antibiotics started,
- and patient doesnt have pneumonia
- discontinue them
- At once
- If continued, 5 days should suffice
- Dunbar et al. High-dose, short-course
levofloxacin for community-acquired pneumonia a
new treatment paradigm. Clin Infect Dis 2003
3775260. - Etc.
53VAP Duration of Rx
- Shorter than longer
- Chastre et al. Comparison of 8 vs 15 days of
- antibiotic therapy for ventilator-associated
- pneumonia in adults a randomized trial.
- JAMA 2003 290258898.
54CoNS bacteremia
- How do you know if its real or contamination?
- Real
- Hospitalized, IV (phlebitis), fever,
leukocytosis, multiple positive cultures - Contamination
- Present on admission/no IV, no fever, no
leukocytosis, few positive cultures/denominator -
55(No Transcript)
56Additional recommendations
- SCIP
- C.difficile
- Pneumonia
- CAP
- HAP
57Surgical Care Improvement Project (SCIP)
- Antibiotics for surgical prophylaxis (Bratzler
et al. Clin Infect Dis. 2004 Jun
1538(12)1706-15) - Which agent?
- Function of most common pathogen(s)
- Staph. aureus
- First generation cephalosporin
- If PCN-allergic
- If high prevalence of MRSA
- Anaerobes
- Cefoxitin
- When to start?
- 1 hour pre-op
- When to stop?
- 1 dose only
- Within 24 hours
58(No Transcript)
59(No Transcript)
60HAP
61Duration Criteria to d/c antibiotics
- By the numbers, e.g. 5, 7, 10, 14 days no!
- Empiric discontinuation, once temperature and WBC
have normalized - Notable exceptions
- Endocarditis
- Osteomyelitis
- Community-acquired pneumonia 5 days
- Healthcare-acquired pneumonia abbreviate
- Uncomplicated UTI 3 days
- Clin Infect Dis 19992974558
62(No Transcript)
63Physician/administration approval and
notification
- Medical Executive Committee
- Physician champion
- Physicians
64Sample letter to physicians
- Dear Colleague,
- In an attempt to confront the MDRO
(multi-drug resistant organism, e.g. MRSA) and C.
difficile epidemics, our Hospital is initiating
an Antibiotic Stewardship Program. Our goal is
to promote judicious antibiotic use.
Implementation will be through review of patients
on antibiotics, then physician notification to
consider Rx modifications. This has been
approved by the Medical Executive Committee.
65Physician Response
- Bell-shaped curve
- Dr. D
- Dr. S
- Dr. C
- Dr. O
- Antibiotics viewed as drugs of fear
- Fear of omission
- Law suits
- Fear of commission
- Law suits
66(No Transcript)
67Outcomes Measure Interventions
- patients reviewed
- interventions recommended
- Divided by patients of reviewed
- interventions accomplished
- Divided by recommended
- Change to avoid allergic reaction
- Drug-drug interactions addressed
- Change to different antibiotic based on CS
- Change dose
- IV-to-po switch
- Redundancy addressed
- Antibiotics discontinued altogether
68Outcomes Measure Interventions
- patients reviewed 500
- interventions recommended 45
- Divided by patients of reviewed 9
- interventions accomplished 38
- Divided by recommended 84
- Change to avoid allergic reaction 0
- Drug-drug interactions addressed 0
- Change to different antibiotic based on CS 8
- Change dose 0
- IV-to-po switch 24
- Redundancy addressed 0
- Antibiotics discontinued altogether 68
69OutcomesRates
- C. difficile
- MDRO
- MRSA
- VRE
- GNR
- ESBL
- CRE
70OutcomesNegative Consequences
- Keep a close eye out for any patient who suffers
because of an antibiotic stewardship
intervention, viz. - relapse of infection
- from antibiotic deficiency
-
71Reporting the Outcomes
- Hospital
- PT Committee
- Infection Control Committee
- Medical Executive Committee
- MRSA Collaborative
- Federal Agencies
- JCAHO
- CMS
- Public relations
- Local newspaper
72Cost Implications
- Its the right thing to do, regardless of cost
issues - Antibiotic costs savings predicted/proven
- Administration happy
- Personnel needs to be recognized/compensated
- Pharmacist
- ID or other MD oversight
- Self-perpetuating
73Results of an Antibiotic Intervention Program in
a University-Affiliated Teaching Hospital
Ruttimann al. Clin Infect Dis 2004 38348-56.
742008 Antibiotic Cost Per MonthMidwest Regional
Medical Center
75BREAK
76Vignettes
- Asymptomatic UTI
- Viral URI
- Exacerbation of COPD
- Pneumonia vs CHF
- Immunocompromised host with fever
- Antibiotic duration
- C. difficile
- SCIP
77Asymtomatic UTI
- An 83 yo woman suffers from dementia and resides
in a nursing home. The NH staff is concerned
about her increased confusion and decides to send
her to the local ER. VS BP 140/90, P 90, RR
16, T 98.6. PE WNL except for mild confusion.
No Foley. WBC 10.1. U/A 5-10 WBC/hpf. Dx
UTI. Rx Avelox. The following day her urine
culture returns with E.coli, gt100K. Avelox is
continued x 1 wk. She becomes more confused.
And she develops C.diff antibiotic-associated
colitis -
78- Comments
- On occasion, sepsis can present with normal or
low temperature and WBC, and with confusion
However, she wasnt septic based on the normal BP
and P - An asymptomatic UTI does not need Rx.
- Avelox is not indicated for UTI.
- Quinolones can cause CNS problems
- All antibiotics can cause C.diff AAC.
- The elderly and NH residents are predisposed
79Antibiotic StewardshipAsymptomatic bacteriuria
- This patient appears to have asymptomatic
bacteriuria which does not merit antibiotic Rx. - Infectious Diseases Society of America
Guidelines for the Diagnosis and Treatment of
Asymptomatic Bacteriuria in Adults Clin Infect
Dis 2005 40 64354
80Viral URI
- A 72 yo diabetic man developed nasal congestion
and cough productive of purulent sputum. He went
to his local ER where the evaluation was
noteworthy for a temperature of 99.6, normal
respirations, mild tenderness to palpation and
percussion over his sinuses, clear lungs, a WBC
of 7.8 with 6 eosinophils and CXR showing
chronic scarring. His blood sugar was 311. He
was admitted. After a sputum was obtained for
CS, he was started on Rocephin and Zithromax for
possible community-acquired pneumonia. The
sputum had gt25 epithelial cells and was rejected.
The symptoms persisted for another 3 days.
Levaquin was added. He developed C.diff
antibiotic-associated colitis, his fifth episode.
81 - Comments
- Great respect and extra attention must be given
to immunocompromised hosts, e.g. diabetics. - Yet even immunocompromised hosts can catch
otherwise benign, self-limiting viral URIs for
which antibiotics are not indicated. - 99.6 isnt fever
- A reasonable clinical approach would be to d/c
antibiotics and follow clinically, re-thinking
their indication if the patient develops symptoms
of a bacterial superinfection, e.g. fever.
82Antibiotic StewardshipViral URI
- This patient appears to have a viral URI which
does not merit antibiotic Rx - Review of Acute Rhinosinusitis. JAMA.
2009301(17)1798-1807
83Exacerbation of COPD
- Its February, and a 60 yo smoker with COPD
developed worsening of his chronic cough and SOB.
His sputum has become more copious, thicker,
discolored and foul-smelling, and he has noted a
fleck of blood. He has not had any chills or
fever. On physical exam, he is receiving O2
through nasal prongs. His respiratory rate is
24/min and slightly labored. His temperature is
99.1, BP 95/70, pulse 120. His breath sounds are
distant and there are scattered ronchi and
wheezes. The WBC is 11.1. A CXR shows emphysema
and a faint haze at the bases interpreted as
cannot rule out pneumonia.
84- Although influenza and RSV has been reported
in the community, rapid tests for influenza AB
and RSV are negative.There are many PMNs and
mixed flora on the sputum gram stain. It
ultimately grows H. influenza and the
pneumococcus (PCN MIC 1.0). He is admitted to
hospital and is treated with Cipro. -
85- Comments
- Since its respiratory virus season, this is a
good bet. - Rapid tests have variable sensitivity. Go with
the epidemiology - Give an anti-influenza agent, ASAP
- While the H.flu and pneumococcus could represent
otherwise benign colonization, either could be
playing a pathogenic role. - And colonization is the first step to infection,
so why wait? - Hes too fragile to risk withholding antibiotics.
- Use a respiratory quinolone, i.e. not cipro-, but
rather levo- or moxi- - Make sure he has received influenza and
pneumococcal vaccines -
86Antibiotic StewardshipCOPD exacerbation
- Recommendations
- Tamiflu
- Change from Cipro to Levaquin
87Pneumonia vs CHF
- A 90 yo with a h/o CHF has become more short of
breath over the past few days. There have been
no fevers or chills. On physical exam the
temperature is 97, RR 24, BP 160/100 and pulse
80. Bibasilar rales are noted on auscultation.
Theres a cardiac gallop. The CXR shows
cardiomegaly and pulmonary congestion consistent
with CHF, cannot rule out early pneumonia. The
BNP is 1567. BioZ says CHF. He receives Lasix
and improves. Rocephin and Zithromax were also
started in the ER, for possible pneumonia.
88- Comments
- CHF seems readily apparent.
- While pneumonia isnt entirely impossibleand he
could have boththe potential side-effect of
antibiotics dont seem worth the risk in this
case. - Blame the ER for having started them
- ER
- Hospitals front door, EMTALA
- Dx often uncertain
- ABs used liberally
- ABs can/should be d/cd promptly, once ID unlikely
89Antibiotic Stewardship Pneumonia vs CHF
- Recommendation CHF is apparent, and
pneumonia seems unlikely, so consider d/c
antibiotics.
90Immunocompromised Patient with Fever
- A 45 yo woman has fever complicating her
metastatic breast cancer and its chemotherapy.
She presents with chills and shortness of breath.
Her temperature is 105, RR 32, BP 90/70, pulse
130. Her lungs are clear. The WBC is 0.3.
There are bilateral infiltrates on the CXR. She
is started on Fortaz, Vancomycin, Zithromax,
Diflucan and Zovirax.
91- Comments Too complex to intervene.
92Antibiotic Duration?
- A 92 yo nursing home resident (where C. diff has
been epidemic) is transferred to the hospital for
decreased mentation and poor intake. Her BMs are
normal. On admission her temperature is 101 and
the physical exam non-diagnostic. She has a 16K
WBC and her creatinine is 3.1. There are 5-10
WBC in the U/A and the CXR reads cannot R/O
pneumonia. She is treated empirically with
Rocephin, Levaquin and vancomycin. Cultures of
urine and blood remain negative. There is no
diarrhea to suspect C. diff. A repeat CXR shows
no change. She promptly defervesces and her
WBC has normalized when repeated at 48 hours.
93- Comments
- The diagnosis is uncertain presumably
infected, but source (i.e. site and pathogen)
not defined. - Whether she improved from the empiric antibiotics
or not is also uncertain. - Pneumonia the CXR often remains abnormal
several weeks after the clinical syndrome has
resolved - Injudicious to continue ABs until CXR resolution
- She is at considerable risk for C. diff and other
AB-associated problems. - So it wouldnt be unreasonable to d/c
antibiotics.
94Antibiotic StewardshipAntibiotic Duration
- Recommendation Consider d/cing antibiotics,
as the temperature and WBC have normalized.
95C. difficile
- An 85 yo WF is admitted from the NH with C.
difficile. Her temperature is 102 and her WBC
is 65,000. She receives Vanco IV and po, Flagyl
I V and po, Immodium, probiotics and Rocephin.
96- Comments Refer to the C. diff guidelines
- Continue po Flagyl
- d/c other antibiotics
- d/c Immodium
97SCIP
- An 85 yo WM is admitted to the hospital for a hip
fracture. He undergoes ORIF and receives
peri-operative antibiotics. These are continued
indefinitely. His wound is clean and he has a
normal temperature and WBC.
98- Comments Refer to SCIP guidelines
- Recommend d/c antibiotics post-op
99(No Transcript)
100Antibiotic StewardshipSummary/Implementation
- Decide if you want to do it.
- Decide whos going to do it.
- Must have a PHYSICIAN CHAMPION
- Seek approval from the Medical Executive
Committee. - Decide upon form of communication phone call
vs notation in chart. - Send an introductory/explanatory letter to the
Medical Staff. - Do it.
- Measure the results.
- Present and discuss results.
- Review and improve.
101(No Transcript)
102(No Transcript)
103Questions/Discussion