Title: 1. dia
1Need for Liberalization in legal Legislation
The Focus on Money Market Funds (MMFs)
UAIB Conference June 18 - 21, 2009, Yalta Sándor
Szalai Deputy CEO regional operation OTP Fund
Management Ltd.
2Motto
Without differences im opinions there would not
be even horse race
Mark Twain Pudding Headed Wilson
3Nature of the current crises Is it severe?
Breakdown of crises by their nature from 1970 to
date
Credit crises
10
1
3
4
31
18
9
Real estate bubble based
Equity bubble based
Others 46
The current crises is the 5th from the last 132
where all the 3 dimensions as reasons are present
Notes 122 recession on OECD since 1970Source
IMF working paper What happens during
recessions, crunches and busts, December 2008
4Was the impact on equity markets serious also in
historical comparison?
2008 was the second worst year in the last 183
years
Source Bloomberg, OTP Fund Management Ltd.
5And how much the financial industry was hit?
6Start-up statements and thoughts
- One of the most serious crises in capital
markets history with severe real economy
effects - Heavy impact on all the higher risk capital
market segments and asset classes like equities - Banking industry is especially under fire lack
of liquidity, expensive funding, worsening
profitability and many bad performing, capital
market related productv
???
- Shaking confidence of clients in financial
institutions and products - Sharply increasing risk aversion, turning towards
cash as safe heaven - Pressure on supervision authorities and on
codifiers for restriction and more transparency
???
Liberalization of capital market related products
is reasonable at these times at all?
???
It depends Have a look at a certain practical
problem in our region
7What happened on CEE equity markets in 2008?
deep fall
- The crisis pushed CEE local equity markets into
heavy sell-off in 2008 - Size of fall exceeded decrease of developed
markets (SP500-DAX-NIKKEI -38-42 Hang
Seng-India -49-52), mainly driven by
significant jump in risk premiums - New EU members Croatia clearly underperfomed to
CETOP20 markets lower liquidity, higher
valuation
8 and serious decreases in fund market sizes
Data source EFAMA, Bamosz
- Former EU accessors with larger market size
suffered less, except for the Poland as the
largest - Group of new EU members and Croatia lost 2/3 if
their total market, except for Romania as the
best performer
9Critical points strong preference of local
equity investments
Data source EFAMA, Bamosz
- Croatia-Bulgaria-Poland correlation between high
proportion of equity funds and the deep fall of
fund market sizes - Romania as exception high ratio of
institutionals, seed money, money market funds
saving collection - Czech Republic and Hungary law risky fund
exposure moderate decline in fund market sizes
10And how it was going on in Ukraine?
- Mutual funds money market related investment
limits till January, 2009
- Up to 30 of the prevailing NAV in cash and cash
equivalents, and gold
???
- Due to unsufficient availability of bonds and
restrictions on any foreign assets, derivatives
and alternative assets local equities became
obligatory elements of local funds investments - As a result of it there was no safe heaven
alternative fund vehicles available when the
crises came - Crises caused dramatic losses at almost all the
running mutual funds
???
- Market of local mutual securities funds was hit
at its infant stage of development - Investors initial confidence broken
11Which solution was missing? - money market funds
for sure
- Key characteristics of EU/CEE MMF tools
- Mutual fund, usually as UCITS (stricter
diversifications limits 5/10/40 as general
20 for deposits) - Investments mainly in deposits, different bonds
with shorter maturity, repo transactions - As a result of it low volatility with moderate
expected return (close to term deposits
performance) - Low cost vehicles moderate or zero distribution
fees, low additional fees - Short settlement period (usually T1/2 days or
even T0), low face value of investment
- Reasons why MMFs segment is not develop in many
of the CEE countries ?
- Early (infant) stage of development on mutual
fund markets Bulgaria, Romania, Ukraine - Low risk moderate performance attribution no
serios attractivity compared to equities - Legal environment led the market towards higher
risk investments Poland, Ukraine - Temporarily overperforming local equity markets
attracted savings Bulgaria, Ukraine, Poland,
Croatia - High central depositary fees ruined the
preformance of MMFs Bulgaria - Concrete legal restrictions in investment limits
Ukraine
12What do we love MMFs? ?
- Why are MMFs benefitial solutions for our
customers? Because they
- provide easily understandable and usable
investment solution for the households everyday
savings - are optimal also for corporates liquidity
management - are low risk investments and thus, well adjusted
to CEEs financial culture - can serve as proper start-up education tools for
mutual fund investments - provide good safe heaven type investment
opportunities when riskier asset classes are
falling
- Are MMFs benefitial also from the banking system
point of view?
- In case of consequent legal legislation and
related riskliquidity management MMFs are safe
solutions without serious reputation risk when
offered, even in case of critical market
conditions - Benefitial supplementary element of the product
offering good for client retention and
acquisition - Funding tools for banks fund collection at
reasonable price - Direct revenue through management fee income
13International experiences MMFs in Europe
Fund categories on the UCITS fund market -
2003-2008
Market share of MMF from the total fund market
2008Q4
Figures contain only UCITS fund related numbers
Source EFAMA report
- Equity Funds significant decrease of AUM during
the crisis net cash outflow revaluation - MMFs clear safe heaven function - attracting
flows from other funds, mainly from equity funds - MMFs as basic saving instrument its market share
is ususally 30-50 on the total mutual fund
market - MMF as the only fund type which could generate
net cash inflowsin 2008, supported by positive
yields
14Domestic experiences MMFs in Hungary
Development of mutual funds in Hungary 1997-2008
Share of cash vs. Securities type investments in
households savings in Hungary
24
50
76
50
Source Hungarian National Bank
Source Association of Hungarian Investment Fund
and Asset Management Companies
- Clear process of securitisation within households
savings, compared to 1995 weight of weight of
securities type investments increased from 24 to
50 stabil weight even in critical years (2003,
2008) - Increasing diversification on fund market in
terms of fund types widening sortiment of higher
risk solutions, however, MMFs became the leading
instrument and remained stable even in critical
years - Structured guaranteed funds became popular,
thanks to their limited risk higher potencial
yield attribution
15In-house experiences fund assets
diversification within OTP Bank Plc.
- 31.12.2004.
- Moderate width of product range
- No previous regular training of sales staff for
diversifiaction and fund portfolio concept - Very high concentration of assets in one single
fund type (short) bond funds - Law awerness level both on sales and buy side
regarding product knowledge - High risk of non-diversified product portfolio
both on OTP and client side
Breakdown of fund classes by clientele types
- 30.04.2009
- Very intensive product development, extension in
product offering - Launch of HUF mone market product (pure deposit
fund) January 2005 - MMF takes over the role of base product
- Thanks to conscious product development and
education clear move ahead of equity and capital
protected funds
Source OTP Bank DataWarehouse
16OTP MMF becoming key instrument without
cannibalization
Start of crisis
Capital gain tax introduction
EUR mn
- Sept. 2005 to date steady growth of MMF while
deposit volumen remains stable - no serious
cannibalization - August 2006 introduction of capital gain tax
resulted in immediate inflow into products with
fixed interest, with longer maturity OTP bonds
and mortgage bonds - October 2008 significant demand for products
with fixed interest rate and increased deposit
guarantee term deposits, OTP bonds, mortgage
bonds paralell withrawals from OTP MMF
17Close to term deposit performance with daily
liquidity
- OTP MMF 3M p.a. past yield was close to but 1-2
below the best prevailing retail deposit offer of
OTP Bank Plc. - Difference between peformances of the 2 key
instruments can be considered as price of
liquidity - Investors are tend to pay this price as they are
compensated through the daily liquidity
18Development of OTP MMF penetration in retail
clientele
Source OTP Bank DataWarehouse
- Around 330 000 active retail clients with
securities account in OTP Bank Plc. ca. 10 of
total clientele - 120 000 clients have MMF ca. every 25th retail
client has MMF within OTP Bank Plc. - The numbers of clients having OTP Bonds and
Mortgage Bonds is also constantly growing as a
clear result in strengthening risk aversion due
to the credit crises and related capital market
impacts
19Conclusions We need
- to do efforst and bring new innovations
- to think of opportunities for modernization and
adjustment of legal legislation - to educate ourselves, our sales staff and our
clients permanently and - to intoduce new ideas and products through simple
ans easy understandable basic solutions
in order to avoid
20these kind of situations
21Thank you for your attention!