Title: Your brain evolved to decide:
1Your brain evolved to decide
2Progress in Alzheimers Disease
- Greg M Cole, Prof. Medicine and Neurology, UCLA
- ASSOC. DIRECTOR, GRECC, Greater LA VAMC
- ASSOC. DIRECTOR, Alzheimers Disease Research
Center, UCLA
Aristotle taught that the brain exists merely to
cool the blood and is not involved in the
process of thinking. This is true only of certain
persons. - Will Cuppy
3What is Alzheimer's Disease?
Alzheimer's disease is a progressive,
degenerative disease that attacks the brain and
results in impaired memory, thinking, and
behavior. It affects an estimated 4 million
American adults today . Extracellular Amyloid
Plaques and intracellular tangles, NEURON AND
SYNAPSE LOSS.
4"Is Your Brain Really Necessary? R. Lewin
Science 2101232, Dec 1980
- Although the boy had an IQ of 126 and had a first
class honours degree in mathematics, he had
"virtually no brain". A CAT scan showed a thin
layer of brain cells to a millimeter in
thickness, the rest was cerebrospinal fluid. The
young man continues a normal life with the
exception of his knowledge that he has no brain - "I can't say whether the mathematics student has
a brain weighing 50 grams or 150 grams, but it is
clear that it is nowhere near the normal 1.5
kilograms." Dr J. Lorber, Neurologist
51995-Neuron loss the cause of dementia?
Born with 100 Billion Neurons Living/Learning/Tra
ining/Studying---Neurons form Networks
Neurons loss causes network deficiency leading to
memory loss , other cognitive deficits and
behavior changes.
6Neuron replacement? Where do you get spare
parts? Get Rael or Stem Cell Initiative ?
7NEURONS CONNECTIONS SYNAPSES
- NEUROTRANSMITTERS TRANSDUCE THE ELECTRICAL SIGNAL
FROM THE PRESYNAPTIC NEURON (AXONAL) ACROSS THE
GAP TO RECEPTORS ON THE POST-SYNAPTIC
(SOMATO-DENDRITIC )SIDE OF THE NEXT NEURON AT
SYNAPSES - EXAMPLES OF NEUROTRANSMITTERS ACETYLCHOLINE,
DOPAMINE, NOREPINEPHRINE, SEROTONIN, GLUTAMATE
LOST
8- MR, AD and APP Tg mice have dendritic spine
defects - Dendritic spine formation and loss requires
regulated actin assembly and disassembly which is
central to synaptic changes during learning
(plasticity)
Multiple Mental Retardation syndromes and AD
overlap with dendritic spine defects and
cognitive deficits. Downs syndrome epitomizes
this overlap, spine defects
9Dendritic Arbor, Spine Synapse loss
MOOLMAN, SHELANSKI-04
10Where we were 10 years ago
- Disease caused by neuron loss
- Two camps amyloid fibril toxicity and tangles
- No accepted animal models
- Difficulty in diagnosis of AD until autopsy
- confirmation.
- Cholinesterase inhibitor treatments
- Very few clinical trials directed at the causes
of underlying disease
11Current FDA-approved therapies employ
cholinesterase inhibitors which treat the loss
of cholinergic neurotransmitter activity but
have little affect on causes of underlying
disease leading to synapse and neuron loss
- Donepezil (Aricept)
- 5 mg gradually increasing to 10 mg qd ( half-life
70 h, hepatic metabolism) - Galantamine (Reminyl)
- 4 mg bid increasing to 12 mg bid, half-life 6 h,
hepatic metabolism
- Rivastigmine (Exelon)
- 1.5 mg bid increasing to 6 mg bid half-life 2h
(8 h in brain), non hepatic metabolism
12 Mutations Implicate Abeta
13Genetics of Alzheimers Disease
Genetic Cases
Late Onset (gt90)
Early Onset (lt10)
Unknown Mutations
Chr12 ? Locus
Chr1 PS2
Chr19 APOE
Chr21 A?PP
Chr14 PS1
20
Up to 60
lt5
15-60
75
70 of AD cases unexplained, likely polygenic and
will require risk assessment chip
14SEARCH FOR WMDTaoists believe in tau protein
-Tangles ßaptists believe in ß-amyloid Protein
Plaques
- or Invisible Aß oligomer toxins in the middle?
15Insoluble Toxic Deposit
Amyloid Protein Folding and Self Aggregation
Soluble, NonToxic
Monomer
Dimer
Trimer
Oligmer/Protofilbril
Amyloid filbril
16Aß Oligomers
(Courtesy Dr. Jeffery Cummings, UCLA)
17(No Transcript)
18Pathogenesis Of AD Amyloidosis
Secretion
Aggregation
Fibrillogenesis
B
Microglial Cell
Neuron
F
D
A
I
N
H
C
E
G
Reactive Astrocyte
Clearance
Clearance
Clearance
19Transgenic Tests for Risk Factors- 1Tg 2576
(Hsiao) Mice Transgenic for human Amyloid
Precursor with AD mutation lots of amyloid but
little or no synapse or neuron loss
20(No Transcript)
21Candidate Risk Factors for AD Yellow -tested in
APP Tg mice
- Increase risk
- Aging
- ApoE E4
- Head injury
- Inflammation-CRP
- High cholesterol,low HDL
- High fat diet/Type II diabetes
- Low fish/DHA
- High blood pressure
- High homocysteine
- Low exercise?
- NOSE PICKIING??
- Decrease risk
- Die young
- ApoE E2
- Education enriched environ
- NSAIDs-ibuprofen, flurizan
- Statins
- High Fish/DHA
- ? Red wine modest alcohol
- Fruits Veggies- blueberries
- Vit E/VitC
- Folate?
- Exercise? enriched environ
2223 studies show NSAIDs reduce AD risk-McGeer
meta-analysis
23Effect of ibuprofen in TG mouse modelLim et
al., 2000, J. Neuroscience. 20579814
- Chronic (10-16 mo) ibuprofen reduced
- plaque burden and Aß levels 40-50
- Interleukin 1ß levels
- Microgliosis
- Astrocytosis
- Neuritic plaques
- Caspase activation per plaque
24Evidence that NSAIDs directly effect g-secretase
and Aß42
- No involvement of multiple other NSAID targets
COX NFkB lipoxygenases peroxisome
proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR) signaling - Weggen Nature 2001 JBC 2003, Morihara J Neurochem
2002, - Sagi JBC 2003, Eriksen JCI 2003
- Aß42 reduction was preserved in cell-free systems
- -Takahashi,Tomita, Iwatsubo et al JBC 2003,
- Sagi JBC 2003, Eriksen JCI 2003
- PS-1 mutations APPmut around g-sec site (V717)
influence efficiency of Aß42 suppression by
NSAIDs - Weggen JBC 2003
25Problems with NSAID Approach
- Dosing? Are chronic high doses needed?
- Chronic NSAIDs have GI CVD toxicity issues
- NSAID primary prevention trial with COX-2
inhibitor and naproxen-Breitner - Dec 2004, Trial stopped due to questions about
chronic safety and CVD with Vioxx, Celebrex,
naproxen etc - Alternative R-enantiomers (R-flurbi in trials )
- ALTERNATIVE NSAIDs?
- What about diet?
26Myriad R-flurbiprofen (flurizan) phase II trial--
800 mg BID, 48 patientsG. Wilcock (Bristol)
27(No Transcript)
28Mc D DAY- McDonalds Invades Japan
29DHA (C226, n-3) and brain
- Essential fatty acids-
- linoleic acid (182 n-6 gtgtgtarachidonic (ARA, n-6
series) - Linolenic acid (183 n-3) gtgtgtdocosahexanoic acid
(DHA, n-3) - n-6 pro-inflammatory, n-3 are anti-inflammatory
- Ratio of n-6/n-3 is optimal near 41.
- DHA ( fish, algae) is crucial in brain/retina
development and CNS maintenance in adults - DHA is very high in brain (31 of FA in PE in
cortex) - Six double bonds make it most susceptible to
oxidative attack.
30Mouse chow has abundant DHA, C226, n-3) (from
fish).
- Fish and DHA intake reduce AD risk, (Kalmijn,
Grant, Kyle, Morris and others) - Low n-6/n-3 PUFA ratio diets have less risk of AD
with an optimum protection from 41 ratio - DHA or derivatives like neuroprotectins are
neuroprotective in multiple systems - NIH-31 based chow has an 41 n-6/n-3 ratio . Is
the diet protective?
31 BAD Diet depleted of DHA(w3)
- Tg2576 and Tg- Mice aged to 17 months on
standard (Purina 5015 ) breeder chow diet
(w-6/w-371) - From 17 to 22.5 months, groups placed on 3
different diets - 1. Standard diet (w-6/w-3 71)-soy
- 2. BAD diet ( w-6/w-3 851)- safflower
- 3. BAD diet DHA (w-6/w-3 81).
32APP Transgenics on DHA depleting Bad diet -
Calon et al Neuron Sept 2004
- Major loss of dendritic spine protein, drebrin,
PSD-95 PI3-K p85 in model AD - Increased oxidative damage and focal postsynaptic
caspase activation , but no neuron loss. - Increased cognitive deficits
- CaMKIIa, but not NR2B loss restored by DHA -in
press, Calon et al 2005 EJN
33(No Transcript)
34DHA lowers plaque burden
Low DHA
High DHA
35DHA treatment causes reduction in insoluble Ab42
and Ab40 levels of APPSw mice-
Insoluble Ab42
Insoluble Ab40
36DHA protects against diet-induced increase of
oxidative damage
Carbonyls
Tg
40 30 20 10 0
Optical density
p lt 0.001 vs. Standard diet p lt 0.01
vs. Low DHA diet
37TG mice (but not Tg- mice) had significant CNS
DHA depletion. Consistent with increased
oxidative damage in Tg2576.
38Diet X Tg Interaction
39DHA Inhibits GSK3ß a major tau kinase in Ent
Cortex
- GSK3ß (tau kinase 1)
- can
- Mediate Aß toxicity
- Cause apoptosis
- Drive tangles
- GSK3a can
- regulate g-secretase
GSK inhibitory ser9 phosphorylation is increased
by DHA in vivo.
40(No Transcript)
41Vit E (10-16 mos) failed to protect
Oxidative damage (carbonyls)
Insoluble amyloid
And Vit E failed to protect against
- Atherosclerosis, lung cancer
- Lipoprotein oxidation in AD CSF
- Transition from MCI to AD
42(No Transcript)
43 What is Curcumin?
A group of polyphenolic plant pigments,
responsible for currys yellow color.
- Extracted from the roots of Curcuma Longa plant
- Ground into a powder used in Asian cuisine
- Marketed OTC as a mixture of three related
compounds - curcumin, (being the most active)
- demethoxycurcumin
- bisdemethoxycurcumin
- collectively termed "curcuminoids"
Roots
Powder
Wild Flower
44Incidence of Dementia in India Compared to the US
Incidence Per 1000 Person- Years
(Chandra et al, Neurology 2001 57 985-989)
45Curcumin from Turmeric .
- diferulomethane, M.W. 368.4
- Cancer chemoprevention, Phase II inducer
- Antioxidant (OH, O2-, NO), inhibits brain lipid
peroxidation 5-10x better than vit E - Anti-inflammatory ( inhibits induction of iNOS,
Cox-2, cytokines etc) - Lowers total cholesterol, raises HDL
- Metal (iron) chelator
- Favorable toxicity profile (animals/people)
- Life extension in mice
46Curcumin resembles known amyloid and oligomer
inhibitors
- Curc inhibits prion assembly-B Caughey
- Curc inhibits fibril assembly
- Curc inhibits oligomer assembly
- Other aggregates in neurodegenerative diseases???
47Curcumin inhibits Aß aggregation in vitro- Yang
et al JBC 2004
48In brain sections, Curcumin (left) labels amyloid
plaques just like thioflavin (right)
curcumin
Thioflavin S
49Curcumin in diet (B) or injected iv (C,D) labels
CNS plaques in vivo demonstrating brain
penetration and avidity for amyloid
50Curcumin prevented fibril formation,
disassociated pre-formed fibrils (In vitro- Ono
et al. 2004 (IC50lt 1µM)) , and reduced plaques
51In vitro, with rat microglia on AD sections,
Curcumin increases µglia in high plaque but not
low plaque areas compared to vehicle-treated
adjacent sections
52Curcumin stimulates murine microglial
phagocytosis of plaques in human AD sections
53Curcumin reduces total Aß (by ELISA) from human
AD sections incubated with murine microglia
54Curcumin induces amyloid phagocytosis in vivo?
- RED -Aß
- GREEN -microglia
- Yellow overlap
- 6 mos curcumin in APPsw mice
55Some NSAIDS reduce amyloid
56(No Transcript)
57Curcumin Inhibition of Oligomer Formation as
Compared with CR
- 22 mer
- 11 mer
- 5 mer
- 4 mer
- 1 mer
- 1 mer
Oligomer -
-
Monomer
58Curcumin (NSAID/AO) reduces drebrin
postsynaptic marker loss
59(No Transcript)
60Pilot Curcumin Clinical TrialJ. Ringman J.
Cummings (UCLA Alzheimer Center)
- 40 patients with 0, 2000 and 4000 mg
- before and after 6 months drug examining CSF
biomarkers (oxidative damage, inflammation, tau,
amyloid ) cholesterol - PET imaging of amyloid and energy metabolism
- Cognitive function out to 12 months.
61Conclusions
- NSAIDS like ibuprofen reduce amyloid pathogenesis
and AD risk, but may have safety issues with
chronic high dose use - The curry spice curcumin is a safe and intriguing
alternative polyphenolic antioxidant/ NSAID with
multiple anti-amyloid activities - The omega 3 fatty acid DHA reduces AD risk,
effectively limits AD pathogenesis and has an
outstanding safety profile
62Developing Tools for Early Detection of
Alzheimers Disease
Amyloid and Tau Imaging
SS
FDG-PET
Cognitive Stress Test
5-HT1A
Genetic Risk
Onset
Current Clinical Approach
Cognitive Function
Silent Period
Early stage
AD
Time
63Cerebral Metabolism in Alzheimers Disease
Progression and in Normal Brains-an index of
synaptic activity?
Normal
Early Alzheimer's
Late Alzheimer's
infant
64AD Tangles/Plaques, Metabolism and 5-HT1A
Receptors
65(No Transcript)
66PET -F-18FDDNP Logan plot parametric images
- In vivo (Barrio, Kepe, Small)
wild-type control rat
AD Tg rat
67K. Hsiao Ashe, Science 2005
Images courtesy of Karen H. Ashe, University of
Minnesota
68FDDNP In vivo Labeling of Tau Aggregates in Tau
TG
Collaboration with Karen Ashe, U.Minn
69(No Transcript)
70Where we are today
- Better diagnosis through imaging and much better
imaging at research tool stage - Multiple valuable animal models
- Some treatments with limited efficacy
- Suggestive positive trials that appear to slow
progression (Vaccine, aggregation inhibitor,
Flurizan,) - More than 53 Clinical Trials to find out the ways
to treat or prevent AD, most based on amyloid
hypothesis.
71Conclusion Control Risk Factors for Dementia to
Prevent
- Increase risk
- Low exercise
- High cholesterol,low HDL
- Type II diabetes
- High saturated fat
- Inflammation-CRP
- Low fish/DHA
- High blood pressure
- High homocysteine
- Protection
- Exercise (walk gt2 miles/day)
- Statins-Lipitor trial positive
- folate
- High Fish/DHA, low sat fat
- Vit E/Vit C ibuprofen
- Curcumin
- polyphenolsHigh Fruits Veggies, Juices
- ? Red wine modest alcohol
72In the next 10 yrs
- Early (pre-MCI) diagnosis combining imaging with
better probes and blood tests - Effective prevention strategies, but no proof
- Anti-amyloid therapeutics will slow progression
- Attempts at stem cell therapy to treat?
- Successful tau therapies in new animal models
- Clinical trials with anti-tau therapies will
improve cognitive function - Combination therapy to restore dendritic spines
and synaptic function of remaining neurons will
be a remarkably effective treatment?
73Where we are going IF NOTHING IS DONE- Expect 14
Million US Cases
High
Median
Millions
Low
Year
74Whole World Dementing?
- The world's population is ageing.
- 18 million people in the world with
dementia. - 66 of people with dementia live in developing
- countries.
- Dementia numbers will increase, especially in
rapidly - developing and heavily populated regions
such - as China, India and Latin America
- EXPECT DOUBLING AND DOUBLING AGAIN
75Salmon for dinner
76UCLA, Sepulveda VA Medical Center Alzheimers
Disease Research Laboratory, 2002
77Lab Collaborators
Collaborators Sally Frautschy K. Hsiao Ashe A.
Triller B. Teter N. Salem T. Montine
Lab Takashi Morihara MD, PhD Sheldon Ball,
MD,PhD
Frederic Calon, PhD Giselle Lim, PhD Lixia Zhao,
PhD Fusheng Yang, MD Oliver Ubeda P.P.
Chen Walter Beech Jonathan Yao
Support NIH, Alz Assoc, VA, Siegel Life
Project