Policing: Ideals v' Realities

1
PolicingIdeals v. Realities

• Dr. Matt Robinson
• CJ 4535
• Injustice in America
• Appalachian State University

2
Basics of American policing

• The allocation of police officers to various
  government levels will have effects on what
  police do
• Policing at different levels of government is
  focused on different forms of behavior (p. 144).
• MOST police agencies and officers are at local
  level of government!

3
(No Transcript)
4
(No Transcript)
5
Basics of American policing

• Since most police work for local level of
  government
• The focus of the typical cop in the United
  States is on street crimes
• Not on white-collar or corporate crimes!

6

• Less than 5 of police officers are focused on
  white-collar or corporate crimes!

7
Ideals of police behavior

• Police officers are expect to serve FIVE basic
  roles (see p. 147)
• 1) Enforce the law
• 2) Preserve the peace
• 3) Prevent crime
• 4) Provide services
• 5) Uphold rights
• Of these five roles, the typical police officer
  spends most of his time each day not fighting
  crime (p. 147)

8
Ideals of police behavior

• Police still serve crime victims in numerous ways
  (see pp. 149-150)
• Because most policing is incident-driven instead
  of problem-oriented
• This is why police have so little effect on the
  crime rate! (see p. 150)

9
Ideals of police behavior

• Police are expected to behave in a certain way
• according to the Law Enforcement Code of Conduct
  (see pp. 153-155)
• Some key words from document?
• Compare key words from document with this!

10

• Anyone know who this is???
• Does he look like a threat???

11
A Real-World Challenge to the Ideals

• Robert Davis, 64 year old retired elementary
  school teacher
• Beaten by 3 New Orleans police officers and 2
  federal officers
• Charged with disorderly conduct, being
  intoxicated in public, and assaulting an officer!

12
(No Transcript)
13
(No Transcript)
14
(No Transcript)
15
(No Transcript)
16
(No Transcript)
17
(No Transcript)
18
See the graphic video here
http//www.wwltv.com/perl/common/video/wmPlayer.pl
?titlewww.wwltv.com/101005beat.wmv
19
Innocent bias

• The vast majority of police likely follow the
  IACP mandates
• Yet, because of structural impediments, the
  reality of policing in the United States clearly
  run counter to the ideals we expect (p. 155)
• Police do not have to be college educated AND
• Police are paid way too low!

20
A Real-World Challenge to the Ideals

• What can we realistically expect from our police
  officers who are held to such high standards when
  they are not required to have a college education
  and when are paid so poorly? (p. 155)