Title: A New Tub Opportunity
1A New Tub Opportunity
T
- TSEs-EcoSpray Polyurethane System Provides a
Green, ZERO Styrene, Ultra Low Emission, Solvent
Free Option For Innovative Manufacturers
S
E
INDUSTRIES
2TSE INDUSTRIES, INC.5260 113th Avenue North,
Clearwater, Florida 33760800-237-7634 FAX
727-572-0415www.TSE-Industries.com
VP SPECIALTY CHEMICAS DIVISION Tony
Rindone 727-540-1310 757-698-5031
cell Tony.Rindone_at_TSE-Industries.com
Composite Business Development Manager Mike
Raday 727-540-1322 757-510-2655
cell Mike.Raday_at_TSE-Industries.com
3Current Polyester Tub Scenario
- Thermoset polyester extensively uses both styrene
monomer and MEKP as volatile solvents risk of
fires in process storage areas - Styrene monomer has been (in some studies) shown
to be a carcinogen, and is currently classified
as a suspected carcinogen. It also can cause CNS
issues, and lead to fatal cardiac sensitization
(IARC). Styrene is classified as a hazardous air
pollutant, and emissions are strictly regulated
as a VOC. - Enzymes have recently been found in human lungs
that convert styrene into styrene oxide, which
has developed tumors in lungs of mice. - MEKP is a severe skin irritant, requiring careful
treatment as a hazardous waste. Must be disposed
of at a RCRA approved facility. - Styrene monomer may soon be regulated even
tighter, limiting production and forcing several
large industries to scramble for alternatives.
(spa, tub, RV, boat, etc)
A New Strategic Approach is Needed
4Impact of Styrene and MEKP Useage
- Limitations on emissions affect plant output
- Styrene permits unavailable in certain areas
limiting growth - Future potential for worker exposure lawsuits
- Expensive ventilation and incineration equipment
-
- Hazardous waste handling adds expense
- Yield losses are high, due to styrene losses
- Potential fire issues due to flammability of
styrene and MEKP
The Use of Styrene is Vulnerable to Legislative
Changes
5Polyurethane Background
- Polyurethane is an extremely versatile chemistry
that allows creation of both thermoplastics and
thermosetting plastics ranging from very soft to
hard and rigid. As with polyesters, two liquid
components are used, plus catalysts, fillers and
reinforcements. The two basic components for most
common polyurethanes are isocyanates and polyols.
- No styrene monomer, MEKP or solvents are used.
Some isocyanates are regulated, but handling and
disposal is much less hazardous and much less
expensive than for styrene and MEKP. - Polyurethanes generally have higher tensile
strength and impact vs polyesters, but slightly
lower stiffness or flexural properties.
Optimization of the fiberglass reinforcement
(chop length glass percentage) can close the
stiffness gap. Polyurethanes can also be foamed
to lower densities have much quicker cycle
times than polyesters. - Polyurethanes are more expensive materials than
polyesters, but that cost can be offset by faster
cycle times, lower overall costs and shorter oven
cure times.
6MDI POLYOL KEY RM PROCESS FLOW
- Production of MDI
- Well Head ?Refinery? Benzene ?Nitrobenzene?
Aniline?MDA?MDI - Producton of Polyol
- Well head ?Cracker ?Propylene ? Propylene Oxide
?Polyol
7POLYURETHANE ADVANTAGESVSFILLED STYRENE ESTERS
- ABSENCE OF ANY MONOMERIC STYRENE OR ANY OTHER
VOCs THAT CAN BE EMITTED INTO THE ATMOSPHERE
(NEGLIGIBLE VOCs) - FASTER APPLICATION, CURING TIMES AND DEMOLD TIMES
RESULTING IN 50 TO 70 FASTER PRODUCTION CYCLE
TIMES - POLYURETHANES ARE LESS BRITTLE AND ABSORB ENERGY
MORE READILY UNDER IMPACT AND SHOCK LOADINGS - SIMILAR TENSILE AND FLEXURAL STRENGTHS
- ELASTOMERIC MEMORY IS RETAINED HELPING IN IMPACT
RESISTANCE AND FATIGUE TOLERANCE - SUPERIOR ABRASION RESISTANCE
- IMPROVED ADHESION TO BOTH ACRYLIC, ABS BACKED
ACRYLIC AND POLYCARONATE ABS BACKED ACRYLIC - GOOD HYDROLYSIS RESISTANCE AND RELATIVELY LOW
WATER ABSORBTION
8POLYURETHANE HEALTH AND SAFETY
- SPRAY OPERATION MUST BE DONE IN A WELL VENTILATED
BOOTH WITH CLIMATE CONTROL - SPRAY GUN OPERATORS AND OTHER BOOTH OCCUPANTS
MUST WEAR FULL-FACE, POSITIVE PRESSURE AIR-LINE
RESPIRATORS OR CARTRIDGE RESPIRATORS TO PREVENT
INHALATION OF MIST AND VAPORS AND APPROPIATE
PROTECTIVE CLOTHING, BOOTS AND GLOVES TO PREVENT
SKIN CONTACT - FLASH POINTS OF ISO AND POLYOL ARE CLOSE TO 400
ºf - VOLATILITY IS EXTREMELY LOW, IE, ONLY 1 /
1,800,000 OF THE VAPOR PRESSURE OF WATER - REACTED WASTE IS NON-HAZARDOUS
- HS INFORMATION ON MSDS
- Polymeric Isocyanate - This product is a
respiratory irritant and potential respiratory
sensitizer. Moderate skin irritant. The
ingredients of this product are not classified as
carcinogenic by ACGIH or IARC, not regulated as
carcinogens by OSHA, and not listed as
carcinogens by NTP. - Polymeric isocyanate - This material is not a
hazardous waste under RCRA 40 CFR 261. Small
quantities should be treated with a decontaminant
solution. The treated waste is not a hazardous
material under RCRA 40 CFR 261
ISOCYANATES ARE CLASSIFIED (N120) BY THE EPA AS A
REPORTABLE ONLY ON AN ANNUAL BASIS
9RECOMMENDATIONS FOR SPRAYING POLYURETHANES
- IF EMISSIONS lt50 PPB, A HALF FACE DUAL CARTRIDGE
AIR PURIFYING RESPIRATOR IS OKAY FOR PROTECTIONS
(MIST SUPPRESSOR WITH ORGANIC CARTRIDGE) 10 X OF
EXPOSURE SAFETY FACTOR - IF EMISSIONS ARE lt250 PPB, A FULL FACE DUAL
CARTRIDGE AIR PURIFYING RESPIRATOR MUST BE
SPECIFIED 50 X EXPOSURE SAFETY FACTOR
10TSE Advantage
- Leader in custom polyurethane compounding
- Provides on site, multi skilled tech service team
(TSE as resin supplier, and MVP as pump equipment
vendor) - On site training support, both for the process
and handling of chemicals - TSE has proven experience using polyurethane
resins to pass ANSI testing,as well as tougher
customer internal specs - TSE development has created a lighter
polyurethane reinforced tub vs tubs reinforced
with the standard filled styrene polyester - Significant freight savings due to lower freight
classification - Lower weight makes it easier for contractors to
handle
TSE is the Best Choice for a Strategic
Polyurethane Partner
11Benefits of TSE-EcoSpray Polyurethane
New Markets
- Gain market share and penetrate new markets.
Green polyurethane resins are an alternative to
filled polyesters. - Provide higher throughput, with the potential of
plant consolidation. - Savings in process labour variable cost
reduction. - Freight savings by reducing weight of tubs
- Improved yields and reduced returns/rejects,
resulting in lower cost - Elimination of mixing step of the filler in the
resin (mix room) quality and cost improvement. - Eliminate the presence of styrene MEKP, which
are flammable chemicals, lowering insurance
requirements and reducing risk of fires. - Eliminate environmental problems, odours of
styrene in process at fence line, and hazardous
waste issues. - Eliminate HS exposure problems with styrene.
Exposure limit for employees are presently being
reviewed and might be reduced to as low as 20
ppm. Styrene might be re-classified by EPA as a
potential carcinogen in 2007. - Eliminates emission permit issues and risks
associated with tighter future permits - Polymeric isocyanate does require safe handling,
but is not volatile, is not a hazardous waste,
and is not a carcinogen. Only annual reporting is
required by EPA.
Lower Costs Lean Mfg.
Environmental
Provides a cost effective, Lean, environmentally
friendly option to increase market penetration
12Partners Involved
TSE Industries Inc. Clearwater, Florida
Innovative polyurethane supplier with expertise
in formulation and processing. Provides custom
formulations and start up support/on site
training.
MVP Industries
Current pump and applicator supplier responsible
for polyurethane equipment modifications.
13PRODUCT
TSE Polyurethane Ready to Use System
14PRODUCT
TSE Polyurethane Ready to Use System
15PRODUCT
TSE Polyurethane Ready to Use System
16Fixtures Made With TSE Polyurethane
No Shrink, tight Fitting Fixtures
17PRODUCT
- TSE Aliphatic PU Gel coat PU Resin
TSE Polyurethane Ready to Use System
18PRODUCT
TSE Polyurethane Ready to Use System
19PRODUCT - TSE Aliphatic Solid Surface
TSE Polyurethane Ready to Use System
20Tangible Savings PU Resin vs Styene Resin
- Total Elimination of styrene emission loss from
spraying and during curing - Reduction of overspray
- Freight savings due to lower cost freight
classification - Labor headcount reduction Overtime expense
reduction - Significant improvement in right first time tubs
conventional and air tubs - Reduction in cure time from 90 mins to 30 mins
- 4.5 to 5 min cycle times for manual lines
conventional tubs, ie, 92 to 102 tubs/day - 20 min cycle times times for manual lines air
tubs, ie, 24 tubs per day
21Intangible Savings Styrene Ester vs PU
- Health less worker exposure to styrene
monomer vapors - Safety less risk of fires from flammable
polyester and MEKP catalyst - Environmental eliminates need for emissions
permit and eliminate odors in process area and at
fenceline - Less Rejects - tighter fitting polyurethane
fixtures will significantly reduce dimensional
rejects - Volume Growth - possible GREEN certification
offers potential for product differentiation and
qualification for clean air buildings. Increase
capacity is available due to significant
reduction in process cycle time - Frees up Floor Space due to significant
improvement in right first time and reduction in
cure time from 90 mins to 30 mins - Adhesion improvement in adhesion to Acrylic,
ABS backed acrylic and Polycarbonate ABS backed
acrylic
22Capital Estimate Ready to Use Polyol ISO
A. 1 MVP 11 Pump with Recycle and Chopper
22,000 B. Ovens to house two tote bins
25,000 C. Dehumidification equipment and
ventilation 35,000 D. 2
agitator for tote bins in ovens 5,000 E. 1
post cure oven _at_ 135ºF to 150ºF 30,000 F. 1
(16 ft) cooling area with over head fans
8,000 G. 1 breathing air compressor with
piping to spray booth area 2,000 SUB-TOTAL
127,000 Optional Conveyor System 50,000??
23ANSI CERTIFICATION RESULTS
- STATUS OF RESULTS
-
- 1. ANSI Tests done on cut pieces
- Thermal resistance (blister)
PASS - Water absorption through cross section
PASS - Thermal shock PASS
- 2. ANSI Tests done on the whole unit Acyrlic,
ABS, Polycarbonate/ABS - Drain fitting connection
PASS - Point impact load test
PASS - Load on rim
PASS - Load on bottom
PASS - Radii load test
PASS - Load on supported area
PASS - Fire resistance PASS
- Adhesion test PASS
24Future Product Directions
- Capitalize on the lack of styrene emissions to
enter highly regulated markets (western US, for
example) - A real opportunity to lead the way in these
previously closed geographies if permits issues
have restricted your entry - Exploit the green, ie, elimination of styrene
emissions, characteristics as a green option - Brand new market opportunity the time is right!
- Segment the market by using different backings
(low density foam, high density foam, colors,
glossy skin, etc.) - A rare chance to differentiate and share shift
from competitors - Position aliphatic PU Gel coat on a tub with PU
reinforcement as a product offering that bridges
the gap between standard gel coats and high end
acrylics - New market opportunity
- Produce an aliphatic PU Gel coat, tough shower
with PU reinforcement to enter the Home Depot and
Lowes arena with a more reliable product - New market opportunity
Presents a Chance to Break Free of the Pack
25In Closing
TSE is committed to helping those organizations
that truly want and/or need to convert from
polyester to TSEs State-Of-The-Art
polyurethanes. Whether your motivation is driven
by the EPAs current or impending regulations,
the need to gain a leading competitive edge in
your market, increased capacity, or more
importantly to strengthen your organizations
financial future by promoting higher standards
for quality, productivity, safety, health and
environmental. Together with TSE, your
commitment and our TSE-EcoSpray polyurethanes
the transition is possible. Please call if you
believe that polyurethanes can make a difference
in your organizations future.