Title: Effective People Management
1Effective People Management
- Khaled F. Sherif
- Chief Administrative Officer
- The World Bank
- Course Material available on
- http\\www.ksherif.com
2What is T.A.?
- Transactional Analysis Is ...
Personality Theory Simplified
Motivation Theory Simplified
A Leadership Style
A Training Tool
An Easy Way of Understanding Who says What, and
Why People Act and Interact the Way They Do
An Aid in Dealing with Conflict Problems
3Reasons for Popularity of T.A. In Management
Simple Language
Built-in Humor
Non-Threatening Self-analysis
Appropriate For Normal People
Useful at Work At Home
Demonstrated Success in Bus. Organizations
4Basic Human Ego States(Personality States)
- FURTHER BREAKDOWN OF EGO STATES
LECTURING, CRITICIZING, MANY OUGHTS, SHOULD
DONTS
P (PARENT)
CRITICAL PARENT NURTURING PARENT
CONSOLING, TAKING CARE OF OTHERS, SYMPATHY
A (ADULT)
ADULT
OBJECTIVE, RATIONAL, ORIENTED TOWARD PROBLEM
SOLVING, DE-EMPHASIZE EMOTION
MODIFIED BEHAVIOUR TO CONFORM TO ADULT
EXPECTATIONS, MANUPULATIVE, SUMBISSIVE
C (CHILD)
ADAPTED CHILD NATURAL CHILD
PLAYFUL, IMPULSIVE, NATULRALLY CURIOUS CREATIVE,
FUN LOVING, REBELLIOUS
5Critical vs. Nurturing Parent
6Natural Child vs. Adult
7Typical Ways of Expressing Ego States on the Job
CANT YOU TURN IN AN ICA ON TIME JUST ONCE?
CRITICAL PARENT
WHAT, IT TAKES TWO WEEKS TO PREPARE A PSR?
IM SURPRISED AT YOU THE QUALITY OF THIS PAD IS
LOUSY
TAKE A REST STOP ON YOUR WAY BACK, THE MISSION
WAS TOO LONG
NURTURING PARENT
CAN I HELP YOU EDIT THE PCD, HES ASKING TOO
MUCH OF YOU
YOUVE DONE A SWELL JOB ON THAT AAA, BUT YOU
MUST HAVE BEEN UP ALL NIGHT
WHAT ARE THE ALTERNATIVES IF WE MISS THE BOARD
DATE?
ADULT
CANT WE REACH SOME SORT OF COMPROMISE ON THE
TRANCHE RELEASE?
WHAT CONSEQUENCES WILL THIS SAP DELEGATION
HAVE?
ANYTHING YOU SAY, YOURE THE DIRECTOR
ADAPTED CHILD
SORRY,THE PAD IS LOUSY ILL TRY TO IMPROVE IT.
WHAT WOULD ECSPF DO WITHOUT YOU
NOBODY FOLLOWS THAT PROCUREMENT RULE ANYWAY.
NATURAL CHILD
FORGET ABOUT IT, HES JUST A SECTOR MANAGER
ITS MY AWS DAY, OF COURSE IM NOT COMING TO
MEET WITH THE DELEGATION FOR THE SPRING MEETINGS
8Types of Interpersonal Transactions
P
P
P
P
P
P
A
A
A
A
A
A
C
C
C
C
C
C
COMPLEMENTARY
CROSSED
ULTERIOR
P
P
P
P
P
P
A
A
A
A
A
A
C
C
C
C
C
C
VERBAL COMMUNICATION (A CRITICAL PARENT CAN BE
SILENT !!!)
EXPECTED RESPONSE, NO CONFLICT
PRODUCE CONFLICT, STOP COMMUNICATION, HURT
FEELINGS
NON-VERBAL HIDDEN MEANING
9Examples of Complementary Transactions on the Job
- ACS THE PAD NEEDED RE-FORMATING SO I TOOK THE
LIBERTY OF MAKING IT LOOK BETTER - TTL YOU SURE KNOW HOW TO TAKE CARE OF ME,
- SECTOR MANAGER WHAT CAN WE DO TO MEET THE BOARD
DATE? - PTL WE CAN TAKE A COUPLE OF PEOPLE OFF THE OTHER
SERBIA PROJECT FOR A WHILE AND PUT THEM ON THIS
ONE.
- MISSION LEADER DONT FORGET YOUR TENNIS RACQUET
FOR THE MISSION TO BOSNIA - MISSION MEMBER IM GLAD YOU HAVE YOUR
PRIORITIES RIGHT
P
P
P
P
P
P
(1)
(1)
A
A
A
A
A
A
(2)
(2)
(1)
C
C
C
C
C
C
(2)
NURTURING PARENT TO ADAPTED CHILD
NATURAL CHILD TO NATURAL CHILD
ADULT TO ADULT TRANSACTION
10Examples of Crossed Transactions on the Job
- PTL ON THE PHONE COME SEE ME IN MY OFFICE NOW!
(DEMANDING TONE OF VOICE) - ACS WHY DONT YOU COME OVER HERE? ITS JUST AS
CLOSE!
- SECTOR MANAGER DID YOU FINISH THE BUDGET
ESTIMATES? - BUDGET ANALYST HOW CAN I IF THE WHOLE PROCESS
DOESNT MAKE SENSE.
- PTL WHATS THE RULE ON GETTING AN INTERNATIONAL
CELL PHONE - ASSISTANT HOW SHOULD I KNOW, WHY DONT YOU LOOK
UP THE RULE FOR YOURSELF
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
(1)
(1)
(1)
A
A
A
A
(1)
A
A
A
A
(2)
C
C
C
C
(2)
(2)
C
C
C
C
(2)
ADULT-TO-ADULT CROSSED BY CRITICAL
PARENT-TO-CHILD RESPONSE
PARENT-TO-CHILD CROSSED BY CRITICAL PARENT OR
REBELLIOUS CHILD RESPONSE
ADULT-TO-ADULT CROSSES UP BY DISCOUNTED CHILD TO
PARENT RESPONSE
11Examples of Ulterior Transactions
- EMPLOYEE SORRY, THE AAA WONT BE READY FOR
TOMORROWS END OF THE YEAR DEADLINE. - SECTOR MANAGER ITS O.K. IVE BEEN THINKING OF
ASSIGNING THIS TO SOMEONE ELSE ANYWAY.
- IT SPECIALIST THIS DOCKING STATION HAS GOT
EVERYTHING YOUD EVER WANT FROM A COMPUTER BUT
YOU HAVE TO BE REGULAR TO HAVE ONE. - CONSULTANT WELL I AM FIXED TERM YOU KNOW..
(HIDDEN MEANING WHO DOES HE THINK I AM?)
P
P
P
P
(1)
A
A
(1)
(1)
A
A
(2)
(2)
(1)
C
C
(2)
C
C
(2)
12StrokingThe Types of Strokes You Seek Depend on
Your Okayness
POSITIVESTROKES
NEGATIVE STROKES
CONDITIONAL STROKES
PUT-DOWNS CRITICISM DEGRADING RIDICULE SCOLD
ING PUNISHMENT DISCOUNTING ALWAYS STRINGS
ATTACHED THE STRINGS HAVE SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES
PRAISE COMPLEMENTS RECOGNITION AFFECTION REWA
RDS SYMPATHY CONSOLATION SELF-SATISFACTION
FROM JOB WELL DONE ALWAYS STRINGS ATTACHED THE
STRINGS MODERATE
STROKES WITH ULTERIOR MOTIVES (ADAPTED
CHILD) STROKES GIVEN FOR WHAT YOU DO, RATHER
THAN FOR WHO YOU ARE (CRITICAL PARENT)
- PERFORMANCE ORIENTED STROKE (STRINGS USUALLY
- LINKING A DELIVERABLE TO
- A PROMOTION
- (ADULT)
- ACCOMODATION CONFORMITY ORIENTED STROKES
(CRITICAL PARENT - ATTEMPTING TO SHAPE
- BEHAVIOR AND CREATE
- ADAPTED CHILDREN
- TYPOLOGY)
13Critical Parent Gray Stamp Zingers
A woman without a man is like a fish without a
bicycle When turkeys want to marry they think
of swans
Do someone a favor and it becomes your job
Anything is possible if you dont know what your
talking about
You can pretend to be serious you cant pretend
to be witty
What we learn after we know it all is what counts
Its always dangerous to be right when the boss
is wrong
When you have a pen, you have no paper, when you
have paper, you dont have a pen, when you have
both, you have no message
The explanation of a disaster is always made by a
stand-in
14Critical Parent - Damaged
- Do critical parents show patterns of abnormal
behavior? - To some degree they are in fact damaged.
- Some are exhibiting behaviors that are very black
and white - Hes great hes useless, there is no in between
- You are either a God, or a waste of space
- The reason critical parents are damaged is that
they in some instances hurt others to feel better
about themselves - Hes a fool, because hes not as experienced as I
am - Hes an idiot, because he didnt go to the same
school that I went to - Hes useless because he doesnt write well, or
present well, and is comparing a poorer skill set
with his own - Every time he finds someone who doesnt measure
up, he/she feels better about who they are
15Basic Psychological (Life) Positions Your Self
Image
- 3. IM NOT OK YOURE OK
- CHILD-TO-ADULT EGO STATE ACTIVATED. FEELINGS OF
INFERIORITY, GUILT, DISAPPOINTMENT IN SELF
PREDOMINANT. USUALLY TRIGGERED OUT OF FEAR
- 1. IM OK YOURE OK
- WIN- WIN, HEALTHY, OPTIMISTIC, ADULT-TO-ADULT
INTERACTION. IDEAL LIFE POSITION ON OFF THE
JOB. NUMEROUS GOLD STAMPS
- 2. IM OK YOURE NOT OK
- CRITICAL PARENT EGO STATE ACTIVATED. MAY EVOLVE
FROM BEING HURT OR DISCOUNTED. FEELS DISTRUST,
ANGER, SUPERIORITY. GRAY STAMPS IN PLAY
- 4. IM NOT OK YOURE NOT OK
- LACKS TRUST IN OTHERS. FEELINGS OF HOPELESSNESS,
DESIRE FOR REVENGE, OFTEN EXTREME DEPRESSION.
SERIOUS BLACK STAMPS IN PLAY
- 5. IM OK, IM NOT SURE ABOUT YOU
- (KEEP IN MIND GRAY, BLACK GOLD STAMPS)
16Im OK, Im Not Sure About You
- Typically, this is the state that your in when
you meet someone for the first time - However, this not necessarily always the case
- You can meet someone that is so much like you,
that it triggers an Im OK, Your OK initial
response, until proven otherwise - You can also meet someone so much not like you,
that it triggers an Im OK, Your Not OK initial
response, until proven otherwise - In most instances, relationships are formed by
transactions that either tend to be positive, or
tend to be negative - If the transactions remain positive, over time
gold stamps accrue and you start building an Im
OK, Your OK relationship - If the transactions are pre-dominantly negative,
over time gray stamps accrue and you start
building an Im OK, Your Not OK relationship - If the negative gets nasty, really nasty, then an
Im Not OK, Your Not OK relationship develops
17Im OK, Your OK One of Its Most Common Forms
- When you have a relationship with someone in this
mode gold stamps, possibly several of them, have
accrued - There is mutual respect between you and most
importantly there is trust - You can rely on that person, and they can rely on
you - You know more about them than what is just at
work. You might know there kids, and they might
know yours. You share things that are not just
professional, but are private as well - You see this in the Bank consistently among
people that travel together often and in very
difficult environments - Many of my Im OK, Your OK relationships
accrued from going to countries like Bosnia
immediately after the war. With gun shot fire
almost every night, we all started checking in on
each other, and were concerned when someone was
late for breakfast, or late from a meeting - That concern, created a pattern of caring, that
interface led to the development of gold stamps - You tend to have lunch more often with people in
this category, or you invite them to your home.
This is your tennis partner, but more
importantly, this is your friend
18Im OK, Your Not OK One of Its Most Common
Forms
- Unfortunately, most of our relationships are in
this mode - This appears when we think were smarter, better,
or more committed than someone else - It also comes from repetitive disagreements, or
when you consistently are overruled - For example, if you are a lead TTL and in the
middle of an important meeting when the boss is
asking everyone for their opinion, he turns to
you and says Can you photo copy this for the
rest of the group? - You might do it, but it triggers a gray stamp
- In turn this gray stamp, combined with others,
defines your relationship with this person
squarely in the Im OK, Your Not OK category - On average, about 8 of every 10 people we work
with are labeled by us in this category - When this happens work does not tend to be fun
- This is what gives you the feeling of not wanting
to get out of bed Monday morning and you start
thinking Oh my God, not again
19Im OK, Hes Not OK
Good morning
Good morning
Did you see the game yesterday?
Could he be any less professional?
What a kiss-up
20Im OK, Shes Not OK
Good morning
Good morning
Check out hair
Evaluate skin
Inspect jewelry
Is that a real tan?
Hiding cellulite?
Decide if shoes are cute or ugly
Compare figure
Any surgery?
Ive seen that dress
Too much skin
21Im Not OK, Your OK One of Its Most Common
Forms
- This can stem from a third party reaction to a
Im Not OK Your Not OK set of transactions - A colleague has taken your supervisor to an
administrative tribunal - You are asked to testify
- You have such fear of that supervisor that when
asked questions about your boss, you answer them
in a way that doesnt get you into trouble - Problem is, now you have let your colleague down
who you knew was in the right - Behavior like this is normal, but is usually
generated our of fear - If the boss explains an action related to a
staffer implying the person is incompetent, you
many know this not to be true, but you want to
avoid conflict with your boss, so you say
nothing, or in its worst form, you implicitly or
explicitly support this judgment - When faced statements like What an idiot, you
say nothing even when you disagree - When you interact with the person thereafter, the
Im Not OK, Your OK mode kicks in - Yup youll pick up the lunch tab too.
22IM Not OK, Your Not OK One of Its Worst Forms
- Why do some really nasty things get said about
people in the work place, a lot of the time so
absurd that they poison the work environment? - This consistently occurs when a relationship
between two people deteriorates to the "I'm Not
OK, Your Not OK" category. At this stage, one
person, usually the subordinate, feels so wronged
by their supervisor that they feel justified in
saying, or putting in writing (usually in
anonymity), allegations that are extremely
personal and accusatory. - If you have ever come across this, it is easy to
spot. - The accuser is usually very emotional and deeply
troubled by his or her interaction with their
supervisor. The person may feel threatened, was
threatened, or generally feels humiliated and
discounted. - The response to this is often self defense and
this can take on various forms. When the worst
forms of "I'm Not OK, Your Not OK" kick in, it is
like a bad divorce between two people that is
getting really nasty. - In its worst form, people then start taking
sides, and transference sinks in. The office
atmosphere becomes divisive and a pattern sets in
that usually leads to new and more troubling
accusations or events occurring weekly, or even
daily.
23Conflict at Work I
- Did You Hear the Latest (Reuters in the work
place)? - EMPLOYEE PLAYING THE ROLE OF REUTERS SHARING
OFFICE RUMORS AND GOSSIP. THE RUMORS KEEP YOU
ON EDGE, BUT CONSISTENTLY PROVE TO BE WRONG AND
TEND TO CREATE AN IM OK YOUR NOT OK ENVIRONMENT
KICK ME
SORRY, I COULDNT FINISH THAT ICA TOO MANY
TASKS AT THE SAME TIME
OH MY GOD THIS PLACE IS GOING TO PIECES
THATS OK, I UNDERSTAND (ULTERIOR MESSAGE
THATS NOT OK AND MAN ARE YOU GOING TO GET IT)
PARTNERS SCRIPT IM OK YOURE NOT OK.
24Conflict at Work II
YES, BUT
WHY DONT YOU SEND THE PROCUREMENT PLAN UP FOR
CLEARANCE?
IF IT WERENT FOR MY BACK TROUBLE, I COULD HAVE
FINISHED ALL THE BINDERS YOU NEEDED FOR THE
DIRECTORS MEETING.
WELL, THE PACKAGE ISNT FULLY FINISHED YET IS
IT?
USES REAL OR IMAGINED HANDICAP AS CONSTANT
EXCUSE. NEGATIVE SELF-IMAGE IM NOT OK
SELF-PITY. CONTINUALLY LOOKING FOR CONSOLATION OR
PITY FROM NURTURING PARENT.
A FREQUENT GAME BETWEEN STAFF AND LINE PERSONNEL.
THE HOOKER MAY ACTUALLY ASK THE OTHER PERSON
FOR HELP WITH SOMETHING, THEN THE OTHER PERSON
SYSTEMATICALLY FINDS FAULT WITH ONE SUGGESTION
AFTER ANOTHER.
25Conflict at Work III
HURRIED MANAGER
THESE YPs STRAIGHT OUT OF THE PROGRAM, THEY
THINK THEY KNOW EVERYTHING.
IVE GOT TO DO EVERYTHING MYSELF AROUND HERE!
YEAH, WE WERE NEVER LIKE THAT YOU KNOW.
COMPULSIVE MANAGER WHO TAKES ON MORE AND MORE
RESPONSIBILITY, OFTEN MORE THAN HE/SHE CAN
HANDLE, THEN COMPLAINS ABOUT HOW BUSY HE/SHE IS.
MAY STILL BE PLAYING OUT THE ADAPTED CHILD EGO
STATE IN RESPONSE TO CRITICAL PARENT WITH HIGH
EXPECTATIONS. SEEKS NURTURING PARENT STROKES.
GOSSIP TYPE COMPLEMENTARY TRANSACTIONS BETWEEN
TWO CRITICAL PARENT EGO STATES. MAY FOSTER TEAM
SPIRIT, BUT IN A NONPRODUCTIVE, NON-OBJECTIVE
DIRECTION. POPULAR WITH COMMITTEES.
26Conflict at Work IV
NIGYSOB
HOW COULD I HAVE BEEN SO STUPID, I CANT FIND
THE LATEST PAD ON WORD I DONT HAVE A BACK-UP
NOW, IVE GOT YOU, YOU S.O.B
CLASSIC EXAMPLE OF PERSECUTOR SETTING UP HIS
VICTIM. LOVES TO ACTIVATE HIS CRITICAL PARENT EGO
STATE. OFTEN SETS IMPOSSIBLE TASKS FOR
SUBORDINATES, GIVES INCOMPLETE INSTRUCTIONS, THEN
GETS READY TO GIVE A KICK.
EXAMPLE MANAGER I HEAR THEY ARE LOOKING FOR
A PRIVATIZATION SPECIALIST IN THE
CENTER. SUBORDINATE HOW ABOUT YOUR
RECOMMENDING ME FOR THAT POSITION? MANAGER
YOU CONSIDER YOURSELF A PRIVATIZATION
SPECIALIST?
MAKES DUMB MISTAKE, GETS NEGATIVE STROKES FROM
CRITICAL PARENT AND THEN BECOMES CRITICAL PARENT
ALSO. A PATTERN OF TRANSFERANCE BUILDS
27Conflict at Work V
BOSNIA PER
- NOW I/WEVE GOT YOU YOU SOBs
A PER IS CRITICIZED HEAVILY AND DESCRIBED AS A
TERRIBLE PRODUCT
IN AN OFFICE DOMINATED BYCLIQUES THE SECOND IN
COMMAND TAKES CHARGE
A NEW TTL IS ASSIGNED HE REVERSES THE CHAPTERS
BUT DOESNT ALTER THE CONTENT THE PER NOW
RECEIVES A GLOWING REVIEW BUT ALL THATS REALLY
CHANGED IS THE NAME ON THE DOCUMENT!!
NOW ITS TIME FOR HIM AND HIS TEAM TO GET EVEN
WITH THOSE THAT ARE NOT MEMBERS OF THE OK CROWD
28Conflict at Work VI
IF IT WERENT FOR YOU
WELL,IF YOU SHOWED ME HOW TO DO IT FROM THE
BEGINNING THIS WOULDNT BE HAPPENING
IF IT WERENT FOR THAT DIRECTOR, I COULD HAVE
BEEN A SECTOR MANAGER BY NOW.
CANT YOU INPUT AN I/O RIGHT JUST ONCE?
IF IT WERENT FOR SOMEONE OR SOMETHING IS A
FAVORITE COP-OUT, BLAME OTHERS FOR SUPPOSEDLY
UNAVOIDABLE CIRCUMSTANCES FOR LACK OF
ACHIEVEMENTS, CHILD EGO STATE ACTIVATED.
BOTH PLAYERS TRADE INSULTS OR ABUSES, ENGAGE IN
ATTACK AND COUNTER-ATTACK. OFTEN DETERIORATES
INTO SHOUTING MATCH. TWO IM OK YOU ARE NOT OK
POSITIONS CLASHING. WORSE A MANAGER CAN THEN
TAKE SIDES CAUSING MORE DAMAGE
29Conflict at Work VII
RAPO
THAT NO-GOOD SO--SO!
SECTOR MANAGER HAVE YOU SEEN ALEX THIS
MORNING? SUBORDINATE NO, ALEX NEVER GETS IN
THIS EARLY! USED TO DEVELOP TRANSFORM THE IM
OK, IM NOT SURE ABOUT YOU MODE INTO IM OK,
HE/SHE IS NOT OK
I WOULDT WANT YOU TO TELL ANYBODY WHO CLUED YOU
IN, BUT DID YOU KNOW THAT YOUR SECTOR MANAGER
DIDNT SUPPORT YOUR PROMOTION AT THE DMT?
SAYING THINGS IN CONFIDENCE IS OFTEN AN
ULTERIOR TRANSACTION. PLAYER HAS A HIDDEN
AGENDA, ACTIVATES HIS MANIPULATIVE CHILD EGO
STATE.
30 Conflict at Work VIII
DO YOU KNOW WHO YOURE TALKING TO?
I AM THE PTL AND YOU BETTER REMEMBER THAT
MISTER
I THINK THIS SHOULD BE A TWO TRANCHE OPERATION.
YES, WHAT A GREAT IDEA. I WONDER WHY I DIDNT
THINK OF THAT MYSELF
COMPLEMENTARY TRANSACTIONS BETWEEN PARENT AND
CHILD EGO STATES. POPULAR GAME IN COMMITTEES.
SOMEONE WHO ALL OF A SUDDEN WANTS TO USE TITLES
AND BE FORMAL. MAY BE PLAYING CRITICAL PARENT
31Conflict at Work IX
IM NOT SAYING HELLO
HERES A GOOD SNUB FOR YOU FELLA!
I GOT A 5 THIS YEAR, WHAT DID YOU GET?.
IM NOT SURE, BUT I CONSIDER THINGS LIKE THIS
PERSONAL.
PLAYING OUT THE CRITICAL PARENT EGO STATE IN
RESPONSE TO WHAT WAS PERCEIVED TO BE A CRITICAL
PARENT TRANSACTION. THE MESSAGE IS IM OK YOUR
NOT OK. BUT, WHAT HAPPENS IF THIS PERESON LATER
BECOMES YOUR BOSS?
THIS CAN EASILY BECOME A TRANSACTION BETWEEN TWO
CRITICAL PARENT EGO STATES. USUALLY SPREADS AND
CREATES MORE CRITICAL PARENTS BY TRANSFERENCE
32 Conflict at Work X
- WHAT DID HE MEAN BY THAT?
HE CANT TELL THE DIFFERENE BETWEEN THE FOREST
AND THE TREES
WHY IS IT THAT I SEE YOU BOTH TOGETHER ALL THE
TIME?
WHO DOES HE THINK HE IS, THE MANS BEEN HERE A
WEEK AND HES FIGURED THE PLACE OUT
WHAT DID HE MEAN BY THAT, HES SUCH A JERK
NATURAL CHILD TALKING TO CRITICAL PARENTS THE
COMMUNICATION SOUNDS FINE, BUT IT ISNT.
NEW PERSON JOINS A TEAM USUALLY REPLACING SOMEONE
THAT WAS LIKED. THOSE AROUND HIM TEND TO PLAY
CRITICAL PARENT MAKING IT HARD FOR THE PERSON TO
BE ACCEPTED
33Conflict at Work XI
- TRAIN YOUR OWN REPLACEMENT?
- EMPLOYEE BEING ASKED TO EFFECTIVELY TRAIN THEIR
OWN REPLACEMENT EITHER BY BEING DUPED, OR BEING
TOLD OUTRIGHT YOUR OUT, BUT THIS IS WHAT YOU NEED
TO DO BEFORE YOU GO
DONT BEG
I CAME TO SEE YOU TO SEE IF THERE IS ANYTHING WE
CAN DO TO IMPROVE MY PERFORMANCE REVIEW AND
SALARY ADJUSTMENT
OH MY GOD I CANT BELIEVE THIS
I JUST HATE PEOPLE WHO BEG
SCRIPT IM OK YOURE NOT OK.
34Transference
- What is Transference?
- Transference occurs when two people have a I am
OK, Your OK relationship, and a third-party is
introduced who has a I am Not OK, Your Not OK
relationship with one of these two people - Very often, the relationship state that exists
between the third-party and the principal is
transferred to the other person. This often
creates a I am OK, Your Not OK relationship
with that person as well
35First Party Transference
- What is First Party Transference?
- First party transference occurs when a person,
usually a supervisor, has had a bad experience
with a subordinate - The subordinate has failed to meet the
expectations of the boss, by giving him/her a
sub-standard product, by not being timely, or
possibly by consistently getting complaints that
the person mishandled relationships with peer or
clients on that job - From this outcome, the supervisor starts forming
an Im OK, Hes Not OK lens towards the
subordinate. - This thinking starts getting the supervisor to
avoid giving this person the next high profile
project, or to begin to discount this person more
generally
?
36An Example of Second Party Transference
- Second party transference starts occurring when
someone is passing on a judgment about a person
to someone else - For example, when Wei and Thomas have an Im OK,
Your OK relationship - And, Thomas has an Im OK, Your Not OK
relationship with Lars, what do you think can
happen? - What happens when Lars is only partly aware of
this tension?
??
Lars
Thomas
Wei
37An Example of Second party Transference
- Through transference, Wei can quickly develop an
Im OK, Your Not OK relationship with Lars - Lars then doesnt understand why Wei isnt
incorporating him into his team - Lars also cant understand why Wei was never
willing to give him a chance since they never
really worked together
??
Lars
Thomas
??
Wei
38Second-Party Transference
- Another example Anna and Wei have a strong Im
OK , Your OK relationship - Anna has a Your Not OK Relationship with Lars
- Lars applies for a job where Wei is the hiring
manager what happens then?
Im really interested in the open position
??
??
Sorry, youre not the right guy for it
Lars is a lazy bum
39Third-Party Transference
- Third party transference occurs when either a
team, or more than two people, have passed
judgment on a staffer that is either negative or
positive. - For example, Wei and Lars have an Im OK , Your
OK relationship - Lars feels he has earned a promotion to an open
position - Ken tells John to Hire Claudette, not Lars, for
the open position (cronyism/previous
relationship)
Lars
Open Position
Ken VP/Director
Wei SectorManager
40Third-Party Transference
- Claudette is hired. Lars resents that he was not
promoted and is unhappy with Wei, his Sector
Manager. From the get go Lars has a poor
relationship with Claudette, because he feels she
did not earn his job - Wei is unhappy that Ken (the Director)
big-footed him on the hire and to save his
relationship with Lars, he starts being critical
of Ken
??
??
??
??
41Third-Party Team Transference
- An example of team transference can involve a new
Director who comes in and has an Im OK, Your
OK relationship with a particular group. The
new Director tends to work with a defined team
(click) and to rely on old relationships heavily - Two or more team member in the new managers
click have an Im OK, Your Not OK relationship
with Lars and Alex and they bad mouth them to the
Director - The Director, through transference, forms a
negative opinion of Lars and Alex, and therefore,
they are selected for only the worst assignments
in the department (reassigned from Turkey to
Tajikistan)
??
42Third-Party Transference Clicks (Teams)
How can Lars and Alex repair their relationship
with the new manager?
??
43Third-Party Transference
- Third-Party transference can occur when Lars, who
has a bad relationship with his managers and
tries to move from Dept X to Dept Y. - Lars managers effectively block his transfer
through transference and now he finds himself in
a dead-end
??
??
Ken Head of Dept Y
??
Wei Head of Dept X
Thomas Manager in Dept X
Lars Employee in Dept X
44Image Transference
- What is Image Transference?
- When people start developing a perception of who
you are, an image is formed from one person, and
is transferred from one person to another person
and/or to a group of people - There are different types of image transference
that involve groups including - Emissary
- Clicks vs. Teams
45Emissary Transference
- Characteristics
- A senior manager appoints/inherits a surrogate
who tends to be very a critical parent - The surrogate has terrible communication skills
- The image of the senior manager is hurt by
transference as this is the person staff see and
work with the most
46New Manager Transference
- Characteristics
- A new manager is appointed and his predecessor
is beloved by several members of the existing
team - They are unhappy with the selection and cannot
understand why management made a change - Staff are happy to hear negative views of the new
manager from others to transfer to the rest of
the team
47Old Manager Transference
- Characteristics
- A new manager is appointed to a new position, but
has various strong Im OK, Your OK, relationships
with people in his old work group - The new manager starts intimidating staff in his
new work group to nudge them out.
48Clicks vs. Team Transference
- Characteristics
- Manager trusts select people in the work group
more than others - Over time the manager tends to discount the
opinions of those he doesnt trust and puts them
at arms length and doesnt give them important
assignments
49The Introvert
- Characteristics
- Doesnt go out with the group
- Doesnt communicate
- Closes the office door
- Image
- Smart, but has poor communication skills, not
management material
50Party Animal
- Scenario
- While away on mission, Marks dark side begins to
appear. - The impact of late nights and a hang-over is
evident when he comes late to breakfast - Image
- Mark is seen as a player, whose priorities are
likely not work-related as much as having his fun
51Kiss-Up
- Characteristics
- Very close to one manager and one manager only
- Will do/say whatever it takes to make the manager
happy - Image
- Peers are weary of the kiss-up and know that
anything said in their presence will be used
against them to advance the kiss-ups own
interests
52Lost
- Characteristics
- Never really sure of what he or she wants
- Always asks for one thing but isnt happy when
you do exactly what was asked - Image
- Not really qualified technically to be in the
position he is in, but he/she has somehow earned
that position and everyone else suffers
Can you please get me a pencil?
What the hell is this?
53Mr. Critical
- Characteristics
- Always is seeking and suggesting that there is
something wrong with other peoples proposals or
ideas - Not necessarily offering better ideas, just
constantly complaining that the ideas that are
being suggested will not work
And, thats all we have for today
54Mr. Know-It-All
- Characteristics
- Believes that he is more knowledgeable than
everyone else, including his superiors - Always has an answer for everything, although the
answer may not always be relevant to the question
And, thats all we have for today
55Transactional Analysis
- The 80/20 rule 80 percent of your success is in
managing people and 20 percent relates to doing
your job well - If this is true, what is the level of okayness
with your subordinates, peers, supervisors and
most important clients? - It is important to determine where you stand with
the people working closest to you. With whom do
you have gold stamps and with whom do you have
gray stamps
56Why Do Bad Managers Survive?
57The Organization and Who Makes into Management
- One of the most important elements that impacts
how transactional analysis influences behaviors
in the workplace is which behaviors are rewarded
and which behaviors are penalized by the
organization and its management - Different organizations have different management
structures and reward mechanisms, and this can
have a significant impact on who becomes a
manager and who is simply unable or unwilling to
make that leap - Although company culture is widely-recognized
as a key component of any organizations success
or failure, it remains highly underrated when it
comes to understanding what it takes to make it
into the management stream and why so many in the
upper echelons make it without the requisite
technical or academic qualifications - Company culture may also allow poor managers to
thrive in certain instances and this relates in
certain instances to how staff are conditioned
58How Bad Managers SurviveUnderstanding Stockholm
Syndrome
- Psychology and human behavior manifest themselves
most prominently in the most extreme of
circumstances - That is why we can learn a great deal from these
instances and apply them to the workplace - In 1973, a group of robbers held employees of a
bank hostage for a short period of time in a farm
house Stockholm, Sweden - After being surrounded by police and barricading
themselves with the hostages and making repeated
threats to kill them, the criminals eventually
found that they had no option other than to
surrender - What is remarkable about this case is that in
this short period, the hostages began to
sympathize strongly with their captorseventually
refusing to testify against them and even coming
together to raise money for their criminal defense
59How Bad Managers SurviveUnderstanding Stockholm
Syndrome
- Although Stockholm Syndrome may seem unfathomable
to many, there are numerous other examples of it
manifesting itself, including two additional
famous instances - In the 1970s, millionaire heiress Patty Hearst
was abducted by the Symbionese Liberation Army,
before eventually joining their cause and
participating in a robbery with them - More recently, Jaycee Lee Dugard made headlines
when she was rescued following 18 years in
captivity. The catch, however, was that she had
fathered two children from her captor and never
attempted to escape despite the brutal nature of
her kidnapping
60Why Does Stockholm Syndrome Occur?
- There are multiple theories for why Stockholm
Syndrome takes place, the most prominent being - Psychological Cognitive dissonance tells us that
people dont like to be unhappy for long periods
of time, so if they are confined to a situation
that they do not like, they find a way to like it
(i.e. by bonding with their kidnappers) so that
they do not remain unhappy - Psychoanalytic This theory suggests that there
is a psychological shift that occurs when the
victims are exposed to certain acts of kindness
from their captors. Although these acts may be
self-serving, the exposure to them could lead the
victims to believe that they stem from inherent
kindness
61How Does Stockholm Syndrome Manifest Itself in
the Workplace?
- Negative Reflex Conditioning This is when we
actively work to eliminate the negative
experiences we endure and replace them with
positive and satisfying ones. - For example, managers that promote innovation and
seek feedback from their teams are ones that
typically get the best results from their staff.
This is because these individuals feel that they
are incentivized to do excellent cutting edge
work - Meanwhile, managers that operate in a rigid
environment where they simply seek from staff
outputs that are 100 percent replicas of what
they are thinking quickly alienate their
subordinates. This is because it is difficult for
staff to replicate exactly what their manager is
thinking. Moreover, staff in these situations
are typically working with the fear of getting
something wrong rather than on focusing on
delivering the best products
62Negative Reflex Conditioning
63Negative Reflex Conditioning
Another TTL spends most of her days working on
non business related items and takes on an ESW on
pensions in another country in the region
64Mimicking Behaviors
65Negative Reflex Conditioning How Poor Managers
Survive and Thrive
- Battered Wife Syndrome
- Mistreated wife
- Beaten / humiliated / discounted / unappreciated,
no respect - Children mimic behavior of father
- Wife doesnt leave
- Wife accepts the abuse
- Wife has nowhere else to go
- Wife never complains to family or friends
- I beat you and then I tell you I love you
without ever saying it. - Wife manages to survive
- Battered Employee Syndrome
- Mistreated employee
- Humiliated / discounted / no recognition, no
respect - Staff mimic behavior of manager
- Employee doesnt leave
- Employee accepts the abuse
- Employee has nowhere else to go
- Employee never complains to colleagues or more
senior management - Employee manages to survive
66Negative/Positive Reflex Conditioning How Poor
Managers Survive and Thrive
- Stockholm Syndrome/Critical Parent
- Manager highly critical towards staff and very
insecure - Manager perceives his knowledge and ideas trumps
others - Thinking outside his box is tantamount to him
perceiving the staff member as a fool and an
idiot - Manager treats select staff miserably yet no one
formally complains - Manager has a tendency to show the staff he is
mistreating certain acts of kindness in,
unanticipated promotions, salary increases - Staff reaction is to be dumbfounded.
- I beat you and then I tell you I love you
without ever saying it. - The act of kindness keeps the staff member at bay
with no negative feedback appearing written or
verbal in the work place
- Stockholm Syndrome/Nurturing Parent
- Manager very kind nurturing parent with no
relative experience in job to which he/she are
assigned - Manager is weak professionally and lacks job
content and experience - Manager shows continued kindness to all
- Promotions, recognition, salary increases the
norm - This is the managers form of conditioning.
- The acts of kindness keeps staff members at bay
and his lack of technical savvy ceases to be an
issue over time.
67Reciprocity Positive Reflex Conditioning
You walk into a car dealership and youre
immediately greeted by the car salesman
A technically unqualified manager is appointed in
your office and remains friendly with his entire
staff
After buying you coffee and taking you around the
dealership, he cuts it short by telling you not
to buy anything today because prices will be
slashed within two weeks
Following a friendly one on one staff meeting, he
levels with you that youre the most
knowledgeable person about your technical
expertise and he doesnt believe in
micro-managingleaving you to fully manage
yourself
68Reciprocity Positive Reflex Conditioning
You appreciate the advice hes given you and
decide to wait to buy the car
You appreciate the responsibility and trust hes
put in you, and go back to work
You and the car salesman get along very nicely
when you learn that you both have a common like
for motorcycles
You and your new boss start getting along
famously, you realize that he likes the same
soccer teams and shares a lot of your hobbies and
interests
69Reciprocity Positive Reflex Conditioning
You begin to really like this sales guy and you
make it a point to buy the car from him convinced
that he gave you a huge discount
You start getting closer to the boss, you not
only do your work without his interference, you
start taking on some of his work too
He throws in some additional perks and free
options, and youre delighted as you drive away
in your new car
You get a promotion and a great SRI, and keep
taking on more responsibility
70Reciprocity Positive Reflex Conditioning
When the customer satisfaction survey comes
around, you give the salesman the highest ratings
possible
When the managers feedback form comes around,
you give your boss a glowing recommendationas do
most others in the department
Because you befriended the salesman, and you
actually believe he did you a favor on the price
of the car, you feel you owe him. You owe him
great feedback, and you owe him an opportunity to
sell you another car down the line
Because you see your manager as a friend, even
a mentor, and because you are getting rewarded
for what you do, you begin to black out the
flaws this manager brings to the table, technical
or other
AND IT HAPPENS REPEATEDLY AND THE CYCLE CONTINUES!
71Transactional Analysis
- Back to the 80/20 rule This rule also says that
your job environment is functional when 80
percent of your relationships at work are based
on the I am OK your OK principle - If the opposite is the case than your job is
dysfunctional - Most of us are somewhere in between.
- You can still have a lot of not OK situations
at work and still be effective it just wont be
fun.
72Transactional Analysis
- Keep in mind that the 80/20 rule can still be in
your favor but you could still have major
problems. - Why? Because having an I am not OK your not OK
relationship with your driver in Bosnia is less
relevant having this relationship with your
boss is relevant - Keep this in mind for your home situation as well
73Transactional Analysis
- To understand why some of your relationships work
and others dont you need to assess your own
behavior and that of others. - Which mode are you in the most, parent, adult,
child? - Which mode are your subordinates and peers in?
- Which mode is your boss in?
74Transactional Analysis
- Understanding your relationships with others
relates to gold stamps and gray stamps - Whether we like it or not we accrue gold stamps
for situations we handle well and gray stamps for
situations we handle badly - This is what defines our okayness with other
people - For some one gray stamp is enough to put you in
the category of I am OK your not OK - For others a ton of gold stamps may not do much
at all
75How to Minimize Conflict
Realize that it takes two to generate conflict
Conflict is indeed a choice
Always avoid being a third party in any conflict
Turn on your adult ego state in critical
situations
Its always ok to play nurturing parent until
other person is ready to stand on his own feet
Separate the person from the act Do not
criticize personality
If you find yourself in front of a critical
parent, realize that there is no need to defend
yourself if you are not the cause of his/her
problem but merely an opportunity to find relief
from pressure
Always try and move the person out of an ego
state that is damaging
76How to Manage Conflict
Refuse to participate
Keep changing your ego states until you find what
works
Manage your own critical parent reactions
Manage transference by reaching out to others
Never present yourself as a victim
Manage your relationships more broadly
Avoid linking yourself to a camp, never be in us
against them mode
Survive, change is always around the corner
76
77Basic Guides Which Can Help You in Working With
People
Cooperation cannot be forced
You communicate more through action than words
Sentiment and emotion count
Everyone likes to feel important and avoid
ignoring someone whenever possible
Everyone wants to know that they matter
Dont forget to show appreciation consistently
78A Few Final Words of Wisdom
The definition of being wise is when you have
something stupid to say dont say it
One nice thing about people with big egos is they
dont talk about other people
The person with the least expertise has the most
opinions
If you tell the truth, you dont have to remember
anything
Just because everything is different doesnt mean
anything has changed
Good judgment comes from bad experience,
experience comes from bad judgment
Anyone can admit that they were wrong the true
test is admitting it to someone else
When things go wrong, dont go with them
79Closing Thoughts
- Finally, remember there are situations that cant
be fixed, just too many black stamps, or office
jealousies. - Sometimes no matter how much it hurts, how much
you care for a job, its just over and you need
to walk away - Always try and move forward, and try and make the
best from a bad situation and learn from it - Its OK to simply survive and to move forward
from a bad situation
80Review of Buzz Words(But They Can Also Be Tools
for Better Understanding)
- GAMES
- NIGYSOB
- AINT IT AWFUL
- KICK ME
- RAPO
- UPROAR
- STUPID
- (WHAT OTHERS
- CAN YOU NAME?)
- COLLECTING STAMPS
- GOLD STAMPS
- GRAY STAMPS
PARENT ADULT EGO STATES CHILD
- PAYOFF
- CONSCIOUS
- UNCONSCIOUS
CRITICAL PARENT NURTURING PARENT NATURAL
CHILD ADAPTED CHILD
- ROLES
- VICTIM
- RESCUER
- PERSECUTOR
- STROKES
- POSITIVE
- NEGATIVE
- CONDITIONAL
- TRANSACTIONS
- COMPLEMENTARY
- CROSSED
- ULTERIOR
PARENT TAPE CHILD TAPE
BASIC LIFE POSITION