Title: OUA AP Development
18th CEI Summit Economic Forum
PPP Models to Build Airport Infrastructure
Matching the Demand in Central Europe
Welcome
2Agenda
- Need to Build Up Airport Infrastructure in
Central Europe - Private Sector Involvement in the Airport
Industry - Public Private Partnerships
- Case Study PPP-Structures as Means for
Successful Airport Development
3Agenda
1
- Need to Build Up Airport Infrastructure in
Central Europe - Private Sector Involvement in the Airport
Industry - Public Private Partnerships
- Case Study PPP-Structures as Means for
Successful Airport Development
4Central Europe is in terms of traffic volume one
of the smallest worlds markets but with strong
growth potential
1
Key Points
- Central Europe is a growing air traffic market
and according to industry forecasts this will
continue. - The 10 biggest national air transport markets in
the continent account for 75 of the air
passengers and 80 of the air freight - The relatively stabile level of demand is
attributed to fast growing GDPs in the region - However, growth is limited
- by lacking competition and insufficient airport
infrastructure and - competition with railroad network and other modes
of ground transportation
Source Airport Information 2004
5The CEI countries have been witnessing growing
passenger and cargo volumes until 2003..
1
Passenger Volumes CEI countries (Number of Pax)
Cargo Volumes CEI countries (tonnes)
Source IATA, Lufthansa Consulting
6but, without Italy and Austria, CE countries
showed only growths in passenger traffic but none
in air cargo
1
Passenger Volumes CEI countries (Number of Pax)
Cargo Volumes CEI countries (tonnes)
Source IATA, Lufthansa Consulting
7But for the next years GDP and passenger
forecasts are above world average underpinning
development potentials
1
GDP Development 2005-2005CEI countries vs World
Average
Passenger Forecast 2005-2008CEI countries vs.
World Average
Source IATA, Global Insight, Lufthansa Consulting
8Increasing importance for aviation as main
transport mode in international traffic flows
1
Passenger Traffic at Central European Airports
2004
Key Points
- Rapidly developing transportation markets
- Growing interests of the Low Cost Carriers, and
market stimulation effect - Integration into EU Market
- Participation of national carriers in Alliances
(e.g. LOT Star Alliance) - Seating capacity on international flights
continually increasing - But No domestic air transport markets in most of
the Central European countries (except Italy and
Poland)
Country
Passengers tsd
gt high growth potential
80.345
Total
Source ACI, Albatross, Lufthansa Consulting
Sample of 49 Central European Countries
9There is a great potential for air cargo
development
1
Air Cargo Traffic at Central Europen Airports 2004
Key Points
- Central European air cargo traffic accounts only
for less than 3 of the worlds air cargo market - Real intra-continent cargo flows does not exist
yet. - 80 of inter-continental cargo traffic is
related to trade with Asia and less than 10 to
trade with Middle East countries. - Huge transit potential, but poor cargo
infrastructure at the most of the Central
European airports - Air imports are dominated by IT goods,
pharmaceuticals, electronic, machinery parts and
textiles goods
Country
Cargo
Total
Source ACI, Albatross, Lufthansa Consulting
Sample of 49 Central European Countries
10Capital expenditures in Central Europe airports
increased in the last 5 years
1
Major Airport Developments in Central Europe (gt
500 mill. USD)
Airport Capital Expenditure by Region (in mill.
USD)
- Rome-Fiumicino staged terminal expansion until
2005 US 2.9 billion - Lublin/Poland, completely new airport planned in
eastern Poland US 2.3 billion - Vienna, new Terminal 3, apron, tower, office park
US 880 million - Zagreb, Master Plan projects US 600 million
- Prague, major terminal expansion, new runway US
585 million
Source ACI Airport Economics Survey 2004
11Barriers have to be removed to continue with
infrastructure improvements allowing for
sustained expansion
1
- Bourgas and Varna
- Copenhagen Airports emerged as the winner of the
tender and was ready to invest in the
expansion and modernization of the facilities. - Fraport AG/BM Star consortium and the Frenche
Vinci groups attacked this deciscion. - Supreme Administrative Court demanded reopening
of negotiations with the both airports - Bourgas and Varna are now pressing hard to find
measures of coping with the lack of terminal
capacity to serve the increasing volumes of
passengers
Example Bulgaria
- Budapest Ferihegy Airport
- Originally 10 consortiums were interested in
Budapest Ferihegy Airport - The initial tender was declared invalid by an
employment court - A single-round closed tender was launched then
and opened to the five parties shortlisted
in the original tender - Copenhagen Airports was also participating in
the process, but announced its decision to
pull out - Also Australian Macquarie Airports dropped its
bid - Three bidders only went forth as the tender
closed for the majority stake
Example Hungary
Source local and international press
12Agenda
2
- Need to Build Up Airport Infrastructure in
Central Europe - Private Sector Involvement in the Airport
Industry - Public Private Partnerships
- Case Study PPP-Structures as Means for
Successful Airport Development
13Some privatisation trends...
2
- The privatisation run of the 1990s slowed down
after 2000 the privatisation wave is on a
recovery path in Europe and North America, where
we see the highest level of activity in line
with anticipated worldwide traffic increases - Still only 4 of the worlds airports can be
considered being privatised - Projects embrace all types of concessions and
models and a wide range of financial instruments
in developing countries (Asia in particular)
Public-Private-Partnerships are increasing - Investor groups are diversifying and expanding
their business scopes IPOs and green-field
developments are increasing (with mixed success) - Central Europe is still largely bypassed by
infrastructure privatisation (due to lack of
market opportunities and capital, investment
climate, etc.) Total investments have been
declining
14Airport Privatisation activity is increasing
after a period of standstill
Examples
15Agenda
3
- Need to Build Up Airport Infrastructure in
Central Europe - Private Sector Involvement in the Airport
Industry - Public Private Partnerships
- Case Study PPP-Structures as Means for
Successful Airport Development
16What is a public-private-partnership (PPP)?
3
- A PPP is broadly defined as
- a cooperative venture between the public and
private sectors, built on the expertise of each
partner, that best meets clearly defined public
needs through the appropriate allocation of
resources, risks and rewards.
17Understanding the motivation of the public and
private sector as well as the lenders one is key
for any PPP
3
18Private Sector participation trend in airport
infrastructureWhich model option meets the
interest of all parties?
3
Policy Options/
Option 1
Option 2
Option 3
Option 1
Option 2
Option 3
Roles
Roles
- Service Concessions
- Management Contracts
- Multiple Concessions
- BOT, BOOT, BTO etc.
- Long Term Leases
- Master Concessions
- Multiple Concessions
- Trade Sales
- Capital Markets
PPP Options
Ownership
Ownership
Private Sector
State
Private Sector
Investment
Investment
Private Sector
Management/
Management/
Private Sector
Private Sector
Operation
Operation
19Successful PPPs are based on attractive assets,
clearly defined concessions, and a sound business
plan
2
20The regulatory environment and the qualifications
of the project partners are prerequisites for
goal achievement
2
21Certain risk factors in the Central European
airport market need to be addressed and managed
3
RISK!
22The projects funding life cycle is driven by the
partners objectives, by the nature of the
business and by associated risks
3
GROWTH PHASE
START- UP PHASE
Traffic growth
Airport concept Air transport market potential
analysis
Facility and process improvement Exploitation of
market potential New route development
Start of operation
Company formation (SPV) Airport development
concept/masterplan Operations concept Route
development and airport marketing concept
AirportCompany Activity(Conces-sionaire)
PROFIT LOSS
Maturity Full Operations Revenue Growth Capital
Sourcing for Expansion
Expansion Free Cash-Flow generation Positive
Income (fuel growth)
Growth Revenue Generation
Start-up Validation of Concept Market
Confirmation
Seed Start-up Capital (for Feasibility Studies,
Market Testing, business formation)
Investment Phases
Institutional Investors Public Market Securitizati
on
Banks / Loans Financial Institutions ABLs
Customers Trade Lease Mezzanine Finance
Government Suppliers Strategic Partners Early
Stage Equity Funds Mezzanine Finance
Private Funds Angels Micro-financing
Sources of Financing
23Agenda
4
- Need to Build Up Airport Infrastructure in
Central Europe - Private Sector Involvement in the Airport
Industry - Public Private Partnerships
- Case Study PPP-Structures as Means for
Successful Airport Development
24The capitals new airport project presents
elements of three separate transactions
4
25The air transport market has distinct features
4
Passenger Traffic 2003 - 2027
Key Points
- In 2002, the country had approx. 230.000 air
passengers, of which 90 have been handled at the
capitals airport - Regional traffic flows Europe 31, West Africa
34, Other African countries 24, and 11 to
other regions - Passenger structure 89 scheduled passengers 7
charter passengers and 4 non-commercial traffic - Today, Air Cargo exports are largely based on
perishables (vegetables and fresh fruits) this
dominance will decrease until 2027 - Compared to exports, Air Cargo imports have
played a minor role since 1981.
Air Cargo Traffic 2003 - 2027
Source Lufthansa Consulting
26The development of airport capacity to meet
future demand requires investments of approx. 200
250 mill. Euros
4
- Project A Infrastructure development
- Responsibility Government
- Investment Government
- Project B Construction of airport
- Responsibility Concessionaire, (Government)
- Investment Concessionaire, private investors
- Project C Land commercialisation
- Responsibility Government
- Investment t.b.d. after valuation
Development of existing airport/ Access to the
new airport
Phase 1 Construction
Operation
Phase 2 Expansion
Land Commercialisation
2006
2010
2015
27A Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) as operating
company of the airport is composed of a
combination of private investors
4
Potential Split of Shares in the SPV
-
- The composition of investors is driven by
Government interests, investor interests and
availability of local, regional and international
capital - The Government will take an appropriate capital
share - Foreign investors / operators of the new airport
will take a majority share - The split of shares in any PPP needs to in line
with the risks and rewards associated with the
investment.
28Government participation in the transaction is
indispensable
4
Revenues at the airport
Magnitude of the investment
Revenues from the low passenger (2004 240.000)
and cargo volumes (2004 4.800 t) do not justify
the investment and do not present an attractive
investment opportunity.
TTL investment is unlikely to be sourced from the
local and regional investment community alone
alternative ways of financing need to be found.
Government Participation in the privatization
- Privatization Model PPP 25-year concession
renewal option - The Government will have to subsidize the project
with at least 45 of Phase I of the project - Phase 2 can be financed from internal sources
29The privatisation strategy is based on a number
of financial criteria for the SPV as the
operating concessionaire
4
- Government contribution of a substantial part of
the investments in Phase 1 - Start-up equity of the SPV usually should be at
50, depending on the composition, i.e. cash vs.
assets provided by construction firms - According to similar projects, the long-term
debt/equity-Ratio as based on a realistic
business plan shall not be lower than 70 30
during the term of the concession - Internal Rate of return (IRR) of at least 12 for
SPV to reflect various risk dimensions properly - Positive cash-flow during the term of the
concession - Payments of concession fees to the Government
- Dividend payments to the shareholders of the SPV
- Tax holiday for the operating company
- Debt Service ability of the SPV under various
scenarios and loan structures
30To enhance the feasibility of the project to
investors, all revenue sources will have to be
transferred to SPV
4
Cargo Handling Concessions
Airside Service Concessions
Pax and A/C Handling Services
Concession Revenue
SPV
Landside Service Concessions
...
Concession Revenue
...
31Conclusions
4
- There is a huge need for infrastructure
developments at many airports in Central Europe,
but limited public budgets are available. - PPPs are not a panacea for government inability
to fund necessary airport infrastructure projects
but can provide a solution when the resources of
private and public partners are bundled where
conventional privatisations are not possible. - To be considered as investment opportunity by the
private sector traffic has to be above certain
thresholds - but only few air transport markets
in Central Europe have sufficient traffic yet. - PPPs with a fair allocation of risks and rewards
provide a means to raise necessary funds and
know-how on the basis of a realistic business
case. - Risk mitigation strategies have to be developed
to protect the public and private partners,
including e.g. re-definition of the airport value
chain, tax advantages, direct subsidies, etc. - The uniqueness of each airport development
requires always a tailored approach structuring a
PPP.
32For further contact
Dr. Raphael von Heereman Executive Director
Lufthansa Consulting GmbHVon-Gablenz-Str. 2
650679 CologneGermany Tel. 49 (0)221 88 99 6
- 56 Fax 49 (0)221 88 99 6 - 60 e-mail
Raphael.Hereman_at_lhconsulting.com www.lhconsultin
g.com
33for your
attention
Thank you