t a t eepste

1
???????? ????t?? ??a t?? ?e???ep?st?µe?

• S????S?? ?G??F???S S??????S?
• G. ?a??ad????

S?ßßat? 9 ??????? 2005, ?????ast??
?????? ??G??????
2
??sa?????? ???µ???s?

• ?e?t???? e??t?µa
• ??? p??pe? ? ???????a µa? ?a ???s?µ?p???se? t??
  p??sfata
• ap??t??e?sa ???s? ??a t?? e???fa??
• ?a? t?? ?e?t?????e? t??

3
??sa?????? ???µ???s?
???a ????a ??a t?? ?st???a t?? ?????

• ?t?? ?????s?? 2002
• ?at??t?ta ??F ?a? ?a?ep?st?µ?? t?? Westminster
• ???ta?????? st???? ?a d?e?e????e? ?at? p?s? ??
  p???te? t?? ????p?? µp?????
• 
  ?a pa????? p??ta????st??? ???? st? d?µ?s??
  d??????, ?a?
• 
  µ???sta p??? se ???s?µa ep?st?µ????? ??µata.
• ??????, ? ep????? ?ta? a??µesa se 3 ??µata
• Ge?et??? ???a???? ?a? t?? ap????pt????f?s? t??
  a????p???? ?e?et???? ??d??a
• ?a??te???????e?, ???p?? µ??a???? se
  µ???-d?ast?se??, ? ?p??a ??e? ep?f??e? epa??stas?
  st?? ?at????
• ?p?st?µe? t?? ???ef????

4
???a ????a ??a t?? ?st???a t?? ?????
G?at? ??? ? ?e?et??? µ??a????

• ?d? ????a??e? ta te?e?ta?a ?????a st? d?µ?s??
  d??????
• ? ?e?et??? d?µ? µp??e? ?a ??e? ap?t??esµa st??
  a????p??? s?µpe??f???. ?µ??, a??µ? ?a? ta ????d?a
  as???? t?? ep?d?as? t??? µ?s? t?? e??ef????.

5
???a ????a ??a t?? ?st???a t?? ?????
G?at? ep???????a? ?? ?p?st?µe? t?? ???ef????

• ?e???? ap??a??pt??? st???e?a
• 3 sta 10 ?t?µa st?? ????p? ?p?f????? ap? ??p??a
  e??efa???? d?s?e?t?????a
• St?? ????p?, 1 sta 5 ?t?µa ?p?f????? ap?
  ?at??????
• 1 sta 4 ?t?µa st?? ??sµ? p?s???? ap? ??p??a
  ?????? ? ?e????????? d?ata?a??
• ?? ??e??e? de?????? ?t? ?? e??efa?????
  d?s?e?t?????e? e??????ta? ??a p??? ap? t? 1/3 t??
  s???????? ??st??? t?? as?e?e??? sta e???pa???
  s?st?µata ??e?a?.
• ?? 2004 ? ep?ß????s? t?? e?????? s?st?µ?t??
  ??e?a? e?a?t?a? t?? e??efa????? d?s?e?t???????,
  a????e sta 386 d?? e???.

6
???a ????a ??a t?? ?st???a t?? ?????
G?at? ep???????a? ?? ?p?st?µe? t?? ???ef????
?a??te?e? µ???d?? d?????s?? ?a? epe?e??as?a? t??
st???e??? (???s? ?/?), ????? ?d???se? se
epa??stas? t?? ?e???ep?st?µ??

• ?e????? ?p???se?? µe ????????? ?a? ????? d??stas?
• ?? ep?st?µ??e? ?a µp????? ?a d?aß????? t??
  a????p??? e???fa?? ?a? ?a p??ßa????? se ???se??
  p??? st?? p?e?µat??? ??e?a t?? a????p??
• ??t?? ?? p????f???e? d???t???, µp????? ?a e??a?
  d?a??s?µe? st??? e???d?te? ? t??? asfa??st??
• ??p?? µpa????µe stad?a?? st? ?????? t??
  d?????s?? µe f??µa?a ? µe eµf?te?µata,
  p??ß??µat???? p??s?p???t?t??
• ??p?? stad?a?? ?a a???s??µe ?a ßaft????µe t?
  d?af??et???t?ta d?s?e?t?????a ???ad?, e?t??
  ap? t?? ?at??????, ? t?? ep??et???t?ta, ?s??
  a???? ?e??s??µe ?a ?e?ape???µe t?? af???µ?da,
  t?? ???e??? ???????, t? st?e? ?a? t?? ?p????a!!
• ??p?? e?t?? ap? t? d?????s? ?a a???s??µe ?a
  µ???µe ??a ße?t??s? (p.?. e?f??a)

7
Connecting Brains and Society

• The present and future of brain science what is
  possible, what is desirable? European Workshop,
  22 and 23 April 2004, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
• Medicalisation
• Enhancement and Social Justice
• Reductionism and personal identity
• Responsibility and Free Will
• Privacy and Personal Freedom
• Ethics of Research and Information Exchange

8
??sa?????? ???µ???s?

• H ta?t?t?ta t?? ?????
• ?????? ??t???
• MEETING OF MINDS - European CitizensDeliberation
  on Brain Science
• ????????? t?t??? e??as?a? ???????? ????t?? ??a
  t?? ?e???ep?st?µe?
• S??p?? t?? ?????
• ?a p??sf??e? se p???te? ?a? ?µ?de? t?? ???????a?,
  t?? e??a???a ?a ep??e?s??? t? d?µ?s?a ?µe??s?a
  d??ta?? se ??µata ? ? p?? af????? t??
  ?a??µe???? ???
• ?a d?aµ??f?se? ??e? µe??d??? e???pa????
  d?a??ß????s?? se ep?st?µ????? ?a? te?????????
  ??µata.
• ?????e?a 1 ??eµß???? 2004 ??t?ß???? 2006

9
??sa?????? ???µ???s?
?? p??ta????st??

• 126 ????pa??? p???te?
• d??ad?
• 9 ?µ?de? 14 p???t??
• ap? 9 d?af??et???? ???e? t?? ????p??

10
??sa?????? ???µ???s?

• ????? s?µµet?????

• ???t?? 12 ?ta???? ap? 9 e???pa??? ???t?
• ?ta????
• King Baudouin Foundation (??????)
• ?a?ep?st?µ?? Westminster (UoW)
• F?aµa?d??? ??st?t??t? St??µ?s?? ?p?st?µ?? ?a?
  ?e???????a? (F?aµa?d??? ?????t?ta, ??????)
• ?p?t??p? ?e???????a? ?a??a? (Danish Board of
  Technology, ?a??a)
• Cité des Sciences et de l Industrie (Ga???a)
• Stiftung Deutsches Hygiene-Museum (Ge?µa??a)
• Fondazione IDIS- Cittá della Scienza (?ta??a)
• ??st?t??t? Rathenau (???a?d?a)
• Science Museum / Dana Center (?.??etta??a)
• ?a?ep?st?µ?? t?? Debrecen, ???t?? ?at????? ?a?
  ?p?st?µ?? ??e?a? (????a??a)
• ?d??µa ???e??d?? (????da)
• ?a?ep?st?µ?? t?? ??????, SPIRAL (Ga?????
  ?????t?ta, ??????)

11
Ge???? ???µ???s? ??a t? ????

• ????? s?µµete???t??
•  

?e?t????? S??t???st?? King Baudouin Foundation
(project coordinator) ??????? S??t???st?? 11
f??e?? (national coordinators) S??t???st???
?p?t??p? e?p??s?p?? t?? 11 f????? (Steering
Committee) ??????? Oµ?de? ????? ???????
s??t???sµ?? ?a? ???p???s? ????? 2 ????pa??? 9
??????? ?????O??S (European - national
Facilitators) ??????? S?µß???e?t???? ?µ?de?
(Advisory Groups) Oµ?de? ??d?afe???t??
(Stakeholders Group)
12
??sa?????? ???µ???s?

• ??? ???µat?d?te?ta? t? ????
• µe d??e? ap? t? ße????? ?d??µa King Baudouin
  Foundation
• µe ep???????s? t?? ????pa???? ?p?t??p?? (6? ?-?
  ??a t?? ??e??a, S??d?? ???s?? ?p?st?µ?-???????a)
  
• µe ?at? ß????s? s?µµet??? t?? e?????? eta????

13
Ge???? ???µ???s? ??a t? ????

• F?se?? ?????
• 3 e?????? s??a?t?se?? d?a????? ????a (?d??µa
  ???e??d??)
• ??sa?????? S????t?s? ????t?? (S?ßßat? 7 ????a??
  8 ?a??? 2005)
• 1? ?????? S????t?s? ????????s?? (23-24-25
  Septeµß???? 2005)
• 2? ?????? S????t?s? ????????s?? (21-22-23
  ??t?ß???? 2005)
• 2 e???pa???? s??a?t?se?? ???????e?
• 1? ????pa??? S????t?s? ????t?? (3-5 ??????? 2005)
• 2? ????pa??? S????t?s? ????t?? (20-23 ?a???a????
  2006)
• 1 e??ast???? d????s?? ap?te?esµ?t?? ????a
  (?????? 2006)

14
??sa?????? S????t?s? ????t??

• St????
• G????µ?a t?? e???????? ?µ?da? ????t?? µeta??
  t???, µe t??? d????a??t?? ?a? µe t?? eµ????t?
• ???µ???s? ??a t? ????
• ?????e??s? µe t??? ?a???e? t?? d?a????? p?? ?a
  t???????
• S??t?µ? epe????s? t?? 6 ?a?a?t???st????
  pe??pt?se?? t?? e?sa??????? ??d?s?? - ?d???? ??a
  t?? p???t? (ADHD, Alzheimer, Brain Enhancement,
  Gilles de la Tourette - brain surgery, Brain
  Imaging, Brain Plasticity)
• ?????? d?e?e???s? t?? ??µat?? ?a? a?ta??a??
  ap??e??
• ??µ??????a e???????? at???ta? ?eµ?t?? p?? ?a
  s???t??e? st?? 1? ????pa??? S????t?s? ????t??, µe
  5 ???s?µa s?µe?a ??a ???e pe??pt?s?.
• ??p?? ?d??µa ???e??d??, S?????? 387, 17564
  ????a, ?????sa S?µß??????1
• ?µe??µ???a S?ßßat? 7 ????a?? 8 ?a??? 2005.

15
???t? ????pa??? S????t?s? ????t??
???t? s????t?s? ???? t?? e?????? ?µ?d?? ????t??

• St????
• S??p??
• ?? 126 ????pa??? p???te? ?a s???t?s??? t??
  ap??e?? t??? s?et??? µe t?? ep?st?µe? t??
  e??ef???? ?a? ?a p??sd????s??? ????? ??µata p??
  ?a ??e?a? ?a e?e?e???s??? st?? ep?µe?e?
  s??a?t?se??.
• ?p?t??esµa
• ??a s????? s?µpe?asµ?t?? ?a? s?st?se??, p?? ?a
  pa?a????? ap? t?? e???pa??? ?µ?da ????t??, ta
  ?p??a ?a ap?te??s??? t? te???? ?e?µe?? t?? ???t??
  ????pa???? S????t?s?? ????t??.
• ???e p???t?? ???s?µ?p??e? t?? e????? t??
  ???ssa s????? 8 ???ss??- µ?s? ?p??es???
  d?e?µ??e?a? ?a? µet?f?as??.
• ??p?? ???????e? (??????)
• ?µe??µ???a 3-5 ??????? 2005

16
???t? ?????? S????t?s? ????????s??

• 2? e????? s????t?s? t?? µe??? t?? e????????
  ?µ?da? p???t??.
• ?as??? s?µe?a
• ? s?ed?asµ?? t?? s????t?s?? ?a ??ße? ?p???? ta
  ?d?a?te?a s?µe?a
• est?as?? t?? e???????? ???????a?, p??? st? ??µa
  t?? ?e???ep?st?µ?? t??
• e??ef????.
• ?as??? ep?d???? t?? ???t?? ?????? S????t?s??
  ????????s??
• ??a??t?s? ap? t??? p???te? pe??ss?te??? st???e???
  ??a ta ??t?µata p?? e?d?af?????. ??? p????f???e?
  ?a pa?????? e?d???? ? e?p??s?p?? ?µ?d??
  e?d?afe???t??, p?? ?a p??s??????? ap? t???
  d????a??t?? ??a t? s??p? a?t?.

17
?e?te?? ?????? S????t?s? ????????s??

• 3? ?a? te?e?ta?a e????? s????t?s? t?? µe??? t??
  e???????? ?µ?da? p???t??
• ?as??? ep?d???? t?? ?e?te??? ?????? S????t?s??
  ????????s??
• ???????? ?a? a?ta??a?? p????f????? ?a? ap??e??
  µeta?? p???t??, e?d???? ?a? ?µ?d?? e?d?afe???t??,
  se e????? ep?ped?.
• ?? p???te? ?a s???e?t??s??? t?? p????f???e?
  p?? ??e?????ta? ??a ?a s??µat?s??? µ?a ?????
  ?p??? p??? st? ??µa.
• ??aµ??f?s? e??? S?ed??? e?????? a???????s??, ?a?
  s?et???? s?st?se??
• ???et??µas?a t?? pa???s?as?? t?? ap?te?esµ?t??
  t?? e?????? a???????s??, st? ?e?te?? ????pa???
  S????t?s? ????t??.
• ??p?? ?d??µa ???e??d??
• ?µe??µ???a 21-22-23 ??t?ß???? 2005

18
?e?te?? ????pa??? S????t?s? ????t??
?e?te?? ?a? te?e?ta?a s????t?s? t?? µe??? t??
e???pa???? ?µ?da? p???t??.

• ?as??? ep?d???? t?? ?e?te??? ????pa????
  S????t?s?? ????t??
• ?a???s?as? t?? e?????? p??pa?as?e?ast????
  ?e?µ???? a???????s??, p?? pe???aµß?????
  pa?at???se??, ap??e?? ?a? s?st?se?? t?? e??????
  ?µ?d??.
• ??aµ??f?s? e??? ??????, e???pa???? ?e?µ????
  a???????s?? ?a? s?st?se?? ??a t?? ep?st?µe? t??
  e??ef????. ?????pt??? ?d? ?µ???t?te? ?a? d?af????
  ap??e?? ?a? a???? µeta?? e???pa???? ?????.
• ???et??µas?a t?? pa???s?as?? t?? ap?te?esµ?t??
  st? e??? ????? ?a? t??? f??e?? d?aµ??f?s?? ?a?
  ????? ap?f?se?? (p.? ????pa??? ?p?t??p?, st???
  a?µ?d???? ??a t?? ?p?st?µ? ?a? t?? ??e??a),
  pa???s?a t?? ??? ?a? ??????.
•  
• ??p?? ???????e? (??????)
• ?µe??µ???a 20-23 ?a???a???? 2006

19
???ast???a S?µß???e?t???? ????t????

• ?as??? s?µe?a
• ?as???? ep?d???e??
• ?a pa???s?as?e? t? te???? e???pa??? ?e?µe??
  a???????s?? t?? p???t??, ?p?? ??e? d?aµ??f??e?
  µet? t? ?e?te?? ????pa??? S????t?s?.
• ?a s???t????? t? ?e?µe?? ?a? ta ap?te??sµata t??
  ?e?te??? ????pa???? S????t?s?? ????t?? µe
  e?d?????, ?µ?de? e?d?afe???t??, f??e?? ???a???
  p???t???? ?.a.
• ?a d??e? ? e??a???a sta ??? ?a ep????????s??? µe
  t?? e????? ?µ?da p???t??,
• ?a p??ß???e? ? p??t?ß????a t?? ??a????? ????t??
  ??a t?? ?e???ep?st?µe? se e????? ep?ped?.
• ?? ???µe? t?? p???t?? ?a ep??e?s??? t??
  ?ate????s? t?? e???pa???? ?a? e?????? p???t????
  st?? ?e???ep?st?µe? t?? e??ef????.
•  
• ??p?? ?d??µa ???e??d??
• ?µe??µ???a ?????? t?? 2006.

20
???ast???a S?µß???e?t???? ????t????
S?µas?a t?? ?????

• ?? a?t? ? ?s??s? ep?t??e?
• Ta ep?ßeßa??se? ?t? ?? p???te? µp????? ?a
  s???µ????? ape??e?a? ?a? ?a s??e??????ta?, ??a ?a
  ep??e????? t? ???? ap?f?se?? st?? ????p?.
• ? µ???d?? p?? ?a a???????s??µe, ?a µp??e? ?a
  efa?µ?ste? ?a? se ?????? t?µe?? d?µ?s???
  d?a?????.
• ?e? ?a t?????µe p?s? ap? t?? e?e???e?? (?p?? p.?.
  st?? pe??pt?s? t?? ?e?et???? µ??a?????)
• ?? ???????e? µe s?µµet?????? d?ad??as?e?, ?a
  d?e?e???s??? t? t?p?? st?? ?e???ep?st?µe? t??
  ???ef???? ?a? ?a p????? ap?f?se?? p??? ?????
  ap?de?t?? ?a? ep???µ?t?? ?ate????se??.