From state centric and military focused to comprehensive approaches

1
????????, ?????? ? ?????? ??????? ???????????

• ?? ?????????? ?? ??????? ???????????

2
From state- centric and military focused to
comprehensive approaches
3
????????

• ???????,
• ??????,
• ???????,
• ?????????????? ?
• ?????????? ???????????

4
??????? ??????????? ??? ??????? ????????????
??????
5
??????????? ? ?????? ???????????? ??
????????????? ??????? ???????????

• ???? ?????????? ??????????????? ???????
• ?????? ? ???????????? ????????????? ??????? ?
  ?????? ? ?????
• ?????? ????????????? ? ??????????????? ??
  ????????????? ???????????? ???????? ????????
  ???????

6
??????? ???????? ????????? (Rosenau) ? ????
??????????? ?????????

• ?????????????- ????????????? ? ???????????
• ????? ?????? ? ???? ???????

7
?????? ???????? ???????????

• ??? ?? ?????????? ??????? ????????????
• ????? ?? ??????? ???????
• ?? ?????????? ???????????
• ????? ?????????? ?? ???????, ???? ? ??????????
  ??????????? (Terriff)

8
????????? ???????????

• ?????
• ?????????
• ?????????
• ?????????- ??????????? (Buzan)
• ????????

9
?????????? ??????? ??????? ???????????

• ?????? ???? ?
• ?????? ????

10
?????????????????? ????? ??????? ???????????

• ?????????? ????? ?
• ?????????? ???????

11

• ??????????? ??????
• Area Studies
• ????????? ???????????
• ????????? ?????????
• ????????
• ????????? ???????
• ?????????? ???????????
• ???????????
• ?????????? ???????
• ??????????

12
??????? ????? ? ???????????

• ?? ????????? ????? ? ????????? ?????? (Ullman)
  ?? ?????????? ??????? ???????? ??????? ???????????

13

• ????? ???? ???????? ??????? ???????????
  ??????????? ?????? ??????????? ? ?????? ??????
  ????????? ????????? ????????? ?? ? ??????,
  ??????? ??????? ?????? (Adrian Hyde- Price)

14
??????? ??????? ??????????? ? ???????? ???????
???????????? ??????? ? ??????

• You cant shoot an ozone hole (Robbie Stamp)
• Threats without enemies (Gwyn Prins)

15
???????? ??????? ??????? ??? ????????? ???? ??
?????????? ? ????? ? ???????????

• Homer- Dixon
• Marc Levy
• Daniel Dedney

16
??????????

• Buzan, Barry, People, States and Fear, Harvester
  Wheatsheaf, London, Second Edition, 1991
• Gärtner, Heinz, Adrian Hyde- Price and Erich
  Reiter, (Eds.), Europes New Security Challenges,
  Lynne Rienner Publishers, Boulder, Colorado, 2001
• ?????, ????????, (??????????), ??????? ???????
  ???????????- ??????? ????????, ???????? ?17,
  ?????? ?? ???????- ????? ??????, ???????, 2003
• ?????, ?., ??????, ????? ? ???????????- ?????????
  ???????? ???????????, ???????? ???? ???, ????????
  ?????????? ?????, ???????, 2002
• Terriff, T., Croft, S., James., L., and Morgan,
  P., Security Studies Today, Polity Press,
  Cambridge, 1999

17
????? ?? ?????!