Title: THE INFLUENCE OF SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS (SES) ON STUDENTS
1THE INFLUENCE OF SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS (SES) ON
STUDENTS ACADEMIC AND LINGUISTIC PERFORMANCE
PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
- Celeste Roseberry-McKibbin, Ph.D.
- Professor, California State University,
Sacramento - and
- Speech Pathologist, Elk Grove Unified School
District - www.hhs.csus.edu/homepages/SPA/Roseberry
2www.
- hhs.csus.edu/homepages/SPA/Roseberry
3Material excerpted from
- Roseberry-McKibbin, C. (2008). Increasing
Language Skills of Students from Low Income
Backgrounds. Available from Plural Publishing
Company - www.pluralpublishing.com
- (858) 492-1555
4INTRODUCTION AND MY BACKGROUNDWe have a great
deal of diversity at my elementary school1/3 of
our students are ELLs (English Language
Learners). 60 are on free/reduced lunch, and 9
are White the other 91 are children of colour
5In any discussion of service delivery, we want to
follow principles of evidence-based practice
- Requires an integration of best research evidence
for clinical procedures with sound judgment and
clinical expertise (Roseberry-McKibbin Hegde,
2006). - Means that as much as possible, we as clinicians
should use only those procedures that are
supported by research.
6Outline for this morning
- 1. Legal considerations
- 2. Factors impacting oral language
characteristics of low-SES children - 3. Practical strategies for use by professionals
- 4. Developing vocabulary skills
- 5. Specific strategies for low-SES preschool
children - 6. Enhancing literacy skills of low-SES
elementary- aged and adolescent students - 7. Increasing low-SES students executive
functioning skills
7No Child Left Behind
- Addresses inequities in several ways
- Students with disabilities must participate in
state accountability systems for reading and math
in grades 3-8 - Accommodations are allowed for these students as
necessary - Schools must show adequate annual progress toward
all students being proficient in math and
reading, or the school will face penalties.
8Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA
2004)
- LEAs (local education agencies) are allowed to
eliminate the IQ-achievement discrepancy gap that
formerly was mandated in order to qualify
students for many special education services - There is a greater emphasis on pre-referral
services - Schools may now use more funds for early
intervention - Some schools are utilizing an RTI (response to
intervention) model to support low-SES children,
especially in the early grades.
9II. FACTORS IMPACTING ORAL LANGUAGE
CHARACTERISTICS OF LOW-SES CHILDREN
10LANGUAGE CHARACTERISTICS CORRELATED WITH LOW SES
- Being poor does not cause children to have
language and behavioral impairments we should
never equate poverty with dysfunction - However, certain language and behavioral
characteristics are associated with being from a
low-SES background
11Limited access to health care
- Can impact language skills
- If the mother is malnourished during pregnancy,
this impacts brain development - Children who are often sick miss school
12If children come to school sick or hungry
- They have difficulty learning
- It is hard to concentrate
- If they have middle ear infections, this can
impact listening and even written language (e.g.,
reading, spelling)
13Research has documented
- A strong correlation between adults education
and their income levels. - Long-term welfare dependency is associated with
low literacy skills and a lack of a high school
diploma
14Caretakers who have little formal education
- May not provide adequate oral language
stimulation for their children - They may not believe that it is important to talk
with babies and young children (who are not
treated as conversational partners)
15Again, research shows that
- Low-SES parents tend to provide less language
stimulation than middle- and upper-income parents - One study showed that the amount of verbal
stimulation provided to children, along with SES,
significantly related to the childrens verbal
skills at 5 years of age
16In terms of educational levels of caregivers
- Research has found that SES is more critical to a
childs language development than ethnic
background - The factor most highly related to SES is the
mothers educational level
17An example in working a puzzle (Woolfolk, 2004)
- Low-SES mother No, that piece goes here!
- Middle-SES mother What shape is that piece? Can
you find a spot that is straight like that piece?
Does the color match Nolook again for a
straight, red piece. Yes, try that onegood for
you!
18The middle-SES child
- Is benefiting from verbal elaboration,
problem-solving opportunities, conceptual
development, and encouragement to take initiative - The low-SES child is getting no opportunities to
gain these skills, which are so important in
school
19Hart Risley 1995
- Conducted longitudinal studies of families from
various ethnic and SES backgrounds. - Over several years, they observed in the homes of
3 groups of 1-2 year old children from 3 groups
1) welfare, 2) working class, 3) professional. - Hart, B., Risley, T.R. (1995). Meaningful
differences in the everyday experiences of young
American children. Baltimore Paul H. Brookes
Publishing Co.
20Hart Risley concluded that
- SES made an overwhelming difference in how much
talking went on in a family. - The family factor most strongly associated with
the amount of talking in the home was not
ethnicity, but SES
21Hart Risley extrapolated thatIn a 365-day
year, children from professional families would
have heard 4 million utterancesChildren from
welfare families would have heard 250,000
utterancesChildren from working class families
fell somewhere in between
22- Even by 3 years of age, the difference in
vocabulary knowledge between children from
welfare and middle class homes was so great that
in order for the welfare children to gain a
vocabulary equivalent to that of children from
working class homes, these welfare children would
need to attend a preschool program for 40 hours
per week where they heard language at a level
used in the homes of professional families.
23Book
- Whatever it takes
- Richard DuFour
- How to help parents talk with babies
- Reading Rocketsa website for encouraging
readingsuggestions in different languages also
(Color in Colorado)
24III. PRACTICAL STRATEGIES FOR USE BY
PROFESSIONALS
25Teachers and other professionals such as SLPs can
increase the number of childrens conversational
experiences in the classroommany low-SES
children need this, especially when they are in
the early elementary grades (Weiner, 2001)
26Ways to increase childrens conversational
experiences in therapy rooms and especially
classrooms include
- Talk to individual students as they complete
their work (e.g., You finished cutting out the
picture of the rabbitnice job.) - Allow children to converse nonverbally if they
still are uncomfortable speaking (e.g., If the
sun is shining, clap your hands. If it is
recess time, stand up.
27Other ways to increase childrens conversational
experiences include
- Bring in volunteers to have conversations with
children about their interests or what they are
doing in school - Give all students opportunities to practice
various forms of language. For example, students
need many opportunities to practice negotiating,
making requests, explaining things to others, and
problem-solving. - Arrange the physical setting of the classroom so
that it promotes talking and interaction.
Teachers, SLPs, and other professionals can
provide learning centers, interactive classroom
displays, and large tables for group work.
28In addition to having many conversational
experiences
- Many low-SES students, especially if they are
older, need to learn how to take notes
effectively - They may never have been taught to do this
29With regard to notetaking, students often need to
be explicitly taught to
- Focus on key/content words and write them
downdont write down all the function words that
are not semantically relevant. - Distinguish between content and function
wordsbig and little words - Students may need a review of the parts of
speechfor example, they may need to remember
what adjectives, nouns, verbs, and articles are - In this way, they can remember that most key
words are adjectives, nouns, and verbs articles
are the little words
30Students can underline or highlight the
key/content words in sentences.
- The weather is hot in the summer.
- Abraham Lincoln was a president of the United
States. - Many people think that dogs are mans best
friend. - When they learn to do this, they can then be
taught to take notes, writing down just the
key/content words.
31With regard to notetaking, we can also
- Allow students to use a variety of writing
instruments. Allowing students to choose their
own writing instruments heightens their interest
in the writing process and in the information
they are hearing. - Some children with illegible handwriting benefit
from using mechanical pencils - From personal experience, I recommend 0.9
millimeter leads, as these do not break as easily
as 0.5 millimeter leads!
32We can encourage students to
- Use a highlighter pen when reviewing notes. The
color will add interest and contrast. - They need to be taught to only highlight key
words and phrases, not whole sentences, as this
will aid in quick skimming/review later on - Rewrite their notes by hand. Handwriting notes
again helps embed these notes in memory - Copy notesespecially definitions of termson the
backs of index cards. Students can carry these
cards with them and review them during down time. - Explain their notes to another person. Talking
about the information contained in notes and
trying to teach this information to another
person is extremely helpful in increasing
students retention of the material
33To increase overall comprehension for notetaking,
general listening, and reading, we can use
visualization to help students form pictures of
information that they read or hear.
- Tell them that they can picture a TV in their
brain/mind/head when they hear or read things,
they can make pictures on this TV. - Help them with this process by beginning with
familiar items in their homes (pet, sibling,
living room). For example, I will ask a student
to tell me about his dog. When he has done so, I
will tell him that his dog is not present he was
able to describe the dog by using a picture in
his brain. - Nanci Bell (1991) has a comprehensive program
called Visualize and Verbalize. This program
helps students learn to form detailed mental
images to build skills in vocabulary, reading,
and writing.
34IV. DEVELOPING VOCABULARY SKILLS
- It is important for students of all ages to build
their content knowledge/ conceptual foundation
within meaningful contexts. Drill without context
is usually ineffective. - Develop knowledge of classroom/ curriculum
vocabulary. We can ask teachers to provide us
information about what vocabulary they are
teaching in the classroom.
35For example, if I have students from a classroom
where they are learning about the ocean and
marine life
- I use materials about the ocean and marine life
as part of my therapy session. - In this way, students are getting classroom
vocabulary and concepts reinforced.
36New words need to be learned in context
- Ideally, students should have concrete
experiences when they learn new information - For example, if they are being taught about
horses, it is ideal to actually see and touch one - If actual experiences are not available, objects
and then pictures can work well
37We can ask students to describe pictures and give
word definitionsthese skills are predictive of
success in literacy and school achievement
38If students draw pictures of new words they are
learning.
- Then they will remember the words much better
- Payne (2003) If you can sketch a picture of it,
then you know it!
39- It is helpful for students to write out
vocabulary words. - Some students struggle so much with
writingespecially spelling--that in order to
save time, I have them verbally tell me the
sentence they want to write. I write the sentence
on an erasable white board and they copy it. - In this way, they cement the vocabulary word
even more firmly into their minds. They also get
to practice writing words out correctly. In
addition, they practice the important skill of
sentence formulation. - When possible, I have classroom teachers give me
lists of spelling words the class is working on
that week. I try to incorporate these words into
therapy as much as possible. The children benefit
greatly, and teachers love it!
40We can use context-embedded strategies to teach
vocabulary
- An example follows, where the professional such
as the SLP or regular education teacher teaches
low-SES students about the moon
411. The professional brainstorms with students
about what they already know, building on their
previous knowledge
- What do you know about the moon?
- Students might answer It is up in the sky or
It shines at night. - The professional can record all these answers on
a paper or whiteboard.
422. The professional uses visuals to focus on the
topic
- For example, the professional might use a
PowerPoint presentation, video, or pictures to
show the first landing on the moon - The professional can then ask students to
describe what they see
433. The professional provides hands-on experiences
to reinforce the information
- For example, using a lamp or projector as the sun
and a tennis ball as the moon, the processional
demonstrates how the shape of the moon appears to
change. - The students sit in a circle and help move the
moon around the circle in the light of the
sun. - The professional might also have the students
jump two or three times to demonstrate the
effects of gravity. S/he can discuss the moons
gravity and how it affects tides.
444. The professional has students record
experiences in their notebooks.
- For students with writing issues, these
experiences might be typed onto a computer - It is ideal if students can keep logs or journals
for review of concepts that they have learned
455. The professional reviews test vocabulary and
concepts with games and worksheets.
- There are many options here. I have found from
clinical experience that many students really
enjoy Bingo and Charades. They may also enjoy
Pictionary, where they have to draw a
word/concept and have other students guess what
it is.
46For many low-SES students
- Learning vocabulary is difficult because it is
taught auditorily in an abstract way with no
visuals or movement - Using strategies such as those just reviewed can
help new vocabulary words become
context-embedded, and therefore much easier to
learn and remember
47- V. SPECIFIC STRATEGIES FOR LOW-SES PRESCHOOL
CHILDREN
48Increasing Literacy Skills
- Reading, writing, spelling
- ?
- Phonological awareness
- ?
- Oral language
- ?
- Foundation is environmental experiences and
exposure
49Begin with phonological awareness
- Phonological awareness is the ability to
consciously reflect on and manipulate the sound
system of a language. - It is foundational to success in reading,
writing, and spelling - Low-SES preschoolers especially need to develop
phonological awareness skills (Roseberry-McKibbin,
2007).
50Use the following hierarchy
- 1. Count the of words in a sentence
- 2. Count the number of syllables in a word
- 3. Count the number of sounds in a word
- 4. Identify rhyming words
- 5. Use sound blending skills (e.g., What word is
this? S-u-n - 6. Identify the first sound in a word
- 7. Identify the last sound in a word
51Other ideas include
- Use rhythm sticks and clapping to facilitate
knowledge of how many syllables there are in a
given word. Students can clap out the syllables
or use rhythm sticks to tap or shake for each
syllable. - Ask students to bring items from home that begin
or end with target sounds - Use a grab bag where students pull an object/toy
out of the bag and tell the beginning or ending
sound in the word. - Use rhymes such as Dr. Seuss. Many low-SES
preschoolers with LLD have underdeveloped rhyming
skills.
52We can also
- Use stories with Rebus-style pictures and ask
students to read the pictures - Read a familiar story or poem and have students
fill in missing words
53If books are read many times..
- Children obtain more vocabulary and information
each time they read the story. - When they are familiar with a story, they can be
encouraged to read it to peers and family
members. This increases their confidence with
reading.
54- Researchers such as Fey, Windsor, and Warren
(1995) and Kaderavek and Boucher (2006) caution
that some children may not be motivated to read.
This can be due to lack of exposure to books in
the home, lack of desire to sit still and focus,
and other variables. - Thus, it is extremely important for professionals
to make reading books motivating and enjoyable.
55Ideas to make book reading enjoyable and
motivating include
- Keep book reading time short.
- Use predictable books because they have
simplified and repetitive text that engage
childrens interest. - For example, a predictable book might start off
with 10 little monkeys, sitting in a
treeteasing Mr. Alligatorcant catch me! Along
comes Mr. Alligator, quiet as can be, and SNAPS
that monkey right out of that tree. 9 little
monkeys etc.
56Professionals can use books that
- Have highly exciting or dramatic story themes
- Have manipulative parts like flaps and movable
tabs to engage children. - Have buttons to press that make noises (e.g., a
choo-choo noise for a train) or play music. - Have many colorful pictures that accompany the
words. Often, children who have limited exposure
to books will become disinterested in books that
have many words on each page.
57And we know that we should encourage caregivers
to read, read, read!
58Written Language Attainments Preschool Period
- We need to be sure that before they enter
kindergarten, our preschool students can - 1. Display interest in reading sharing books
- 2. Hold a book right side up
- 3. Identify the front and back of the book
- 4. Identify the top and bottom of a page
- 5. Look at and turn pages from left to right
- 6. Identify the title on the book cover
59- 7. Identify titles of favorite books
- 8. Distinguish between pictures and print on a
page - 9. Know where the story begins in the book
- 10. Identify letters that occur in their
own names - 11. Print the first letter of their name
- 12. Recite the first 10 letters of the alphabet
60- 13. Point to the first letter in a word14.
Differentiate uppercase from lowercase
letters15. Use terms such as letter, word,
alphabet - 16. Point to words individually as they are read
- 17. Respond to signs in the classroom
- 18. Recognize common environmental signs (e.g.,
stop sign)
61VI. WORKING WITH LOW-SES ELEMENTARY-AGED AND
ADOLESCENT STUDENTS ENHANCING LITERACY SKILLS
62Many SLPs do not view literacy as something that
is our job. Many of us in public schools work
with students who have oral language problems,
and literacy is viewed as the province of other
professionals such as Resource Specialists.
- However, ASHA (2004) has been increasingly
emphasizing the role of the SLP in supporting
students with written language problems. - Low-SES students are particularly vulnerable to
written language difficulties
63There are many easy, simple, inexpensive
activities that SLPs can incorporate into therapy
to provide additional support to these students.
- In this section, we shall discuss some of these
activities that cost practically nothing and
potentially make a big, positive difference for
low-SES students.
64SUPPORTING LOW-SES STUDENTS WITH
- WRITING, FINE MOTOR, TRACKING, AND SPELLING
PROBLEMS
65Writing can be difficult
- Today in the U.S., most special education
- referrals involve students who have difficulty
with writing.
66Students may have difficulty because
- 1. They have poor composition skills
- 2. They have weak hand/finger muscles and poor
finger dexterity - 3. They may come from environments where writing
and other pre-readiness fine motor skills have
not been emphasized.
67Teachers assume that
- Children come to school ready for paper-pencil
tasks they should start writing immediately - In fact, many are not ready and need to do
activities like painting and playing with clay - In todays kindergartens, there is no time for
this children are asked to write before they are
ready
68Handwriting without Tears
- Is a multisensory, developmental approach that is
virtually 100 successful. - It is excellent for ELL children it is very
visual and tactile - It is also good for children who are left-handed,
who reverse their letters, and who have
difficulty forming their letters. - www.hwtears.com
69- There are many simple, inexpensive activities
that can be used to help children who have
difficulty with writing and fine motor skills
70These include
- Use small pencilse.g. golf or bowling sizethe
ensure an accurate grip - Put a ? in the upper left hand corner to orient
students as to where to begin writing. - Have the child make letters in clay or playdough
- Have the child trace letters in a salt or sand
tray to enhance the kinesthetic feel of the
letter.
71- Have the child pick up small objects with
tweezers. If we are teaching vocabulary through
small objects, we can kill 2 birds with one
stone by having children use tweezers to pick up
these objects this will help develop fine motor
skills. - Encourage the child to squeeze a squishy ball
during listening activities. This enhances
attention and helps strengthen hand and finger
muscles. - Overteach right vs. left. Many low-SES students
confuse right and left. I have pre-adolescents
who are still inaccurate with these concepts! - Make sure the child is sitting at 90 degree
angles. Her feet should be flat on the floor, her
posture straight, and her stomach touching the
table. Her nonwriting hand should be flat and
should support the paper as she writes.
72- Have the child write letters in the air, writing
from the shoulder - Have the child wake up her body by stomping on
the floor, moving aroundthis will enhance
concentration. - If the child is a leftie, the paper is turned in
the opposite direction
73- Make sure the child can easily write the letters
A STONE these are the most frequently used in
the Dolch list - Teach spacing by having children overexaggerate
spacing when they are first learning to write - Use the Skittle test! If there is enough space
for a Skittle to be placed between words, the
child gets to eat the Skittle.
74- Enhancing Reading Comprehension Skills
75We Can Teach Basic Sight Words
- The of and a
- To in you is
- That it at he
- For on are as
- With his they be
76- If low-SES students sound out basic sight words
each time they encounter these words, reading
comprehension and fluency will be slowed down
greatly (Peregoy Boyle, 1997). - Professionals can drill these sight words with
students until the students can read them quickly
and automatically. - I use index cards and write the words down, one
word per index card. - When students can read the words quickly and with
automaticity, reading comprehension and fluency
are greatly enhanced!
77PREVIEW-VIEW-REVIEW APPROACH
- Use classroom textbooks to teach students this
approach - This helps teach class curriculum content and
enhance reading skills
78BEGIN WITH PREVIEW
- 1. Get an overview of the chapter
- 2. Read the main idea sentence of key paragraphs
- Highlight key vocabulary words
- Read the concluding paragraph or summary
79VIEW THE CHAPTER
- 1. Read the text aloud and have students follow
along - 2. Stop and have students explain content in
their own words - 3. Help the student organize and outline notes
and readings
80- 4. Review class notes which pertain to the
chapter - 5. Scaffold for the student
- 6. Help the student use context to enhance
comprehension of words
81Help the student visualize what is being read
82REVIEW
- 1. Look over chapter headings and divisions again
- 2. Ask questions about the content
- 3. Help the student answer questions at the end
of the chapter
83Also review by
- 4. Have the student summarize the chapter in her
own words - 5. Ask the student for his opinions about what
was read - 6. Ask the student if she has any questions
about the chapter - 7. Help the student make up test questions about
the content they have just read.
84Again, SLPs can incorporate these ideas.
- To support low-SES students of all ages as they
learn to read, write, and spell. - These ideas can be used as adjuncts to therapy
for increasing the students oral language
skills.
85VII. INCREASING LOW-SES STUDENTS EXECUTIVE
FUNCTIONING SKILLS
86What is executive functioning?
- Executive functioning (EF) has to do with
goal-directed behavior that is important for
success in lifes activities - EF can be likened to an air traffic controller
that monitors and coordinates all activities it
can also be likened to a maestro that conducts an
orchestra (Eberle, 2003)
87EF is critical in terms of
- Thinking about the future
- Being able to evaluate potential consequences of
ones choices
88We enlist EF when we.
- Set goals to achieve what we want
- Determine what is necessary to attain those goals
- For example, if we want a certain job, we think
What job do I want to obtain? (goal) What skills
do I have, and are they pertinent to that job?
What steps do I need to take to attain my goal of
obtaining this particular job? (determining what
is necessary to obtain those goals)
89Fundamentally, characteristics of EF include
- Developing plans for future actions
- Holding those action sequences and plans in
working memory until they are executed - Inhibiting actions that are not relevant
90EFs are
- The problem-solving processes that are utilized
at the outset of a novel, automatic task - Fundamentally intertwined with working memory and
inhibition
91Low-SES students may be vulnerable to EF
deficits(Farah, Noble, Hurt, 2006)
- If they are from homes where they have been
socialized toward interdependent behavior and
external control of behavior by authority rather
than to self-regulation and independent,
internalized self-control. These types of homes
are typical in many cultures (Lynch Hanson,
2004 Roseberry-McKibbin, 2008 Santos Lee,
2004 Sharifzadeh, 2004) - Because many have been shown to have working
memory deficits again, successful EF is directly
related to working memory - EF deficits can inhibit the learning of social
and academic language, and dramatically slow down
students progress in school - Ultimately, EF deficits can negatively impact
students academic, linguistic, and career paths
92Components of EF that we may need to teach
directly include (Eberle, 2003 Packer, 2004
Singer Bashir, 1999)
- Inhibiting irrelevant actions
- Attending selectively
- Demonstrating emotional control
- Restraining and delaying responses till an
appropriate time - Setting goals and planning steps to achieve those
goals - Planning for the future
- Shifting flexibly between activities
93We need to especially emphasize teaching students
to
- Inhibit their immediate responses to stimuli,
thereby allowing themselves time to plan and
organize and set goals - Pause for self-reflection and self-analysis
943 Simple Questions We Can Teach Students to Ask
Are
- 1. What is the problem I am having right now?
(take time to analyze the problem) - 2. Why am I having this problem? (identify cause)
- 3. What can I choose to do about it? (behavioral
adjustment) - An example of a simple choice chart follows
on the next slide.
95My Choice Chart
- Student Name________ _________Date________
- What I wanted was_____________________________
- The choice I made was The consequence of my
___________________ choice was - ___________________ ______________________
- Next time, I could choose to The consequence of
that ___________________ choice would be - ___________________ _____________________
- I will remember that each choice I make leads
to a consequence. I will try to make good choices
so that I can experience good consequences!
96Another example of an EF chart for low-SES
students
- Is illustrated on the next slide
- This can be printed, laminated, and put on or in
the students desk as a reminder of utilizing EF
strategies in the classroom - Most teachers are very open to having students
use this type of chart, and may even find the
principles/steps useful for the whole class
97Executive Functioning Strategies
- 1. Stop, breathe, and think ahead
- 2. Allow myself enough time to get things done
- 3. Be organized and neatwrite things down
- 4. Set goals
- 5. Create and carry out steps to achieve my
goals - 6. Focus, pay attention, stay on track
- 7. Evaluate my actions did I do what I needed to
do to achieve my goals? - 8. Ask myself What could I do differently next
time to improve upon my performance?
98If SLPs and other professionals can help low-SES
increase their EF skills
- They can help these students take a giant step
toward success in all realms academic, social,
and ultimately, career
99It takes a village to raise a child.
- Thank you for all your hard work as an integral
part of that village.