Title: Taskforce Summit
1- Taskforce Summit
- on
- IP Value Extraction Corporate Valuation
- (Part 1)
- Â
- Highlights
- from the
- Taskforce Work Session
- to Develop the Standards Protocols
- for the
- IP Secondary Market
- Ford Global Technologies, Inc.
- May 22-23,2003
2CONTENTS
- This is a four part tutorial. The executive
summary is repeated on the first 3 slides in each
presentation. You may want to skip to page 6 to
begin the new part. - PART 1 IP Corporate Valuation Defines how
IP and other intangibles affect corporate value. - PART 2 The IP Secondary Market Initiative
Defines how the Taskforce is developing the means
to bring IP into Americas Capital Markets - PART 3 Taskforce Accelerated Licensing Program
Describes How to get Cash for IP with two
corporate analyses - PART 4 Overcoming the Obstacles Defines Ways
to Overcome Objections by Your Corporate
Colleagues
3Executive Summary
- The Taskforce Accelerated Licensing Transactions
provide a reliable vehicle to generate IP based
revenues, profits and cash. - The IP Secondary Market will create ready demand
for IP and stimulate improvements in the
innovation process. - The IP Secondary Market will establish
stabilize the valuation process for IP. - The obstacles to corporate use of IP backed
transactions is the internal capabilities and
functioning among the various disciplines within
the enterprise. And the apprehensions regarding
the post Sarbanes Oxley environment ..
Something this Summit expressly addressed and
converted to meet anticipated IRS concerns.
4Executive Summary p2
- The ability to develop a set of commonly
acceptable standards for the valuation of IP and
other intangible assets becomes the foundation
for defining corporate and shareholder value. - The SEC and FASB are looking to the Taskforce for
help with identifying key measures and metrics
that link intangible assets with performance. - America and its companies must address the
reporting implications of the transition to a
knowledge economy.
5The Linkages Among IP Backed Transactions, Demand
for IP and a Secondary Market
- 1) The sale of selected portions of the IP
Portfolio creates a supply of new product for
Wall Street investors who recognize the growing
importance of value extraction in the knowledge
economy - 2) The ability to repackage and resell these
packets of IP based on risk and reward creates a
more specialized capability to manage and extract
value from the IP. - 3) The reliability of value standards and ratings
of IP quality and credit worthiness provide a
framework for continuing demand for IP that can
be openly traded in Americas Capital Markets - Hence the need to begin trading IP in a safe
arena-the Taskforce arena.
6PART 1- IP Affects on Corporate Value
-
- The Taskforce Approach to
- Building, Reporting and Realizing IP and
Intangible Value - in the
- Competitive Enterprise
7IP Affects on Corporate Value
- The Affects of IP
- On Intangible Value
- of the
- Enterprise
- in
- Capital Markets
-
- Dr. Steve Henning
- Partner
- Marks Paneth Shrone
8IP Affects on Corporate Value, p2
- a) The SEC recognizes the growing importance of
global technical issues such as valuation of IP
and intangible assets, not only so that the
regulatory community can be smart about keeping
integrity in Americas capital markets, but also
because it is a fundamental issue with internal
management. - Â
- b)Â Â We (including FASB the SEC) have to figure
out the valuation process and methodologies we
are going to use here in the USA. - Â
- c)Â Â Â Only 45 of our capital markets value was in
the form of hard assets by the end of 2000. - Â
- d)Â Europe is more progressive in valuing
intangibles and this is undoubtedly the way of
the future. - Â
- e)Â America and its companies must address the
reporting implications of the transition to a
knowledge economy. That is one of the focal
points of the Taskforce.
9IP Affects on Corporate Value, p3
- f) Â For example, some firms listed on the
London Stock Exchange (LSE) are already
recognizing some previously unrecorded intangible
assets. Listing rules of the LSE require the
following percentage ratios (of the target to the
acquirer) be used to determine if acquisitions
and dispositions are sufficiently large, thus
requiring shareholder approval - (1)Â Â Â Â Assets
- (2) Profits
- (3) Consideration to assets
- (4) Consideration to market capitalization
- (5) Gross Capital
- Â
- g) Transactions where any percentage ratio is
25 or more require shareholder approval. This
is why some firms have an incentive to
voluntarily recognize previously unrecorded
intangible assets.
10IP Affects on Corporate Value, p4
- h) America and its companies must also
convey to investors the value that intellectual
property and other intangible assets possess.
The Taskforce is intent on assisting in this
process. - FASB has the role of defining what should be
recognized and how. - j) The SEC has the responsibility of defining
what should be disclosed and how. - k) The Taskforce search is the same as that
of SEC FASB what are the key measures and
metrics that link intangible assets with
performance. In fact, the SEC and FASB are
looking to the Taskforce for help with
identifying those factors.
11IP Affects on Corporate Value, p5
- Â The SEC already has specific indicators it seeks
for RD. They include - Â Â (1) Business done
- Â Â Â Â (2) Business expected to be done
- (3) Status of RD and relationship to new
products - (4) New capital investment plans uses
- (5) NO requirement to disclose information that
would compromise competitive position
12IP Affects on Corporate Value, p6
- m) The government is asking What do you value
and why? Currently there is a big difference in
view between the financial view (reporting) and
the operational data used to support day to day
management. The impetus is growing to develop the
framework so that companies, shareholders,
investors and the regulatory community can
document, analyze and better understand how the
growing contribution of intangible assets to
corporate value. - Â
- Â Â n) The establishment of a secondary market
backed by IP or intangible assets would eliminate
this confusion and conflict about intangible
value, because there would be a market that
could (and would) define those variables daily. - Â
-
13IP Affects on Corporate Value, p7
- o) There has been a halt to foreign registrations
in the wake of the Sarbanes - Oxley Act and the
requirement in Europe to shift to International
Accounting Standards by the end of 2005 means
America must deal with these issues because they
do affect our competitive capabilities.
14IP Affects on Corporate Value, p7
- In Summary
- The ability to develop a set of commonly
acceptable standards for the valuation of IP and
other intangible assets becomes the foundation
for defining corporate and shareholder value. - Americas capital markets need these
definitions, measures and metrics in order to
realize the potential economic growth from the
knowledge economy. - This process begins with the Taskforce
leadership in shaping the future economic model.
15Contact Information
- For more information, Please contact the Center
for Advanced Technologies 214/800-8810 or e-mail
bshearer_at_km-iptask.og - The Center for Advanced Technologies is a
non-profit corporation committed to economic
growth and - innovation through improved management
processes, technological innovation, executive
education and organization development. - The Center established the Taskforce in 1998 and
serves as its managing partner.