a a t ptstta

1
???ste?d?? ?. ?at??? ?p??????? ?a????t?? F???s?f?a
? ???a??? Te???a? Tesµ??
?a ???a t?? ????p???t?sµ???t?ta?
? ?eta??ste?s? ap? t?? 20? st?? 21?
????a YSUN-Greece 21 ?e?eµß???? 2006
2
????? p??? ßa?µ? µp????µe ?a a?e????µe
s?µpe??f???? ?a? a?t????e?? p?? ?????ta? se
a?t??es? µe t?? f??e?e??e?e? ?a? d?µ???at????
a???? Fukuyama t???? t?? s???t?s?? Huntington
s??????s? p???t?sµ?? ??e? d??a??µa t?
f??e?e??e?? ???t?? ?a ep?ß???e? t?? a???? t??
3
? pe??pt?s? Khalid Adem

• ? ?????pa? Khalid Adem e??atast????e st?? ?.?.?.
  t? 1992, se ?????a 16 et??. G????se t? µe????t???
  s????? t?? Fortunate st? ??????? ?a? t??
  pa?t?e?t??e t? 1997 st?? ??t?? ?µp?µpa. ??e?
  ?e??????e ?a? ? ???? t??? t? 1999.
• ? ???????e?a ep?st?e?e st?? ?.?.?. ?a? t? 2001 ?
  Khalid e?e??e? µe t? ß???e?a e??? f???? t??
  ??e?t???de?t?µ? st? d?????? ???? t??
  ???s?µ?p????ta? ?a??d?.
• ?et? t? d?a????? µe t? Fortunate ?a? ?at? t?
  d????e?a t?? d??ast???? d?aµ???? ??a t??
  ep?µ??e?a t?? pa?d???, ? p???? s?????? t?? t??
  ?ata?????e? ??a t?? ??e?t???de?t?µ?.
  S???aµß??eta? ?a? t? ???µß??? t?? 2006
  ?atad????eta? se de?aet? ???e????.
• S?µf??a µe t?? ?at??es? t?? p???? s?????? t??
  ??pe ?t? ??e?e ?a p??state?se? t?? pa??e??a t??,
  p?? a?t? e??a? t? ????µa t?? Te??.

4
??e?t???de?t?µ?

• O Adem ?atad???st??e ??a ßa??? s?µat??? ß??ß? ?a?
  ?a??p???s? a???????
• ?µ?s?? µet? t? d??? ? ??e?t???de?t?µ? ????e
  ?d????µ? ?????µa st?? p???te?a t?? Georgia
• St?? ?????p?a ? ??e?t???de?t?µ? de? apa???e?eta?
• ??? ?f?sta?ta? ap? t? 46 ?? t? 95 t?? ???a????
  (a?????a µe t?? pe?????)
• ???µa ?a? ???sµ???? ??pte? ???st?a??? de?
  ßapt????? ????ts?a p?? de? ????? ?p?ste? a?t? t?
  d?ad??as?a

5
??e?t???de?t?µ?

• ?e??p?? 130 e?. ???a??e? ????? ?p?ste? t?
  d?ad??as?a (100 e?. se 28 af???a????? ???e?).
  ???e ????? 3 e?.
• St?? ?.?.?. e??a? pa????µ? se 16 p???te?e? ?a?
  ap? t? 1997 apa???e?eta? µe ?µ?sp??d?a?? ??µ? ??a
  ta ?t?µa ??t? t?? 18.
• ?a???a?t? t?? ????? ?p?ste? 168.000 ???a??e?, ??
  50.000 e? t?? ?p???? e??a? a?????e? (Centers for
  Disease Control Prevention)
• St? ???µ??? ?as??e?? apa???e?eta? ap? ta µ?sa t??
  de?aet?a? t?? 1980, ?µ?? 74.000 (7.000 ??t? t??
  16) ????? ?p?ste? t? d?ad??as?a.

6
?p?? t?? p?a?t????

• G?a t??? ?pe?asp?st?? t?? p?a?t???? ? d?ad??as?a
  a?t? e??a? ?d?a?te?a s?µa?t??? (???s?e?t??? ?a?
  p???t?st???) ??a t?? pa??d?s? t???. ?p?te?e? ??a
  e?d?? te?et?? µ??s?? ?a? e???????s??.
• Robert Hinde (Cambridge) apa???e???ta? t??
  p?a?t???, fe??µaste sa? ap????????te? ?a?
  ?e?ap?st????, p??spa???ta? ?a e?afa??s??µe ??a?
  p???t?sµ? p?? t?? ?e????µe ?at?te??
• Asha Samad (CUNY) ????e?ta? ??a d?af???
  ap??e??. ?? ???????e?e? p?? t? ?????? a?ap??? ta
  pa?d?? t??? t??????st?? t? ?d?? ?s? ?a? µ?a µ?s?
  ?µe???????? ???????e?a

7
?? d???se?? Jack Straw

• ? Jack Straw e??a? ß???e?t?? t?? Blackburn ?p??
  t? 25-30 t?? ?at????? e??a? µ??s???µ????.
• ?? ??t. 2006 d?µ??????se s??? st? ??eta??a ?ta?
  ??t?se ap? ?se? ???a??e? t?? ep?s??pt??ta? st?
  ??afe?? t?? ?a afa???s??? t? µa?t??? p?? s??pa?e
  t? p??s?p? t???.

• Se d???se?? t?? t???se p?? se µ?a d?t???
  ???????a ?p?? ?? e?f??se?? t?? p??s?p?? ?????
  µe???? s?µas?a ??a t?? a????p??? ep????????a, ?
  ?s?aµ??? µa?t??a d?µ?????e? d?a????sµ? ?a?
  pa??????e? ?????t?te?.
• ?? e?d?µas?e? a?t?? apa???e???ta? se d?µ?s?a
  ?t???a ?a? e?d???se?? st?? Ga???a, t?? ??????a,
  se ???sµ??e? pe?????? t?? Ge?µa??a? ?a? a????.
• ???a? t? ?d?? a?e??? t? ?a ???ße?? t? p??s?p?
  s?? st? ??s?, ?s? ?a µpe? µ?a ???a??a µe µ??? ?a?
  ????? µp?te? se ??a t?aµ? (Anne Applebaum)

8
(No Transcript)
9
??t?d??se??

• ? d?af???p???s? ???eta? ap? t?? Straw, ??
  d???se?? t?? ?p???? ap?de??????? ßa??? ???e???
  ?ata???s?? (ß?eta????? ?s?aµ???? ???a??se??)
• Oliver Letwin ?a ap?te???se ??a ep????d??? d??µa
  ?a ?e? st??? a????p??? p?? ?a ?t?????
• Paul Cruickshank (NYU) ?? niqab ep??????? ?a t?
  f????? ??e? ???a??e? p?? a?????? se µet???pa?e??
  µ??s???µa????? ???????e?e? ap? t? ??t?? ?s?a ??
  ?p??e? de? t??? t? ep?ß?????? ?a? p????? f????
  a?t?t??e?ta?. ?? ??e? ??p??e? µe t?? t??p? a?t?
  a?t?d???? st?? s?µf????s? t?? ?????? t??? µe t??
  ß?eta????? a??e?.
• St?? ??????a ta ????ts?a p?? ?????? ?a f???s???
  µa?t??a t? ?e????? s?µß??? e?e??e??a? ?a?
  ???a??e?a? ape?e?????s?? ap??a?t? se ??a
  a?ta????? ??sµ??? ???t?? (a?s?????ta? µeta?? t??
  ????? e?e??e?e? ap? t? µ?da, ta ?a????t??? ?a? ta
  ep??et??? ß??µµata t?? a?d???).

10
??? ?a? t?s? µ??s???µa????

• Ann Hollander (Slate) p????? ap? a?t?? t??
  e?d?µas?e? e??a? a???ß?? ?d?e? µe e?e??e? p??
  f????sa? ?? ???a??e? ??a ?????de? ?????a st??
  ????p? (µ???? t?? 16? a???a) ?a? f????e a??µa
  st?? a???t???? pe?????? t?? a?at?????? ?a?
  ??t??a?at?????? ????p??

11
Corpus Christi

• ?et? t?? ß?µß?st??? e????e?a st? µet?? t??
  ???d???? ? µ??s???µ???? ?e??a? ?a?
  a?t?d????sµ???? d??ast?? Omar Bakri Muhammad t??
  ???ast????? t?? Sa??a st? ???d??? e??µ??se t??
  e????e?e? t?? ß?µß?st??. ? ß?eta???? ??ß????s?
  t?? ap??ase.
• 6 ?????a ????te?a t? ?eat???? ???? t?? Terrence
  McNally Corpus Christi pa???s?a?e t?? ??s?? ??
  ?µ?f???f???. ???st?a????? ???a??se?? ??????sa?
  p??et?f???a ?at? t?? p?eµ???a t?? ????? st?
  ?d?µß?????.
• ? Muhammad e??d?se fetf? ??t??ta? t? ?a??t?s? t??
  McNally ??a t?? p??sß??? e??? p??f?t?

12
Mahmoud Shalash

• ?µ?µ?? st? Lexington, KY t?? ?.?.?.
• ?a t??a ß?µata ??a t?? s?f????sµ? µ?a? ???a??a?
  ap? t? s????? (4.34 ???a????)
• ?a t?? ??µ?se? t? s?µas?a t?? ?a a??????e?? t??
  e?t???? t?? s?????? st? ?s??µ
• ?a t?? e??ata?e??e? µ??? t?? st? ??eß?t?
• ?a t?? de??e? e?af?? ????? ?a t?? p???a??se?
  s?ßa?? s?µat??? ß??ß?, ?a t?? sp?se? ???a??, ?a
  t?? af?se? µp?e ? µa??a s?µ?d?a ?a? se ?aµ?a
  pe??pt?s? ?a µ?? t? ?t?p?se? st? p??s?p?

13
Rawls Okin

• John Rawls ep?????? s??a??es? (overlapping
  consensus) ??a s????? a???? p?? µp????? ?a
  de?t??? ?????p?? µe d?af??et???? a?t????e?? ??a
  t? a?a??, ??a modus vivendi ?????????? s???pa????
  d?af??et???? a????p??
• Susan Moller Okin ?e? s?ß??ta? ???? ??
  p???t?sµ?? ta ?t?µa ?s? ?? f??e?e??e?e?
  ???????e?. ? p???p???t?sµ???t?ta e??a? s?ed??
  p??ta a?t??et? µe t? f??e?e??e?? feµ???sµ?. ??a
  ????t???a p?? de? s?ßeta? ta d??a??µata t??
  ???a???? de? a???e? ?a t? seß?µaste ??te ?a
  a?a????????µe s???????? d??a??µata sta µ??? t??

14
? a??? t?? ß??ß??

• ? µ??ad???? s??p?? ????? t?? ?p????
  ??µ?µ?p??e?ta? t? ???t?? ?a pe?????se? t??
  e?e??e??a t?? at?µ?? pa?? t? ????s? t??
  te?e?ta??? e??a? ??a ?a ap?t???e? t? ß??ß? se
  ???a ?t?µa. ?e? ??µ?µ?p??e?ta? ?µ?? t? ???t?? ?a
  pe?????se? t?? e?e??e??a t?? at?µ?? ??a t? d???
  t?? ?a?? (s?µat??? ? ?????). ?e? d??a???ta? ?a
  t? ?p???e?se? ?a ???e? ? ?a µ?? ???e? ??t? d??t?
  ?p?t??eta? p?? ?ts? ?a e??a? ?a??te?a ?? a?t? ?
  d??t? ?a t? ???e? e?t???ste?? ? ??at? s?µf??a µe
  ??p????? ?ts? e??a? p?? s?st? ? p?? s?f?. ??
  ?t?µ? e??a? ????a??? p??? st?? ea?t? t??, p???
  st? s?µa t?? ?a? st? µ?a?? t??.
• John Stuart Mill (On Liberty, 1859)

15
John Stuart Mill (1859)

• ?????? ?e????? ?t? ß??pt??ta? ap? ?p??ad?p?te
  s?µpe??f??? de? t??? a??se? ?a? d?sa?as?et???
  ?a??? p??sß???e? ta a?s??µat? t??? ?e?
  ?p???e? ?µ?? s?????s? µeta?? a?t?? p?? a?s???eta?
  ??p???? ??a t?? ?p??? t?? µe t?? p??sß??? p?? ?
  ?p??? t?? p???a?e? se ??p???? ?????. ?p?? de?
  s??????eta? ? ep???µ?a e??? ???ft? ?a ????e? µ?a
  ts??ta µe t?? ep???µ?a t?? ?d???t?t? t?? ts??ta?
  ?a t?? ??at?se?.
• (Mill 1859 6.12)

16
????? a?t???µ?a

• ?a a?t???µa ?t?µa e??a? e?e??a p?? µp????? ?a
  d?aµ??f?s??? t? ??? t??? ?a? ?a ?a????s??? t??
  p??e?a t?? - e??a? d?µ??????? t?? d???? t???
  ?????? ??sµ??.
• Joseph Raz

17
?? d??a??µa st?? ?d???t?s?a t?? ea?t??

• ?? ?t?µ? ??e? ap???t? ??e??? t?? s?µat?? t??.
  ?a?e?? de? d??a???ta? ?a t?? apa???e?se? ?a
  e????e? ?a? ?a ????e? t? s?µa t??.
• ?a?e?? de? ??e? d??a??µa ?a t? eµp?d?se? ?a
  ep????e? t?? t??p? ???? t??.
• ???µa ?? a? ?? ep?????? t?? p??sß?????? t??
  ????????? ?????.

18
?? d??a??µast? µ?-f??e?e??e?? t??p? ????

• ?s??e? se ??e? t?? pe??pt?se?? p?? ????? ?a
  ?????? µe t?? e?e??e??a t?? ??f?as?? (µa?t??a,
  ???s? ?a???t???? ??s???)
• ?e? ?s??e? ?ta? ß??pteta? ??a t??t? p??s?p?
• ?s??e? se ???e pe??pt?s? ??f?as?? ?p???? (Omar
  Bakri Muhammad, Mahmoud Shalash)

19
? ep?ß??? ap? d?µ?s???? f??e??

• ? ???ast?? Michael Regan st? St. Louis apa???e?e
  ta t???µp???a st?? a????sa p?? d????e?
• St? ?a?ep?st?µ?? t?? York ap??????e µ?a ß?????
  ?a????t? ?ta? a??????e ?a afa???se? t? niqab ?at?
  t? d????e?a t?? s??e??as?a? t?? µe t?? ?a????t?

20
? ep?ß??? ap? ?d??te?

• ? Federal Express apa???e?se st??? ?pa??????? t??
  ?a f????? ???s?e?t??? s?µß??a / ??a est?at????
  ap???se ??a? S?? ?p?????? t?? p?? a?????ta? ?a
  ????ste?
• ???sµ???? S?µa??? ta??t??de? st? ae??d??µ?? t??
  ????e?p???? a?????ta? ?a µetaf????? pe??te? p??
  ????? µa?? t??? a????? s?µf??a µe fetf? t??
  Muslim American Society
• ?e?e?ta?? pe??stat??? st?? ?afet???a VERO st??
  ??µ?t???. ???? 4 µ??e?, t?? ????a?? t? µes?µ???,
  µ?a pa??a tess???? ???? t?? µe????t?ta? e? t??
  ?p???? ? µ?a µa?t???f????sa µp??a? st?? s?ed??
  ?de?a ?afet???a. Se de?te???epta ?at?f?ase ?
  se?ß?t???? ?a? t??? apa???e?se ?a ?a??s???. ?
  d??a??????a ?e? ep?t??p??µe se µa?t???f????se?
  t?? e?s?d? st? µa?a??. ??p??µaste. ?? ????
  ?s???a? ta ?ef???a ?a? ß???a? ap? t?? ?afet???a.
  ??a????ta? a???saµe ?a µ???µ???????? sta t???????
  Bunlara Al Kaide lazim (Abdulhalim Dede, ??
  apa??t????t t?? ??µ?t????, Trakyanin Sesi
  9/3/2006).

21
Sa? e??a??st?!
ahatzis_at_phs.uoa.gr http//www.phs.uoa.gr/ahatzis